WWE has had a difficult year, in much the same way that a skunk has a difficult smell. Ratings have slipped to their lowest in almost 20 years, former legends have become persona non gratas, there's a growing disconnect between fans and the superstars at the top of the card, and even Mick Foley is close to unsubscribing. Even Mickles! In WWE's defence they've had a dreadful run of luck this year. Injuries have plagued the company with Cesaro, Rusev, Tyson Kidd, Seth Rollins, Daniel Bryan, Sami Zayn, Randy Orton, Sting, Nikki Bella, Jey Uso and more being forced to take significant time off, cutting down an already thin roster and often forcing the company to drastically change their plans at the last minute. In a parallel universe where none of these injuries happened, the company could be in much better shape. Furthermore, it's not exactly their fault that some of their legends, whom they rely on for so much nostalgia, assassinated their own public personas with an almost sniper accuracy. Hogan, Snuka, Billy Gunn - these guys added value to the company and their tarnished legacies only serve to further confirm in the minds of the general public that wrestling is a low form of entertainment for low people. None of the problems faced by WWE this year would be too much for the company to overcome individually, but taken together, like a man dying from a thousand paper cuts, they create an absolute annus horribilis (that's nowhere near as dirty as it reads) for Big Vince and his factory of grunting meatboys. By the time the clock strikes 12 on December 31st, the company would dearly like you to have forgotten all of these...
10. Announcers Instructions Leaked
In July of this year, photos were posted to Reddit of a leaked memo addressed to the WWE announce teams, outlining the Do's and Don'ts of their jobs. Though the memo is only allegedly official, owing to the merciless fallout that would be suffered if anyone came forward to publicly verify it, the guidelines had been previously covered by The Wrestling Observer Newsletter in 2013 and the photos seemed to line up with what they originally reported. The 8 page document is a bible for the play-by-play guys, giving them both general and strictly specific rules to follow when commentating. Some of the rules make a huge amount of sense and betray a narrative awareness, like "call every pinfall, because you aren't supposed to know when the match shall end", or "tell the audience something they might not be thinking, adding depth to the storyline". Some, however, are utterly arbitrary and betray little more than micromanagement. For example, see the list of words to avoid (pictured above), or the fact that the memos tells the announcers to "be themselves" but also "talk in soundbites." At one point it says "play-by-play announcers cannot be emasculated by their broadcast partners." Cough. JBL. Cough. It's an embarrassing leak for the company because, while some might take comfort in the fact that at least the company has a plan for their announce team, that plan is often confused, self-contradictory and mired in tiresome branding ("never use 'wrestler', always use 'superstar'") so that it only really succeeds in painting WWE as being soulless and averse to experimentation.
9. #CancelWWENetwork
With the Royal Rumble just over a month away, the fans have to wonder if WWE will go three-for-three and tank yet another January PPV with stubborn fan-baiting booking. In 2014, the Rumble died a slow death when it became apparent that Daniel Bryan, the man that the fans had ear-marked to be 'their guy' was not even going to be entered into the Rumble, never mind winning it. They turned on supposed fan-favourites like Rey Mysterio and the returning Batista, smothering the end of the match with derision. A year later, crap lightning struck again. Bryan had returned and, once again, the fans were desperate for him to be victorious. This time, he was the eleventh man eliminated and, taking this as a personal slight, the fans ramped their negative reaction up to 11. They destroyed the PPV, rejected Roman Reigns' big win, and even booed The Rock! The outrage peaked when the hashtag #CancelWWENetwork began to trend worldwide, with fans going as far as screenshotting pictures of their cancelled subscriptions and uploading them to social media. Normally, controversy creates cash, and Vince even said (in a conference call detailing the company's fourth-quarter earnings), that he thought the outage was good for WWE, and that everyone who unsubscribed would keep watching. With ratings all the way down, however, and with the company still persisting with Reigns as their top babyface, that complacency may have run out and the company will be wanting the fans to forget just how much hell they're capable of raising if they don't get their own way.
8. Billy Gunn Fired For PED Use
Billy Gunn, aka Monty Sopp, the man with a Muppet's name and a fixation on people's bottoms, is no longer with WWE, after the company discovered he had been suspended from the sport of powerlifting for taking performance enhancing drugs, and fired him. Allegedly, Gunn received his suspension after tests revealed that he had nine times the legal limit of testosterone in his bloodstream. NINE TIMES. He had so much man-hormone inside him that I'm surprised he wasn't covered in fur and coughing up entire bears. This is a tough blow for the company, what with Gunn being such a public figure for WWE. After all, he had a nostalgic run with the tag belts as part of the New Age Outlaws with Road Dogg back in 2014, ran in on HHH's match against Sting at WM31 and was a front-and-centre part of shows like Tough Enough that documented the work being done at the Performance Centre, where Gunn worked as a trainer. After all the steroid and substance abuse scandals of its past, WWE cannot afford to have anyone on their roster be caught flaunting its Wellness Program, especially someone in authority like Billy Gunn, someone who's been tasked with fostering the talent of tomorrow. Mr Ass is gone and his association with the company is, WWE hopes, soon to be forgotten.
7. Exploiting Reid Flair's Death
It's tempting to just put the entirety of the Divas Revolution as this entry and just call it a day, but WWE seems ever-determined to drive that particular piece of branding into the ground, not letting us forget it, even if we wanted to. The same cannot be said for the contract signing between Paige and Charlotte, however. During the segment, which aired in the main event slot on the November 16th Raw, Charlotte tearfully mentioned her brother Reid Flair, who died of an overdose in March 2013. It was an oddly jarring moment, as the feud between the two ladies hadn't escalated anywhere near the point where such raw subject matter would be appropriate - if it ever would be. Paige even said, "your little baby brother... he didn't have much fight in him, did he?". That's utterly horrible. And before you say it, yes I'm aware Paige was 'supposed to be a heel'. Doesn't make it any less exploitative and awful, though. To make matters even worse, WWE didn't contact either of Reid's parents before they aired the segment, prompting furious, now-deleted, tweets from Elizabeth Fliehr, Reid's mother, calling the whole thing "disgusting", "disrespectful" and "cruel". Even Dave Meltzer, who's in tight with the company, was outraged, stating that "a company with the slightest bit of class would have never even considered this idea for a second". The company want you to forget that they ever aired those comments, so much so that, less than a week later at Survivor Series, the lines were nowhere to be found in the pre-match video package, and the announcers gave them nary a mention.
6. The Ratings Plunge
WWE ratings are down right now. They are seriously down, reaching lows that the company hasn't seen since for nearly 19 years. The fallout show to Survivor Series (which should have seen big views, new champ and all that) drew a mere 2.964 million viewers, marking the first time since 1997 that company failed to average more than 3 million viewers. It's difficult to gauge exactly how much WWE are being personally affected by their declining viewership. After all, their paymasters are USA, not the advertisers, and NBCUniversal are sticking by WWE, judging from a recent press statement:
WWE programming delivers one of the most massive live audiences in cable on a weekly basis and is consistently a top performer for our networks
The subscriber count to the Network is still going up, as is WWE's stock, but then fans read conflicting reports from Dave Meltzer, calling the recent ratings dive a "disaster for WWE". Obviously, declining ratings are never good news. It's indicative of fan disinterest in the product, and if the numbers continue to fall to record-breaking lows, NBCUniversal might not stay quite so supportive of Vince and Co. Regardless of how much the company is actually suffering right now, whether a lot or not at all, the ratings issue is generating a constant stream of negative press and after it inevitably picks up come WrestleMania season, this is one broken record WWE won't mind the fans forgetting.
5. Seth Rollins' Leaked Pics
Hey, who wants to see a picture of Seth Rollins' d**k?! Step right up, kids! So Seth Rollins has a highly photogenic penis. That's just a fact. Don't even try and spin that, WWE, you can't do it. It's a champion's penis and that's all there is to be said about that. Evidently, the WWE cannot handle the sheer majesty of The Architect's member because they seriously don't want to talk about it. Or maybe its because the WWE is strictly PG-rated and the whole affair centred around nudity and adultery. But they were probably just intimidated by his size. In February, Seth Rollins accidentally posted to Instagram and Twitter a nude selfie taken by Zahra Schreiber, a model and NXT developmental rookie. Whoops. That turns to double-whoops when you take into account that Seth was engaged to another woman at the time. Triple-whoops is achieved when the fiancée in question, Leighla Schultz, then decided to take revenge by posting pictures of Seth's private area to social media. Clearly, this whole thing is murky as hell, and the exact opposite kind of publicity that WWE wants to generate in 2015 (in the Attitude Era, maybe a different story). However, if Seth received any punishment for the leak it didn't translate to the screen, as he was crowned WWE World Heavyweight Champion just 2 months later. The problems for Seth end there, but Zahra Schreiber on the other hand...
4. Zahra Fired For Nazi Pictures
Ms Schreiber's infractions against company policy continued in August, when she was fired after it came to light that she had posted questionable pictures to her Instagram account in 2012, before she joined the company. These pictures, it turns out, had something of the Nazi about them. One was a picture of a My Little Pony decked out like Hitler (that old chestnut), and the other was a picture of a collage with a swastika on it. Schreiber's response when called out on this pictures: "I like history, ha". Despite the pictures being deleted, WWE caught wind of the growing number of fans calling for Schreiber's termination and promptly obliged. Ironic joking gone wrong, a genuine fascination with history, or even actual pro-Nazi inclinations, it ultimately doesn't matter, because WWE are so staunchly opposed to discrimination in all its forms (only these days, mind. Remember how the Mexicools used to come down to the ring on lawnmovers?) that it had no option but to show Schreiber the door. After all, if WWE committed to firing Hulk Hogan, how the hell could they justify anything less for a rookie?
3. Jimmy Snuka
There are no jokes to be made here. This is a horrible situation filled with nothing but pain. In 1983, 'Superfly' Jimmy Snuka's girlfriend Nancy Argentino died from head trauma she received in a hotel room near Allentown, Pennsylvania. Despite foul play being assumed (her wounds were found to fit the template of severe domestic abuse) and despite Snuka being the only suspect, the case was allowed to go cold for 32 years, and he was never charged. However, in September of this year, a grand jury determined that it had in fact been Snuka who had repeatedly assaulted the Argentino, and he was arrested and charged with third-degree murder. WWE have since suspended Snuka's Legends contract with the company, removed his profile from the Hall of Fame section of their site and, according to a press statement, are "removing his images from our media platforms pending the outcome of this case". If the charges are true, they're truly monstrous, but that's not the only source of WWE's problems. Snuka described in his autobiography that Vince McMahon attended a meeting with the district attorney at the time of the incident. Also in attendance were the case's medical examiners and detectives, and Snuka noted particularly that Vince "had a briefcase with him". After this meeting, the case went cold. Now, these are all disparate details that in no way build a convincing argument of wrongdoing against Vince McMahon, but it's evident that, for a number of reasons, WWE don't want their fans to think too much about this horrible state of affairs.
2. The Bill DeMott Allegations
In March, Bill DeMott resigned as head trainer at the WWE Performance Centre after repeated allegations of misconduct and sexual harassment went public and #FireDeMott started trending on Twitter. Over ten separate wrestlers and ex-trainees have come forward in the last few years with allegations that include physically assaulting and bullying trainees, forcing athletes to perform dangerous drills without properly warming up (which lead to documented injuries), and using homophobic and racial slurs. He was accused of ripping a t-shirt off of Rusev who'd had recent neck surgery, pulling the ring ropes back and hitting trainees in the mouth with them, calling one of his prospects a "pedophile" and another a "f****t". Derek Bateman, now performing as EC3 in TNA even weighed in about DeMott's actions, tweeting: https://twitter.com/EthanCarterTNA/status/573002341944848384 In 2013, the company claimed to have conducted a full investigation into allegations brought against DeMott and his teaching methods, but ex-WWE stars like Briley Pierce (aka Ryan Nemeth, Dolph Ziggler's little brother) have doubted the legitimacy of such an inquiry, when the company omitted to question him, despite being one of the named victims. DeMott may have jumped before he was pushed but the multiple accusations have cast a dark shadow over the Performance Centre, formerly one of the biggest jewels in WWE's crown.
1. Hogan Fired In N-Word Scandal
How could anything else be number 1? Hulk Hogan was a treasured member of the WWE Universe, a champion of American values in the 80s, and remained one of the biggest icons in the sport even after he retired from in-ring competition. This year, he was fired by WWE after racial comments he'd made in private were leaked during his ongoing sex tape scandal lawsuit. That is one hell of a sentence, one I never thought I'd type. Hogan was scrubbed from WWE.com, his profile removed from the Hall of Fame section of the site, and his Legends contract terminated. WWE's corporate activism is at such a stage that it simply cannot afford to be associated with anyone charged with racial discrimination of any sort. Despite the Hulkster being one of the most recognisable people on the planet, the company have had to cut the ageing cash-cow loose for the sake of their dwindling credibility. The loss of Hogan represents the pinnacle of a very long year for WWE, one in which Fate gave them repeated chair-shots to the head.