10 Times A Special Guest Referee Actually Improved A Wrestling Match

Hey, look, officials who actually DO something.

By Jacob Trowbridge /

In the typical wrestling match, the referee is about as important as the ring apron. Sure, without them, everything would look a little "off," but from an entertainment standpoint, they offer little to the match itself. Referees are ignorant, mostly invisible, and recently, even nameless phantoms that haunt the ring and occasionally get the attention of the medical staff if something goes horribly awry. So it's not necessarily that hard for a special guest referee to earn their title and make the proceedings a little more memorable. Anytime the company wants to toss a little extra flash into a match or add another obstacle for one of the competitors to overcome, just use a special guest referee. At their worst, the inclusion of the special refs have no real purpose other than adding some more star power to the card. (After all, Mike Tyson made the happenings before WrestleMania pop, but how much did he actually add to the match between Stone Cold and Shawn Michaels?) Yet, at their finest, the inclusion of a special guest referee can raise the stakes, intensify the drama, and most importantly, inflate the entertainment value to a whole new level.

10. The Mega Powers Vs. The Mega Bucks (SummerSlam 1988) - Ref: Jesse Ventura

Jesse "The Body" Ventura (dressed that night as Jesse "The Casual Pirate" Ventura), who had been relegated to the announce booth for some time, was chosen as the special guest referee by the team of Ted DiBiase and Andre the Giant, who declared Ventura the only "fair and neutral" option. (Villain speak for "someone we can pay off.") The announce team of Billy Graham and Gorilla Monsoon painted him as aggressively incompetent throughout the entire match, and it's glorious to hear Graham, who invented the flamboyant muscleman gimmick Ventura would later adopt, repeatedly spit, "Jesse, do you job, man." But the moment it was really necessary to have someone like Ventura officiating occurred at the end of the match, when Miss Elizabeth casually took off her skirt to distract Andre, DiBiase, Bobby Heenan and Virgil, giving her guys Hogan and Savage time to recoup on the outside of the ring. They needed a red-blooded, self-professed "sex machine" as a referee to forget the rules (forgoing the requisite 10-count) at the sight of some well-toned butt cheeks. Ventura was the perfect choice, and sold his dumbfounded excitement perfectly.

9. The Rock Vs. Triple H (Judgment Day 2000) - Ref: Shawn Michaels

It's never a bad idea to have an animated referee during an hour-long Iron Man Match. It just gives the audience a little something extra to pay attention to during the slower moments. (Not that there were too many of those during this excellent display, but still.) Michaels sold every move with dramatic cringing, acting like most of the fans in attendance who just happened to get thrown a ref's shirt and asked to officiate just before the match started. The violent maneuvers were given even more pizzazz thanks to Michaels and his expressive face and visible shudders. Of course, the most famous moment from this particular round of HBK-as-REF involved the ridiculous amounts of interference coming from DX, The McMahons, and pretty much anyone else in back that wasn't already half in the bag by the end of the night. To counteract the 6-on-1 beating that this devolved into after Michaels was incapacitated (while trying to keep order because, remember, there was no love lost between HBK and HHH at the time), The Undertaker came out to the ring to clean house. But Michaels cleared the cobwebs just in time to see Taker give the Tombstone to Triple H, which by rule, gave the deciding win to Hunter.

8. Hulk Hogan & Mr. T Vs. Paul Orndorff & Roddy Piper (WrestleMania I) - Ref: Muhammad Ali w/ Pat Patterson

This was a much more efficient use of an "enforcer" as a referee. Not only did his involvement make sense from a practical standpoint (two referees in a tag team match that promised this much anarchy seems like a no-brainer), but if you're going to go all-in with the Rocky tie-ins, you might as well have the real-life Apollo Creed there, as well. The crowd was almost as pumped for Ali's entrance to the ring as they were for Mr. T and Hogan. But unlike the Tyson example, Ali was truly a "guest" star here, used primarily just to watch the outside of the ring and make sure nothing got out of hand. The first WrestleMania main event had animosity oozing out of its pores, with Piper and Orndorff raising the stakes of how much heat two guys could possibly get from a crowd, doing so by causing chaos and breaking the rules at every opportunity. WWE really wanted to sell just how insane this match could get, and that's where Ali's mere presence is appreciated. They told fans right from the top that this would be too hectic for Pat Patterson alone to keep order, and proved Ali's usefulness right out of the gate. Once both teams started going at each other (with added outside interference from Bob Orton and Jimmy Snuka), Ali stepped right into the mix, breaking things up with a couple of jabs to Piper, and the promise of a knockout punch to Orton if he got out of line again.

7. Shane McMahon Vs. Vince McMahon (WrestleMania 17) - Ref: Mick Foley

Mick Foley doesn't have the best track record when it comes to being a special guest referee. Normally, he acts as the standard, down-the-middle official, which you might notice, is literally the same role as every regular referee in the WWE. It's like they just really want to use his theme music and showcase his homemade referee shirt. And for much of this match, we saw that same version of Referee Foley. He mostly stood by and watched the proceedings, only breaking up a random catfight between Trish Stratus and Stephanie McMahon after watching from the sidelines for a couple of minutes (presumably trying to disguise his erection lurking in those sweatpants). But then Vince got that crazy look in his eye, and appeared hellbent on doing something awful to his catatonic, wheelchair-bound wife. That's when Foley inserted himself into the melee, getting in Vince's face and backing him down. This led to Vince rapping Foley with a couple of genuinely frightening chair shots. (That one to the head brought on flashbacks of the Rock vs. Mankind I Quit Match.) Though he was laid out for a couple minutes, Foley eventually regained consciousness and started a massively satisfying assault on Vince, pummeling him into the ring post and setting Shane McMahon up for a jaw-dropping Coast to Coast missile dropkick. And that is a good of a reason as any to include him on this list.

6. Bret Hart Vs. The Undertaker (SummerSlam 1997) - Ref: Shawn Michaels

This was the first time we all realized that Shawn Michaels could add some serious depth to a match, just by putting on a skintight, black and white polo shirt. Just a few short months before the infamous Montreal Screwjob, Michaels was the special guest referee between Hart and Undertaker. He was threatened with a ban from wrestling in the United States if he didn't call the match impartially, which was a nifty angle to play. Michaels may have been trying his damnedest to remain impartial, but every time Hart got in his face over what he perceived to be a slow count or some other unfair judgment, the crowd popped with anticipation of these two going at it. But it all went relatively smoothly, right up until the last 10 seconds. Michaels was laid unconscious while Hart used a chair on the Undertaker. HBK didn't officially see it happen, but saw the dented chair in the ring and called Hart out for it. Hart then spat in Michaels' face, which was enough to break HBK's vow of neutrality. He wound up to take a swing at The Hitman, who ducked, leaving Undertaker to take another lump to the head. Michaels had no choice but to make the 3-count and declare Hart the winner, which intensified their feud, and became the jumping off point for the HBK vs. Undertaker Hell in a Cell match a couple of months later.

5. Umaga Vs. Bobby Lashley (WrestleMania 23) - Ref: Stone Cold

The conceit of this match was about as dumb as they come: A "hair vs. hair" match between Donald Trump and Vince McMahon, with Lashley and Umaga basically acting as avatars for the two obnoxious millionaires. (Of course, there are much more racist tones to view this idea through, but we'll just leave it at that.) What J.R. referred to as "hands on officiating," others might view as being "the enforcer," which is certainly how Stone Cold applied himself in this match. Whenever things got out of hand and someone (usually Umaga) tried to ignore the rules, The Rattlesnake didn't just get up in his face, he physically made them heed his warnings. This also allowed for some welcome physicality between Stone Cold and Vince (and Shane...and whoever else got in his way). And although the in-ring action between Umaga and Lashley was pretty terrific, the stakes surrounding it often fell flat. Thankfully, Austin was able to elevate the match and add some much-needed grounding. Basically, Stone Cold saved what might have been one of the tackiest gimmick matches in recent history.

4. The Undertaker Vs. Triple H (WrestleMania XXVIII) - Ref: Shawn Michaels

Hey, look at that, another match with Shawn Michaels as the referee. Kinda seems like this guy knows his way around a ref uniform. This was one of the better, most intense buildups for a special guest referee this side of Mike Tyson, with Michaels giving a barrage of promos that really touted his involvement in what would become "the end of an era," even referencing how Undertaker ended his own career a couple of years prior. The action inside the ring was meager, to put it nicely. Unfortunately, on the biggest stage of them all, both Undertaker and Triple H failed to live up to the physicality of their match at the previous year's WrestleMania. In fact, with the exception of a couple well-placed spots (specifically, a series of barbaric chair shots to a defenseless Undertaker), most of the high drama came from Shawn's involvement. It wasn't Hunter's vicious assaults on the Undertaker that worked (we'd seen him do this kind of thing a million times before), it was HBK stepping in to protect Taker, while struggling with whether or not to end the match. Watching Shawn make the count on his old friend, and kneeling beside him after the match was finished, was an emotional moment. And that hug he gave to Undertaker? Jeez. Tissues were in short supply that night.

3. The Rock Vs. Triple H (Smackdown, 1999) - Ref: Shawn Michaels

By now it should be obvious that Michaels' presence just seems to make a lot of things better, which is why he's no stranger to popping into the ring as a ref. (Also, it was the ideal way to utilize him in small portions while letting him nurse his back injury.) But in this particular match, Michaels wasn't just some added flair wearing bike shorts. He was the damn maestro. Michaels was pretty much doing visual commentary throughout the match, feeding the action with every motion. And as the Commissioner, Michaels did everything he could to appear impartial for the duration of the match, keeping Shane McMahon from interfering and even going so far as to eject Chyna from ringside after he caught her giving The Rock a low blow. But as The Rock had the match (and WWE Championship) all but won, he went to drop The People's Elbow...only to be met with Sweet Chin Music from the guest referee. It was a shocking moment that paid off because Michaels had played the beats so convincingly before that. The superkick truly seemed to appear out of nowhere, and gave us one of the most surprising finishes to a match in Smackdown history.

2. Stone Cold Vs. Dude Love (Over The Edge 1998) - Ref: Vince McMahon

Inserting Stone Cold's arch rival, Mr. McMahon, as the official in this title match was a stroke of genius by WWE's creative team. Not only did it increase the obstacles for the Rattlesnake, positioning him firmly as the underdog, but it gave him someone else to play off. Vince couldn't even pretend to be unbiased, since one of the guys in the match was literally his worst nightmare, but the multiple altercations between Foley and McMahon leading up to the match at least added a sense of unpredictability. Would Dude Love attack McMahon again, even though they'd formed something of a truce recently? Would Vince find a way to screw both of the competitors over? It was an interesting dynamic. But it was McMahon's mid-match decision to turn the ordeal into a No Disqualifications Match (coincidentally just as Love was ready to put Austin through the announce table) and then a Falls Count Anywhere Match (just as Love delivered a neckbreaker on the ramp), that proved how entertaining it was having an antagonistic referee in the bout. There was also the requisite "Oops, Foley inadvertently hit the ref with a chair" moment, which was a bit predictable, but it led to Austin using an unconscious McMahon's arm to make the 3-count while pinning Foley, which made it worthwhile.

1. Triple H Vs. British Bulldog (Smackdown, 1999) - Ref: The Rock

Do me a quick favor. Try to remember literally any moment from this match between Hunter and the blue jeans-wearing British Bulldog that doesn't directly involve The Rock. This was a title match for the WWE Championship, and yet the star of the match wasn't even a competitor. The Rock (along with his sunglasses), stole the show with his endlessly entertaining brand of contempt. He sarcastically applauded their finishing moves rather than make a 3-count, repeatedly ignored low blows and other illegal maneuvers, and even opted to switch roles into commentary at various points. But the defining moment came went Rock went to make the count in favor of the Bulldog:
"One... two... It doesn't matter if the Rock counts to three!"
It was the biggest pop of the night by far, and preceded an epic beatdown on both competitors by The Great One. And after the dismantling, he went ahead and stole the belt for good measure.

The Undertaker Vs. Kane (Judgment Day: In Your House) - Ref: Stone Cold