10 Times WWE Tried To Recapture The Magic (And Failed)

If Ric Flair has taught us one lesson in life, it's leave the memories alone.

By Darren Hyland /

Dredging up past glories has been a favourite pastime in WWE for many years now. Legends of the business are regularly trotted out, paraded for nostalgia pops and short-term rating bumps at the expense of the long-term future of the company. Almost as often, the most effective storylines and moments from years gone by are rehashed and updated, to varying degrees of success.

Advertisement

While some of these retreads are handled with the proper care, and just enough nostalgia to call back to the original without slipping into parody territory, the hit rate for these types of angles is criminally low. Leaving the past alone has been a struggle for WWE through the last decade as TV ratings continue to fall, and the company leans ever more heavily on the fading stars and worn-out tales of a period that is now out of touch with modern-day wrestling.

Some of the entries on this list reference specific matches involving Superstars that should have been nowhere near the ring, some take in a shocking moment that couldn't possibly be replicated to the same degree of emotion, and some reflect on times WWE almost actually pulled off that old magic one more time before failing to follow through once again.

10. Mike Tyson Punches Chris Jericho (Monday Night Raw)

This moment reflects the stark change from Attitude to PG. Firstly, DX in 2010 were a drop in the ocean compared to the revolutionaries who ushered in the second wrestling boom in the '90s. Shawn and Hunter had made right some of the wrongs from the 2006 reunion debacle of two middle-aged men dropping excrement on other middle-aged men, but this was not 1997. This DX included Hornswoggle.

Advertisement

On the other side of the coin you have Mike Tyson, who wasn't the greatest performer when he turned on Michaels in 1998. Over a decade later, Tyson telegraphed the turn, firstly from his body language but mainly by taking half an hour to remove his shirt.

Credit has to go to Jericho here. The reaction to the pop for Tyson's reveal was perfect, and the expression as he looked around to see the DX tee was priceless. Still, the original incident closed WrestleMania XIV, while this was a throwaway Raw tag match featuring one of the revolving door of guest hosts they were employing at the time.

9. Vince McMahon Vs. Bret Hart (WrestleMania XXVI)

Well, this one was a struggle. WrestleMania XXVI wasn't exactly a one-match show - and nowhere near the atrocity we would bear witness to the following year - but this match drags down the overall grade by one or two points. It was that bad. The idea to put one man a decade into retirement in the ring against the then-65-year-old McMahon, and then have them wrestle for over ten minutes was a baffling one.

Advertisement

Actually, 'wrestle' is too strong a word. It was a painfully slow encounter featuring a prolonged family beatdown of the boss. Every living Hart got their licks in, and while it was no doubt therapeutic for them, it was a slog of epic proportions for us.

Attempting to capture any of The Hitman's magic from the '90s was foolhardy, to say the least. He went on to win the United States title by submitting The Miz, before ending his in-ring career with four multi-man match victories. One of the greatest ring generals of all time should never have been brought back to active performing, particularly factoring in the stroke he suffered in 2002.

8. Triple H Vs. The Undertaker (Super Show-Down)

The End Of An Era match at WrestleMania XXVIII was a marvellous affair. Of the string of world-class matches The Undertaker reeled off from 'Manias 23 through 29, the two against Trips are among the best. The Hell In A Cell match didn't carry the technical perfection of his double-header with HBK, but the story was told magnificently between three of the greatest performers in wrestling history.

Advertisement

Six years on from the end of that era, the foes clashed again in a 'Last Time Ever' contest at Super Showdown in Melbourne, Australia. Unsurprisingly, both men were a step slower ('Taker, in particular), and the match was a plodding twenty-seven-minute shadow of both WrestleMania matches. Even the No DQ stipulation and the additions of Shawn Michaels and Kane at ringside just couldn't capture that same unhinged brilliance from the turn of the decade.

Also, while technically this battle was the last singles match between the pair, all four men mentioned above got into the ring one last time in 2018 for a match that lasted over twice as long as the next longest on Crown Jewel. The less said about any of that, the better.

7. Any Recreation Of The Montreal Screwjob

Sticking with Shawn Michaels for one more entry, The Montreal Screwjob was a momentous day for professional wrestling and WWE as a whole. It birthed the Mr McMahon character, began the breakdown of on-screen kayfabe, and set the groundwork for the Attitude Era to change the game in the Monday Night Wars. You may have heard about this match before.

Advertisement

It took precisely one year for the Screwjob to be repeated. At the next Survivor Series, The Rock aligned himself with the evil Mr McMahon, going on a tear and actually benefiting immensely from the heel turn offered by the replicated finish. From then on, things got sillier and more tiresome by the year.

Anything featuring Shawn Michaels? Screwjob. Bret Hart is involved? Screwjob. An event in Montreal? Natalya, she's related to Bret, right? You get the idea. The raw nature of the original was so real, and the atmosphere and legacy so etched into every fan's mind, that any attempt at recreation falls flat and feels forced. The bit needs to be retired: this is one that can never be redone well, even if they legit shoot on somebody.

6. The Authority: Vinnie Mac Wannabees

In compiling this list it has become apparent just how many immeasurable moments Vincent Kennedy McMahon has been a part of - such as becoming the single greatest authority figure in wrestling history. Ironically, it is the same Vincent Kennedy McMahon who is trying to imitate many of his own successes, to no avail.

Advertisement

Bringing The Authority in as the newest attempt at a heel figurehead of Monday Night Raw in 2013 was cursed from the get-go. The General Manager Merry-Go-Round on Raw had become so ridiculous that it was impossible to care about who was kayfabe running the show. As good a heel team as Stephanie McMahon and Triple H was, opening every show with upwards of twenty minutes of self-appreciation got tiresome in a hurry.

To boil down the Mr McMahon character to one key feature is a disservice. However, the fundamental reason that character has become so revered is down to the utter zaniness of Vince. The man went out of his way time and again to ham it up whenever he was on screen. Mr McMahon was a meme before memes, just waiting for the internet to catch up. The Authority was dull, monotonous, and frankly hard to watch.

5. Ryback's Streak

There was a time in 2012 when Ryback was rather over with fans. The 'Feed Me More' chants were audibly organic, and WWE seemed intent on boosting The Big Guy by giving him a promising undefeated streak when the new gimmick debuted. As the story stomped along to a WWE title shot, the formulaic nature of each match began to wear thin.

Advertisement

Instead of projecting Ryback as the next big star of the PG Era, however, the comparisons to another muscular bald gentleman with an impressive unbeaten run grew as Ryback's winning ways went on. The Goldberg chants were harsh on the new Superstar although, in fairness, he wasn't exactly a virtuoso in the ring.

Ryback's routine of destroy jobber, repeat, was kept a little interesting when he began giving two enhancement talents the Shellshock simultaneously but it was never enough. WWE couldn't even get Goldberg to recreate Goldberg's WCW run. They attempted the same trick twice with Ryback, even giving him an Intercontinental title run in 2015, having him win one of the worst Elimination Chamber matches in history to seal the deal.

4. The New Nexus (Not That New Nexus)

Heading to Ryback's WWE origin story, and I'll get this out there right now: the debut and initial run of The Nexus was lightning in a bottle. Before they were fed to John Cena they tore up the company with a genuine chip on their shoulder, and it was glorious. As we all know, the story didn't end the way the fans, The Nexus, Chris Jericho or Edge had hoped it would.

Advertisement

It seems that WWE hasn't learned a thing from that experience a decade ago. Once again, they have created a faction to come in as unsigned outsiders, illegitimate parasites, and then neutered their own feral beast and turned them into a laughing stock. The Nexus came straight in at the top with a stunning ringside wrecking job and beatdown of John Cena and CM Punk. So far Retribution have mainly been jumping in on other people's feuds.

This is not a knock on the members of Retribution. However, even if WWE rescue them from the dumpster fire that the creative team lit themselves, that initial impact has been lost forever. While The Nexus started with an explosion before going out with a whimper, Retribution has been thrown overboard before even leaving port.

3. 'Woken' Matt Hardy

Ugh. If there's one thing WWE enjoy more than poorly ripping off their own past ideas, it's taking another company's game-changing concept and WWEifying it. Case in point: 'Broken/Woken' Matt Hardy.

Advertisement

Love it or hate it, the 'Broken' persona of Matt Hardy created a fresh buzz around the business, the likes of which hadn't been seen in years. The elder Hardy Boy had finally cast his own shadow, and positioned himself front and centre of the industry as one of the most out-there thinkers in the game. The Final Deletion was loathed by wrestling purists, but it provided us with something different, something so out of the box that it would never have been allowed to happen in the world of WWE until it found popularity somewhere else.

Following the immense attention for Brother Nero, SeƱor Benjamin, and Smokin' Joe the kangaroo, the stupendously bad House Of Horrors match was born. The outrageous cinematic matches we got at WrestleMania 36 may never have been conceived, pandemic or not, without The Final Deletion. As soon as the 'E got their hands on Matt Hardy, the slickness of the production and the overreliance on certain noises and catchphrases (a common WWE trope) got the better of the angle. They managed to turn the most unique and talked-about character in wrestling at the time into a one-dimensional Superstar, falling into line back in the mid-card.

2. Shield Split 2.0

When Seth Rollins took two steps behind his Shield colleagues in 2014, chair in hand, it was a stunning moment in wrestling. The group had been on an absolute tear since their introduction to the company as a team two years prior, and the timing was perfect. To leave the fans wanting more and create an outcry that it was too soon to break up the group was admittedly excellent booking on WWE's part.

Advertisement

Rollins went on to become WWE Champion with the greatest Money In The Bank cash-in we've ever seen, Reigns was freed up to be the next John Cena, and Ambrose was criminally misused until his exit from the company in 2019. Before Jon Moxley returned to our screens, though, we were made to wait three years to see The Shield get back together, in a rare case of WWE not rushing through storylines for a diminished payoff. Then, WWE rushed the second betrayal of The Shield for a diminished payoff.

Ambrose's initial attack on Rollins was a surprise moment for sure, due to the fresh announcement regarding Reigns' leukaemia. Everything that happened after that was just a letdown. The direction Ambrose's character went was such left-field cringe that it actually hurt the legacy of the group. The second Shield split didn't catch fire like the first, due mainly down to WWE's appalling treatment of Ambrose.

1. John Spear-na

If WWE wanted to create the next John Cena from 2009-2019, forcing a Superstar down the fans' throats to immediate rejection, they succeeded completely: the attempt to fast-track Roman Reigns from The Shield's muscle to babyface world champion worked about as well as the title for this entry. Reigns had already tasted tag team gold alongside Seth Rollins, but having him come out of the Shield's split straight into the world title picture was too much, too fast.

Advertisement

It has to be said that this strategy could have worked. As is often the way with WWE, Reigns' push was truncated to get The Big Dog where the company wanted him as quickly as possible. Had Roman built his brand of badassery solo for a year or so, then follow more or less the same beats as he actually did, he might not have garnered the boos. Instead, he had cheesy promos and Super Cena meme booking.

Ambrose and Rollins were the fans' choices for the breakout Shield star. As soon as Reigns began his ascent, things went south for the Universe-appointed chosen one. He was the 'WWE guy' in The Shield, and his 2015 Royal Rumble win preceded three world titles in the space of five months. Fortunately, his heel work alongside Paul Heyman has finally unlocked the potential of a superb athlete. In a way, Reigns is now the household name WWE wanted him to be, so, mission accomplished?

Advertisement