10 Totally Ineffective WWE Heel Runs

Less heat than the shady side of an iceberg.

By Andy H Murray /

Playing heel is supposed to be easy. Unhampered by the moral restraints of their babyface counterparts, wrestling's bad guys can essentially get away with doing and saying whatever they want, so long as it gets them booed. It's much easier to get people to hate you than like you, and thus, the sport's villains are often said to have a much easier time getting over than the roster's heroes.

Advertisement

This may well be the case, but being an effective heel is a lot more difficult than grabbing a microphone and saying a few mean things each week. If the performer can't make the audience buy into their act, they'll draw no reaction at all, and if they're too affable, they'll be cheered in spite of their actions. Both represent failure in every heel's ultimate goal of drawing crowd heat, and WWE history is peppered with examples of both.

Some flopped because of the way they were presented by the company, while others just weren't skilled enough to flourish in their newfound spotlight. Either way, none of these heel runs generated lasting vitriol from the crowd, and each was eventually abandoned.

10. Jesus

Aaron Aguilera initially served as one half of Los Conquistadores during an angle with Edge and Christian at the turn of the century, but was let go at the story's conclusion. It took him four years to make it back to WWE, but he eventually re-emerged as Jesus in 2004.

Advertisement

Carlito had just become United States Champion at the time, and was embroiled in a feud with the fast rising John Cena. Having taken the title in his first match company, Carlito enlisted Jesus as his bodyguard, leading to an ill-conceived angle that saw Aguilera kayfabe stab Cena in the kidney during an altercation at a Boston nightclub. This kept John off television for a month, but he eventually returned, first regaining his US Title, then facing Jesus at Armageddon.

Cena inevitably triumphed, but WWE literally wrote Jesus to stab another human being as part of the storyline, and he still couldn't get over. The audience were almost silent as he emerged for the Armageddon match: Jesus failed to connect on every conceivable level, and he was eventually released in 2005, having gone for back surgery immediately after the conclusion of the failed Cena feud.

9. Luther Reigns

Though he was under WWE employ for close to two years, Luther Reigns failed to make any impact as a member of the full-time roster. Debuting as SmackDown General Manager Kurt Angle's assistant, he was handed a relatively high profile role alongside 'The Olympic Hero,' and engaged in a lengthy feud with Big Show throughout his first few months on television.

Advertisement

The rivalry spanned several PPV cycles, and often incorporated Angle and Mark Jindrak (the duo's new ally), but completely failed to get Reigns over as a heel. The trio eventually formed a new 'Team Angle,' with Jindrak and Reigns playing henchmen while working as a tag team, which led to a feud with The Undertaker in February 2005. Unsurprisingly, Luther was defeated, and Jindrak eventually turned on him.

Though he was struggling to get any kind of crowd reaction whatsoever, WWE didn't give up hope on Luther. They eventually decided to resume his feud with Show in one last roll of the dice, but it failed again, and Luther was relegated to Velocity shortly after. Not even the rub of working with Angle, Show, and 'Taker could get Reigns over, so noticeable were his deficiencies.

8. Vladimir Kozlov

Vladimir Kozlov was always relatively well presented by WWE, at least in his early days. A big, burly Ukrainian, he had his icy death stare down to a tee, and his (initial) lack of entrance music helped him stand out from the rest of the roster. The trouble was that Kozlov absolutely stunk between the ropes, and while he was able to mask this when squashing jobbers, it became a huge problem when he was elevated.

Advertisement

Kozlov was a big lad, which, as we're all aware, is often all it takes for a main event push in WWE. Having spent his first few months trashing enhancement wrestlers, he was inserted into the WWE Title picture through assaults on Jeff Hardy and Triple H, and he bombed horrendously. Kozlov wasn't over, wasn't putting on good matches, and while WWE kept him unpinned until Elimination Chamber 2009, he wasn't gaining any real traction at the top of the card.

His career went into free fall thereafter. Having flopped as a monster heel, Kozlov became a comedy character by 2010, and eventually left WWE the following year, having had his leg (kayfabe) broken as part of Mark Henry's Hall Of Pain angle.

7. Heidenreich

Say what you will about modern day WWE, but it has been a long time since we were presented with a gimmick as laughable as Heidenreich's. A former NFL football player, he joined WWE in 2003, and was immediately inserted into a free agent storyline while under the control of an unknown entity named "Little Johnny."

Advertisement

The angle was abandoned without resolution, and Heidenreich disappeared. He returned as a poetry reading psychopath in 2004, and that's when things got particularly weird. One night on SmackDown, Heidenreich attacked commentator Michael Cole, dragged him backstage, and, ahem, had his way with him in a bathroom.

The angle was intended to put Heidenreich over as a monster, but it was far too ridiculous for the fans to buy into. Like Giant Gonzalez before him, Heidenreich was booked against The Undertaker soon after, but it flopped completely, bottoming out with an atrocious Casket Match at the 2005 Royal Rumble. Heidenreich was exposed as a subpar worker, and combined with his ridiculous character direction, this made his heel run completely ineffective.

Heidenreich eventually linked up with Animal as a new member of the Legion of Doom, but while the duo held the Tag Team Championships for a while, the big man was out of the company by 2006.

6. Zeus

Integrating professional wrestling into mainstream celebrity culture has always been one of Vince McMahon Jr.'s biggest goals, though it has rarely been as invasive as it was in 1989.

Advertisement

Hulk Hogan had just starred in the horrendous No Holds Barred movie, in which he went to battle with Zeus, a ruthless monster heel. Instead of keeping the rivalry on the silver screen, McMahon decided to bring it to the ring, and actor Tom Lister Jr. was quickly brought in to feud with 'The Hulkster.'

Lister had the size and the look, but not the skill. He'd never wrestled a match prior to joining WWE, and predictably stunk, though WWE invested a great deal of effort into making him look like a force. This eventually saw him team with Randy Savage to face Hogan and Brutus Beefcake at SummerSlam '89, and while 'Macho Man's' skill helped mask his partner's deficiencies, the villainous duo fell.

Zeus cooled off immediately. He was aligned with Ted DiBiase afterwards, but the feud continued, and eventually concluded inside a Steel Cage that December, with Beefcake and Hogan once again defeating Savage and Zeus. The only thing Zeus got over 'The Hulkster' throughout the feud was a handful of no-sell spots, and Lister left the company shortly aferwards.

5. Lord Tensai

It's a good job that Matt Bloom has been able to make a significant contribution to WWE behind the scenes, as his last in-ring run was a total nightmare.

Advertisement

He was always a serviceable midcarder during his first run with the company, but WWE had grander plans when he returned from a fruitful Japanese spell in 2012. Taking influence from Bloom's stints in NJPW and AJPW, WWE created the 'Lord Tensai' character, and immediately tried to push him as a monster heel.

Tensai flattened Alex Riley in his first match, then embarked upon a solid winning streak that including victories over John Cena and CM Punk - two of the company's biggest stars. There was one major problem, though: the crowd.

Bloom was taunted by chants of "Alllllberrrttt" from the very first match. All the fans could see when this supposed monster stepped through the ropes was a man once named after a penis piercing, and they couldn't take him seriously at all. The wheels gradually starting coming off Tensai's run until it became a full on trainwreck, and after ditching his follower Sakamoto, going on a winless streak, and losing what little credibility remained, Bloom turned face to become Brodus Clay's dancing sidekick.

4. The Underfaker

Whatever positive attributes Brian Lee may have possessed as a professional wrestler, he wasn't allowed to show them during his first WWE run. Having previously worked for Jim Cornette's Smoky Mountain Wrestling, where he was a two-time Heavyweight Champion, Lee was signed by Vince McMahon in 1994, and soon became the lead antagonist in one of the era's most maligned storylines.

Advertisement

Lee played an imposter version of The Undertaker, who'd disappeared after losing to Yokozuna at the Royal Rumble. He started appearing dressed like 'The Deadman,' with Ted DiBiase claiming that he was actually the original 'Taker, and that he'd been convinced to join the Million Dollar Corporation. He clearly wasn't, though, and this all built up to a match at SummerSlam '94, when The Undertaker finally met The Underfaker.

The faux-Phenom was soundly defeated in an absolute stinker of the match, and while the idea of Lee continuing in the role was initially suggested, the story was dropped soon after. It had completely failed to get Lee over with the crowd, and the SummerSlam match was a total flop, with the 'Faker looking severely out of his depth. He was released later that year, but would eventually return as Chainz in 1997.

3. Giant Gonzalez

Giant Gonzalez' feud with The Undertaker was supposed to install him as wrestling's next big monster heel: instead, it turned him into a laughing stock, and resulted in two of the worst matches of 'Taker's career.

Advertisement

Their WrestleMania IX bout is a historically bad contest, but their SummerSlam '93 rematch might be even worse. Quite why WWE decided to re-book a match that stunk up their biggest show of the year is anyone's guess, but the second clash was even more of a plodder than the first, with 'Taker's inability to safely execute a Tombstone on the lumbering giant forcing a weak clothesline finish.

Gonzalez was released that October, but there was more to his failings than shoddy match quality. Height was the former El Gigante's positive trait, and while he was billed at an outrageous 8', this couldn't compensate for his complete inability to connect. It didn't help that he was forced to wear a full bodysuit with airbrushed muscles either, with his amateurish aesthetic turning him into an object of ridicule rather than fear.

A complete failure, even by the oft-derided New Generation era's lowly standards, Gonzalez' push and presentation were complete miscalculations from Vince McMahon and the creative team, and his name has since become a punchline.

2. Rikishi

WWE could've used the "who ran 'Stone Cold' over?" storyline to build their next major heel, but the company completely dropped the ball. Rikishi's reveal as the perpetrator didn't just nuke the storyline as a whole, but it destroyed the former Intercontinental Champion's heat to a point he could never recover from, though he remained with the company for several years after the initial turn.

Advertisement

It was a terrible idea from the start. Rikishi was immensely popular as Too Cool's dance partner, and the sudden change from happy-go-lucky upper-midcard novelty act to cold-blooded attempted murder was too much for most to stomach. His "I did it for The Rock" promo became a proto-meme, and WWE tried to mask the failure by inserting Triple H as the mastermind behind the act, but it was too little, too late.

Rikishi went from drawing some of the company's largest babyface pops to reactions that barely registered a decibel as a heel. He soon transitioned into a listless tag team with fellow Polynesian islander Haku, before WWE attempted to salvage his career with a 2001 face turn. Unfortunately, the damage was irreparable, and Rikishi never returned to his old level.

1. Jim Ross

WWE audiences were first introduced to a heel Jim Ross in September 1996. Having just reinstated him to the announce team, WWE played up the idea that Ross was still bitter about his legitimate sacking in 1994. Having worked a front office job for the previous couple of years, JR claimed he'd purposely let the recently departed Razor Ramon and Diesel walk away to harm the company, then brought in his own set of fake Outsiders, thus beginning one of the era's most loathed storylines.

Advertisement

The September 23rd episode of Raw saw JR deliver a worked shoot on the way he'd been treated by Vince McMahon, but it backfired. Instead of jeering Ross' outburst, the fans cheered him for shooting on the Chairman, and the entire angle was ditched soon after.

You'd think that WWE would've learned their lesson, but no: they tried it again in 1999. JR had been absent from television after another bout of Bell's Palsy, and found that Michael Cole had taken his job upon returning. Ross was overcome by bitterness once more. He hired 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams as his bodyguard, and started hijacking Raw with his own personal announce booth, but again, those pesky fans refused to fall in line.

Crowds liked Ross, and disliked Cole. Thus, JR was cheered when he booted his young rival in the family jewels. The angle was soon abandoned, and JR returned to the booth at WrestleMania XV.

Advertisement