10 Times Vince McMahon's WWE Pet Projects Failed Him
Vince genuinely thought Bobby Lashley was going to be one of the biggest stars ever...
According to the Wrestling Observer, Vince McMahon doesn't really understand what all the fuss is about when it comes to Sami Zayn. That shouldn't surprise many who have followed McMahon's career as the patriarch of WWE. Vince definitely has his own ideas in mind for what being a prototypical 'WWE Superstar' entails.
Guys like Zayn don't cut it if that template, one preoccupied with bulging muscles and an emphasis on size, is to be believed. Of regular height, realistic muscle proportions and average looks all round, the current fan favourite lacks the 'larger than life' aesthetic that McMahon generally favours.
When analysing Vince's top pet projects over the years, it becomes clear that muscles and size are important to him. Hulk Hogan, The Ultimate Warrior, Batista and John Cena are all notable examples of men McMahon saw as being instant, face-of-the-company superstars.
For the most part, it's a system built on what has drawn the company money. Hogan and Cena, for example, are undeniable success stories, pulling in millions for the McMahon family.
Yet, there are those that must be considered failures. These 10 men were all pet projects of Vince, never quite reaching the potential the WWE owner had in mind for them...
10. Nathan Jones
It's not difficult to see why Vince McMahon was interested in Nathan Jones. Standing around 7ft tall and with muscles aplenty, the gigantic Australian also had one hell of an interesting backstory: during the mid-1980's, he became involved in numerous armed robberies and was considered one of Australia's most wanted men.
Spending time in a maximum security prison, Jones was the kind of real-life fodder that would have at one point been perfect for The Big Boss Man. WWE didn't have to put too much thought into his character when they signed him in 2002, it just had to be crazy.
An early, Hannibal Lecter-esque persona didn't last long before WWE tried to pair Jones up with The Undertaker. Unfortunately, aside from looking the part, the big man lacked the basic fundamentals necessary to wrestle actual matches. That would hurt him in the end, as he'd show no signs of improvement by the end of 2003, despite time in developmental and working television and pay-per-view matches.
Tired of the hard travel and backstage politics in WWE, Jones elected to walk away from the promotion at that point. He never lived up to the potential his look promised, much to the disappointment of WWE's head hancho.
9. Ezekiel Jackson
Before an influx of world-class talent moved from the independent scene to WWE, the company were finding it difficult to create their own stars. Developed in the old Florida Championship Wrestling system (pre-NXT), Ezekiel Jackson was another musclebound performer who definitely had the right look to warrant a WWE push.
Initially, Jackson played the role of bodyguard to The Brian Kendrick, before moving to the failed ECW brand. There, he'd eventually become ECW Champion, the last in WWE's lineage of the title before it was abandoned. That wouldn't be the last championship management would put on the man in an attempt to get him over.
A member of The Corre in 2010, he later feuded with former stable mate Wade Barrett over the Intercontinental Title. At the Capitol Punishment pay-per-view in June, 2011, Jackson defeated Barrett to bag the gold. Meanwhile, fans were less than convinced by the guy.
Numerous injuries, including muscle tears that necessitated surgery, got in the way of WWE's plans. In April, 2014, Ezekiel left the company, never really managing to make the most of the push he was handed.
8. The Giant Gonzales
Of all the men on this list (including Nathan Jones), The Giant Gonzales arguably had the least amount of wrestling ability. Admittedly, his gargantuan size did play a part in that, but the former basketball player rarely looked athletic. Wearing a ludicrously cheesy 'monster' outfit during his appearances, the giant felt out of place even in the cartoonish WWF of 1993.
Whilst the likes of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels were having tremendous matches with all comers, The Undertaker was saddled with The Giant Gonzales. At WrestleMania IX and SummerSlam 1993, the pair had some of the worst bouts in memory. They followed on from the guy's run as El Gigante in WCW, which was equally as drab.
Debuting at the '93 Royal Rumble, Gonzales never showed anything worthwhile. His push was one based on sheer size and nothing else, never coming close to producing the magic of previous giants like Andre The Giant.
By late-1993, Gonzales was gone. His run hadn't been a success by any means, once again letting Vince McMahon know that wrestling fans desperately wanted faster wrestlers, ones capable of high levels of performance inside the ring.
7. Vladimir Kozlov
Squash matches do have a place in pro wrestling, even now, but surely the wrestler chosen to benefit from them has to be worthwhile. With Vladimir Kozlov, that wasn't the case, as he was ill-equipped to cope with the high expectations WWE had for him in 2008. Such misplaced faith would lead to one of the year's worst title matches.
At the Survivor Series in November '08, Kozlov awkwardly tried to follow the lead of Triple H. Before Edge interrupted and bagged the title, the match was failing badly. For anyone complaining about the pushes of guys like Roman Reigns now, at least Reigns can work lengthy matches.
Kozlov couldn't, and didn't really take to pro wrestling despite a genuine combat background. He was another WWE tried repeatedly to get over, even having him defeat The Undertaker cleanly on an episode of SmackDown. That exercise proved fruitless, because people just didn't buy into the guy.
A comedy tag-team with Santino Marella was the best part of his entire WWE run, one that ended in 2011. WWE really tried to push Kozlov, but either he wasn't ready or good enough to succeed.
6. Bobby Lashley
By 2005, WWE had experienced some success with the likes of Randy Orton, John Cena and Batista. All had developed into crucial members of the main roster, promising years of potential main event stardom to come. That same year, the company tried in vain to add Bobby Lashley to that list.
During his near 3-year tenure in the promotion, Lashley won the ECW Title twice and the United States Title once. Much like many others on this list, he had a definite upside. Looking absolutely excellent from a physical standpoint, Bobby just didn't connect with the audience at all. Personality, or lack thereof, was a real problem.
Lashley was even chosen to represent Donald Trump in the 'Battle Of The Billionaires' at WrestleMania 23. Going against Vince McMahon's representative, Umaga, he was a featured part of the largest show of the year. That was his biggest moment in WWE before being released in early-2008 following a spell on the sidelines with a shoulder injury.
He did challenge for the WWE Title in 2007, but it was almost as though those in charge had mentally moved away from Lashley even then. That lack of connection with fans hurt him.
5. Fandango
There was a time when Fandango was being sent over on media duty to the UK, appearing on Sky Sports as an ambassador for WWE. Hyping upcoming tours, he was a hot ticket for the briefest of periods. Unfortunately for the dancing man, such star appeal was limited in scope, and didn't last too long.
Much of Vince McMahon's fanfare over Fandango seemed to stem from the actions of fans on the Raw broadcast post-WrestleMania 29. On that show, Fandango had defeated Chris Jericho, a huge win for his career. Come Raw, fans were in a party mood, dancing and singing along with the man's infectious entrance music.
That caused a stir in WWE and McMahon felt like he could capitalise on the online interest to create a new star. This idea didn't last very long, either, as fan interest started to wane and WWE decided to stop featuring Fandango so heavily.
A unique entry on this list, Fandango didn't appear to be the kind of wrestler McMahon would put a whole load of focus on. For a short while, he did, but it didn't lead to much success for the wrestler overall.
4. Mabel
Undoubtedly one of the worst main events the pay-per-view series has ever witnessed, Diesel's WWF Title defence against Mabel at SummerSlam 1995 was the pits. It wasn't a match many fans particularly wanted, but McMahon put the weight of the WWF machine behind the big man at the King Of The Ring.
Ahead of others in the tournament like Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker, 'King' Mabel was crowned. A popular mid-card babyface in the early-to-mid-1990's, Mabel was part of Men On A Mission with his partner Mo. They were an attraction, but not one that could be turned into main event box office.
That's something McMahon found out when he tried to push Mabel into the headline pack. Fans rebelled on the idea, something not aided by the fact the man was utterly atrocious inside the ring.
Mabel couldn't live up to the WWF's hype during matches, and his main event experiment was all but over by the end of the year. That wasn't soon enough for those believing the awkward big man (who injured numerous peers) had no place in main events.
3. Ahmed Johnson
After trying to force guys like Mabel into the main event scene, it was clear that the WWF roster was thin on the ground. Vince McMahon didn't have too many options, but he looked hopefully at the incoming Ahmed Johnson to click with fans and spark some interest in what was a failing product.
Debuting in late-1995, Johnson was another thick and muscular performer who had raw potential. Sadly, he was another who was prone to being reckless inside the ring. Stiff and clumsy, Ahmed had a nasty habit of either injuring himself or hurting opponents during matches.
Upon winning the Intercontinental Title from Goldust at the 1996 King Of The Ring, it seemed only a matter of time before Johnson would be chasing the WWF Title. Kidney issues would get in the way of that, and Ahmed's star was never the same following a feud with Faarooq in 1997.
Joining The Nation Of Domination that year, a hasty heel turn didn't last. Shortly before WrestleMania XIV, he was released from contract. Another pet project hadn't been able to cut it in the long run.
2. The Ultimate Warrior
The disappointment was clear on Hulk Hogan's face as he handed the WWF Heavyweight Title to his opponent, he realised what the conclusion of WrestleMania VI signified. Vince McMahon believed that 'Hulkamania' was yesterday's news, and he was interested in promoting The Ultimate Warrior as Hulk's successor.
Heading into the new decade of the 90's, the WWF crowned Warrior as champion and decided to put full focus on making him the man. It was never destined to last, Warrior and McMahon clashed several times regarding money over the next few years. Meanwhile, Hogan dipped his toe back in after he was called upon to return to the promotion.
By 1992, Warrior was out of the picture for good. All in all, his time in the sun was remarkably brief, and he hadn't been able to properly supplant Hogan as the WWF's top star.
A return in 1996 was similarly short-lived, and it was obvious (to everyone aside from McMahon) that the company had moved on from the main event style Warrior was used to working.
1. Lex Luger
Just as The Ultimate Warrior had been geared for the same purpose, 'All American' Lex Luger was another response from McMahon to the success of Hulk Hogan. Portrayed much the same way 'Hulkamania' had been, Luger's patriotic pandering was arguably even more sickening. Despite the incredible hype, it didn't work out.
Initially, Lex wasn't even supposed to be an in-ring wrestler for McMahon. Signing as the face of the World Bodybuilding Federation, he stepped between the ropes once that experiment flopped. Following a short run as a heel, he was magically transformed into the WWF's next big babyface project.
At SummerSlam 1993, Luger failed to win the WWF Title from the massive Yokozuna. That's where the hype began to fade. Whilst Lex still stayed in the main event picture, he was never given a run with the top belt in the promotion.
Painting a brilliant picture, the louder cheers garnered by Bret Hart at the 1994 Royal Rumble showed that fans weren't fully invested in Luger. People wanted Hart to succeed much more, and McMahon was listening.
What other WWE pet projects can you think of that failed in the end? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!