10 Times TNA Succeeded Where WWE Failed

Sometimes the grass really is greener on the other side of the pro-wrestling fence.

By Martyn Grant /

It’s impossible to argue that TNA has been anything but a distant second to WWE since it began in 2002. However, it's often forgotten that the unloved runt of the industry litter has done a lot of good for the wrestling world since the demise of WCW and ECW in 2001.

Advertisement

When there was nowhere else to go, TNA gave wrestlers an option. When the WWE product was stale, TNA gave viewers an alternative. Most importantly, when WWE squandered a talent, TNA gave performers a stage.

While WWE is universally regarded by workers as the place to go and the ultimate goal for any wrestler worth his salt, Vince and co. don’t always have the golden ticket for everyone. There can only be so many men that make it to the main event of WrestleMania and not everyone is going to get the push of a Steve Austin or a John Cena.

For every WWE home run, there’s a thousand strikes. Luckily for the wrestling industry, TNA has usually been there to pick up whenever WWE has dropped the ball and a large number of wrestlers have flourished in TNA after floundering in WWE.

Let’s flip the script and recount ten times that TNA succeeded where WWE failed.

10. Matt Morgan

Matt Morgan’s run in WWE was so disastrously underwhelming, it’s virtually been buried in WWE history ever since it ended.

Advertisement

Originally debuting as part of the monolithic Team Lesnar at the Survivor Series ‘03, Morgan quickly slipped out of view, appearing sporadically on Smackdown until late January 2004. Despite still being under contract, he didn’t return again until mid 2005, where he was given the gimmick of a stuttering giant. Thankfully, the gimmick died quickly and he was gone for good by July.

After a spell overseas, Morgan finally made his way over to TNA for what would become the run of his career. Debuting as Jim Cornette's backup, Morgan became a singles star in 2008 and took on the moniker of 'The Blueprint'. Articulate, huge, and exuding charisma, Morgan had all the tools to become a superstar.

After several weeks of squash matches, Morgan won the Tag Team Titles with Abyss before eventually feuding with his partner in 2009. Later that year, Morgan would also feud with Kurt Angle, culminating in a marquee match at Bound For Glory ‘09.

Morgan would subsequently become a member of Ric Flair's Fortune stable before joining Hulk Hogan in Immortal thereafter. Although unsuccessful, Morgan also received several shots at the World Championship throughout his TNA tenure.

9. Monty Brown

In the early days of TNA, Monty Brown was one of the most colourful homegrown talents on the roster. A former professional footballer, Brown was no stranger to the spotlight, having competed in Super Bowl XXVIII for the Buffalo Bills.

Advertisement

With his leopard print outfit, his electric persona and his devastating finishing move - The Pounce - the man nicknamed “The Alpha Male” quickly became a TNA standout. Brown seemed on course for an eventual run as World Heavyweight Champion; however, despite several attempts he was never able to win the big one.

Nevertheless, Monty Brown was a big time player in TNA, constantly feuding with headline acts, from Sting and Christian Cage to Rhino and Samoa Joe. Sadly that acclaim would come to an end when he signed with the WWE in 2006.

Bizarrely renamed Marcus Cor Von, Brown debuted as part of the ECW brand. Cor Von became part of ECW’s New Breed stable and made his one and only WrestleMania appearance in 2007 in an 8-man tag between the New Breed and the ECW Originals.

After feuding with CM Punk, Cor Von took a sabbatical for what was reported as “family issues” and never returned. He was released from his WWE contract three months later and never wrestled again.

8. Scott Steiner

The Scott Steiner of latter day WCW was the ultimate badass of wrestling. Sadly, when he entered WWE, it was quickly evident that that wasn’t going to be the case with Triple H around. While his initial debut was met with huge excitement, by the time he stepped into the ring with 'The Game' at Royal Rumble ‘03, Steiner was exposed and a far cry from the “Big Bad Booty Daddy” of WCW.

Advertisement

Truthfully, Scotty was suffering from drop foot syndrome at the time, with severe nerve damage in his foot, leaving it virtually numb. Meanwhile, Triple H was also coming off a partially torn quad in late 2002, which didn’t help matters. Instead of protecting Steiner, they placed him in an impossible situation, which ultimately resulted in a steep decline for WCW’s last big star.

When Steiner arrived in TNA in 2006, he was a new man. With his razor tongue re-sharpened and his head in the game, Steiner became an asset to TNA and did a lot to get over younger talent, from Petey Williams to Samoa Joe. Steiner performed better than anyone predicted and regularly had the Impact Zone in awe, as he began to dust off his tricks from yesteryear, including the Top Rope Frankensteiner and the Steiner Screwdriver.

7. The Knockouts

In 2007, WWE’s Women’s Division was a far cry from the Women’s Revolution we know today. With their females still labelled “Divas”, the WWE’s female sideshow was just that. An over-reliance on models with no prior wrestling experience made matches almost unwatchable and saw the Women’s Championship around the waist of some seriously dubious champions.

Advertisement

TNA countered WWE’s Divas with the newly-founded Knockouts Division - a completely opposing presentation of women’s wrestling. While there was still a healthy presence of T&A in TNA, the Knockouts put a strong focus on athleticism and, believe it or not, actual wrestling.

The division began to pick up steam by centering around intriguing match-ups and feuds, most notably Gail Kim’s rivalry with Awesome Kong. The two quickly established the division as something worth tuning in for and paved the way for a host of great women wrestlers to follow.

With stars like Sarita, Tara (WWE’s Victoria), and Taylor Wilde, TNA offered athletic contests with wrestling that wasn’t just watchable but enjoyable, more akin to Trish Stratus and Lita than Kelly Kelly and Layla. Along with great acts like The Beautiful People, TNA capitalised on the strength and depth of the division by also introducing the Knockouts Tag Team Titles, which lasted from 2009 until 2013.

6. The X Division

When TNA debuted the X Division as their glorified rebrand of WCW’s Cruiserweight Division, fans were naturally sceptical having seen WWE drop the ball spectacularly with their own Cruiserweight Championship. Luckily, any initial scepticism was eradicated within seconds of the first opening bell.

Advertisement

Lightning fast action, incredible high spots and aerial manœuvres the likes of which had never been seen made the X Division must-see viewing. Better yet, it gave TNA something that WWE didn’t have and gave smaller wrestlers an opportunity to become stars.

TNA placed a lot of emphasis on the X Division in the early days and gave their X performers centre-stage and time to shine. This proved infinitely wise and the first few years of TNA were exemplified by the action of the X Division and the wars over the X Division Championship.

As they often said, the X Division was about “no limits, not weight limits”. While a somewhat confusing statement itself, it did open up the door for stars like Samoa Joe and Kurt Angle to mix it up with top "cruiserweight" talent. The division gave birth to stars like Christopher Daniels, Low-Ki and AJ Styles, who would all go on to become huge stars of the league after been given WWE tryouts prior and never been picked up.

5. Bobby Lashley

When Bobby Lashley debuted in WWE, he had everything that Vince McMahon looks for in a main event star. He was big, he was athletic, and he was ripped to the bone; sadly for the audience, the one thing he lacked was mic skills.

Advertisement

Lashley saw a meteoric rise in the WWE and, within a year, had won the United States Championship. He would also go on to hold the ECW Championship twice in the WWE’s revived version of the Philadelphia brand, and memorably appear as Donald Trump’s surrogate wrestler in the Trump vs. McMahon “Battle of the Billionaires” at WrestleMania 23.

Nevertheless, Lashley never seemed to truly connect with the audience and was gone by mid-2007, having been fed to John Cena at the Great American Bash and suffering an injury thereafter. He was quietly released in early 2008. Lashley would appear sporadically for TNA throughout 2009 and early 2010 with little impact, attempting to spread himself between wrestling and MMA at the time.

However, when he returned in 2014 as a heel, he seemed refocused and won the World Heavyweight Championship within months. As champ, Lashley became a better performer all-round, with vastly improved mic skills and smoother wrestling ability. Lashley has become a true asset to the company ever since.

4. ECW Alumni

The day ECW folded in 2001 was a dark day for the industry, bringing an end to one of the most iconic companies in wrestling history.

Advertisement

It also spelled trouble for a lot of talent that had plied their trade in the land of extreme. Stars that had been World Champions in ECW would never reach the same level of success in WWE and, for the most part, barely saw a main event. Treated largely as afterthoughts, the ECW alumni would commonly flounder in the midcard of WWE as a means of advancing the perceived “real stars” of WWE.

The same cannot be said for TNA. When former ECW royalty made their way over to Nashville, they were treated as stars and many of the men that had once been so integral to ECW were once again given a fair shot at making it once more.

Former ECW Champion Jerry Lynn immediately became a key player in the X Division and is immortalised in the history of the promotion as one the X Division pioneers. Meanwhile, heavyweight headliners of ECW like Raven and Rhino, neither of whom were given a fair shot at the main event in WWE, quickly became woven into marquee matches after their arrival and both became World Champions shortly after.

3. EC3

When Mike Hutter first appeared on WWE TV as Derrick Bateman, he was a young wrestler with a good look and seemingly a bright future ahead of him. Appearing on Season 4 and later Season 5 of the original NXT format, he regularly featured on the show and was beginning to become a fixture of the developing WWE brand.

Advertisement

Sadly for Bateman, his career with WWE wouldn’t last and he would be gone by mid-2013. However, within months, Bateman made his debut in TNA as Dixie Carter’s spoiled nephew, Ethan Carter III. With that, EC3 was born.

EC3 made an immediate impact in Impact Wrestling, debuting at Bound For Glory and defeating a number of jobbers in the weeks that followed, establishing himself as a hated heel. Over the next year, Carter began to make a name for himself as a genuine talent in TNA, facing the likes of Eric Young, Samoa Joe, and Bully Ray.

Carter eventually graduated to headliner and defeated Kurt Angle for his first World Heavyweight Championship in June 2015. Carter has since become a two-time World Champion and is now a staple of the TNA/GFW roster, considered by many as a homegrown talent of TNA Wrestling.

2. Bully Ray

Repackaging an established tag team act as a singles star is one of the hardest feats in pro wrestling. While countless tag team specialists have flopped as singles in the past - from Bart Gunn to Road Warrior Animal - a select few have gone on to become stars in their own right, with Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart as the two ultimate examples.

Advertisement

As such, when Brother Ray and D-Von went their separate ways in TNA, few predicted that either man would flourish without the other. With Team 3D being such an established tag team, it was going to take a lot of work to get them over as a singles commodity.

WWE had tried and failed at this in 2002 with the original WWE draft. Bubba Ray Dudley was a floundering mid-card act on Raw while Reverend D-Von was a floundering mid-card act on SmackDown. Inevitably WWE gave up on the split and reunited the team a year later. Thankfully, TNA were far more steadfast in their approach.

Bully Ray was born out of the ashes of Team 3D and would go on to become one of the best heels in the business. With two reigns as World Heavyweight Champion, Bully Ray rose to the occasion and surpassed all expectation, achieving unrivalled career success in the process.

1. Sting

The last true holdout from WCW never to appear in WWE, Sting finally made the switch to Vince McMahon’s group in 2014.

Advertisement

In a realisation of everyone’s worst fears, the WCW talisman would go on to be totally misused in WWE. They needlessly changed his iconic music, overdubbed his voice in vignettes and completely over-booked his debut match against Triple H at WrestleMania, which coincidentally he lost. To make a bad situation worse, his next big bout wouldn’t arrive for six months and resulted in a career-ending neck injury. All in all, a regrettable run if there ever was.

Conversely, Sting’s time in TNA was peppered with highlights from the moment he arrived and his career saw a complete resurgence under the TNA banner. Sting quickly became one of the poster boys of the Nashville brand and gave the company a legend’s credibility when it needed it.

With several World Title runs, classic feuds and great matches, Sting turned back the clock and gave fans a taste of his glory years, a decade out of his prime. His bouts with Kurt Angle, Joe, and AJ are particularly memorable, while he can also lay claim to wrestling both Ric Flair and Hulk Hogan in their final televised bouts.

Advertisement