10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Samoa Joe

That wet whimper of a final appearance, body issues, and Brock Lesnar battles.

By Andrew Pollard /

At it stands, Samoa Joe is the hottest free agent in the wrestling industry.

Advertisement

One of the ten names formally released by WWE just over a week ago as of this writing - 15 April, to be precise - the Samoan Submission Machine now finds himself with the wrestling world in the palm of his hand.

A two-time NXT Champion, two-time United States Champion and a Dusty Classic winner, Joe's time under the WWE banner was a fruitful one, yet there's a sense that Vince McMahon's company only scratched the surface with what they could've done with Joe during his six years under contract.

Still, it's not like Samoa Joe will be short of suitors, with him surely having the pick of the promotions when it comes to where he lands next. And what is WWE's major loss, will clearly be someone else's major gain.

As is so often the case with WWE, there are a whole host of things the company would prefer that wrestling fans immediately put out of their mind where it pertains to this former TNA World Champion - and here, then, are ten things WWE is likely eager for you to forget about the ridiculously talented Samoa Joe.

10. WWE Never Saw Samoa Joe Getting To The Main Roster

Despite how much of a big deal Samoa Joe felt like at select times during his main roster WWE run, the Samoan Submission Machine was never originally intended to be anything more than an NXT talent.

Advertisement

As Joe has explained over the years - including on the WWE Chronicle episode centred on him - one of the very first things said to him during his very first meeting with Triple H, was that Vince McMahon would never be interested in moving him to Raw or SmackDown.

Citing how Vince wouldn't be keen to push a wrestler in their late-30s on one of the company's main roster brands, Hunter was nothing if not brutally honest with Joe in that initial meeting.

The former TNA World Heavyweight Champion would clearly prove McMahon wrong, with his work in NXT obviously catching the attention of those in the upper echelon of the WWE food chain. Not just his in-ring ability and character work, mind, for Samoa Joe's first ever WWE t-shirt immediately became one of WWEShop.com's biggest sellers.

At 36 years of age, Joe made his NXT debut at March 2015's TakeOver: Unstoppable show. Two years later, he'd debut on the main roster, laying out Seth Rollins - and proving that WWE's oft-ageist approach is a total load of horsesh*t.

9. WWE Allowed Him To Work For Other Promotions

While the 'forbidden door' has seemingly been blown open as All Elite Wrestling continues to work with the NWA, IMPACT Wrestling, New Japan Pro Wrestling, AAA and others, WWE is notoriously a closed shop for the most part.

Advertisement

Sure, WWE has set up deals with the likes of wXw, EVOLVE and ICW, yet that's clearly only so that WWE can have content for the WWE Network, whilst also having an 'in' when it comes to the talents of those promotions.

What was most unique about Samoa Joe's early tenure under the WWE banner, though, was in how the one-time ROH World Champion was allowed to take outside bookings during that time.

After making his NXT bow at March 2015's TakeOver: Unstoppable, Joe actually went on to work matches for the likes of House of Glory, Xtreme Wrestling Alliance, Pennsylvania Premiere Wrestling, Impact Championship Wrestling, Prairie Wrestling Alliance, All American Wrestling, Preston City Wrestling - and he'd even challenge for Jay Briscoe's ROH World Title just a week after first appearing in NXT!

By August of that year, Samoa Joe would become exclusive to WWE, and he'd go on to win the first of his two NXT Championships the following April.

8. His Final Appearance Was P*ss-Wet In A Poncho

Samoa Joe is one of the greatest wrestlers of his generation. Even within WWE, they still had times where they presented his as a genuine big deal who could making anybody on the roster go 'night, night'.

Advertisement

Still, what is the final image WWE gave audiences of Samoa Joe? Why, that's of him standing in the p*ssing rain, wearing a poncho, while WrestleMania 37 was hit by atrocious weather.

When you think of the opportunities WWE had to really push Joe to the moon at several points across his six years with the company, that final image of the two-time NXT Champion's WWE tenure is sadly a fitting visual.

Somehow WWE bungled Samoa Joe, one of the elite 'killers' of modern pro wrestling. They had gold in their hands, but they never really even knew it.

In NXT? Sure, Joe was utilised as one of the top tier players whose back the brand was placed on during his time in the land of black and gold. Away from that, his main roster run saw Joe taken for granted - with him being viewed as someone who could be plugged in at any spot on the card, rather than viewed as someone you can strap one of your World Titles to.

Sadly, it was with a wet whimper that Samoa Joe's final WWE days came to a close, when quite easily he could've been one of those tearing it up in the ring at Raymond James Stadium earlier this month.

7. WWE Turned Him Down Due To His Body

Heaven forbid a male wrestler isn't 6'2", 250 lbs of chiselled, tanned muscle and with the looks of a Hollywood movie star.

Advertisement

For the longest period, Vince McMahon and those higher-up in WWE had a set body image in mind for their talent. Hell, even now there's still a sense of that running wild through WWE - as seen by the changes made to Keith Lee's attire when Limitless moved from NXT to Raw last year.

While WWE opted to cover up Lee's upper body once he was brought to the main roster, Samoa Joe was turned down at several points by the company due to his body type.

Joe himself has detailed over the years how Jim Ross - who famously used to head up WWE Talent Relations - outright told him that he was not the sort of talent the company was looking for.

Putting it a little more bluntly on his Something to Wrestle podcast, Bruce Prichard stated:

"I’ll tell you why he wasn’t considered. [It] was because they thought he was a fat Samoan. He looked out of shape – he wasn’t the body type that Vince liked and they felt that it wouldn’t work.”

Thankfully, places such as Ring of Honor and TNA saw the value that Samoa Joe brought to the table - and for WWE, all of this is a horrendous look for them.

6. His Huge, Acclaimed Success Outside Of WWE

In the WWE narrative, the only success and accomplishments that matter are those achieved within the confines of World Wrestling Entertainment.

Advertisement

It's rare that WWE ever fully acknowledges outside achievements, and audiences often see the company having to walk a fine line of telling you why a new talent is a big deal, yet not giving you the specifics on that 'why'.

For example, the likes of Shinsuke Nakamura, AJ Styles, Finn Bálor and the Good Brothers have usually found WWE bigging them up as having dominated "in Japan", rather than outright naming New Japan Pro Wrestling and the actual plaudits and titles won by such talents in NJPW.

There are exceptions to this, of course, with a rare mention of the IWGP Heavyweight Title by JBL upon Styles making his shocking WWE debut back at the Royal Rumble in 2016.

When it comes to Samoa Joe, WWE will want you to forget about anything the Samoan Submission Machine achieved in his pre-WWE days. Hell, they wanted you to forget that during Joe's time in the company.

In Samoa Joe, this is a wrestler who has won the respective World Championships of both Ring of Honor and TNA; who was a pivotal part of bringing prestige to ROH's famed Pure Championship; who won awards from the likes of Pro Wrestling Illustrated and the Wrestling Observer for his own performances, his matches and his rivalries; who has three of Dave Meltzer's sought after five-star ratings; and who has had absolute bangers with everyone from Kurt Angle, to CM Punk, to Nigel McGuinness, to Kenta Kobashi, to Christopher Daniels, to AJ Styles, to Brock Lesnar, to Takeshi Morishima, to Daniel Bryan, to Shinsuke Nakamura, and so many more.

Samoa Joe is good. Like, really good.

5. He Was The Samoan Joe That Fans Wanted

It's over eight years since a Samoan named Joe made his main roster WWE debut at the 2012 Survivor Series.

Advertisement

That particular Samoan Joe is Roman Reigns, of course, and WWE spent so many years trying to cement Reigns as their poster boy babyface, ala John Cena, Steve Austin, Bret Hart, Hulk Hogan and the other top 'heroes' who Vince McMahon's promotion has at times based so much of their product around.

In the case of Cena, Big Match John proved that it's truly tough to have a crowd universally pulling for a wrestler these days. And for Roman Reigns, the Big Dog found it even tougher than Cena to win over audiences who forever felt Roman was being forced down their throat.

Reigns is clearly fine these days, with his Head of the Table schtick one of the absolute best in the industry right now. But during those days when audiences were largely rejecting Roman, there was a spell where WWE finally had fans naturally clamouring to see a Samoan Joe kicking ass and taking names.

Unfortunately for WWE's plans, that Samoan Joe was indeed Samoa Joe.

As mentioned elsewhere, WWE never fully ran with the Samoan Submission Machine as a dominant main event star during his time with the company. But man, just imagine what Samoa Joe could've achieved if afforded even a small semblance of the energy and unflinching effort that went into Reigns' push.

4. The Wellness Policy Violation

WWE is clearly eager for each and every one of us to forget about any talents who fail the company's Wellness Policy.

Advertisement

Regardless of the circumstances or of how WWE cannot always be held accountable for such test failures, it's still never a good look for the company whenever they have to publicly announce that one of their wrestlers has been suspended due to testing positive for a banned substance.

For both Samoa Joe and WWE, they'd rather pretend that the talented star wasn't handed a 30-day suspension early last year.

The truth is, 25 February 2020 saw WWE formally announce this suspension, with Joe having breached the company's Wellness Policy for the first time. It has yet to be made public what exactly caused this breach.

At the time of this suspension, Samoa Joe was in the midst of a storyline that saw him alongside Kevin Owens to do battle with Seth Rollins, Buddy Murphy and AOP.

Not only did Joe end up missing WrestleMania 36 partly because of this suspension, but he never had the chance to compete again in a WWE ring before being handed his release earlier this month.

3. He Should've Been The One To Dethrone Brock Lesnar

Having defeated Goldberg to become WWE Universal Champion at WrestleMania 33, Brock Lesnar went on a mammoth 503- day reign with that title before ultimately dropping it to Roman Reigns at 2018's SummerSlam PPV.

Advertisement

The thing is, the Beast Incarnate should've have lost his Universal Championship just three months after defeating Da Man at 'Mania 33.

July 2017 saw Vince McMahon come up with the 'down with the kids' PPV idea of Great Balls of Fire. It was an awful title, the presentation of it was ridiculously cheesy, and Michael Cole forever screaming the show's title in the weeks leading up to the event was truly painful.

One of the few silver linings of Great Balls of Fire, though, is that it had Samoa Joe stepping up to challenge Brock Lesnar for the Universal Championship.

The build to this contest was fantastic, with Joe positioned as an intimidating, legit badass who was Lesnar's equal. WWE had a genuinely white-hot hoss fight on their hands, with fans eager to see the Samoan Submission Machine step over Brock and take his prize.

At Great Balls of Fire, Lesnar would retain in a fun, physical encounter that gave Samoa Joe plenty of time to shine. The argument is, of course, that Joe suddenly had such momentum behind him that he should've emerged victorious on that night.

Still, the issue between Joe and Lesnar rumbled on, with Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman thrown in to serve up a four-way Universal Championship at the following month's SummerSlam. Again though, Lesnar would emerge victorious.

Whether at Great Balls of Fire or SummerSlam 2017, Samoa Joe was the perfect choice at the perfect time to beat Brock Lesnar.

Seriously, just watch this:

2. He's Good Pals With CM Punk

Back during the early 2000s, a whole host of wrestlers were getting all kinds of buzz on the internet.

Advertisement

While names like Amazing Red, Christopher Daniels, AJ Styles, Spanky and Bryan Danielson were all making waves, two wrestlers who were leading the charge for this group of 'hot young things' were CM Punk and Samoa Joe.

Punk and Joe were putting on great match after great match, establishing their reputation as two of the hottest wrestlers on the planet. That was just when each man was competing against other opponents; when you put the two in the ring together, you would so often get wrestling gold.

These two grapplers had done battle in the years before and after, but particularly must-watch is the utterly flawless CM Punk vs. Samoa Joe trilogy that played out across the second half of 2004. With Joe as the reigning ROH World Champion, the pair battled to two 60-minute time limit draws before a third bout which saw the Samoan Submission Machine finally get the better of the Second City Saint.

Away from their in-ring battles, CM Punk and Samoa Joe are great friends in real life. So much so, the pair were quick to interact on Twitter as soon as Joe was given his WWE release.

For WWE, one has to imagine that they want as few wrestling fans as possible to be aware of this close friendship - especially with both men currently free agents and both already having teased one final showdown somewhere down the line.

1. Just How Big A Deal Samoa Joe Is

In a landscape that now offers AEW and New Japan Pro Wrestling as serious, widely accessible alternatives for wrestling fans, WWE must be worried that Samoa Joe could turn up in one of those promotions and make a serious (no pun intended) impact.

Advertisement

Speaking of which, a return to IMPACT Wrestling cannot be ruled out, of course. Then there's the genuinely mouth-watering prospect of seeing the two-time NXT Champ rocking up to turn Billy Corgan's National Wrestling Alliance on its head. Or maybe there's a stint back where it all really began for Joe, in Ring of Honor.

The point is, a fit and healthy Samoa Joe legitimately has his pick of the wrestling business.

Wherever he ends up, in whatever role that is - be that inside or outside the ring - Joe would be a huge asset to any wrestling company on the planet.

From a WWE viewpoint, they will be eagerly trying to play down just how good Samoa Joe is. After all, the less of a big-time player the former United States Champion is perceived as, the less chance he's got of making a splash in a rival company.

Being honest, the vast majority of wrestling fans have long since stopped paying attention to the narrative that WWE tries to spin on a whole variety of topics - and wherever he ends up, Samoa Joe's stock is already higher than it's ever been.

Advertisement