10 Trades WWE & AEW Need To Make

Aleister Black, Chad Gable, and more who should make the jump between AEW & WWE.

By John Bills /

Trades don't actually happen in professional wrestling. There is a war going on, didn't you know?! Neither WWE nor AEW are looking to strengthen their opposition, no matter the benefits that might come their way in exchange. No matter how much sense the trades may make, the simply won't happen.

Advertisement

Still, it doesn't hurt to speculate.

We live in a wonderful time for professional wrestling, empty arena shows aside, as there have never been more outlets for quality performers to make their mark. Both AEW and WWE have roster overflowing with talent, men and women looking to make their mark on the pro wrestling industry. The abundance of riches is clear for all to see.

Not all of those pieces are in the right place though, far from it. AEW and WWE may have talented rosters but they also happen to be somewhat bloated, full of quality performers with little to do, fantastic pro wrestlers in the right place at the wrong time. Or is that the wrong place at the right time? Either way, something is wrong.

That wrong can be righted by moving across the divide, by making the jump to the other side. By moving these 10 pieces (well, 13 actually), both sides will be better off.

10. Austin Gunn To WWE

Austin Gunn is in the wrong promotion. In another life, he would still be learning his trade in the WWE Performance Center, having practice matches against equally inexperienced wrestlers and looking for a character to eventually bring to NXT TV. Like many second-generation superstars before him, Austin Gunn would be living the coddled life of someone who started life on the ladder.

Advertisement

As it is, Austin is in AEW, having middling matches that don't seem to show much in the way of progress. What's more, AEW seems to have decided that the best way to use him is by aligning him with his father, former WWE Tag Team Champion and career-midcarder Billy Gunn. If Billy hadn't been released by WWE, it is almost certain that Austin would be in that Performance Center today.

While we're at it, can we stop using the word 'Club' for factions? Bullet Club, Balor Club, now Gunn Club, it really is a case of diminishing returns. Gunn Club just ain't working, although it could still argue to be more effective than the Bullet Hunter Club, the depressingly awful former faction led by Billy's NJPW tag partner, Yoshi Tatsu.

9. Riott Squad To AEW

Professional wrestling isn't always a world of clarity but even in this crazy industry, two plus two sometimes equals four. AEW's women's division needs bodies, talented women who can help bulk up a worryingly thing decision. Ruby Riott and Liv Morgan are two talented women who are in WWE purgatory. You can work out the rest for yourself.

Advertisement

The Riott Squad seemed like a curious group when it first came together, but Riott and Morgan (and Sarah Logan in an earlier incarnation) have displayed natural chemistry that can only come from genuine friendship and enjoyment. In many ways, the two are polar opposites - Riott is a 10-year veteran who spent years on the indies before arriving in WWE, while Morgan is a WWE Performance Center product through-and-through - yet somehow, it works.

WWE doesn't seem willing to give either woman the ball, something that becomes even more frustrating when you consider how ideal they are for AEW. Riott and Morgan are exactly the type of talent that the struggling women's division requires, compelling performers who can give credibility and weight to female midcard while retaining the potential to challenge for Shida's title at any time.

Alas, expect more purgatory for Ruby and Liv.

8. Kip Sabian & Penelope Ford To WWE

There is something very sports entertainment about Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford. There is plenty of irony in that claim, what with them being aligned with the recently-liberated Miro, but Sabian and Ford give off more of a 'WWE' vibe than most of their colleagues. That could all be wrapped up in the arrogance and the beauty, two attributes that WWE still seems to understand.

Advertisement

Even as individuals, the two feel better suited to Vince McMahon's empire than Tony Khan's fledgeling promotion. Sabian is a classic hubristic heel, all good looks and punchability, while Penelope Ford is an undeniably gorgeous woman with plenty of in-ring potential within. Ford could grow into a big star, no matter the promotion.

In many ways, Kip Sabia and Penelope Ford come across as a less sinister version of Karrion Kross and Scarlett. Much, much less sinister. Kross and Scarlett without the Tarantino vibes, or maybe just parallel world versions in the same Tarantino movie. Kip and Penelope have plenty of potential and plenty of ability, but it is possible that those attributes would be better harnessed in the aesthetic-centric world of WWE.

7. Aleister Black To AEW

'Take a seeming can't-miss prospect that WWE has botched and move them to AEW' is going to be a common theme throughout this, so buckle in on that front. The barrage of misused talent begins with Aleister Black, a man who seems to have fallen off the face of the Earth in recent weeks. Losing an eye will do that to you, apparently.

Advertisement

It wasn't a million years ago that Aleister Black was the NXT Champion, an unbeatable bad-ass who had consistently great matches in front of molten-hot crowds. There were even rumours of Paul Heyman being a big supporter, although that should have been more of a harbinger than people realised. Take Lesnar and Punk out of the equation and the success of supposed Paul Heyman Guys leaves a lot to be desired.

Black has been treated like dirt on the main roster. Word on the grapevine is that he has been hankering for a return to NXT, but he would be better off in an entirely different promotion. Whether booked as a sinister heel or ass-kicking babyface, Tommy End would be a great fit in AEW's present and future.

6. Big Swole To WWE

There is a lot to love about Big Swole. The Florida-native exudes babyface fire, accentuated by a physical charisma that cannot be manufactured. Swole may have found herself a little in over her head in her short AEW career to-date, but she has shown more than enough potential to suggest that a long career lies ahead of her.

Advertisement

Would she be better suited to developing in NXT? AEW's women's division is disastrously thin, meaning Swole needs to take a more prominent role than she may well be ready for. On the contrary, NXT's women's division is arguably the strongest in American professional wrestling, with Io Shirai standing atop a mountain that includes Rhea Ripley, Candice LeRae, Shotzi Blackheart, Dakota Kai and plenty more. Swole would benefit greatly from growing underneath these established performers.

National television is a difficult place in which to grow, especially if you are being given a position that demands more than you are currently capable of. If AEW is able to flesh out its women's division then Swole may well be able to evolve in a more natural fashion, but that remains to be seen. As it stands, she'd be better off in WWE.

5. Chad Gable To AEW

Put Chad Gable in any other pro wrestling promotion on the planet and you'd have yourself a star. A genuine wrestling genius, Gable has everything it takes to become a major player in the industry. His in-ring skills are elite-level, he has a weird charisma that is entirely his own, and he is just about as credible as a professional wrestler can be. He has it all.

Advertisement

Well, all except size. The old 'Vince McMahon Only Likes Jacked-Up Dudes' theory has been disproved time and time again, but it is undeniable that height will always afford a performer more opportunities in WWE. The only thing that Chad Gable doesn't have is height. Barring the lightning strike of another Daniel Bryan-style swell of popularity, Gable will never progress beyond his current frustrating level in WWE.

This plainly isn't true in AEW, a promotion that focuses more on strengths than weaknesses. A move to AEW could see Gable become the human suplex machine that he so plainly can be, a powderkeg of technique and strength, out-wrestling anyone foolish enough to cross his path. Better yet, get him to NJPW.

Chad Gable's career should be defined by suplexes and submissions. In WWE, he will always be defined by his (lack of) height.

4. SCU to WWE

The time has come for Christopher Daniels to finally get that legacy run in WWE. His career deserves it, although the prospect of a WWE contract has never carried less value. Still, The Fallen Angel may well finish his career as one of the greatest never to get a proper WWE run. If nothing else, the inexperienced bodies in the Performance Center could do with someone like Daniels to learn from.

Advertisement

If Daniels is going, it makes sense for Frankie Kazarian to go with him. Seemingly evergreen, Kazarian has years of in-ring competition ahead of him but it is difficult to see where he fits in AEW moving forward. Sure, it is always nice to see the former tag champion showing his skills on Dark, but the crowded scene ahead of him suggests his fans can expect little more than secondary show appearances.

Daniels and Kazarian could prove even more valuable in WWE, NXT specifically. There really is little left for them to do in AEW, a somewhat shocking state of affairs when you consider the brief existence of that company. WWE may hate tag team wrestling, but there is plenty more that these two veterans have to offer.

Not Scorpio Sky though, keep that guy in AEW. He is going to be a superstar.

3. Ricochet To AEW

Poor Ricochet. Is there a more depressing status in all of modern-day pro wrestling? WWE's inability to do anything meaningful with a generational talent like Ricochet tells you all you need to know about that promotion's creative malaise. And before anyone talks about promo-cutting ability, that argument has never carried weight.

Advertisement

Besides, Ricochet shouldn't have to cut promos, he should just be left to fly around like only he can, performing athletic feats that have the ability to amaze even the most cynical of viewers. Ricochet should be a star. Only WWE can explain why he isn't.

If Ricochet were an AEW talent, he'd almost certainly be appreciably closer to reaching his potential. He'd be having amazing matches with Kenny Omega, PAC, Jon Moxley, Hangman Page and all the rest, looking like a star and making moments built to last. He'd have ample opportunities to prove the naysayers wrong, to spread his wings and display his full range of talents. Instead, he's locked in what looks like a career role jobbing to The Hurt Business.

How do you fail to make a star out of Ricochet?

2. Santana & Ortiz To WWE

WWE is a pretty wretched place for most tag teams. There is a reason FTR were so desperate to get out, after all. Vince McMahon's distaste for tag team wrestling goes way back, so any tag team signing with his company needs to be ready for potential disappointment.

Advertisement

With that in mind, why would Santana and Ortiz be better off in WWE? 'Better off' might not be the best way to put it, but as of right now the former LAX aren't getting the chance to shine between the ropes. The duo has shuffled down the tag team ranks in AEW, going from the top of the table to pseudo-comedy feuds to being kinda disgruntled at their faction growing.

Where are they going? The busy sea that is AEW's tag team division will inevitably create some spare parts, and the former Proud and Powerful might be the most misused of these. The team has a tremendous combination of character, charisma and in-ring ability, and it isn't hard to envisage an NXT that has Santana & Ortiz ruling the tag division with an iron fist.

1. Samoa Joe To AEW

For the briefest moment, it looked as though WWE knew what it was doing when it came to the Samoan Submission Machine. Joe was the number one contender to Brock Lesnar's Universal Championship and he had the Beast Incarnate rattled, not to mention the fear of God he had put into Paul Heyman. Lesnar and Joe had a tremendously fun match at WWE Great Balls of Fire (remember that?), a match that Joe lost but came out of looking like a beast.

Advertisement

And then, nothing. Not entirely nothing - there have been secondary championships - but as good as. As 2020 draws to a close, one of the most engaging professional wrestlers on the planet finds himself forcing excitement at the commentary table.

AEW has a proven track record of succeeding where WWE refused to. Jon Moxley, Brodie Lee, Cody, FTR and others are excelling in the relaxed, creativity-driven environment. There's no reason to believe that AEW would fail to embrace the violence and legitimacy that Samoa Joe brings to the table.

Injuries mean that Joe's days in the ring are numbered. It is criminal that these moments are being wasted in WWE.

Advertisement