10 Times WWE Got The WrestleMania Main Event Wrong
Honestly, how hard is it to get right?
WrestleMania 36 - and WrestleMania 37! - are happening this weekend, but it was only yesterday WWE admitted that Roman Reigns, who pulled out over a week ago, would not be challenging Goldberg for the Universal Championship.
Braun Strowman's last minute insertion all but indicates that the blue strap won't be headlining one of the two shows - but the fact is, we just don't know yet.
WWE are splitting WrestleMania in half this year, but have not laid out the details of either of them. Logically, Drew McIntyre's tilt at Brock Lesnar will end one, and Becky Lynch defending the Raw Women's title the other. That seems the most equitable solution.
But there other options. Had Roman Reigns been available, it's likely he'd have had a show to close. But then, so long as WWE were 'forced' to bisect 'Mania, he never was going to be available.
The curious circumstances mean that, in truth, the main event has never mattered less. The non-existent crowd will react the same way whatever it is. Might as well go with Baron Corbin vs. Elias.
Most other years, picking the right main event is absolutely crucial. WWE haven't made a habit of making it this easy for themselves. Even when a clear-cut main event is staring them in the face, the company have often reverted to Triple H, because Lord only knows his pen is as mighty as his sledgehammer. If not HHH, it has been his one-letter removed politicking icon Hulk Hogan changing the book to his fancy.
And then there was that year WrestleMania ended with a footballer. No, really.
Just how many other times in the previous thirty-three attempts has WWE got it wrong and made a colossal balls-up of the main event of its annual showpiece?
10. WrestleMania 25: Randy Orton Vs. Triple H
What The Main Event Should Have Been: The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels
The storyline going into WrestleMania 25 was that of Randy Orton making former Evolution stable-mate Triple H’s life a living hell by targeting him and his family on weekly Raw segments. Orton played the role of despicable villain wonderfully, but in a more enlightened era few bought his actions as anything other than scripted fantasy drama. The match was hurt by a stipulation where Hunter would lose his WWE Championship should he be counted out of disqualified, which was designed to add tension and a degree of unpredictability to the bout, but instead served to remove all shortcuts and the potential for wild brawling that would have saved it from the tepid affair it ended up being.
More pertinent was the bout’s position on the card. Had it come earlier in the show, the reaction would likely have been more favourable, but they went on last following an all-time classic Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels match, meaning their contest was fought in front of near silence. Triple H realised this would be the case after watching Michaels-Taker, walking over to Orton in the dressing room and casually telling him, “We are f****d.” He was right.
9. WrestleMania V: Randy Savage Vs. Hulk Hogan
What The Main Event Should Have Been: Randy Savage vs. Hulk Hogan
Huh? No, I haven't erred. And yes, I know it was one of the highest grossing WrestleMania cards ever for the longest time. And yes, I know the main event was the blowoff of a program that went back over two years in storyline terms. No, my issue is not the match but rather the result. I firmly believe Randy Savage should have retained, both for his sake and for Hogan’s. If he went over fans would have believed in him fully as someone on Hogan’s level, making him an even bigger draw down the line for when Hogan eventually usurped him. It also would have helped Hogan, whose big boot/legdrop act was become stale. Fans were starting to see through him as a one-trick pony who always won, and two years later resentment had become outright dislike. By Royal Rumble ‘92 his previous staunch support had turned into sheer disdain, with fans cheering uproariously when he was ousted from the match by heel Sid Justice.
Okay, having the heel go over Hogan at WrestleMania during the Hulkamania era might have been unpopular, but by the same token, Savage was very popular himself. He always had been, even when working Hogan years earlier during the peak of Hulkamania. Plus, he was drawing spectacularly on top. With Savage as champion on one loop and Hogan as the main draw on the other the WWF were breaking box office records on two fronts at the same time. Hogan didn't need the belt to draw, Savage did, so from a business perspective it was illogical to take the strap from him and put all eggs into the Hogan basket. As far as being a money-drawing megastar goes, Savage was never quite the same after that loss.
8. WrestleMania 13: Sycho Sid Vs. The Undertaker
What The Main Event Should Have Been: Bret Hart vs. Shawn Michaels
This is a difficult one. The main event of WrestleMania 13 was changed from the original plan of a Bret Hart vs. Shawn Michaels rematch due to Michaels losing his smile and bailing on the show so that he didn't have to do a job for his perennial rival Hart. At one stage the match was very much on the table, then Vince got cold feet and decided to go a different direction, claiming a rematch from the previous year’s WrestleMania was too predictable. The real reason was Shawn’s refusal to comply with the booking, and when he handed in the WWF Championship and walked away, the WWF had no choice but to change things around.
Why Sycho Sid and The Undertaker were chosen to headline was anyone’s guess, but it likely comes down to what it always comes down to: Vince McMahon is enamoured by giants. The pair didn't have a strong program going into the show, or indeed any real issue at all, and fan interest in the match was simply not there. That much was evident when studying the buyrate for the show, which was one of the worst in WrestleMania history. It didn't help, either, that the contest was an utter chore, with the two lumbering giants unable to piece together a match worthy of Raw, never mind the main event of the biggest card of the year. A Hart-Michaels match would definitely have been preferable, even if it would have ultimately cost us the classic Bret Hart vs. Steve Austin submission match that many consider to be one of the finest WrestleMania matches of all time. Either that or Bret and Austin should have just headlined themselves.