10 Times WWE Creative Ruined A Wrestler's Gimmick

Don't fix what isn't broken to begin with.

By Kevin Wong /

For a WWE wrestler, the road to the top can be rough. Even a surgeon on the mat or a natural entertainer on the mic has to get over with the fans. And in today's post-kayfabe era, that is far easier said than done. Fans, even casual fans, are now aware that everything they see in the ring is pre-determined and choreographed; thus, it's much harder to emotionally invest the viewers in the storylines. 

Advertisement

Even if the wrestler manages to get over, he doesn't want to win too much, lest he is perceived as a handpicked champion, nor does she want to lose too much, lest she be written off as a buried has-been.

So the fans are a tough, tough crowd. But even if they cooperate, the WWE itself can be the worst hindrance of all. And it's not for lack of trying; there have been several times that the WWE has 'helped' wrestlers in the worst possible ways, or scripted awful ideas that make their once promising superstars look stupid.

Gimmicks and characters are fragile things, and when a wrestler is forced to change the very things that got him or her over in the first place, it's usually not a good idea. Here are 10 Times When WWE Creative Destroyed A Wrestler's Gimmick. If it isn't broken, then it's probably not a good idea to fix it.

10. Mr. Kennedy

This guy was pegged as a future World Champion from his debut year. He had everything — the looks, the old school wrestling style, the unbelievable promos, and that indefinable 'it' factor that characterizes all great superstars.

Advertisement

But then, he got drafted to Raw, and it all went to hell in a hand basket. Vince thought that Kennedy was too 'funny' to be a heel, and asked him to change his promos, stop chewing gum, and erase the eccentricities that made him a Smackdown! star. Vince wanted clear 'good versus evil' — no 'tweeners.' And whenever Kennedy was funny, Vince thought that it blurred the line too closely.

Pretty soon, Mr. Kennedy would march to the ring, and not even reach for the microphone — his biggest weapon, his mouth, had been taken away from him, and he was now a generic babyface instead of a funny heel. Combine that with his ill-timed injuries, his Wellness suspension, and an unfortunate bump with Randy Orton, and Mr. Kennedy was on borrowed time.

 After two years of false starts and stops, he was 'future endeavored' in 2009.

9. Lance Storm

Let's be real: Lance Storm is not the most charismatic guy in the world. He's sort of... stoic? But if you're a booker, there are ways around that. You could focus on his technical wizardry. You could make him a strong, sociopath, who talks a little and broods a lot. You could even take it in a comedic direction, and make him the foil to a zany tag team partner.

Advertisement

In other words, you cover for the guy's weaknesses. One thing you shouldn't do is call the guy 'boring' on national television. But that's exactly what 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin did to Lance Storm during the Invasion angle. It was a bizarre oversight; Stone Cold attacked the man instead of his character. 

And if Stone Cold himself thinks Storm is boring, then why, exactly, should the fans care about him either? It cemented a negative perception of showmanship over technical quality. And in many ways, that preference for sports entertainment over wrestling continues today.

8. Hakushi

727553

When this guy debuted during the New Generation Era, he was a breath of fresh air. 'The White Angel' had an incredible presence; those rolled on Japanese characters were badass, his martial arts kicks looked fantastic, he had a long, undefeated streak that gave him legitimacy

Advertisement

But after his first major feud against Bret Hart, Hakushi turned face, and he started doing backstage skits with perennial jobber Barry Horowitz. Hakushi's character was now a wide-eyed, immigrant pupil, and Horowitz was teaching him about American culture. 

Around the same time, Hakushi started losing a lot, to both midcarders and jobbers; everything that had once made him mysterious and scary had been thrown in the garbage. He left the company a short time afterwards, without having won a single WWE title.

7. Emma

We love when the NXT women get called up to the main roster, but we're also terrified by what could happen. That's because down in NXT, females are accorded the same respect as men — Bayley and Sasha Banks will be main eventing the next NXT Takeover.

Advertisement

Meanwhile on Raw, female wrestlers (or Divas, as the WWE condescendingly calls them) fight for screen time. Though a little better now — the Divas Revolution angle is an excellent start — but the booking could still use some polish and forethought.

Emma is a cautionary tale for what not to do with an NXT wrestler. Once WWE Creative brought her up to Raw, they decided to pair the sunny superstar with Santino Marella. She was a 2-bit comedy jobber in no time (she even did Santino's ridiculous waddle to the ring), and several months later, the WWE sent Emma back to NXT to rework her entire gimmick. 

She's currently polishing a heel persona, and hopefully her second call-up to Raw goes better than the first one.

6. Doink the Clown

Here's a character that got progressively less interesting as the years went on. 

Advertisement

When Doink first debuted (the man underneath the makeup was Matt Osborne), he was a scary, evil clown. His circus entrance music turned creepy after several seconds, and Doink himself was sort of mean-spirited and slimy. He was allegedly based  of Stephen King's Pennywise, and the first Doink was a bit more serial killer than comedian.

But eventually, the writers turned Doink face, and he became a straightforward clown — not nearly as amusing or subversive. And when Matt Osbourne left the WWE, a succession of other wrestlers put on the makeup and carried on. Ironically, this defanged gimmick increased Doink's popularity, and the character became beloved by children rather than feared by them. 

Doink still makes occasional appearances, and when he does, he's cheered as a babyface. Fans tend to forget the wasted potential of the original heel character. Maybe it's time to bring it back — a decrepit Doink with a Glasgow smile and a Joker-esque persona? The possibilities would be endless.

5. MVP

When the WWE kayfabe signed MVP as the 'highest paid' superstar in the history of the company, it was easy to hate the guy. He was every single outsized, arrogant, entitled jock douchebag that we ever had the displeasure of meeting. His entrance only reaffirmed this status, with its inflatable tunnel, epic pyro, and encrusted bling hanging from his neck.

Advertisement

But when the WWE tried to turn him face, they destroyed his career beyond repair. WWE Creative's strategy was to have him lose a lot of matches— MVP got ruined by every mid-carder and jobber imaginable, sometimes due to bad luck, and sometimes due to his own incompetence.

The intent was to tear him down, and then build him back up as a fan favorite. But by the time they got around to the second part, his stock had fallen into the basement, and no one respected him enough to care about his redemption. 

MVP was never going to main event - he was a solid midcarder, at best. But now, he wasn't even suited for that, and the WWE released him from his contract soon afterwards.

4. Molly Holly

You know, for a company that claims to be an anti-bullying advocate, the WWE sure has engaged in a lot of body shaming and bullying over the, well, decades. 

Advertisement

Take, for instance, Molly Holly, who had a great heel persona; she was a condescending, prim woman who resented how the Divas division was oversexualized. It's sort of comical how such a sentiment could have been perceived as a heel stance back in the day.

So what did the WWE do? Did they make Molly a sympathetic villain? Did they point out her hypocrisy, and create meaningful feuds and storylines for her? Nah, they just made a bunch of fat jokes, implying that only an 'unattractive woman' would dislike the stripteases. 

Between this, 'Piggie' James and Bull Dempsey today, the WWE has a long way to go if they want to own the anti-bullying moniker and be taken seriously as advocates.

3. 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin

922090

Although he was totally on board with it at the time — it was actually his idea — Austin came to regret his famous heel turn at Wrestlemania 17. It was a story twist that looked much better on paper than it did in reality; memorable booking doesn't always equate to smart booking, particularly in the long run. 

Advertisement

The biggest problem (and even Austin agreed with this) was that no one really wanted to boo him. Austin was the rebel who beat his boss's ass, and the fans loved him for the vicarious thrill he provided. 

Meanwhile, his Two Man Power Trip heel angle with Triple H, where they would rush the ring and beat everyone with steel chairs, never got over; the confused fans, who still loved Austin, didn't know whether to cheer or boo. And although Austin slowly became a face again, he was never as menacing or as anti-authority as he was in his prime.

We can also thank this period for the whole 'WHAT?' thing that still annoys us to this day. 

2. Diamond Dallas Page

You know what doesn't get over with the fans? Sexual predators. If your character is a sexual predator, it doesn't matter whether you're a heel or a face; the fans aren't going to be booing you for the right reasons. There's something about creepy, rapey behavior that hits way too close to home, and it isn't appropriate for sports entertainment.

Advertisement

So of course the WWE decided to take Diamond Dallas Page, a WCW legend and former champion, and turn him into a pervy stalker. Every week, we saw grainy, voyeuristic footage of DDP spying on the Undertaker's wife; he even built a creepy shrine in her honor. 

Was this any way to treat a 3-time WCW Champion? During recent interviews, DDP has expressed regret that he didn't nix the angle; it was a hard lesson in thinking before signing on a dotted line.

Due to injuries, DDP wasn't under contract for very long. But ironically, he's done much more good outside of a WWE ring than inside of one. Both Scott Hall and Jake 'The Snake' Roberts credit DDP with saving their lives via his yoga rehab program.

1. Lana

This was just awful; how did the WWE screw up an entire character, that took them months to build up, in under a week?

Advertisement

When we first met Lana, she was the valet and manager for Rusev, and she was awesome. She had this sexual repression thing going on — a conservative, buttoned-up blouse and tightly wrapped hair, paired with these long, bare legs that were barely covered by a skirt.

She was dynamite on the microphone — sharp, aggressive, angry, and pointed. And lastly, she had great ring psychology — she always knew when to interject herself into a match, and she was the only person who could get Rusev to release his submission holds. "CRUSH!!"

But then, the WWE turned her face and paired her with Dolph Ziggler. And suddenly, everything we liked about Lana vanished in under a week. She was no longer strong and tough — she giggled, wept, and got into silly catfights with Summer Rae. She smiled way too often. She spent most of her time either kissing Dolph or clapping for Dolph.

She traded in her sharp, foxy business suits for faded jeans apparel. It was, for all intents and purposes, a different person, unrecognizable from the original character that drew fans in the first place.

What other WWE gimmicks were destroyed beyond recognition? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement