10 Times WWE Got "The Guy" Wrong

Those times WWE picked their chosen ones and got it all wrong.

By Gareth Morgan /

WWE is constantly looking for their next top stars.

Advertisement

And at time of writing, both the present and future look generally bright for the biggest wrestling organisation on the planet when it comes to main event players.

The likes of Cody Rhodes, Rhea Ripley, Bianca Belair and more are currently hugely popular, top-of-the-card acts - and then you have your Bron Breakkers, Ilja Dragunovs, Jade Cargills, and a fresh class of exciting NXT talents all looking to take up the spots of WWE's key players in the coming years, too.

And while you may assume that the criteria stars need to meet in order to be considered a genuine megastar of tomorrow is relatively obvious - a good look, high-quality performances in-between the ropes, undeniable charisma - history has shown that WWE have had a habit of sometimes choosing poorly/stupidly when the time comes to anoint a new "chosen one".

Over the years, despite there being far stronger candidates on show across the roster, this promotion has foolishly chosen to fully get behind everyone from lumbering giants to personality-devoid prodigies - and the end results were inevitably all kinds of disappointing...

10. Austin Theory

At a glance, Austin Theory seems like a guy who possesses a good number of the qualities needed to be a serious player in WWE.

Advertisement

He definitely looks the part, possessing an undeniably impressive physique. And he can hold his own in-between the ropes, too. (Though he does possess a rather flat finisher in his A-Town Down weapon of choice.)

That match-ender perhaps encapsulated the overall vibe of the former United States Champion during his 2022/23 top guy push under both Vince McMahon and Paul Levesque, with that run highlighting the major flaw holding the 26-year-old back from being a future WrestleMania main eventer: his lack of any real personality.

His work on the mic was extremely uninspired and forgettable. He never once truly captivated an audience, and Theory's Money in the Bank victory brought more dread than excitement, with fans never once buying the uncharismatic talent as a soon-to-be World champ as he carried around his bright green opportunity.

Despite failing to successfully bring home a belt via his cash-in, becoming the only person to challenge for a midcard title with his case and still bloody lose (!), WWE still didn't give up hope on their Austin Theory: Top Guy project.

A victory over John Cena on The Grandest Stage also couldn't convince people to take Theory seriously as the next big thing, though. 

So, WWE wisely opted to wave their white flag and dump him into the tag team ranks alongside the colourful Grayson Waller instead, a move that has actually done more for the lad than those high-profile victories and singles pushes ever did.

9. Solo Sikoa

Another relatively recent attempt to create a new top guy - or in this case, a new 'Tribal Chief' - this run with Solo Sikoa as the leader of the new Bloodline has been a bit of a mixed bag so far.

Advertisement

The Bloodline 2.0 itself has actually started to feel like the genuine threat Paul Heyman was trying to make us believe it was for months, with the introduction of Jacob Fatu in particular and decimating of the aforementioned 'Wise Man' both establishing the squad as a force to be reckoned with on Friday nights.

However, even with this next chapter of the saga finally sparking into life a little, there's still a rather big problem blankly staring WWE in the face here: Sikoa just hasn't commanded the screen at all as the evil faction's new top dog.

He lacks real authority whenever he shows up on screen, and even more so when he opens his mouth. 

Even after orchestrating that aforementioned attack on Heyman, it was still hard to escape the feeling that the genuinely terrifying Fatu stood a better chance of being one of WWE's next top guys than the largely unengaging Solo.

He's still got time to turn it around and fully grow into the role before Roman Reigns returns to take back his Ula Fala. But as of this moment, Solo has looked anything but comfortable at the 'Head of the Table'.

8. The Great Khali

It doesn't take a genius to see what made Vince McMahon give an undefeated streak to and put the top strap on this guy.

Advertisement

Standing at incredible 7ft 1" tall and weighing a massive 347-pounds, The Great Khali had the numbers of an old school wrestling attraction - a giant that, on paper, looked like he genuinely could not be stopped.

And then the bell rang.

Unlike other more modern giants like Big Show, Braun Strowman, and Kane, Khali struggled to really move himself around the squared-circle, with his dodgy knees resulting in most of his plodding matches being a painful watch - even if his besting of The Undertaker early on was still a bit of a shock at the time.

Without Edge going down injured in the first place back in 2007, there's also a chance Khali may never have got his hands on the upside down big gold belt at all - but the decision to go with the 'Punjabi Playboy' as SmackDown's top champ for a spell after that injury just further exposed his limitations as a worker before Batista took away the gold at Unforgiven.

The combination of those lumbering displays in-between the ropes and not exactly riveting promos, due to not speaking all that much English, inevitably led to this becoming yet another failed WWE experiment.

He'd later settle into the role of a comedy performer on the roster. 

Khali definitely wasn't cut out to be the guy, but he still did enough to earn himself a place in the Hall of Fame in 2021.

7. Dean Ambrose

Now this is a bit of an odd one.

Advertisement

A then-Dean Ambrose had proven time and time again that he could be a reliable player for WWE during his run alongside and after The Shield. And in the wake of leaving the company in 2019, he'd very much flourish into a top-level superstar/champion capable of being the face of a company in AEW.

But things just never really clicked for Jon Moxley when he was finally handed the top WWE guy ball back in 2016.

In the wake of the brands being split for the first time since 2011, the super popular Ambrose was trusted with leading the blue brand as its WWE Champion, sitting atop an exciting roster boasting the likes of John Cena, AJ Styles, Bray Wyatt, and Randy Orton.

Rather than a white hot run for the 'Lunatic Fringe' following his awesome Money in the Bank cash-in and enjoyable defences against his former Shield pals, though, his blue show World title reign was largely overshadowed by the aforementioned Cena/Styles rivalry. 

His forgettable defence against Dolph Ziggler at SummerSlam and disastrous interview with 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin didn't do the unconvincing champ any favours either.

Styles would ultimately bring that disappointing time on top of the mountain to an end at Backlash and enjoy a more memorable spell on top.

Mox definitely showed that he had it in him to be the guy later down the road. So, this was largely just a case of the right guy at the wrong time - or maybe in the wrong place.

6. Jinder Mahal

A year on from Dean Ambrose failing to really set the world on fire as SmackDown's World champ, another star's ill-advised reign would make that 'Lunatic's run look like, well, a home run. 

Advertisement

Not really, but you get the point.

A freshly jacked Jinder Mahal suddenly emerged as a new WWE title contender following on from WrestleMania 33. 

And once again, Vince McMahon's obsession with big lads and bulging physiques led to the 'Modern Day Maharaja' lifting his first (and only) piece of World title gold. But, away from the initial shock of seeing him actually conquer Randy Orton at Backlash 2017, the whole run was an unmitigated failure.

Title contests against Orton and Shinsuke Nakamura were some of the dullest of the decade - and that's without even taking into account the horrendous racism present in that latter program.

The properly terrible run was seemingly WWE's way of trying to appeal to the Indian market. But it didn't work, and by the time he did actually make it over to the country with the company, he was actually no longer holding the strap and being bested by Triple H at a house show.

5. Damian Priest

Similarly to the aforementioned Jinder Mahal, by all accounts Damian Priest is a top bloke in real-life. 

Advertisement

But a top guy? The last few months point to that just not being the case, sadly.

Again, Priest can certainly produce in-between the ropes, and has been a little unfortunate of late in his big matches - almost snapping his leg in two at Clash at the Castle and experiencing a pin-fall botch at Money in the Bank - but his week-to-week work as Raw's World champion hasn't really set pulses racing since cashing in at WrestleMania 40.

While certainly a likeable enough talent, he doesn't really have that megastar aura. His delivery on the stick is a bit tedious. The feud of the year that is CM Punk vs. Drew McIntyre has made anything Priest has been doing seem immediately less interesting by comparison. Overall, he's just generally struggled to carry the show as its apparent top player in the same way Seth Rollins or Cody Rhodes did throughout 2023.

Triple H definitely has a soft spot for the Judgment Day man, and was likely hoping that the World title would help elevate his NXT student to the level of bona fide main eventer. 

But it's not really worked out, and a GUNTHER victory at SummerSlam feels somewhat inevitable at this stage.

4. Jack Swagger

Many moons before really getting a kick out of a piece of purple headwear, Jake Hager arrived in WWE as a potential new "guy" the company were very much high on.

Advertisement

It wasn't too hard to see why. 

Here was another talent with a strong amateur wrestling background who had a decent look about him and was relatively young - but he was still a bit of a work in progress, and that much was clear when WWE decided to pull the trigger on him as their new top champ on SmackDown back in 2010.

Fresh off of winning the Money in the Bank ladder match at WrestleMania XXVI, a then-Jack Swagger cashed in on Chris Jericho to lift the World Heavyweight Championship...and that was probably the peak of the run right there.

Sure, he'd pick up a few victories over the likes of Jericho, Edge, and Randy Orton, but when stood opposite those names and the likes of John Cena over on Raw, Swagger didn't feel like the next big thing - he looked inferior.

The uncharismatic star's promos were bland, the matches were just there really, and no one was crying out for another run with the big gold belt in the wake of him dropping it in a Fatal Four-Way match at the titular PLE.

3. Lex Luger

From one failed blonde "guy" fond of wandering around in the ol' red, white, and blue to another.

Advertisement

In the hopes of creating a new Hulk Hogan of sorts (more on him later), Vince McMahon unleashed a Lex Express in 1993. 

Now sure, Lex Luger definitely looked like a million bucks, though he lacked the same level of charisma an icon as big as Hogan boasted. He also certainly had the backing of the company coming into his eventual showdown with Yokozuna over the WWF Championship at SummerSlam, but fans just weren't fully buying it at the time.

And it was that reality which ultimately led to the company getting cold feet and opting not to strap him up in the summer, choosing instead to continue building up the adonis in the hopes of him one day finally connecting with the crowd.

Yeah, about that.

By the time both he and actual fan-favourite Bret Hart fell over the top-rope at the 1994 Royal Rumble, the crowd reactions both men received that night told the story of one person, dressed in black and pink, who was most definitely "the guy" - and another who clearly wasn't. 

And sure enough, when both men received their World title shots at WrestleMania X, it was the 'Hitman' who walked out with the belt as fans took one look at that Hogan 2.0 push and said "that doesn't work for me, brother!"

2. Diesel

Bret Hart would go on to hold that WWF title right up to Survivor Series following his WrestleMania X victory, defending it against the likes of his brother Owen and the next star the company would eventually get behind as their next larger-than-life megastar: Diesel.

Advertisement

The effortlessly cool big man, who'd been acting as Shawn Michaels' bodyguard since his WWF debut, would finally get his chance at being 'The Man' following the 'Hitman's loss to Bob Backlund at the aforementioned PPV. But what followed was another stupid case of trying to replicate what came before, and not leaning into what made Kevin Nash so compelling in the first place.

This smiling big lad unsurprisingly ended up feeling like the latest Hogan-lite offering in no time, and eventually went on to become the lowest-drawing WWF Champion of all time.

He'd reign a year as the company's top guy, but the experiment well and truly failed. Many of the matches, outside of efforts against icons like Hart and Michaels, weren't up to scratch. Also, the top guy character he was being asked to play wasn't one that fans were all that interested in anymore.

Nash was born to be a charming anti-hero, and after finally being conquered by Hart at Survivor Series 1995, it was in that role that he excelled both at the end of his WWF run and throughout his game-changing WCW one.

1. Hulk Hogan

And on the subject of the guy the WWF repeatedly did all they could to replace over the years, 'The Hulkster' was actually the damn problem on the night of WrestleMania IX, and the months that followed.

Advertisement

You see, coming into that show, Yokozuna had been built up as a serious threat to Bret Hart's reign as WWF Champion, and a new top monster that many a plucky babyface would look to overcome in the coming years. But instead of committing to the finish of 'Zuna lifting the winged-eagle at the end of that Las Vegas 'Show of Shows', Vince McMahon had other, idiotic plans.

Late in the day, and after being talked into the idea by Hulk Hogan, he opted to suddenly throw the returning legend into an impromptu main event, with the icon besting this villainous project post-Hart win in a matter of seconds to the sound of cheers throughout Caesar's Palace.

That call to have Hogan hold the title and be the company's top guy for their upcoming international tour (according to Bruce Prichard) made both of McMahon's New Generation talents look crap. 

And a soon-to-be departing Hogan's refusal to drop the title to Hart (he didn't feel he was a main event level player at the time) along with the cheap way he eventually lost it back to 'Zuna (fireball to the face, as you do) just made the company's decision to strap him up in Vegas seem more foolish in hindsight.

Your top guy also burying the belt as a "toy" in Japan isn't exactly the best look either.

Advertisement