10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About AJ Lee

Rants, relationships, and raw deals.

By Andy H Murray /

She retired from the sport close to three years ago, but AJ Lee remains one of the most impactful women's wrestlers of the past decade.

Advertisement

At peak popularity, Lee was one of the most over performers in the company, and an important pre-Revolution vanguard for WWE's oft neglected women's division. AJ, along with the likes of Paige, helped mount the scene's final push away from its superficial past, and towards a future where performers were pushed primarily on merit, not aesthetics.

Spinal injuries, creative frustrations, and her husband CM Punk's departure one year prior prompted Lee's 2015 release. Many lamented her retirement, but few were surprised. It came just two months after publicly skewering Stephanie McMahon for a hypocritical '#UseYourVoice' tweet, and having suffered close to five years of shoddy storylines and character direction, it was an understandable decision.

Lee was put through the wringer several times throughout her WWE run. From her grim early days as part of the NXT reality series to her god-awful string of romantic storylines, AJ's spell was was full of ups and downs, both onscreen and off, many of which her former employers would love to delete from history...

10. Losing To Eva Marie

Eva Marie was bad. So bad, in fact, that WWE effectively turned her in-ring shortcomings (and the fans' exasperation with them) into her gimmick towards the end of her run, with the hard-trolling 'All Red Everything' playing a tremendous avoiding heel.

Advertisement

Whether WWE acknowledged it or not, it was impossible to take the out-of-her-depth Eva seriously whenever she stepped between the ropes. The company's caste system has been incoherent for years, but Eva was on the bottom rung, and AJ was usually sat near the very top. Thus, the redhead besting the former Raw General Manager was a major shock, and it happened twice.

Eva overcame AJ (who was Divas Champion at the time) in two consecutive singles matches back in August 2014. It didn't result in a title shot, either, which makes the booking even more pointless. Why sacrifice your top champion to a green, inexperienced rookie if there's no bigger plan in play?

Unfortunately, this oddball decision was but a drop in the ocean of bad decisions that ultimately sent Lee's frustration with the company skyward, and likely played a role in her eventual departure.

9. Flipping Out On Michelle Beadle

ESPN sportscaster Michelle Beadle was invited to attend WWE's annual Tribute To The Troops show in 2013. A guest of the company, she was invited to hang out backstage, and got to participate in an in-ring angle with John Cena, but ran into trouble with CM Punk and AJ Lee later in the evening.

Advertisement

As the story goes, Beadle and her entourage bumped into the couple backstage. She greeted Punk (whom she considered a friend at the time) with a flippant "what's up, f***-face?", but neither 'The Voice Of The Voiceless' nor AJ saw the funny side. Moments later, Lee was apparently up in Beadle's face yelling at her "not to disrespect [my] boyfriend," leaving the guest shaken.

Punk has since downplayed the incident, acknowledging that while Beadle did greet him as reported, the confrontation between her and AJ was blown out of proportion. On the other hand, Michelle has stated that the situation was so bad, it prompted WWE to personally apologise to her, and that her existing friendship with Punk ended that day.

The he said/she said nature of this story means it is best taken with a hint of cynicism, but it's something that WWE would love to sweep under the rug regardless.

8. Her Spell As Raw General Manager

WWE don't exactly have a shining track record when it comes to appointing effective Raw General Managers, but while AJ Lee's stint in charge of the flagship show wasn't as cringey as the bumbling Kurt Angle's ongoing custodianship, her appointment didn't get over the way the company had intended.

Advertisement

With Raw leaderless, several authority figures from the show's past were brought back ahead of Raw 1000. It was all designed to lead to a big appointment on the 23 July 2012 show, with the likes of Mick Foley and Vickie Guerrero passing through the flagship.

AJ was unveiled in the end. She was one of WWE's most popular performers at the time, but the company had spent her past few character arcs portraying her as "crazy." Thus, handing her a position of power made no sense, and while some of her interactions as an unpredictable boss were entertaining, this three-month stint is best consigned to the past.

Lee's failed run ended with one of her career's worst angles, when she resigned amidst the John Cena scandal storyline that October, ending this complete waste of time on a miserable note.

7. Her Heat With The Bella Twins

When real beef infiltrates the fake world of professional wrestling, the results are rarely pretty, and the legitimate bad blood between Nikki Bella and AJ Lee made it to the airwaves a few years back.

Advertisement

Rumours of heat surfaced in August 2013, when Lee shot down the Bellas (and the rest of the Total Divas cast) in a scathing Raw promo. Scripted or otherwise, it sowed the first seeds of dissent, and Nikki clapped back the following year, eviscerating the "pathetic little girl from New Jersey" in a SmackDown promo that was ultimately edited out of the broadcast.

It continued a few months later. Among other things, AJ would chastise the twins for only returning to WWE for the reality show, using their cache with management to prevent others being pushed (herself included), and Nikki for her relationship with John Cena.

Nikki later accused AJ of turning the audience against her, but it's easy to see why they clashed in the first place. Perception was that while the Bellas had been hired for superficial reasons, AJ was a grafter, and the antithesis of Total Divas' glitz. Still, Nikki had the last laugh, breaking Lee's record 295-day Divas Title reign soon after he rival's retirement.

6. Punishment Booking

As is always the case with such tell-all publications, Lee's 2017 book, Crazy Is My Superpower, brought several new revelations regarding her time in WWE to the table, with one of the most notable built around a quarrel with the writing staff in 2012.

Advertisement

Her love triangle storyline with CM Punk and Daniel Bryan had reached its natural end. AJ's "crazy" character was already problematic enough, but creative pitched she take things to the next level, suggesting Lee start hallucinating on television. She'd kiss leprechauns, dance with dinosaurs, and that would be the basis of her character.

Yes, really.

AJ didn't see the funny side. Having experienced her own battles with mental illness (and those fought by close friends and family) throughout her life, she refused to participate in an arc designed to make light of such situations. Lee said "no thanks," and as they tend to do, WWE went into punishment mode. AJ was taken off television and the road for three full months form July to August. She wasn't injured, and management refused to provide a reason, thus leading to the assumption that it was a punitive measure.

5. The Total Divas Rant

In August 2013, two years' after her partner, CM Punk, had dropped his pipe bomb on Monday Night Raw, WWE tried to recreate the magic with AJ spouting off on the Total Divas cast. It was designed as a means of further portraying AJ as the antithesis to the supposedly superficial reality show crowd, and it was scathing.

Advertisement

As transcribed by cagematch.net:-

Do you wanna know what I see when I look in that ring? Honestly? A bunch of cheap, interchangable, expandable, useless women. Women who have turned to reality television 'cause they just weren't gifted enough to be actresses and they just weren't talented enought to be champion. I have done more in one year than all of you have done in your entire collective careers.

I have saved your divas division, I have shattered glass ceilings, I have broken down doors. Why? So a bunch of ungrateful, stiff, plastic mannequinns can walk on through without even as much as a thank you? You guys can't even walk backstage and shake my hand and looking me in the eye because you know that I worked my entire life to get here.

I gave my life to this and you were just handed fiftteen minutes of fame. I didn't get here because I was cute or because I came from some famous wrestling family or because I sucked...up to the right people. I got here because I am good. I earned this championship and you know what? No matter how many red carpets you guys wanna walk in your four thousand dollar ridiculous heels you will never be able to lace up my Chuck Taylors.

Her talk of "shattering glass ceilings" resonated, but sadly, the promo did more bad than good. It formed the basis of a feud that concluded with an AJ-led group of women falling to the entire Total Divas cast at Survivor Series, but the Bellas and co. were rocked by what they'd perceived as an unwarranted shoot from AJ. You won't see it replayed on any episodes of Raw or SmackDown for that very reason.

4. The John Cena Affair

John Cena was used as a vehicle to remove AJ from her position as Raw General Manager in October 2012. Vickie Guerrero unearthed footage of the duo cavorting, and though the two initially denied the claims, they became a romantic item soon after.

Advertisement

Lee resigned from her role. The ensuing weeks were defined by borderline unwatchable television, including multiple recorded phone calls and a poorly-acted hotel room scene, before the duo accepted their feelings for one another. Cena and AJ embraced on multiple occasions, but the whole thing was mercifully short-lived. The company canned the storyline on the basis that John had become increasingly impatient with Lee's erratic behaviour, but there was no concrete resolution: the couple went their separate ways when AJ double-crossed Cena in a match with Dolph Ziggler, and that was that.

The silver lining was that this allowed Lee to transition into her alliance with Dolph and Big E (Langston), which was one of her career's most productive periods. Still, the storyline made for some grim viewing, and the fact that it flies in the face of Cena's long-held squeaky clean image means WWE would love to delete it from history.

3. "Nobody Wants To Have Sex With You"

In another startling revelation from Crazy Is My Superpower, Lee threw damning allegations at a certain WWE Director Of Talent Relations, who reportedly branded her "unf***able" during her time on NXT's third season.

Advertisement

Her run on the reality show wasn't great. Like the rest of the participants, AJ was forced into dumb contests like "who's the best kisser?", and treated with precisely zero respect from announcers Josh Mathews and Michael Cole, who regularly chastised her for being an actual wrestling fan. Why? Because "nobody wants to have sex [with you]," apparently.

This phrase came straight from the mouth of said WWE executive, who summoned her for a meeting early in her WWE career. From his point of view, Lee was unmarketable, and despite being told that she was easily scoring the highest number of fan votes every single week, she was removed from the show soon after.

Given the time period and the job title, it doesn't take much to figure out who Lee was referring to. Nonetheless, it was a gross, cruel way to treat a talent who'd eventually become one of WWE's most popular acts.

2. Shooting On Steph

Comeuppance is rare for Stephanie McMahon, who remains WWE's most one-sided character. She's a brutal burial merchant who rarely gives anything back. Such instances are always satisfying, because they're incredibly rare, but as WWE's resident bulletproof deity, she has continually torn full-time roster members down without ever rebuilding the damage done.

Advertisement

Steph delivered a trademark tongue-lashing to Lee on the 17 June 2013 episode of Raw, ruining what should've been a title-winning celebration, and effectively sacrificing the Divas Champion to put herself over. The moment WWE would most like you to forget came on Twitter, though.

During the 2015 Oscars broadcast, Stephanie sent out a tweet congratulating Patricia Arquette for her speech on the acting industry's gender pay gap:-

A huge slice of hypocrisy from a woman with a stake in a company who'd been undermining female performers for years. Lee fired back, stating that women's wrestlers had set merchandise sales records and starred in Raw's highest rated segments, yet still received a fraction of their male counterparts' screen time and salaries, prompting a meek "thank you" response from Steph.

An embarrassing public dragging for Stephanie, but it did little for AJ, who was out of the company two months later.

1. Her Marriage To CM Punk

AJ Lee is married to CM Punk, and given that 'The Voice Of The Voiceless' is one of the top names on Vince McMahon and Triple H's backlist, this can't help her legacy in the company's eyes.

Advertisement

Married in June 2014, the duo were together for over a year beforehand. WWE once ran a storyline relationship between the two, but this was before they'd started dating in real life, and the company has never formally acknowledged their actual romance.

The promotion infamously served Punk his release papers on his and AJ's wedding day. This was one of many grim tales revealed in his incendiary appearance on Colt Cabana's Art Of Wrestling podcast, but while the company have denied doing this on purpose, it was seen as a clear sign of malice by many.

Several factors played into Lee's decision to leave the wrestling business, including permanent cervical spine damage. The feeling of being caught between her husband and employers was one of them. Now retired, it's unlikely that she'll ever mount a comeback, but if she ever felt the desire to return to the squared circle, Punk's own burned bridges could make that an impossibility.

Advertisement