10 Times WWE Fans FORCED A Heel Turn

Those rare times when WWE had no choice but to give the people what they want!

By Gareth Morgan /

It doesn't matter whether an unlikely fan favourite's every step is being loudly cheered on by the masses, or an apparent television hero can't raise a fist without getting booed out of the building, WWE have a very arrogant habit of refusing to pivot. Even when all signs point to their ill-fated babyface or heel plan being an evident failure.

Advertisement

But on those rarest of occasions, Vinnie Mac, and more recently Trips, had the common sense to actually listen to the various noises being generated by their paying customers. What a concept.

And after finally hearing just how unanimously rejected the following names unquestionably were as the company's next top babyface champions and contenders, those in the back wisely opted to call a heel audible.

Now of course there was always a chance WWE would have simply opted to go full Roman Reigns and offer up a great big middle finger to those clearly possessing zero interest in audibly supporting another Big Dog. But thankfully, when it came to each and every miscast one-time face occupying a space on this list, Vince, Paul and the rest of the folks calling the shots were giving no choice but to give the people what they wanted.

10. Edge (2004)

Edge's most recent attempt to turn his back on the WWE faithful was a bit of a disaster from start to finish.

Advertisement

Who in their right mind wanted to heckle a bloke that had somehow found a way to come back from a career-ending neck injury after nearly a decade away from in-ring competition?

This wasn't the first time The Rated R Superstar had found himself fighting against the tide somewhat, however. Almost twenty years earlier, what was shaping up to be a promising run as WWE's next up-and-coming babyface hero soon took a turn for the worst in 2004.

Not long after returning from injury that year, fans quickly realised that Edge's general hero schtick had grown a little stale. And by the time the then-Intercontinental Champion rocked up to his hometown of Toronto for SummerSlam 2004, the future world champion was actually booed out of the Air Canada Centre.

Sure enough, it wasn't too long before WWE sensed that a significant change-up was needed to salvage their blonde-haired main event project. And by the time the year was out, Edge had finally began to show flickers of the opportunist slime-ball persona that would ultimately carry him all the way to his first WWE Championship.

9. Lita (2005)

While on the subject of that Rated R character that would eventually take WWE by storm from 2005 onwards, now feels like as good a time as any to dive into Edge's one-time real-life and on-screen love Lita's enforced turn to the dark side, too.

Advertisement

After spending the majority of her much-loved WWE run as an underdog hero, Lita soon felt the wrath of some rather pissed off parts of the fandom on the back of former partner Matt Hardy revealing the star's real-life affair with Edge online.

Before the Team Xtreme icon knew what hit her, a decent portion of the fanbase took it upon themselves to rain down vicious chants of "You Screwed Matt!" and "We Want Matt!" whenever the on-screen face popped up on WWE programming. The most notable example of which went down during an awkward back-and-forth with a then-heel Trish Stratus in April of that year.

Rather than resisting the relentless venom being unjustly hurled Lita's way, though, the call was finally made to have the star align herself with The Ultimate Opportunist on-screen. And the pair would then go on to infamously help blur the lines between kayfabe and reality during their eventual war with Matt throughout the summer.

8. Ronda Rousey (2019)

Hopefully WWE have finally learned their lesson when it comes to The Baddest Woman on the Planet.

Advertisement

When you can confess to being a legitimate badass former UFC Bantamweight Champion, having a fondness for genuinely snapping limbs, and haven't exactly been shy about your feeling towards the average wrestling fan, trying to make anyone believe in you as a plucky underdog or loveable anti-hero is always going to be a tough task.

But that still couldn't stop WWE from stubbornly trying to force a heroic Ronda Rousey down fans' throats at two separate occasions during her somewhat brief time in the land of sports entertainment.

The first infamous occurrence involved a noticeably flustered Ronnie struggling against the waves of boos sent her way in the lead-up to WrestleMania 35, with the vast majority of the WWE faithful being more interesting in cheering on The Man at that point in time.

And just as the company were forced to have Rousey go on a heelish rampage back in 2019, 2022 also saw the SmackDown Women's Championship challenger finally turn her back on the crowd during her fight with Liv Morgan at SummerSlam after never quite finding her feet as a fighting babyface champ on the blue brand.

The lesson here: Just let Rousey bully your favourites and act as a violent, evil end-level boss going forward, yeah?

7. The New Day (2015)

While it may be damn near impossible to imagine a world where the beacons of positivity known as The New Day could ever routinely be sour on WWE programming, that was very much the case back when the group were first making their presence known on the main roster way back in 2015.

Advertisement

Though it was most certainly not a part of the original plan.

After initially being unveiled as a set of annoyingly chipper preachers towards the backend of 2014, fans very quickly wanted nothing to do with Big E, Kofi Kingston, and Xavier Woods as a babyface unit. "New Day Rocks!" very quickly became "New Day Sucks!" But instead of ignoring the fact their positive schtick wasn't quite clicking in the way Vinnie Mac initially hoped, the group soon leaned into the negative reaction and doubled-down on their painfully enthusiastic ways.

The addition of some heelish cheating tactics to get the job done in-between the ropes fully cemented the unit as a gloriously entertaining collection of baddies. And when given that little bit more freedom to commit to their goofy personalities whilst being forced to operate on the heel side of the divide, it was only a matter of time before the charismatic forces of nature became too hilarious to genuinely detest.

6. Seth Rollins (2019)

In another case of WWE hopefully having the sense to not let history repeat itself, fans will most definitely be praying that Trips doesn't allow a newly babyfaced Seth Rollins to wander down the same fateful path he did four years ago in the near future.

Advertisement

Much like in 2023, Rollins had found himself organically getting over with the WWE Universe on the back of his consistently thrilling displays in-between the ropes, with his weekly eye-catching showcases and babyface fire establishing him as a clear favourite to best The Beast at WrestleMania 35.

But upon finally slaying big Brock, Rollins soon saw his heroic Universal Championship run be somewhat derailed by everything from foolish couple angles, a Baron Corbin battle, and a Fiendish debacle.

By the time The Beastslayer had been massacred by Wyatt's demon clown at Crown Jewel, just about nobody honestly wanted to cheer on what the babyface Rollins character had become; that being a generic WWE corporate champ who probably should've kept his Twitter activity to a minimum.

And so, that inevitable fan-enforced heel turn finally went down in the wake of that year's Survivor Series, with Seth morphing into the first form of the eventual vibrant Visionary persona fans sing along with today.

5. Batista (2014)

Much like Ronda Rousey fully expected to return to WWE as a full-blown heel just last year, Dave Bautista also very much felt that making his long-awaited comeback to the sports entertainment world as a villain was the right way to go back in 2014.

Advertisement

But with WWE clearly knowing best, Big Dave was told by the folks in charge that fans would be simply too overjoyed to see The Animal to genuinely reject him with merciless boos. And while that was true for a minute there, Batista knew from the get-go that his strength lay in pissing off the WWE crowd and that his initial warm welcome would inevitably turn sour.

And what do you know, that's exactly what went down in next to no time at all, with the former world champion ultimately receiving one of the most jarring reactions in WWE history upon being the unfortunate soul who wasn't named Daniel Bryan to win the 2014 Royal Rumble.

Vince finally listened to his MCU superstar not long after and allowed Batista to revel in the negativity. And when making his final return to the company five years later, you better believe there wasn't an ounce of babyface fire to be found in the heartless Animal hunting down Ric Flair.

4. Alberto Del Rio (2013)

Some folks are just made to be the bad guy. And that was most definitely the case when it came to the effortlessly arrogant Alberto Del Rio throughout the entirety of his WWE career.

Advertisement

Despite exuding heel energy from the second he strutted through the sports entertainment door, however, the strange move was made to transform Del Rio into a babyface who would ultimately go on to become a fighting World Heavyweight Champion.

The only trouble was that most fans simply didn't buy the naturally cocky star as a heroic force of good from the off. And by the time Dolph Ziggler opted to cash-in his Money in the Bank briefcase on the then-big-gold-belt wearer to the sound of deafening cheers post-Mania 29, it was evident that the Del Rio babyface experiment was reaching its failure of a conclusion.

The two would go at it once again at Payback a few months later, and it was here when WWE successfully executed a double switch that had been forced upon them by fans refusing to react to either Ziggles or Del Rio in the way the folks in the back had once hoped.

3. The Rock (1997 & 2003)

The Rock's doomed Blue Chipper days went on to influence the decision to not introduce debuting stars like Kurt Angle as a clean-cut, all-conquering, smiling hero out of the gates.

Advertisement

And it's not hard to see why as there was a time there when it looked as though The Great One's WWE career was pretty much over on the back of being serenaded with countless "Die Rocky, Die!" and "Rocky Sucks!" chants during his disastrous early time on the roster.

But it was that widespread backlash that provided Rocky Maivia with the fuel to fire up the loud-mouth ball of arrogant charisma that was The Rock upon making his return from injury in 1997.

And after said game-changing creation of the character that would become The People's Champion, Dwayne Johnson also just so happened to experience a similar wave of rejection five years into his near-unmatched popularity.

Fans were wise to Rocky's quest to lay the SmackDown on Hollywood and were only all too happy to boo him out of the company after losing to Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam 2002. But this only provided Rocky with the tools to unleash yet another inspired villain into the universe in early 2003.

A Hollywood Rock, fond of running down towns with a guitar in hand, was brilliantly born and it simply didn't matter what you thought once again.

2. Bayley (2019)

Having already shown a willingness to adapt to the way their audience is receiving the unquestionably gifted Horsewoman, many current WWE fans will likely be holding out hope that Bayley will once again be offered the chance to change things up a little sooner rather than later.

Advertisement

Back when The Hugger first made the decision to turn her back on her Bayley Buddies around the globe, said call was hugely influenced by the star herself realising how her one-time passionate following had now grown tired of her pleasant underdog persona.

After experiencing some pretty rough spells trying to make the gimmick that had gone down so well in NXT work on the main roster, both Bayley and WWE clearly knew there was no option left but to finally allow the former Raw, SmackDown, and NXT Women's and Women's Tag Team Champion the opportunity to give into her dark side in the latter stages of 2019.

And those who had once began to overlook Bayley as a serious threat on the main roster were soon forced to sit up and take notice of the soon-to-be Role Model after witnessing the newly turned heel take an axe to both her signature ponytail and inflatable sidekicks.

1. Randy Orton (2004)

After shockingly becoming the youngest World Heavyweight Champion in WWE history at SummerSlam 2004, the support being sent Evolution's Randy Orton resulted in the company feeling they had no choice but to finally pull the trigger on The Legend Killer as their next main event babyface star.

Advertisement

But similarly to the likes of the aforementioned Alberto Del Rio, after Triple H and the gang booted the Apex Predator out of their group, Orton never quite managed to click as a likeable babyface hero in his subsequent battles with his one-time mentor.

A month down the road, Randy was belt-less. And he would continue to struggle to infuse the cool charm and arrogance that made him a fan-favourite in the first place into his newly hero'd up persona. By March of the following year, Orton's drop in popularity and failure to keep fans from turning their attention to his one-time Evolution teammate led to him once again listening to the voices in his head before long.

And after ultimately being forced to pivot over to The Animal on the Road to WrestleMania 21, it would be a whopping five years before WWE even attempted to nudge Randy back towards the light again.

Advertisement