10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Tough Enough

In-ring beatings, psychological breakdowns and disgraced trainers from WWE's dream-making show.

By Lewis Howse /

The original season of Tough Enough made for truly fascinating viewing. While the secret was out and the business was already exposed, it was still incredible to see WWE continue to peel back the curtain and explain the mechanics of the business a little bit more. Watching Tough Enough you could learn how to execute moves, what it was like backstage at WWE events and also what WWE stars were like out of character (wrestlers frequently made guest appearances on the show). You never knew who would turn up on Tough Enough. You also never knew just what would happen. The show was genuinely unpredictable and was host to a lot of memorable incidents. While it's unknown just how much of it was actually scripted (the company clearly knew who their winner was before the show started) there was a certain air of spontaneity about it that was lacking on Raw or Smackdown. Of course, not all of these unpredictable incidents were welcomed by WWE. They may have made for great television at the time, but they cost them in the long run. Reputations and careers have been ruined or cut short because of Tough Enough. WWE may want to promote it as a 'once in a lifetime' opportunity to live a dream but, for some, the dream was closer to a nightmare.

10. The Triple H Speech

Oh man, the Triple H speech from Tough Enough season one. This did nobody any favours. You could see the intention: take a top star and lecture the rookies on the passion it takes to make it in the business. The fact that Triple H was a heel at the time made it even better. In theory. In practice, Triple H just comes across like a bit of a jerk. He shows them how to bump and punch with intensity, which is fine. But the way he's lecturing the 'kids', you would think he was a twenty year veteran like a Terry Funk. When Triple H delivered the speech, he had only really been a top guy for a year or so. If Triple H was to give the speech now, after a further fifteen years of ring wars, it would have more weight to it. But back then, it just looked like another transparent attempt by WWE to make The Game look like the biggest badass on the planet. It failed. The speech made for good TV, sure, and Triple H made some good points. But it said more about Triple H's opinion of himself than it did about the omiture of the show.

9. One Of The Season 3 Contestants Had A 'Psychotic Breakdown'

Remember Lisa from season three? No? Well, there's a good reason for that. Lisa, a nondescript blonde who never had a hope of winning the competition, only appeared in the first two episodes. During the third episode contestants (and the audience) were told that Lisa had decided that wrestling wasn't for her. Phrases such as 'her mind gave in before her body' were used to describe what happened. Boy, you can say that again. It wasn't a simple case of Lisa feeling a little bit of stress: she had a full-on psychological breakdown. When the rest of the house and trainers were out eating Lisa reportedly stayed behind and started throwing herself into the walls. After that little episode she found the MTV control room, made her way onto the roof of the house and had to be talked down by producers. When her parents came to collect her, she physically attacked them, claiming she had no idea who they were. After that episode, she escaped custody in LAX airport, causing a whole wing to be shut down while attempts were made to find here. But the fun didn't end there. Some time later, Lisa made her way to OVW and claimed that Al Snow and WWE had sent her there for further training. It was untrue. Not taking the hint, Lisa found a way to get backstage at WWE events in September 2002, where she helped set-up the pyro for the events and even had a face-to-face conversation with Vince McMahon. Once WWE officials finally caught onto what was going down and a picture of Lisa circulated amongst WWE security.

8. Daniel Puder Nearly Breaks Kurt Angle's Arm

Daniel Puder became a huge star - in some circles - after an incident on the November 4th, 2004 Smackdown. After trying to exhaust the contestants with squat thrusts and other exercises, Angle challenged the 'winner' (Chris Nawrocki) to a shoot wrestling match. Angle easily won, breaking one of Narwocki's ribs in the process. Angle then challenged any other member of the group to step up and Puder, who had a professional MMA fight with Strikeforce under his belt, accepted. Locking Angle in a very dangerous Kimura, Puder had the Olympic Hero at his mercy. It was only quick thinking from Jerry Brisco (who knew what was going on) and referee Jimmy Korderas that prevented Angle from having his arm broken. Whilst in the Kimura, Angle managed to take Puder down to the mat where Korderas counted a quick three count, even though Puder's shoulders weren't properly on the mat. Angle was understandably annoyed afterwards, asking Puder if he was 'f***ing stupid' and going ballistic backstage. What's most incredible about this incident is that Angle didn't tap out while in the Kimura and was seconds away from potentially having his arm broken. It was stupid of Puder to do it, but he was only reacting to the situation. WWE shouldn't have placed Puder (or Angle) in that situation.

7. Kevin Dunn On-Camera

Here's something you don't see every day: a picture of WWE executive producer Kevin Dunn. Dunn is Vince's longtime right-hand-man, and an extremely powerful person in the WWE. He has been a fixture of WWE for more than twenty years and can, allegedly, help make or break careers. Dunn, who joined WWE's board of directors in 2008, clearly doesn't like his picture being out there. He doesn't even have a picture of himself on WWE's Executive Officers page of their corporate website. But his face was all over Tough Enough, even on episodes that are now freely available on the WWE Network. You can see Kevin Dunn on-camera in the first couple of seasons. He was involved in the initial casting of the show and helped to whittle down the thousands of applicants to the final list of contestants. Dunn says things like 'I don't like him at all' and made sure John Morrison didn't get through in season two because he felt like he was being 'patronised' by him. Later on in season two, the contestants received a chance to have one-on-one conversations with Dunn (and his buckteeth).

6. Just Because You Don't Win Doesn't Mean You Won't Get Signed

The main draw of Tough Enough, at least for prospective contestants, was that the winner would receive a WWE contract. The whole point of the show was for the budding grapplers to prove that they were 'tough enough' and deserved a shot at WWE stardom above all others. It is supposed to be survival of the fittest. The best of the best. In reality, however, even if you don't win the competition, if WWE sees anything in you they're going to sing you regardless. Knowing that going in must be a boost to some of the competitors. From season one, Chris Nowinski and Josh Matthews were signed, even though Maven and Nidia won. Matt Morgan was snapped up after season two, despite the fact Jackie Gayda and Linda Miles won. Marty 'The Boogeyman' Wright and The MIz were signed from season four, when Daniel Puder was crowned winner. WWE won't want fans knowing this. How are they supposed to get invested in the drama when, if WWE likes somebody from the show, there's nothing stopping them from signing them. They even signed Cameron from season five, and her favourite match of all time was Alicia Fox versus Melina.

5. Hazing The New Guys

Whilst WWE is a much different place than it was during the first four seasons of Tough Enough, you can be that certain performers are going to be a little bit jealous and wary of anyone who makes it to the company via the competition since they haven't properly 'paid their dues'. While it can hardly be considered their fault for accepting a reality television gig and a lucrative contract, wrestlers cannot take it out on management so they take it out on the wrestler. That's what happened with pretty much everyone from Tough Enough who made it to the main roster in the past. They were hazed, tested in the ring and backstage. Maven said during his post-release shoot interview that Hardcore Holly 'beat the s***' out of him at house shows for months. Chris Nowinski was also roughed up in the ring when he debuted on Raw in 2002. The cuts and bruises from house show matches were clearly visible when Nowinski performed on WWE TV. The most blatant of these hazings came on-camera at the 2005 Royal Rumble. Daniel Puder was entrant number three. Entrants number one and two? Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero. Puder was like a lamb to the slaughter. After a couple of minutes of chopping, his night got worse when Hardcore Holly entered number four. They just destroyed Puder, cutting his chest open and taking turns chopping him. Announcer Jim Ross made no secret of what was going on. Incidentally, Holly already disliked Puder because Puder had been calling his friends and telling them that he beat Holly for real after Holly put him over on house shows. So he kinda deserved it, really.

4. Former Winner Was In Rehab

Whatever happened to original Tough Enough winner Maven Huffman, anyway? The guy was being groomed for superstardom at one point. WWE wouldn't allow just anyone to eliminate The Undertaker from the Royal Rumble, you know. Then in 2003/4 it looked like he was going to become a member of Evolution and form an association with Triple H. And then...nothing. Maven's career just kind of petered out (as he was jobbed out). After his July 2005 release, Maven hit the indie scene and did some shows for the TNA-affiliated UWF but, after that he just kind of disappeared from the wrestling business. So what was actually up to? Developing a serious addiction to oxycodone and hydrocodone, by all accounts. Maven was arrested in Florida in 2012 after he had been caught 'doctor shopping' (going to various doctor's offices to get more pills than he was prescribed). He was released on a $2,000 bond and faced up to five years in jail. Realising he needed help, Maven underwent WWE-sponsored rehab and cleaned himself up. He now works in medical sales and has recently begun appearances on the convention circuit. Still, WWE won't want people knowing that their inaugural winner became an addict and ended up in rehab.

3. The Disgraced Bill DeMott Was A Head Trainer

WWE want nothing at all to do with Bill DeMott these days. The former Hugh Morrus was embroiled in a scandal in early 2015. Several of DeMott's former trainees came forward and levelled some pretty heavy accusations against him, including unsafe training methods, homophobia and other abuse. Big Bill's face is all over seasons three and five of Tough Enough, where he acted as a head coach. Although Bill's training methods were above board when he was on-camera and he toned down his drill sergeant routine, there were still the odd questionable moments. Such as when DeMott broke down on camera following the Bob Holly/Matt Cappotelli incident. Addressing the group in a house meeting, DeMott got serious and delivered the following speech, while fighting to hold back the tears:
There are motherf*****s who are going to push your buttons...every night on the road, people push my buttons, I wanna kill 'em. Because as a man, I've swallowed more than my share. The bigger men swallow s*** that they don't wanna swallow. You can chose to beat it, or to let it beat you
It was pretty haunting stuff. DeMott has clearly had some issues with guys ribbing him in the past. WWE isn't going to mention the fact that DeMott was a former trainer on the show, given recent events.

2. There Has Been No Truly Successful Winner

When WWE devised Tough Enough, they probably thought it was going to find the next superstar on the level of Steve Austin or The Rock. Considering Tough Enough was originally shown on MTV and did excellent ratings, they more than likely assumed that they could make their guy a 'TV star' before eventually making him a 'wrestling star'. But nobody who has won Tough Enough has come close to approaching that level. The most successful contestant, The Miz, didn't even win it. Season one winner Maven looked promising but never fulfilled his potential. Co-winner Nidia only lasted a couple of years and, while she was good in her role as Jamie Noble's girlfriend, she was as expendable as he was. Miss Jackie and Linda Miles never made any waves in the business. Jackie was too similar to other divas and Miles apparently developed a massive ego and was hated by her peers. They're both no longer active in the business. John Morrison had some success but, like Maven, he never really lived up to his true potential while his season three co-winner Matt Cappotelli's career was cut short due to a brain tumour. WWE never truly forgave Puder for the Angle incident and, when they thought he wasn't improving quickly enough in OVW, let him go in September 2005, before his year-long contract ran out. And what about Andy Leavine from season five? First he didn't properly sell a slap by Vince McMahon or a Stone Cold Stunner during a Raw segment, then he failed WWE's wellness policy. He was released in April 2012, having never wrestled a match on WWE TV.

1. The Bob Holly/Matt Cappotelli Incident

Bob Holly had a long career in WWE. He was involved in some really good matches and was a hard worker. A good company man, if you will. But he will be forever known, to most people, for an incident in which he appeared to rough up Tough Enough season three contestant Matt Cappotelli. Holly, who is as surly as they come, took umbrage to the Tough Enough trainees horsing around in the ring during some downtime. He singled out Cappotelli as the biggest offender and proceeded to give him an a**-whooping during a six man tag match. Stiff at the best of times, Holly's offense looked even stiffer because Holly would not stay still while he was being beat down, causing Holly to catch him in the eye and mouth. Cappotelli came out of the match with a black eye and bloody lip. Later in the episode, he broke down on camera and had to be convinced to stay in the competition. Holly was widely vilified in the wrestling press and on the internet. He was branded a bully but he didn't really care. In Holly's opinion he was 'protecting the business' and has said that he would do it again. WWE received some complaints and it caused a little bit of a scandal when it aired. WWE won't want you remembering this. Whether you think Holly was in the right or the wrong, it got WWE a tonne of bad publicity at the time and several top stars (such as Triple H) publicly renounced Holly's actions. An incident such as this one isn't likely to happen during the forthcoming season of the show.