10 Unbelievably Awful WWE SummerSlam Matches

It's the writers who should have been Summer SLAPPED for booking this nonsense!

By Jamie Kennedy /

SummerSlam is one of WWE's biggest Pay-Per-Views of the year. Traditionally, the event bridged the gap between WrestleMania and Survivor Series, before King Of The Ring was added to the line-up in 1993. Cheerfully, the event has always performed admirably on PPV, and the company regularly pull out big matches to try and make the show as grand as possible. Regardless of any good intentions, there have been a ton of stinkers at SummerSlam. Featured here are 10 of the worst culprits, and this article tries to explore exactly why the creative team felt these matches would work. In fairness, some of them should have been better than they turned out, but others were doomed to fail from the start. The reasons are varied. From performers who should never have reached such a platform, to those who simply didn't do themselves justice, these are 10 of the most unbelievably dreadful SummerSlam bouts in history. When looking back at one of their most infamous events, WWE officials would rather fans didn't draw attention to these matches. Unfortunately for them, the writers need to be called to task for their crimes. Big events such as the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania have thankfully managed to keep lofty standards over the years, but SummerSlam has definitely been a mixed bag, and here's why.

Advertisement

10. Legion Of Doom vs. Money Inc. (SummerSlam 1992)

During their first run in the WWF between 1990-1992, the team formerly known as The Road Warriors didn't do themselves justice. The rough and tough tandem should have been tailor made to rule the tag division in the company, but they wouldn't really ever gain momentum. In '92, the WWF re-introduced the duo's old manager, Paul Ellering, and he brought with him a dummy called 'Rocco'. The idea behind the ventriloquist doll was that it would help the re-dubbed Legion Of Doom connect with children in the audience. Instead of helping, it directly contributed to the growing disinterest from Hawk, who wasn't a huge fan of the way the team were being presented. SummerSlam 1992 was a huge event held at Wembley Stadium, and many felt LOD vs. Money Inc would be a great match. Sadly, it wasn't. According to Animal, Hawk was out of it due to the consumption of pills backstage. Ted DiBiase and I.R.S were good workers, but even they couldn't work miracles with a wobbly Hawk, and the match fell apart. This was a warning sign of what was to come for Hawk in later years, and the match stood no chance due to his condition.

9. The Undertaker & Kane vs. DDP & Kanyon (SummerSlam 2001)

Sitting smack bang in the middle of the WCW/ECW 'Invasion' of the then-WWF, SummerSlam 2001 is memorable for a cracking showdown between Steve Austin and Kurt Angle. Unfortunately, it's also notable for featuring one of the worst Steel Cage matches in promotional history. All 4 guys involved had featured in good matches during their careers, but this one was hampered by the circumstances. Instead of presenting DDP and Kanyon as strong, the booking squad decreed that they were to be slaughtered by the WWF team of The Undertaker and Kane. This was a stupid decision, less than 2 months into his WWF run, Diamond Dallas Page looked like a jobber. In fact, the guy was less of a star in the company than he ever had been in WCW. The cage bout had both the WWF and WCW Tag-Team Titles up for grabs, but that was not the main story. Fans watched in awe as the entire 'Invasion' premise fell apart. There had been excitement for the angle at the previous month's 'Invasion' Pay-Per-View, but that was long gone by the time SummerSlam aired. Such a one-sided Steel Cage match really didn't help.

8. The Great Khali vs. Batista (SummerSlam 2007)

Upon his debut in WWE during the Spring of 2006, even the most casual fan must have realised the company were going to push The Great Khali to the moon. Attacking The Undertaker right off the bat, Khali was presented as a monster heel. Even though he was protected via booking, fans were apathetic once the initial 'wow' factor over his size wore off. By SummerSlam 2007, the giant Indian was programmed opposite World Heavyweight Champion, Batista. The pair were scheduled to battle in the co-main event spot for the title, but the match wasn't that highly anticipated. This wasn't the first time both had tangled, Khali had defeated both Batista and Kane at The Great American Bash, and the tandem had numerous matches on television. At SummerSlam, it seemed like Batista would win back the gold. That didn't happen, a lame disqualification finish ending what had been a poor match. The problem with Khali was his limited ability. Unable to produce lengthy bouts befitting of World Title contests, the gigantic man also didn't have a lot of moves that fans enjoyed watching. The result was a terrible match, one of the worst Batista had featured in since his ascent to the top of the card.

7. Diesel vs. Mabel (SummerSlam 1995)

The clumsy, uncoordinated Mabel should have ever been booked in the main event of SummerSlam 1995. There's a strong argument to suggest that he was only in the WWF Heavyweight Title hunt due to his size, Vince McMahon traditionally favouring larger-than-life performers. Size was really the only thing the big man had going for him, he was not an entertaining wrestler. The problem was, in '95 McMahon didn't have a whole load of options. Stars the size of The Undertaker, Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels were already in matches at SummerSlam, so Diesel needed a challenger. For that exact reason, Mabel won the King Of The Ring in June, and the wrestling world collectively slapped their foreheads. Even worse, Diesel vs. 'King' Mabel was signed to headline the Pay-Per-View. Rather predictably, the match failed to excite. Razor Ramon vs. Shawn Michaels in an Intercontinental Title Ladder Match was incredible, and even Bret Hart vs. Isaac Yankem D.D.S and The Undertaker vs. Kama were better than the headline bout. Mabel injured Diesel's back during the main event, and was banished from working on top of the card from that point on.

6. Kane vs. The Great Khali (SummerSlam 2009)

Another appearance from The Great Khali, and another from Kane on this list. Both had stunk up the joint at SummerSlam 2007 and 2001 respectively, and were handed the chance to reprieve themselves in 2009. Going in, not an awful lot of people had high hopes for the match, and those fears were proven correct once the action got underway. The bout was the very definition of mid-card filler. WWE clearly felt there was an attraction to the idea of watching a pair of giant guys squaring off. Even on commentary, announcers were instructed to sell the old 'irresistible force meets immovable object' spiel, and the bout could have survived if the action had been satisfactory. To put it bluntly, it wasn't. Not only did the match only go around 5 minutes (which is probably a blessing), there was little for fans to cheer about. Neither man was an especially strong babyface or heel at the time, rendering their collision largely pointless. Khali's manager and storyline brother, Ranjin Singh played a part in the mini-feud, but eve that felt tacked on.

5. The Undertaker vs. The Undertaker (SummerSlam 1994)

Oddly enough, for having been one of WWE's longest-running stars, The Undertaker doesn't have a track record of producing excellent matches at SummerSlam. Being fair, there was no chance his bout at SummerSlam 1994 could succeed, especially not following an epic Steel Cage match between Bret and Owen Hart. The Undertaker vs. The Undertaker was a poor choice of headliner. After fans had been thrilled by the Hart brothers, this battle of The Undertaker and his phony counterpart felt contrived. Occasionally, WWE present a match at TV tapings solely for the live crowd, and it usually feels out of place. That was what the main event of the Pay-Per-View felt like at SummerSlam '94, and that's obviously not a good thing. Fans had started leaving by the time the bout marched lazily towards a conclusion. The slow-moving style of the real article was mimicked by the 'Fake' Undertaker, meaning there was nothing of any real note for fans to enjoy. Looking back on the early years of The Undertaker, his matches were often terrible. The character was classic even then, but the action was severely limited.

4. Jerry Lawler vs. Jake Roberts (SummerSlam 1996)

The whole premise for the match between Jerry 'The King' Lawler and Jake 'The Snake' Roberts at SummerSlam 1996 was flawed. By '96, Roberts had put on weight, and his personal life had started to fall apart due to drug and alcohol dependance. Incorporating this into storylines, the WWF had Lawler mock Jake's alcohol addiction, which felt out of place with the rest of the cartoon-like product. Alcoholism is clearly a sensitive issue, and it felt crass that such a real-life situation was being brought into fiction. Mark Henry, who was introduced to provide commentary on the match (in preparation of a feud with Lawler), must have been wondering what the hell he was watching. There was too much stalling during the bout, and the entire segment lasted 20 minutes for a 4 minute wrestling match. To make matters worse, Jake Roberts wasn't even given a big babyface win to shut Lawler up. Instead, the 'King' emerged victorious, which flattened the live crowd. The card desperately needed a babyface win, and this comedy bout was perfect, but it was not to be. The touchy subject matter felt out of place with the comedic stall-fest Lawler and Roberts provided.

3. Virgil vs. Nailz (SummerSlam 1992)

Nowadays, Virgil is relatively infamous for his desperate attempts to capitalise on a long-forgotten WWF/WWE career. There are numerous websites dedicated to taking pictures of the man looking lonely at various fan-signing events around North America, but at least he can look back and say he was part of the WWF when the company was huge in the late-80's. Rather less fortunately, Virgil can also reflect on a singles career that went nowhere. Upon splitting from Ted DiBiase in 1991, Virgil became a mid-card babyface. By comparison, Nailz was a heel character the company had introduced earlier in 1992, and both men would tangle on the main card at SummerSlam '92 in Wembley Stadium. Going less than 4 minutes, the match was a rudimentary squash match designed to make Nailz look like a monster. The problem was that a lot of his initial aura had largely diminished already, even though he'd only been on the roster a few months. Nailz was a terrible worker, and even in squashing Virgil, he looked awkward and unrealistic. This was a match to forget.

2. Ivory vs. Tori (SummerSlam 1999)

At WrestleMania XV, newcomer Tori looked bumbling and incompetent during her match against Sable. The contest didn't exactly earn rave reviews, but there were hopes that Tori could improve and become a vital part of the female roster. Months later at SummerSlam 1999, Tori was floundering again, showing little improvement over her performance at 'Mania during a match against Ivory. WWE have come in for criticism over the years for not adequately preparing female performers for big matches. Names such as Eva Marie and Jackie Gayda instantly spring to mind, as both looked like fish out of water during bouts on television and Pay-Per-View. Tori was the exact same at SummerSlam '99. Almost everything aside from a splash from the middle turnbuckle was botched. For her part, Ivory tried hard to keep the match flowing and together, but it was an impossible task. Tori simply wasn't up to scratch, and the whole affair was summed up by the bungled finish. Messing up a Sunset Flip, Tori was quickly pinned by her opponent, who looked like she couldn't wait to get out of there.

1. The Undertaker vs. The Giant Gonzales (SummerSlam 1993)

One of the worst feuds of The Undertaker's career was against The Giant Gonzales. First starting at the 1993 Royal Rumble, the pair would collide at WrestleMania. Even after that disaster of the match, WWF officials decided to keep the feud rolling through King Of The Ring and into SummerSlam '93. It was odd that either man wrestled at King Of The Ring, but fans should have been thankful for that. At SummerSlam, the match was dubbed a 'Rest In Peace' match, which effectively meant there were no disqualifications. Even the added stipulation of no rules didn't help, Gonzales was too slow and plodding to really do much. Combine his lack of substance to the zombie-like nature of The Undertaker, and there was no chance of a surprise brawl or good match. The Undertaker vs. The Giant Gonzales must surely go down in SummerSlam history as one of the worst matches to ever grace the Pay-Per-View series.