For a long time, WCW was the place to go for "real" pro wrestling. In its previous incarnation as Jim Crockett Promotions, under the NWA banner, it was the alternative to Vince Jr's cartoon wrestling. It was where men, manly men, like Harley Race, Arn Anderson and Magnum T.A. fought about real issues and legitimate grievances. This was always WCW's selling point, and even in the mid-nineties during the Monday Night War, it was the place to go for the best wrestling. Nothing on WWF television could compete with the Crusierweight division's athleticism and innovation and the transformation of Sting was a unique, unrivalled experiment in long-form storytelling. As unwieldy as it did eventually get, there's a reason the nWo were once the coolest thing in professional wrestling. Unfortunately though, WCW had its fair share of problems like everyone else. Whether it was with violence, bad taste or poor booking decisions, WCW managed to go too far a lot of the time. The quest to be the best can often lead to rash decisions, or clouded judgment, and here are just ten examples of WCW not knowing quite when to stop.
10. Dusty Rhodes' Bloodbath
In November 1988, Jim Crockett sold Jim Crockett Promotions to Ted Turner who quickly renamed it World Championship Wrestling. To begin with, Turner left well alone, leaving the people who knew wrestling to govern themselves. One of these people was "The American Dream" Dusty Rhodes, who was the booker for JCP and remained booker after the transition to WCW. One of the few rules Turner did put in place was that there was to be no blood on his television shows, which Dusty swiftly ignored. On the lead-up to Starrcade 1988: True Gritt, Dusty booked an angle where he was stabbed in the eye by Road Warrior Animal, who used one of the spikes from his shoulder pads. It was one of the bloodiest moments in Dusty Rhodes' career, which considering that dude's forehead, is saying something. With this being a huge feud leading into the first WCW PPV, Turner let it play out for a month until Rhodes and Sting's match with the Road Warriors but Dusty was promptly fired after the event. One of the biggest criticisms of WCW over the years is lack of managerial structure, with aspects of the company not knowing what the other is doing, and you can clearly see this was a problem from the start.
9. The Human Torch Match
Sometimes wrestling feuds stem from complex, interesting narratives with years of backstory and character motivation. Sometimes wrestling feuds stem from "Hey, both those dudes wear facepaint." Sting and Vampiro formed a tag-team called "Brothers In Paint" that quickly dissolved when Vampiro attacked Sting and cost him the WCW United States Championship. The rivalry lasted a couple of months until it reached the "Human Torch" match as The Great American Bash 2000. At the climax of the match, Sting and Vampiro fought to the top of WCW's big screen and Sting swaps out with a stuntman. Vampiro then lights the stuntman on fire, who crashes through from the screen onto the stage area. While at least WCW had the sense enough to get a trained stuntman take the fall, any angle involving a wrestler falling from a great height should have been immediately nixed in the wake of Owen Hart's tragic death, which was still all-too-fresh in the memories of fans and wrestlers alike. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IgCQc5N8A3g
8. The Renegade
The Renegade, and WCW's handling of the character could easily be two separate items on this list. Firstly, his introduction was one of the most disappointing debuts in wrestling history. As Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage were feuding with The Dungeon of Doom, Hogan teased "The Ultimate Surprise" accompanied with a silhouette of a man with long hair and tassels (the implication obviously being Ultimate Warrior). The idea of the three biggest stars of the eighties teaming up as a stable was extremely exciting to fans at the time, and when it turned out to be The Renegade, it was a huge disappointment. Secondly, many people criticise WCW for putting too much pressure on the young wrestler's shoulders. He was expected to live up to the legacy of one of the most iconic performers in the history of wrestling, and when he inevitably couldn't measure up, he was cast aside by WCW. He was released by WCW sometime shortly after his last match on December 7, and just over two months later he committed suicide.
7. Judy Bagwell On A Pole
Okay, so not just Judy Bagwell, this is just the most egregious example indicitive of a wider problem. That being, late-era WCW's obsession with "...On A Pole Matches". It's a match that has become synonomous with Vince Russo's tenure in the company, and the running joke is now that you can tell Russo is behind an angle if it ends up with something on a pole. The infamous Judy Bagwell on a Pole match came about when Buff Bagwell was feuding with Kanyon, who was stalking the former WCW Tag Team Champion, and mother of "The Stuff", Judy Bagwell. Kanyon kidnapped Judy and brought her out on a forklift, because in his words, there wasn't a pole strong enough in the country. Despite interference from David Arquette (Making his first appearance in this article) Bagwell successfully defeated Kanyon and won his mother back. Other examples of this overplayed gimmick involve Viagra on a Pole between Billy Kidman and Shane Douglas as part of a storyline where Douglas had erectile dysfunction, Leather Jacket on a Pole between Tank Abbot and Big Al, and the horribly offensive Pinata On A Pole match featuring WCW's luchadores including Psicosis and Juventud Guerrera among others.
6. Virgil Joins The NWO
Once again, this isn't just about Virgil joining the nWo, but his membership is the earliest and most obvious example of how unwieldy nWo membership would quickly become. In the beginning there was Hall and Nash, then Hogan, followed by DiBiase, The Giant and Syxx. All of those make sense, you can rationalise why that character would want to join nWo, and why in turn, the stable would want them to join... but Virgil?! The name Virgil came about as a rib on Virgil "Dusty Rhodes" Runnels, so when he jumped over to WCW, he became Vincent as a shot back towards McMahon. His arrival as the nWo's Head of Security opened the floodgates for anyone and everyone to don the black and white, as he was followed by Eric Bischoff, Buff Bagwell, Michael Wallstreet (IRS), Big Bubba Rogers (Big Boss Man) and Scott Norton. The nWo only got crazier and more bloated from there, as they split into nWo Hollywood, nWo Wolfpac. They later reformed in the wake of the Fingerpoke of Doom, with a B-Team like something out of nineties X-Men comics. By the time nWo 2000 comes into play, it's best to just give up trying to keep track of it because they'd successfully ran the coolest thing to happen to wrestling in an age completely into the ground.
5. Bash At The Beach 2000
Vince Russo's spent the majority of his time at WCW trying to redefine kayfabe and use the fans new knowledge of wrestling's inner workings against them. It didn't go so well. It's hard to tell how much of what happened was planned, and how much was spontaneous, but here goes... Vince Russo was a big supporter of Jeff Jarrett and wanted him to win his WCW World Heavyweight Championship match against Hulk Hogan. Hogan had a creative control clause and decided he didn't want to put Jarrett over. Russo turned this into a story where at Bash at the Beach, Jarrett simply laid down for Hogan to pin him. The plan was then for Russo to fire Hogan, and declare Jarrett the true WCW Champion, with a Champion v Champion match later down the line. When it was time for Russo to cut his promo, Hogan and Bischoff had already left. Russo's tirade against Hogan was extremely negative and inflammatory, and he announced Booker T v Jeff Jarrett for the "real" WCW Title later that night. In the wake of this, Hogan sued Russo for defamation of character but the case was quickly dismissed. It's generally considered that everything up until Hogan leaving was a work, and everything after was a shoot, with Russo double-crossing Hogan knowing he wasn't in the arena. However revolutionary Russo tried to be, it backfired on him by confusing the fans and the boys, as well making sure Hogan never appeared on WCW again.
4. Monday 4th January, 1999
One of Eric Bischoff's and WCW's most well-tested battle plans during the Monday Night War was to learn the result of the pre-taped episodes of Raw, and reveal them on air. This proved to be the biggest misfire in the entire war, and possibly the last nail in the WCW coffin. On January 4th, 1999, Tony Schivone announced
"If you're even thinking about changing the channel to our competition, fans do not, because we understand that Mick Foley, who wrestled here one time as Cactus Jack, is gonna in their World Title. Huh! That's gonna put some butts in the seat!"
What was intended to be a flippant remark about how unnecessary Raw was proved to be WCW's undoing as reportedly 600,000 fans switched the channel to see if Mrs. Foley's Baby Boy was really going to win that title. That's not all though, as January 4th, 1999 saw the infamous Fingerpoke of Doom incident where instead of clashing for the WCW Championship, Kevin Nash sold a finger-poke from Hogan like a knock-out blow, allowing Hogan to win the title and reunite the nWo. These two factors came together to decide the fate of the Monday Night War, as WCW never won the ratings battle again from this point onwards. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGOvL4TQACM
3. Robocop
Crossovers between wrestling and mainstream popular culture are to be expected. It was WWF's Rock 'n' Wrestling Connection that helped launch WrestleMania and become the international powerhouse they are today, but WCW took entirely the wrong tact in 1990. Sting, who was still in his bright orange surfer days, had been feuding with the Four Horsemen, and needed back-up so he enlisted the help of Detroit's greatest hero, the one man war on crime: Robocop. After weeks of teasing an alliance between the Stinger and Robcop, it all came to a head at Capital Combat 1990. The Horsemen locked Sting in a cage and out came Robocop to tear the door off and chase away the heels. This would have been ridiculous almost anywhere in wrestling, but for WCW it was a major blunder. WCW always prided itself to be the alternative to Vince Jr's Cartoon Wrestling, and bringing in a fictional cyborg character just breaks the fiction of wrestling in a way WCW had never really seen before. Unfortunately, this wouldn't be the last time. Eight years later, Chucky, the serial killer doll, would cut a promo on Rick Steiner.
2. Dubious World Champions
Another terrible example of WCW getting cross-promotion with mainstream media entirely wrong is David Arquette's title run. Arquette was (and still is) a huge wrestling fan, and was appearing on WCW promoting his latest film Ready 2 Rumble. He ended up in a match tagging with DDP against Eric Bischoff and Jeff Jarrett, with the stipulating being whoever got the pin won the title. Arquette pinned Bischoff, and won the title from his own tag team partner. Luckily, he only kept the title for just under a month before turning heel on DDP and allowing Jarrett to win it from him, but it was the final straw in the eyes of many WCW fans. It's worth noting that Arquette knew the reaction he would get, and was opposed to becoming the champion. He also donated all of his WCW pay to the families of Owen Hart, Brian Pillman and Darren Drozdov. Unfortunately, this wasn't just a one-time blunder by late-era WCW management. In 2000, Vince Russo had booked himself into a steel cage match for the WCW Championship with Booker T. The match ended when Goldberg interfered and speared Russo through the cage, causing Russo to win the World Championship. Although he would surrender it the next day, this cavalier attitude to one of the most respected championships in professional wrestling didn't sit well with the fans at all. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a3g37-9nu_g
1. Oklahoma
The most appalling and insensitive thing WCW ever did, was the introduction of the character named Oklahoma. Played by former WWF and then-current WCW writer Ed Ferrara, Oklahoma was a bad Jim Ross impression that openly mocked him for his Bell's Palsy. Everything about Oklahoma stunk, and it was an awful, thinly veiled attempt for Russo and Ferrara to air their grievances about WWF on WCW Television. They took it even further when Oklahoma won the WCW Cruiserweight Championship, completely devaluing what had for a long time been WCW's most exciting and legitimate division. While Ross has since made amends with both Russo and Ferrara, even inviting them both separately onto his podcast, The Ross Report, many fans still see it as the lowest of the low when it comes to WCW. There was always going to be shots fired between the two companies, but for the most part it had always remained civil. Mocking a man for his disability was completely over the line, and turned many fans off the WCW product for good.