Wrestlemania 31 was one of the most enjoyable 'Mania for years - both in terms of sheer entertainment, and - the outcome of Sting vs Triple H not withstanding - one of the most satisfying from a booking point-of-view. Crucially, the match between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship didn't disappoint. WWE managed to get the belt off of The Anomaly without making him look any less of a beast, while Roman Reigns, the recipient of so much disdain over his highly debatable readiness for such a spot at the Show Of Shows, looked strong despite defeat. Seth Rollins cashing in his Money In The Bank briefcase was an exhilarating curveball, and a perfect way to crown a new WWE Champion. Satisfying indeed. WWE don't always get it right, however. Every now and then, there are booking decisions that leave us with our heads in our hands. It's usually bad enough on the occasions when the WWE Champion and title are not involved, but when they are, it tends to leave us wondering why they would treat their own championship as an afterthought, and why they would put said championship on a guy they are not willing to back. Champions have been made to look weak, have had their momentum killed, and in some of the more extreme cases, been left to look like complete laughing stocks. Some have sunk without trace, while some have taken years to claw their way back to the main event. Here are 10 of those glaring occasions WWE threw their champion under the bus.
10. Randy Orton (vs. Triple H) - Unforgiven 2004
Evolution. The past (Ric Flair), the present (Triple H), and the future (Randy Orton and Batista). Only, WWE weren't quite ready for the future. At least not yet, and not Randy Orton. The opposite did seem to be the case when Orton won the World Heavyweight Championship at Summerslam 2004 to become the youngest world champ in history, but the next night on RAW, Evolution turned on their bright new star. After getting the thumbs down from Triple H, Orton took a pummelling designed to remind him of his place in the pecking order. In the run up to Unforgiven, Orton gave as good as he got, spitting in The Game's face when offered the chance to return to Evolution in exchange for his World Heavyweight title. At the PPV however, it was Triple H who won the strap, after repeated interference from Flair & Batista. The future had been stopped dead in its tracks, but it wouldn't have been so bad had Orton continued to chase Triple H, finally toppling The King Of Kings at the Grandest Stage Of Them All. Instead, Randy floundered around as a crowd pandering face, while the honour of beating Triple H at Wrestlemania 21 went to the 'other' future - Royal Rumble winner, Batista. It is a testament to the ability of the man now known as The Viper that he managed to come back from this to become what he is today - a 12-time world champion.
9. Chris Jericho (vs. Triple H) - WrestleMania X8
You might argue that this one never stood a chance. Normally, the main event of Wrestlemania is just that - the main event. The match that everyone wants to see, the one that draws the PPV buys, the one that gets everybody talking. Except, at Wrestlemania X8, there was one other match the world was waiting for. It was, of course, Hulk Hogan vs The Rock. If you've seen that match, you don't need me to go over it here. If you haven't, then you really ought to go look it up. Suffice to say, the Toronto crowd were left exhausted and had nothing left for Y2J, The Game, and their battle to be WWE Undisputed Champion. Unfortunate circumstances, yes. Was the feud deserving of better? Aw, hell no. The build up was... well, weird. You might have expected a storyline leading to the match for the WWE Undisputed title at Wrestlemania to be a little more serious, with the focus firmly on champ and challenger. Instead, it was all about the breakdown of Triple H and Stephanie McMahon's marriage, and who got custody of The Game's bulldog, Lucy. Jericho somehow ended up taking little Lucy for a walk, and we realised that WWE had no intention of making us feel like the match was a big deal. Chris Jericho, WWE's first Undisputed Champion, had been relegated to comedy sideshow.
8. The Undertaker (vs. Hulk Hogan) - This Tuesday In Texas 1991
Mere days after Taker had won his very first WWE title from Hulk Hogan at Survivor Series, becoming the youngest champion in history at the time, Undertaker defended the belt against Hogan in a rematch at a strange PPV with the rather catchy moniker, 'This Tuesday In Texas'. Mean Gene did his best to make it sound spicy, but everyone knew the PPV had been thrown together. You have to remember how strongly the Undertaker was booked back then. No-selling and sitting bolt upright every single time he was knocked down. I remember, as a little Hulkamaniac, wondering whether anyone could beat this creepy zombie dude. Even the 'Immortal' Hulk Hogan. This, ladies and gentlemen, was a helluva big deal. If WWE really wanted to strap the jet pack to the Undertaker, they would never have a better chance. But this was never the plan. You have to remember, also, the presence of the Nature Boy, Ric Flair, who had interfered in the match at Survivor Series just days prior, and was all set to get involved again. Undertaker, at this point, was merely a spoke on the wheel. The real beef was between Hogan and Flair, and the real issue was WWE dithering on when to pull the trigger on a match between those two. Of course, they never did - we had to wait until both men had landed in WCW for that - and the title was vacated after Hogan, a face, remember, won it back by throwing ash from Taker's urn into the Deadman's eyes and then rolling him up for the three count. Flair ended up winning the Royal Rumble and the vacant title. Undertaker's recovery from that night is the stuff of legend, of course. Even if he did have to wrestle Giant Gonzalez along the way.
7. Vince McMahon Beats Triple H For The WWE Title (SmackDown 1999)
Given Triple H's status over the years in WWE, it's perhaps a little easy to forget that he was once the hot, rising heel, competing with the likes of Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock for his place at the top of the food chain. Of course, the creative powers at the time decided that the best thing to do with the current WWE Champion was to have the owner of the company, one Vincent Kennedy McMahon, defeat him for the title. Triple H had called Vince out, insulting him and making suggestive comments about his wife, Linda. Vince eventually took the bait, much to the horror of his son, Shane, who had expected to guest referee a match, but thought it might be The Rock involved, or perhaps Mankind. One vicious beat down later at the hands of The Game, and Vince was bleeding like a stuck pig. Then, the glass shattered, and out came Austin. A stunner to Chyna was followed by a stunner to Triple H. Vince was saved. Then, Stone Cold dragged his long-time foe's body over that of The Game for the cover. Shane counted the pinfall, and that was it - Vince was champ in his own promotion, and Triple H was left looking like a chump. The whole charade led to Vince vacating the title, and Triple H winning it back not long after in a six-pack challenge, leaving us pointlessly, inexplicably, all the way back at square one.
6. Bob Backlund Loses WWE Title To Diesel (1994)
Bob Backlund. The ultimate 'transitional champion'. The year was 1994, and Backlund was back in WWE for a second run. Having previously worked for the company from the late 70s to the early 80s, and having had the second longest run with the title after Bruno Sammartino, the WWE that Backlund returned to was much changed to the one he left. He was a throwback to a simpler time, before the outlandish characters of the 90s, and struggled to make much of an impact until he added a psychotic element to his gimmick, regularly snapping during matches and locking opponents in the Crossface Chickenwing. He won his second WWE Championship at Survivor Series, applying this hold to Bret Hart until the Hitman's mother was convinced to throw in the towel by dastardly brother Owen. In today's WWE, the idea of a face vs face matchup for the WWE title isn't such a strange thing, but it was clearly somewhere they feared to tread in 1994. Diesel was to be the next WWE Champion, having just made a face turn, but WWE did not want him winning it from Bret, so Backlund served as the go between. The way it went down, however, made the title itself look cheap, and made Hart look weak for not being able to beat Backlund. Diesel (Kevin Nash to his pals) won the title in just 8 seconds at a house show at Madison Square Garden, pinning Backlund after a kick to the gut and a Jackknife Powerbomb. For all Nash's compliments directed towards Backlund for the way he sold the Jackkinfe - Backlund crawled back up the ramp in theatric agony - it was clear that Bob was done in WWE, and would never be taken seriously as a main event performer again.
5. CM Punk's First World Heavyweight Championship (2008)
Punks reign had started well enough, with that adrenaline-pumping Money In The Bank cash-in on Edge on RAW, moments after the Rated-R Superstar had taken a hellacious beating from Batista. Punk retained against JBL the very same night, and we thought we were all set for Punk to have an enjoyable run with the Big Gold Belt. Oh man, were we wrong. In a classic case of WWE wanting to protect their big hitters, we got a match at The Great American Bash 2008 between Punk and Batista, the man who had enabled his MITB cash-in. So far, so logical. Unfortunately, Punk was made to look oh-so-midcard. Instead of a valiant effort to prove he could hang with the best, Punk got in only sporadic offense. It was, at times, a throwback to those early 90s matches where a jobber faced off against a name. Big Daves constant smirking, as if to say, What are you doing here, with me? didnt help matters. At last, Kane interfered (fair enough - if something already doesnt make sense, you might as well add Kane to the mix) and attacked first Batista, then Punk, chokeslamming him in the middle of the ring, causing a double DQ. The message from WWE was that Punk was not capable of retaining against someone like Batista, a point they then felt they had to underline with Punk eating a Batista Bomb. Incredibly, Punk ended up losing the title in a match he wasnt even involved in. A backstage beatdown from Randy Orton and Legacy meant Punk was replaced in the nonsensical Championship Scramble at Unforgiven by its eventual winner, Chris Jericho.
4. Christian (vs. Randy Orton) - SmackDown 2011
At Extreme Rules 2011, we witnessed one the great feelgood moments in WWE. Following the retirement of his best buddy Edge, Christian went up against Alberto Del Rio in a Ladder Match with The Mexican Aristocrat's World Heavyweight Championship at stake. Just as Del Rio looked set to grab the title hanging above the ring, out rolled Edge in an expensive looking 4x4, honking the horn and causing enough of a distraction for Christian to knock Del Rio flying and make his own way up the ladder to claim his very first world title in WWE. The longtime friends celebrated together in the middle of the ring in what was truly a special moment. The joy was short-lived. On the very next Smackdown, Christian defended the title against Randy Orton in what was, really, a very good match. After succumbing to an RKO from the Viper, however, Christian lost the match and the World Heavyweight title. It was as if Extreme Rules hadn't happened. As if WWE were saying, 'You've had your moment, now we're putting the belt on our guy'. Fans crapped all over it. You could feel the rage. The Internet had become self-aware, and it was angry. Credit must go to Christian, however, who made the most of the situation by turning heel and providing plenty of entertainment with his constant whining about having to defend the title so soon after winning it. After failing to regain the championship at Over The Limit and Capitol Punishment, Christian eventually defeated Orton at Money In The Bank to become a two-time World Heavyweight Champion. No one cared that Christian was supposed to be the heel. The Chicago crowd, and the furious denizens of the internet, rejoiced that the man who should not have lost the title in the first place had managed to get one over on WWE and their handpicked guy.
3. Daniel Bryan (vs. Sheamus) - WWE WrestleMania XXVIII
This one worked out a lot better for Daniel Bryan than it did for Sheamus in the long run, but it sure as hell didn't feel like it at the time. Everyone had kind of been getting used to the fact that the World Heavyweight Championship was no longer anywhere near being on a par with the WWE Championship in terms of prestige, but for those who clung to the idea that it was still a top tier title, the illusion was shattered when the match for the Big Gold Belt opened Wrestlemania 28. The crowd seemed to give a collective 'WTF?' as the match was announced as being first up, before Sheamus made his way to the ring. Still, those in attendance regained their composure and enthusiasm for the arrival of Daniel Bryan, with 'Yes!' chants and signs aplenty. There was no doubt who Miami's favourite was for this one, despite Bryan's status as heel. The bell rang, but we didn't get down to business right away. Bryan, with AJ Lee in his corner, turned round to receive a good luck smooch. Seconds later, Sheamus nailed the World Heavyweight Champion with a Brogue Kick, and the match was over. If it were possible for a Wrestlemania moment to be both 'wow' and 'this sucks' at the same time, then this was it. Daniel Bryan, and the World Heavyweight Championship that Sheamus now held, didn't mean a thing. Luckily for Daniel Bryan, he already had a legion of fans who were willing to wait a couple of years for a proper 'Yes!' moment at Wrestlemania 30.
2. CM Punk's Undisputed WWE Championship (2011)
Remember how hot Punk was in 2011 after Money In The Bank? WWE had its new star. Sure, he disappeared for a while after beating Cena for the title in Chicago, with Cena (who else?) being crowned as a sort of interim champ in his absence, but after returning on RAW ahead of Summerslam, a series of promo battles on the mic with Triple H over the state of WWE meant that Punk still had great momentum. At Summerslam, Punk and Cena went at it once more to confirm the real WWE Champion, with Triple H as guest referee. Like in their previous bout at Money In The Bank, Punk looked like he belonged in the main event, escaping STFs and kicking out of Attitude Adjustments. But sadly, just like in Chicago, we got a finish that was anything but decisive, as Triple H counted the 1-2-3 in favour of Punk while Cena's foot was on the bottom rope. WWE's need to protect Cena was tedious, but not unexpected. And hey, at least the right guy was leaving Summerslam with the title. Those were the thoughts running through our heads until Kevin Nash appeared in the middle of the ring, hit Punk with the Jackknife Powerbomb, and escaped through the crowd. Moments later, Alberto Del Rio cashed in his Money In The Bank briefcase and was the new WWE Champion. Cue the CM Punk/Kevin Nash feud, which did absolutely nothing for Punk, other than lead to a singles match against Triple H that Punk lost, despite The Game being in the twilight of his career. Triple H then feuded with Nash over Big Daddy Cool texting himself instructions to attack Punk from Triple H's phone (huh?), which left Punk with nothing better to do than to go and reclaim his WWE title from Del Rio in a flat bout at Survivor Series that made us wonder what the point was of Nash costing him the strap in the first place.
1. Bret Hart & Yokozuna (WrestleMania IX)
WWE really excelled themselves with this one, arguably sacrificing two champions on the altar of Hulkamania in quick succession. It was champion Bret 'Hitman' Hart squaring off against challenger Yokozuna, a fresh main event with new stars after years of Hogan, Warrior, Savage et al, and unusually for Wrestlemania, it appeared that the crowd would not be going home happy. Hart had Yoko in the Sharpshooter, but lost his hold and the match when Mr. Fuji intervened, throwing salt in the eyes of the Hitman. Yoko made the pin, and Wrestlemania was about to end with a heel champion. That was, until Hulk Hogan arrived ringside to check on his 'friend', Bret Hart. Because all faces were best pals back in those days, y'know. Fuji challenged Hogan to step into the ring with Yokozuna, and all of a sudden, everything was about Hulk Hogan once more. Neither Bret nor Yoko were going to get their Wrestlemania moment; that went, once again, to Hogan. Fuji threw salt into Yoko's eyes by mistake, and Hogan hit the legdrop to give us a new (old) champion. So much for building for the future. Hogan, for his part, worked the crowd brilliantly with his expressions, his delight at being champion again putting over just how important the title was to him. Bret and Yoko, however, had been thrown in the dumpster. All because WWE lacked the grapefruits to let go of the past and the sure-fire draw that was Hogan.