10 Times WWE Leaked Top Secret Information

Featuring damning rehearsals, bizarre company guidelines and the Undertaker breaking character...

By Michael Sidgwick /

There aren't many secrets left in WWE, a publicly traded juggernaut that formally abandoned the thin pretence of kayfabe in 1989.

Advertisement

Everybody has known since the very early 20th century that pro wrestling is an obvious sham. Everybody knows that the small razor blades are used to shed blood. They are small pieces of sharp metal that draw only a shallow, cosmetic cut, and yet Vince McMahon finds them more morally reprehensible than repackaging an adult Japanese performer in a schoolgirl-adjacent outfit. Or another adult female as a childlike figure wearing pigtails who dry humps Randy Orton. It's a good job the FBI gives less of a sh*t about WWE than the media.

The tables are nearly sawn in half; the ladders that explode are made of wood; the thumbtacks are real, because wrestlers are crackers and "It's OK, they're spread across a large surface area aren't they" is an explanation that won't really horrify you if you've been trapped in this demented bubble for long enough.

There are few if any working secrets to reveal - though there are certain bits of information WWE absolutely does not want made public.

Vince McMahon is hardly out there voluntarily offering up what exactly he asked Mustafa Ali to do - but the minutiae is often so fascinating, and the disillusionment so rife, that the lips are loose across all corridors of Titan Towers...

10. The WrestleMania III Attendance

WWE and Dave Meltzer used to enjoy a cordial relationship - cordial enough, bizarrely, for WWE to drop the carny act and casually reveal the truth behind one of its most blustering falsehoods.

Advertisement

For years, WWE insisted that 93,000 fans were drawn to the Pontiac Silverdome in Detroit to watch Hulk Hogan body slam André The Giant, after which, of course, the 650 pound or half-tonne André passed on days later as Hogan recovered from the feat having torn every muscle in his back.

"It took a lot to see him off, but brother, I just about did it, God rest his soul."

It's a typical WWE embellishment: RAW is the longest-running weekly episodic show in TV history, Survivor Series is the one night a year that the stars of RAW and SmackDown compete head-to-head, Randy Orton is an in-ring legend.

But an embellishment it is, as Dave Meltzer clarified.

Meltzer was first alerted to WWE's lie by Zane Bresloff, who worked on the local promotion. Any suggestion that Bresloff had played down the figure, given his later defection to WCW, was brushed aside by WWE itself, who confirmed the real number of 78,000.

This itself has been disputed, in a very interesting piece by David Bixenspan, but WWE all but said they were bullsh*tters to, of all people, Dave Meltzer.

9. The Format Of A RAW Script

In 2014, the script for the April 14 Monday Night RAW script was leaked online.

Advertisement

The sheer detail on the f*cking thing was astonishing. It was as if the writers go to the painstaking lengths of building a miniature ship in a bottle, only using particles of sh*t instead of wood. The pursuit of perfection is so heavily ironic. Vince McMahon is an auteur of terrible children's television.

In one notable tidbit, copy was leaked from a drastically overwritten (and awful) promo directed at Bray Wyatt from John Cena, in which he called Bray "ugly" as a means of building interest in a violent stipulation match. Elsewhere, the incredibly rigid and stilted format, not that it came as much of a surprise, revealed WWE's TV as an abomination.

Bryan Alvarez was told by a source that Stephanie McMahon responded so furiously to the leak that she was "mad enough that she could beat Ronda Rousey in a UFC fight".

Jesus Christ, which dipsh*t was thick enough to think she could do that? Was this a direct Stephanie quote? "I'm so mad, I could beat Ronda Rousey in a UFC fight" is something she might snarl.

Or did Disco Inferno have an agent job at the time that nobody was aware of?

8. The Commentator's Style Manual

In 2015, a since-deleted Reddit user somehow procured from an unknown WWE source a list of guidelines to which its commentary team must adhere at all times.

Advertisement

"Hey listen f*ckheads, it's time for Monday Night RAW!" wasn't on it, unfortunately. The best thing Michael Cole ever said wasn't on WWE TV, which is really saying something.

Incredibly, this was on it - the first line, in fact.

"Manufactured passion is the kiss of death."

Michael Cole must get tongue-f*cked by a corpse every Friday night, Jesus wept.

Other guidelines included:

"Take the high road - don't be crude, especially with the Divas.'

And yet Corey Graves does an impression of Jerry Lawler most weeks. 2010 Jerry Lawler, anyway. Lawler used to actually be funny once upon a time.

"Fully understand the heritage and the history of the business as it gives you what you are doing today more credibility."

These f*ckers don't even call it the wrestling business!

In the "describe the environment" section, the commentators are instructed to describe "what the fans are doing and why," which is strange, because Cole never once said "cheering Daniel Bryan in defiance because they think the booking is dog sh*t."

7. The Rehearsal Of Paul Bearer's Storyline Death

WWE was completely on its arse in 2004, which until very recently was the most wretched year in its history.

Advertisement

1995 is up there, of course, but WWE had no excuse nine years later. They had monopolised all of North America. They had access to virtually every single talent on the continent and the resources with which to promote them.

And they stuck the Undertaker Vs. the Dudley Boyz in a handicap match as the main event of a pay-per-view.

At least they had the self-awareness to realise how sh*te that prospect was, if not the creativity to actually make it any better: the one-off 'Concrete Crypt' stipulation was basically Vince McMahon thinking you'd be swayed by alliteration. It was also a euphemism for "Look, we don't really want to see Bubba Ray Dudley work without a table either, so we'll sell you on it under the promise of a live execution".

If 'Taker refused to lose, Paul Heyman would have killed his manager Paul Bearer. 'Taker won, killed him anyway and remained a babyface (!). The footage of the rehearsed/pre-taped crime scene was eventually leaked, showing the Undertaker break character, which was verboten at the time.

He'll moan about disgracing his own legacy for a Peacock sob story now of course, but it was verboten at the time.

6. Keith Lee's Double Title Win

Sometimes, there's no boiled-over frustration nor malice involved in a leak - just sheer, blithering idiocy!

Advertisement

Back in the days when the Wednesday Night War between AEW and NXT was vaguely competitive - i.e. when the old school Pedro Morales sixty-something fans were piqued by the promise of desperate, reactionary booking with little impact on the demo - NXT counter-programmed AEW Fyter Fest 2020 with the Great American Bash. NXT won overall under the promise of a major NXT and North American Title unification match between Adam Cole and Keith Lee.

The second event of a two-week extravaganza was always the plan.

Don't mind that NXT logo hastily sewn on to a prop from 2004; the benevolent WWE simply wanted to give you the authentic experience of the Bash's halcyon days, at which Kenzo Suzuki and Mordecai ascended to mega-stardom by virtue of their wins over Billy Gunn and Hardcore Holly respectively.

Keith Lee lifted both belts following a match that is decidedly less easy to be snarky about, but the problem was that, held mid-pandemic - or mid-when-capitalism-gave-half-a-f*ck-about-it - the second night was taped as part of a block, allowing the bubble time to protect itself.

Saurav Gurjar, then of Indus Sher, posted a picture of Lee's celebration on Instagram, which common sense would indicate is a bad idea.

Perhaps, as with catching dives, they don't teach it in the Performance Center.

5. WWE Spoils The Draft

The mere concept of an October WWE Draft is itself stupid in a perversely entertaining way.

Advertisement

The annual Survivor Series event is built on the concept of brand warfare. It's meant to be WWE's version of a local sports derby, and there would be something to the concept if they gave half a sh*t about it or weren't so extravagantly thick.

As it stands, the timing of the Draft is so mystifying that the actual sporting equivalent is Rangers selling half of their first team squad on the final day of the January transfer window, and them kissing the badge in the Old Firm days later. Only, that can't be true, because supporters from both sides actually care about their respective teams. At RAW and SmackDown tapings, everybody just sits on their hands, bored sh*tless.

The Draft got even stupider in 2019 when the full list and indeed order of picks was leaked on the day of the first show on the company's website. Perceptive observers noted that the picks had already been telegraphed, spoiling the show as it unfolded.

Dave Meltzer revealed that a note was attached requesting that list be alphabetised, but perhaps the staffer thought "That sounds like a you problem" before just publishing as is.

4. The NXT UK Rehearsal Footage

The mere existence of NXT UK, when it isn't A) unspeakably bland or B) unspeakably grim, is C) perversely entertaining.

Advertisement

Think of it like this.

It was phase one of Triple H's grand masterplan to take over the entire wrestling world to a level beyond even Vince McMahon's national expansion. Where Vince wanted to take the Carolinas, Triple H wanted more. As heir apparent to the throne, he already had the States. Now, he had the UK. After that, he wanted India. Japan. Mexico. And he started this über-monopoly by...

Pushing Gallus in front of about 180 fans and telling some other guys with names like Archie Davies to throw on a pair of kick pads, stare at their hands, and silently mutter "Cor blimey" when an opponent kicked out of their signature.

It was already a dead brand before it suffered yet more embarrassment when, in November 2019, WWE accidentally leaked several hours of rehearsal footage, which was something they'd really never want the public to consume. It's a secretive practise that exposes just how patterned everything is on the very condescending behalf of its talent.

David Bixenspan received a tip from a friend, who stumbled onto the unlisted YouTube video via a presumed glitch. In it, literally every move was rehearsed in excruciating detail, all to get it just right.

Since the eventual broadcast might as well have been unlisted, for how many people watched it, this seems like a gigantic waste of time.

3. Every WrestleMania Main Event For Several Years

Ever noticed how WWE's plans are frequently made public, where AEW's tend not to be?

Advertisement

When was the last time AEW's pay-per-view main event was leaked months in advance?

It's suspicious, no?

It's almost as if Tony Khan has paid every last member of the wrestling media to keep his booking plans secret. It's almost as if pays them to fawn over his product, too, which is why several outlets in December 2019 ran with the headline 'Dark Order Recruit John Silver & Alex Reynolds In Amazing Angle That Was Better Than Anything Those C*nts DX Ever Did, The Promotion Is Fine Actually'.

Or, it might just be the case that - for now - Tony Khan has cultivated a content atmosphere in the workplace, in which morale is mostly high and there's consequently little motivation to spoil the fun?

It's also funny that Dave Meltzer is apparently without sources these days, since he has called every WrestleMania event for years and years.

WWE is a place in which even the most senior, protected acts bemoan the absolute state of it; Kofi Kingston in a recent interview with Metro.co.uk revealed that scrapped plans are "really kind of standard fare for us".

It's little wonder that anonymous sources retaliate by revealing the storylines that do end up happening.

2. That Video Of CM Punk's Arse

There is a video entitled 'CM Punk at Royal Rumble 2014' that remains available to watch on WWE.com to this day.

Advertisement

The video is a silent compilation of gratuitous shots of Punk's arse. His stint in the titular match is zoomed in on, captured in slow motion, and freeze-framed. He struggles with Seth Rollins in the corner as the editor all but leers. Either somebody on the staff really, really likes CM Punk - and why not, he's a piece and a half - or, there's a connection here to a certain infamous court case.

Did...did WWE upload an evidence exhibit to its public website because someone couldn't be bothered to download an MP4?

Yes.

This was WWE's attempt to prove, for the world to see, that there wasn't a "baseball-sized" lump on his back. Key evidence was simply uploaded to dot com.

Or, is this instead part of Triple's Performance Center curriculum 'Ass Sculpting 101': How To Get Rid Of Your Skinny Fat Ass'?

And if so, why's it still up?

Triple H doesn't work there anymore.

1. An Early Pandemic Misjudgment

In the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, WWE held shows on a closed set with minimal original content spliced with recent matches, which while practical and more safe - the fewer people in an enclosed space, the better - didn't half make for some emotional whiplash.

Advertisement

Watching a stadium full of fans enjoying the Royal Rumble before the sharp pivot to echoey, eerie "Oh now I remember, the world is completely f*cking over" empty arena wrestling was just awful.

You can't really blame the talents involved for not volunteering to do anything during a commercial break, but WWE was thick enough to forget that certain international markets didn't align their broadcasts with it. The result, in the case of Bayley and Sasha Banks Vs. Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross, was two full minutes of a stoppage.

Usually, the ad break is just a slow heat spot anyway - you're not going to do your best sh*t when nobody is watching on TV - but since nobody was watching in the venue, either, the match simply...stopped.

Yes, this exposé was mildly humiliating for all involved, but since the reaction was identical to most RAW tapings post-pandemic, what difference did it even make?

Advertisement