10 Times WWE Let Everyone Down At SummerSlam

Literally dousing the heat.

By Andy H Murray /

WWE.com

SummerSlam is generally touted as WWE's second biggest show of the year.

Advertisement

As part of the company's 'big four' pay-per-views, it benefits from a stronger promotional push than everything bar WrestleMania, which has resulted in some truly memorable events since the show's 1988 inception.

The latest edition takes place on August 20th. Highlighted by a Fatal 4-Way for Brock Lesnar's Universal Title, it'll come with an exorbitant amount of hype - though history suggests that fans would be wise to temper their expectations.

SummerSlam has a long history of letting the fans down, despite all the great memories it has created. 2016's incarnation came with 'Show Of The Year' potential, but ultimately failed to deliver on its immense promise, and finished as one of the year's most middle-of-the-road PPVs. Unfortunately, this is only the beginning. SummerSlam's legacy of disappointment runs far deeper than a single show.

This event has delivered iconic moments like Davey Boy Smith's win over Bret Hart (1992) and Shane McMahon's Titantron fall (2000), but it has also left the audience dismayed on dozens of occasions.

August 20th may well succeed, but consider these famous failures before getting too excited...

10. Brock Lesnar Bludgeons Randy Orton (2016)

WWE went into SummerSlam 2016 with a ton of momentum and one of the most exciting pay-per-view cards they'd assembled in a long time, but it was a largely disappointing night. A gruelling six-hour show, it featured a great John Cena vs. AJ Styles match, but almost everything else failed to meet expectations, particularly Brock Lesnar vs. Randy Orton.

Advertisement

It was 'The Viper's' first match since suffering a serious shoulder injury in October 2015, and inexplicably headlined the show over two World Title matches. This would've been fine had the match delivered, but it didn't. Orton and Lesnar spent more time brawling around ringside than actually wrestling, working to a bloody conclusion that put Brock over as a beast, but put Orton at tremendous risk.

The finish saw Lesnar mount his opponent before battering his skull with legitimate MMA-style elbow strikes, opening up a big cut on Randy's head. It was pre-planned, but Orton suffered a concussion, forcing him to pull out of a match with Bray Wyatt at Backlash the following month.

A completely unnecessary way to end the show, it didn't provoke the desired sense of shock from the audience, and instead left us wondering what the hell WWE were thinking.

9. The Ring Of Fire (2013)

The Wyatt Family joined WWE's main roster with a tremendous debut angle.

Advertisement

The characters felt fresh, exciting, and most important of all, different. Their creepy pre-arrival vignettes built immense hype, and they soon started battering their way through the roster, with Kane, R-Truth, and 3MB among the first victims.

This was all done to build towards Bray's big in-ring debut. Having spent the past month sending Kane messages to "follow the buzzards," 'The Eater Of Worlds' met 'The Big Red Machine' at SummerSlam. Sadly, the match was a total stinker, and memorable for all the wrong reasons.

An Inferno match in all but name, the Ring Of Fire suffered from each of the stipulation's usual problems. The crippling heat and lack of oxygen forced Kane and Wyatt to work a numbingly slow, plodding contest that did nothing to put Bray over as a decent worker, and he couldn't even win on his own accord, requiring Luke Harper and Erick Rowan's interference to do so.

The Wyatt Family's momentum was almost killed within those eight minutes. Bray has engaged in all kinds of terrible matches and wacky stipulations throughout his run, though few were worse than the Ring Of Fire.

8. WWE Dominate The Alliance (2001)

The wheels had come off the Invasion angle several weeks prior to SummerSlam 2001, but it was still salvageable by the time August 19th rolled around.

Advertisement

Mistakes had been made, and The Alliance were rarely treated like a legitimate threat. Still, with eight individual championships on the line, the right set of SummerSlam results could've tiled the angle in their favour, and recovered some much needed credibility.

Unfortunately, Vince McMahon had no intention of making his former rival promotions look good. The WWE side absolutely dominated the night, leaving with all but two of the titles, acquiring several new ones in the process.

Edge pinned Lance Storm to take the WWE Intercontinental Title in the opening match. X-Pac left the night as a double champion, having added Tajiri's WWE Light Heavyweight Title to his WCW Cruiserweight belt, while The Brothers Of Destruction did the same in the tag division. The Rock became WCW Champion in the main event. Depressingly, The Alliance's only championship gain was Rob Van Dam's Hardcore Title victory over Jeff Hardy.

A miserable night for the WCW/ECW side, SummerSlam 2001 wasn't quite the Invasion's death knell, but it definitely reduced the angle's momentum to a slither.

7. The Undertaker Vs. The Undertaker (1994)

As far as terrible '90s wrestling angles go, it's hard to beat the fake Undertaker saga.

Advertisement

It came about shortly after Royal Rumble 1994. The real Undertaker was written off television for seven months so he could heal a back injury, but talk of his return started surfacing after WrestleMania X. WWE produced vignettes of people claiming to have seen 'The Deadman' in public, and Ted DiBiase reintroduced the character to the audience, claiming he'd brought 'Taker back from the dead.

This 'Underfaker' was played not by Mark Calaway, but Brian Lee. Paul Bearer eventually brought the real Undertaker back into the fold, and the two were slated to face each other at SummerSlam 1994, resulting in one of the worst matches in the event's history.

The crowd were the first problem. Absolutely nobody bought into the fake Undertaker angle, and who could blame them? The storyline was complete and utter nonsense, and the match was a plodder, with Lee struggling to land a single blow on Calaway. The audience were fortunately put out of their misery following a series of Tombstone Piledrivers after nine minutes, and the angle was quickly abandoned.

6. The Universal Title's Unveiling (2016)

At Battleground 2016, SmackDown's newly drafted Dean Ambrose successfully defended his WWE Championship against Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins, leaving Raw without a top belt. The Universal Title was WWE's solution, with Stephanie McMahon and Mick Foley announcing that the first champion should be crowned at SummerSlam.

Advertisement

Rollins and Finn Bálor worked their way through a qualification tournament, earning the right to clash for the title at the PPV. The physical belt was also set to be unveiled at the event, and there was a great deal of anticipation heading in, with fans not only anxious for the match, but to see what Raw's apparent top prize was going to look like.

The big reveal couldn't have gone any worse, and the belt was derided as soon as it was unleashed. The crowd dismissed it immediately, and chants of "this belt sucks" plagued the ensuing match, turning what was supposed to be a landmark moment into a total farce. While Foley and Rollins both responded defensively on social media, the company only have themselves to blame.

It's not the worst belt they've ever designed, but the big red Universal Title is hideous, and not at all what the crowd were expecting.

5. Vader Falls To Shawn Michaels (1996)

Vader is one of the most misused wrestlers in WWE history.

Advertisement

Widely regarded as one of the best gaijins to ever compete in Japan, he found tremendous success in NJPW throughout the '80s and '90s, and was able to replicate this in WCW, where he became an immediate World Heavyweight Title contender shortly after going full-time in 1992.

He was one of wrestling's greatest monster heels, but WWE never knew how to book him. Debuting in the 1996 Royal Rumble, Vader feuded with Yokozuna at first, then set his sights on WWE Champion Shawn Michaels. It started with a simple attack, escalated with Vader pinning 'HBK' in a tag match at In Your House 9, and culminated in a big SummerSlam singles bout, with Michaels' belt on the line.

This would've been the ideal moment to have Vader go over and cement him as WWE's unquestionable top dog. WWE, however, had different plans. 'The Mastodon' initially won via count out, then picked up another 'victory' via disqualification when Michaels used Jim Cornette's tennis racket.

The farce continued with a third restart, and Shawn pinned his opponent cleanly this time, effectively ending his chances of becoming a top guy.

4. The Undertaker Vs. Giant Gonzalez II (1993)

The Undertaker vs. Giant Gonzalez at WrestleMania IX was an absolute stinker, and perhaps the worst offering in 'The Deadman's' legendary Streak. Leave it to WWE to book a rematch nobody wanted for their second biggest show of the year, then.

Advertisement

Feuding with 'Taker was supposed to put Gonzalez over as WWE's next big monster, but it only exposed his deficiencies. Height was the 7'7" brute's only positive quality. He moved around the ring with the grace and poise of a drunk elephant, struggling to execute even the most rudimentary of wrestling moves, and he hadn't improved by SummerSlam.

Contested under 'Rest In Peace' rules (a No DQ match, basically), there was nothing good about the rematch. Gonzalez was still lumbering awkwardness personified, and while 'Taker wasn't a bad wrestler by any means, he was years away from reaching his peak as a performer, and couldn't drag anything watchable out of his opponent.

The finish was particularly bad. Gonzalez's height meant that 'Taker was physically incapable of executing a Tombstone Piledriver on him without breaking his neck, so 'The Phenom' was forced to finish it with a clothesline. A lame conclusion, but Gonzalez fortunately left WWE soon after.

3. Super Cena Bulldozes The Nexus (2010)

SummerSlam has been a traditional burial ground for great wrestling angles throughout the 21st century, with one of the most spectacular examples coming at 2010.

Advertisement

The Nexus were white hot ahead of the event. Wade Barrett's were coming off one of the most viscerally thrilling debuts in WWE history, having literally destroyed an episode of Monday Night Raw. The ensuing weeks saw them obliterate everything before them, leading to a big seven-on-seven match at SummerSlam that they'd surely win, continuing their incredible momentum.

Unfortunately, The Nexus ran into Super Cena that night.

John led a team containing the likes of Chris Jericho, Edge, and former Nexus man Daniel Bryan against the invaders, and the elimination rules whittled it down to him vs. Justin Gabriel and Barrett. What followed was one of the most staggering burials of Cena's career, with him fending off both Nexus members single-handedly, submitting Wade just seconds after Gabriel's elimination.

The Nexus lost everything that night. Their momentum had been destroyed by Cena, who reportedly refused to put the group over despite Jericho and Edge's protestations, and they were never the same again. Predictably, the feud ended in a literal burial, with Cena trapping Barrett beneath a pile of chairs at TLC that December.

2. The Entire 1995 Event

One of the New Generation era's worst major shows, SummerSlam 1995 was saved only by a strong Intercontinental Title ladder match between Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon. The rest of the card was a turgid mess, and nowhere near good enough for a show regularly pushed as WWE's second biggest pay-per-view of the year.

Advertisement

Let's start with the worst of the bunch: the main event.

Diesel's WWE Championship defence against King Mabel deserves to go down as one of WWE's all-time worst headlining matches. While Diesel was never a particularly exciting wrestler, his opponent made him look like Ricky Steamboat. Big, slow, and dangerously clumsy, Mabel's mere presence was enough to kill the match, and his performance was predictably sluggish.

The undercard wasn't much better, either. Bret Hart has stuck facing Isaac Yankem DDS, while The Undertaker had the unenviable task of trying to drag an enjoyable Casket match out of Kama. The undercard flopped too, with Bob Holly vs. a young Hunter Hearst Helmsley the main offender.

Fans have rightly come to expect excellence from SummerSlam, given the event's billing, but while this show wasn't close to the horrors of King Of The Ring '95, it was still one of the year's worst.

1. Kevin Nash & Alberto Del Rio Kill The Summer Of Punk (2011)

No wrestler was hotter than CM Punk heading into SummerSlam 2011.

Advertisement

His 'Summer Of Punk' storyline had been a complete success, with his Money In The Bank showdown with John Cena creating one of the most electric atmospheres in wrestling history. WWE probably brought him back to television too soon, but his momentum continued throughout his return, and he was set to wrestle John Cena for the WWE Undisputed Championship at the event.

Sadly, SummerSlam 2011 was the night the Summer Of Punk died. The Chicagoan once again defeated Cena, but he was attacked by the returning Kevin Nash in the aftermath. The former Diesel came out of nowhere, downing Punk with his Jackknife Powerbomb, allowing Alberto Del Rio to run to the ring, cash-in his Money In The Bank briefcase, and take the belt.

It was a staggering momentum-killer for Punk, whose creative direction had been murdered. The storyline eventually devolved into a bizarre feud against Nash and Triple H, and 'The Game' buried him even deeper with a win at Night Of Champions.

These booking decisions sucked the life out of an incredible, attention-grabbing storyline, and it started at SummerSlam.

Advertisement