10 Times ECW Went Way Too Far

From dangerous stunts to misogyny, ECW wasn't all awesome.

By Kieran Shiach /

The influence ECW had on professional wrestling cannot be understated. Even after all the books, the reunion shows, the documentaries (both official and otherwise), ECW's lasting legacy is that it provided the raw tools for both WCW and WWF to succeed as greatly as they did during wrestling's most prosperous period. Paul Heyman's keen eye for talent, and maniacal business methods masterminded a revolution. In ECW, everyone had a place. If you wanted to be there, Heyman would find something for you to do. Whether you were high-flying, brawling, technical or hardcore, ECW was the place to try new things and force the entire wrestling world to catch up to the rest of nineties pop-culture. While Heyman undoubtedly succeeded in this venture, sometimes ECW went too far in the name of revolution. ECW is remembered unfairly for being the "hardcore" promotion when it was so much more than that, but it's always going to be the stuff that crosses the line that gets remembered, and ECW had that in abundance. A lot of the time it was just the case of the audience not being ready for that type of storytelling, but on too many unfortunate occasions real people got really hurt. Here are just ten examples of ECW going just too far in their quest to entertain.

10. Sandman Takes Kayfabe To A New Level

By early October 1994, Sandman and Tommy Dreamer had become fierce rivals, and it had all built up to an I Quit match between the pair. During the brawl, Sandman took time to gloat and lit his trademark cigarette but during Tommy Dreamer's comeback he accidentally knocked the object into the Sandman's eyes, supposedly blinding him. What happened next proved that while Sandman may not have been anywhere near the best in the ring, his commitment to the sport was unquestionable. He disappeared from public life, took no phone calls and had his wife answer the door at their home. He stuck to this for weeks, until November To Remember 1994 when during Sandman's retirement party he revealed it had all been a ruse to trick Tommy Dreamer into doing his dirty work under the belief he was doing it in The Sandman's honour. This is one of the most memorable ECW because it shows how deep and devious Paul Heyman's genius goes, and how convincing of a leader he can be, which is a theme that will certainly reoccur when discussing ECW for any length.

9. The Flaming Towel

When you talk about Extreme, and you talk about Hardcore, you start with Terry Funk and Mick Foley. The two men have pushed the limits of their bodies for as long as fans can remember, but this incident at a live event in 1995 might have been too much even for them. At the time, Cactus Jack was a cowardly heel trying to convince Tommy Dreamer not to follow the ECW dream, and to go to WCW where he could make money and retire comfortably. Terry Funk was in Dreamer's corner, Raven would eventually show up to even the odds, and naturally it all broke down. Foley and Funk wanted to replicate a spot they had done in Japan, where they wrap a kerosene soaked rag around a steel chair and use it as a weapon, and that's where everything went wrong.
Well, when Funk swung the chair, the towel broke loose, and the fire was bigger than they thought. It burned the rope that tied the towel to the chair. The towel came off the chair and flew onto Funk's back. Funk rolled out of the ring. His shirt was on fire. A fan reached over and tried to put him out. Funk burned his arm pretty good, but the fan really burned his fingers. - Paul Heyman (The Rise and Fall of ECW)
The fan would later sue the company unsuccessfully, and Paul Heyman would go on to apologise for the incident, promising to never use fire in ECW, a promise that would not last that long. Mike Johnson of PWInsider, who was there that night, even said "A lot of people were freaked out by that incident and I don't blame them as I remember being furious that evening. If you were in the building that night, you would have thought it was the end of ECW ... It was easily the worst moment in the history of the company."

8. Joey Styles' Unfortunate Remark

You know the story about Madusa going to WCW with the WWF Women's Championship? And you know about how terrified Vince McMahon was of Bret Hart doing the same thing with the WWF Championship? Well it actually happened with Mike Awesome and the ECW Title. Mike Awesome was ECW Champion, but refused to sign a new contract citing owed wages from Paul Heyman, and he signed with WCW joining the New Blood. An injunction was filed to stop Awesome appearing on WCW television with the title, and a convoluted compromise was reached where Mike Awesome (a WCW wrestler) would lose the ECW Championship to Tazz (a WWF wrestler) on an ECW show. Unfortunately, that's not the only controversy here. When WWE put on their first One Night Stand event, he wrestled Masato Tanaka, and it seemed like no-one was happy to see him. While he eventually won over the crowd, Joey Styles was aggressivley hostile on commentary about Awesome, to the point it was just uncomfortable, including saying "Suicide Dive by Mike Awesome, and it's a shame he didn't succeed in taking his own life" Tragically, Mike Awesome did in fact kill himself two year later, adding a much larger layer of sadness on what should be a very enjoyable match. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LLrulcZ9UXY

7. "Thank You Sir, May I Have Another"

In 1994, Paul Heyman was having a tough time getting Tommy Dreamer over as a babyface. Everything he tried, including making him the only person to ever kick out of the Superfly Splash, just made the fans hate him more. Around the same time, an eighteen year old American student in Singapore named Michael Fay was sentenced to caning for vandalism. This quickly became massive news across the country, and gave a madman in Philadelphia an idea. Heyman arranged a "Singapore Cane" match between The Sandman and Tommy Dreamer, with the loser having to take ten lashes with the cane. Thanks to the interference of Woman, Sandman got the victory, but comissioner Tod Gordon attempted to restart the match due to the interference. Tommy Dreamer refused this decision, and chose to take the lashes to prove he wasn't just a pretty boy. Sandman's shots were so vicious he broke part of the cane, and split Tommy's back on the first blow. Fans watched on as Dreamer refused Woman's compromise to kiss her feet instead of the lashes, and some even begged Tommy to stay down. Dreamer took every single shot, even goading The Sandman on by quoting Kevin Bacon in Animal House with the immortal words "Thank you sir, may I have another." Finally, Tommy Dreamer was a star in ECW. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1lgRniDpH3o

6. Bill Alfonso Nearly Dies To Save His Job

In 1997, ECW was rocked when it was discovered that Tod Gordon was conspiring with WCW's Terry Taylor to recruit a bunch of ECW talent and jump ship. While the only person to go to WCW as a result of this was Perry Saturn, referee and manager Bill Alfonso was apparently the most enthusiastic about the proposed jump. When the plan was discovered by Paul Heyman, the decision was made that Fonzy would have to leave the company. At ECW: As Good As It Gets in October '97, Tommy Dreamer and Beulah McGillicutty faced off against Rob Van Dam and Bill Alfonso, with the plan being for Dreamer and RVD to take each other out and the match left in the hands of, essentially, non-competitors. What happened next was, what Paul Heyman described on Talk Is Jericho as "Five of the most intense realistic minutes in ECW history." During those five minutes, Alfonso was accidentally cut along an artery and lost and unreal amount of blood. Heyman said in the same interview that Fonzy lost so much blood, he should have died. When the smoke cleared, and it was apparent that Bill Alfonso wasn't going to bleed to death, Paul Heyman conceded that after the performance he just gave, he couldn't in good conscience fire the man and Fonzy kept his job.

5. Chair-maggedon

In one of the most replayed, memorable moments of ECW history, Terry Funk and Cactus Jack got a little more than they bargained for when they tried to partake in some audience interaction. At Hardcore Heaven 1994, The Public Enemy interfered in a match between Funk and Cactus and attacked both men. As the hardcore legends fought back against the Enemy, Terry Funk asked for a steel chair from the crowd. What happened next is one of the most surreal images in wrestling history, as dozens and dozens of chairs flew into the ring, so many that they completely buried The Public Enemy. While it's an exciting visual, and no-one was too hurt, knowing what we know about steel chairs now it's kinda scary. Terry Funk takes chair to the back of the head and immediately uses it as an opportunity to fall down and roll the heck out of the ring, but if that chair had been and inch lower, or at a different angle it could be an entirely different story. ECW got lucky that this incident went as well as it possibly could, and thankfully everyone made it out of the ring okay. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRFqhmm9xHA

4. Shane Douglas Trashes The NWA World Heavyweight Championship

In the tradition of Lou Thesz; in the tradition of Jack Brisco; all of the Brisco Brothers; of Dory Funk Jr, of Terry Funk, the man who will never die; and the real €œNature Boy€ Buddy Rogers upstairs tonight. From the Harley Races, to the Barry Windhams, to the... Ric Flairs, I accept this heavyweight title. Wait a second... wait a second, of Kerry Von Erich, of the fat man himself Dusty Rhodes... this is it tonight Dad, God that's beautiful...and Rick Steamboat... and they can all kiss my ass! In August 1994, a tournament was held to crown the new NWA Champion, and Paul Heyman was looking for ways to expand NWA Eastern Championship Wrestling into something more than a regional territory. The NWA settled on ECW Heavyweight Champion Shane Douglas as the man to carry the gold, and the tournament was hosted by ECW. Only Paul Heyman, Tod Gordon and Shane Douglas knew what would happen from there. Douglas threw the title to the ground, and christened himself the first ECW World Heavyweight Champion. This move shocked the wrestling world, and put ECW on the map instantly, and set the standard for the ECW product going forward for the rest of the decade. Not long after this incident, they would rebrand as Extreme and never look back to their time in the NWA. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kpEjrKqf3s

3. Too Hot For TV

More than any other rivalry, Raven and Tommy Dreamer is probably the defining feud of ECW's history and it was all over a girl. Beulah McGillicutty was the "fat girl at camp" who pretty-boy Tommy had rejected and had sided with Raven. Over the course of the angle, Beulah dropped Raven and went with Tommy, claiming to be pregnant. She was replaced with Kimona Wanalaya, but she quickly dumped Raven as well and sided with Shane Douglas. When Douglas faced Raven for the ECW Championship, he dropped a bombshell on the ECW crowd. Not only was Beulah not pregnant, while Beulah was cheating on Raven with Tommy, she was also cheating on Tommy with Kimona. Beulah then came out to the ring and writhed around on the mat making out. This was far too much for television stations and advertisers to handle at the time, and even though the kiss never made it to TV, it was still too controversial and according to Tommy Dreamer on Paul Heyman's new documentary DVD, it got them thrown of every single network they were on. While homosexual representation is important in all forms of media, this stunt was crass and exploitative. It wasn't about the lesbian couple, it was for the heterosexual 18-35 year old male ECW audience to salivate over. Dreamer's later comments of "I'm hardcore, I'll take them both" are equally crass and devalue both female characters' worth as people. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x370kc_ecw-lesbian-kiss_fun

2. Raven Crucifies Sandman

In October 1996, Raven and The Sandman had been engaged in nearly a year long feud that got as personal as it could get when Raven had turned Sandman's own son Tyler against him. During The Sandman's match against 2 Cold Scorpio at High Incident, Tyler interfered to help his father win the match. As they embraced, Raven attacked Sandman with a singapore cane, and with the help of Stevie Richards and Blue Meanie, proceeded to tie him to a wooden cross and place a crown of barbed wire thorns on his head. At this time, Kurt Angle was considering entering the pro wrestling industry, and he was a hot commodity as his Olympic success was only months old at that point. He had been invited to the ECW show by Shane Douglas, but when he saw the Raven/Sandman segment, he stormed out demanding that his likeness never appear on the same show. While pretty much everyone believes Paul Heyman knew about the angle, he swore that he didn't. On the same show, he made Raven go out to the ring and apologise to the fans and wrestlers that he may have offended with his use of religious iconography. Further controversy arose between Raven and other roster members, as Raven is Jewish making his use of Christian symbols even more charged. Raven however claims he was merely "using religious iconography to convey an artistic standpoint." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEwyLIiSlAs

1. The Mass Transit Incident

At an ECW live event in November 1996, Axl Rotten was not there as scheduled for his tag team match with D-Von Dudley against New Jack and Mustafa Saed. An untrained seventeen year old named Erick Kulas convinced Paul Heyman that he was a wrestler trained by Killer Kowalski, and he wrestled under the disgruntled bus-driver gimmick "Mass Transit". Kulas looked much older than his seventeen years as he was over 350lbs and nearly six foot tall, and he was vouched for by a wrestler that Heyman knew. During the match, New Jack bladed Kulas and The Gangstas began to beat him down, leading his father to shout "Ring the fucking bell. He's 17!" at which point medics intervened to take care of Kulas while New Jack continued to play up to the crowd.
I don't care if the motherfucker dies! He's white. I don't like white people. I don't like people from Boston. I'm the wrong nigger to fuck with.
In the subsequent civil trial, many wrestlers came to New Jack's defense and stated that Kulas had given him permission to perform the bladejob. A camcorder recording of the incident reveals New Jack asking Kulas "You alright?" which reinforced New Jack's defense that he wasn't actively out to injure the teen. A jury acquitted New Jack of all charges in the criminal court, and all he was ruled as not liable in the civil case against him. Everyone was at fault here. Heyman should absolutely not have booked he had no knowledge of, regardless of his age. Kulas should never have stepped foot into a wrestling ring without any training, and New Jack should not have agreed to blade someone he didn't know. The entire incident is the worst thing to ever happen in ECW, and a serious black spot on the company's legacy. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xu5dq_ecw-mass-transit-incident-full-matc_sport