10 Times WWE Got The WrestleMania Main Event Wrong

By James Dixon /

Advertisement

4. WrestleMania XI: Bam Bam Bigelow Vs. Lawrence Taylor

WWE.com

What The Main Event Should Have Been: Diesel vs. Shawn Michaels

Advertisement

“We should have gone on last,” complained Kevin Nash when quizzed about the main event of one of the most underwhelming WrestleMania shows of all time. And indeed the WWE Championship contest pitting Nash’s Diesel against the increasingly-popular heel Shawn Michaels certainly should have. And while we are at it, the result should have been different too. Diesel was failing as WWF Champion and struggling to draw houses, leading to veteran agent Gerry Brisco openly joking about how much longer the WWF would be running on Diesel power. Fans were clamouring for a Shawn Michaels title win. They had watched him steal the show for years and despite his heel status they were now firmly invested in him as their number one guy, even if Vince McMahon couldn't see it.

McMahon just couldn't get over the fact that Michaels wasn't a seven-foot giant, and Nash, well, was! He had no faith in the two Kliq best buds to pull a respectable buyrate on their own, because he struggled to comprehend how anyone could take Michaels seriously as a threat to Diesel due to the size difference. With a shallow roster and an unwillingness to go back to the well with the likes of languishing talents Bret Hart, Owen Hart, or The Undertaker, McMahon decided to step outside the box in searching for his answer. He found it in the form of NFL legend Lawrence Taylor, whom he was thrilled to learn was willing to work a match on the biggest show of the year.

Advertisement

McMahon believed Taylor’s involvement would serve as a fine way to bolster PR as the WWF attempted to rebuild their image following a shocking few years of being dragged through the mire with legal wrangles relating to sexual abuse of minors, steroid pushing, and other costly lawsuits. Taylor was mainstream, and McMahon theorised that having him onside meant having the press onside. It didn't work out that way. Taylor’s appearance was criticised by most serious sports papers, with many questioning what he must have been thinking cheapening his status by stepping into the “phony” world of pro wrestling. McMahon might have been sated by the buyrate, which he was convinced would blow other WrestleMania shows out of the water due to the presence of Taylor. Not so. The card flopped spectacularly, despite Taylor’s match with midcarder Bam Bam Bigelow coming off far better than anyone expected, the experience charring McMahon’s fingers so badly that he refused to endorse a single celebrity tie-in at the following year’s extravaganza.

Advertisement

Advertisement

3. WrestleMania XXVII: The Miz Vs. John Cena

WWE.com

What The Main Event Should Have Been: John Cena vs. The Undertaker

Advertisement

The Undertaker’s incredible WrestleMania Streak was still alive, John Cena was still roundly despised by the vocal majority, and this was WWE’s chance to present the never-before-seen epic WrestleMania main event clash between the pair that ultimately never came to pass. While pitting the two against each other would have meant a significant shift around in the booking prior to the supershow, it would have been worth it for the match that would have followed.

Instead, Undertaker wrestled Triple H in the middle of the card in an overbooked self-indulgent match-up, and Cena fought for the championship against perhaps the most unlikely WWE Champion and WrestleMania main-eventer in history, The Miz. The former reality TV star and Tough Enough alum was on the run of his life as a genuine heat-seeking heel so at the time it probably seemed like a good idea. Over time, it has entered WrestleMania annals as a joke of a decision. Even The Miz's unlikely revival in 2016, leading to an improbable rematch in Orlando (albeit in a mixed-tag) did nothing to lessen this opinion.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

2. WrestleMania 2000: Triple H Vs. The Rock Vs. Mick Foley Vs. Big Show

WWE.com

What The Main Event Should Have Been: Triple H vs. The Rock

Advertisement

The only singles match on the entire WrestleMania 2000 card pitted Terri Runnels against The Kat in a Catfight match, with the rest of the show made up of triple threats, scrambles, four-ways, and multi-mans. It was a mess, and one of the WWF’s low points in an otherwise incredible 2000.

After months of Hunter ruling the WWF with an iron fist alongside his storyline wife Stephanie, fans were tiring of the duo’s omnipotent double act and were desperate to see Triple H unseated at the annual extravaganza. After all, the heel champion always lost and received their comeuppance at WrestleMania. The man deigned as the fans’ hero was The Rock, who was perhaps the most popular he had ever been. A Rock vs. Triple H match was what everyone wanted to see, and if their classics at Backlash and Judgment Day in the following months are anything to go by, it would have been sensational.

Advertisement

Instead the WWF decided to shoehorn the overweight Big Show and the recently retired and similarly-overweight Mick Foley into the match, giving a four way that nobody wanted to see with the supposed draw of the bout featuring “a McMahon in every corner". It was egomaniacal, nepotistic booking at its most extreme, and one of the most underwhelming WrestleMania main events on record. Even worse, the heel won the match, going against years of established WWF convention and leaving fans with a bitter taste in their mouths once the curtain fell on the sixteenth edition of the show.

Advertisement

Advertisement