10 Underrated Stars That WWE Should Never Have Released

Those future endeavours turned out pretty rosy, didn't they?

By Jack Morrell /

WWE.com

Not every wrestler gets to challenge for the big belt. The card is pyramid shaped for a reason, but that just means there's room in the rest of the card for everyone.

Advertisement

At present, it's more or less the same six men in rotation, getting TV time and storylines over and over again. Now, not everyone gets to be Daniel Bryan (hey, it looks like even Daniel Bryan doesn't get to be Daniel Bryan), or have their Cinderella story propel them to the main event.

Many wrestling fans love Heath Slater's work but are still well aware of the limitations of the performer: he's probably upper midcard at best, even if they give him a ball to run with. Equally, Zack Ryder was horribly treated by WWE, but not many people would suggest that he deserved to be pushed to the moon for having a successful Youtube show. However, not being buried would be a start.

Advertisement

The point is that on a three hour show, with a two hour show later in the week, there's enough television time for everyone, and there's no justifiable reason for talented performers to be signed, invested in, given positions in the company, and then told that there are no suitable storylines for them, or no television time available.

The following ten men were released by WWE before their worth to the company could be properly realised. In some cases, these men represented some significant investment of time and money, which was abandoned when they received their marching orders. Nevertheless, they had greater potential than the WWE chose to see in them or exploit.

Advertisement

Here's how.

10. Evan Bourne

WWE.com

A high-flyer almost on a par with the incredible Neville, and certainly the equal of any other in the WWE's history, Matthew 'Evan Bourne' Korklan debuted in WWE on June 3rd 2008 and immediately impressed with his fluid movement inside the squired circle.

Advertisement

Sadly, Korklan would break his foot in four places and dislocate it in five places in a car accident in March 2012. I didn't even think you could dislocate your foot in five places, never mind break it in a further four places, but that's the fate that befell Bourne. That may be legitimately the worst thing I can ever imagine happening to a foot.

Korklan would reappear in NXT a year later in competition with Sami Zayn, but a return to the main roster never materialised, and fifteen months after that he was released from his contract, WWE clearly deciding they had no idea how to reintroduce him to their programming.

Advertisement

Korklan, now back to performing under his previous name of Matt Sydal, is currently an indie sensation. Given that there were no hard feelings involved in his release, one would assume that the door will be open at a later date should WWE decide to give Evan Bourne another run.

9. Brodus Clay

WWE.com

George 'Brodus Clay' Murdoch spent a lot of time in WWE developmental, beginning in Deep South Wrestling in 2006. He worked for Florida Championship Wrestling between 2007 and 2011, dropped in on the old, mad, bad NXT for its fourth season (coming in second place to Johnny Curtis, aka Fandango), gatecrashed the main roster as an enforcer for Alberto Del Rio, and finally reappeared on RAW in January 2012 as a happy, dancing hippo of a man, nicknamed 'the Funkasaurus', and accompanied by Naomi and Cameron as the Funkadactyl dancers.

Advertisement

That's a lot of developmental, so much so that it's actually surprising that Murdoch made it to the main roster at all. Nonetheless, the Funkasaurus gimmick was fresh and fun for a while, although WWE clearly had no idea what was supposed to happen next.

The answer turned out to be 'not a lot'. Over the next couple of years, Murdoch did a whole lot of dancing and precious little else. He would be paired with main event flop Tensai as a comedy team, Tons O' Funk, and embark upon a short-lived singles run at the end of 2013 as a villainous monster heel.

Advertisement

Released in June 2014 after returning to NXT, Murdoch has since joined TNA and is currently a part of storylines concerning Ethan Carter III and his pursuit of the TNA World Heavyweight Championship. Murdoch had far more of an upside than he was permitted to show in WWE both in the ring and especially on the mic - the man is a funny, articulate talker, as well as a superheavyweight beast.

He ticked a lot of boxes but that wasn't enough to save him, it seems.

Advertisement

8. Ricardo Rodriguez

WWE.com

Best known as Alberto Del Rio's ring announcer in his original run with WWE, Jesús 'Ricardo' Rodríguez had four years of experience on the US independent circuit under a luchador gimmick (Chimaera) before he was drafted to WWE in 2010.

Advertisement

Rodríguez would work as Del Rio's heel sidekick on the main roster while he actually wrestled under the Chimaera name in Florida Championship Wrestling. He'd later change to a different masked persona, El Local, teaming with Tyson Kidd under another hood as Los Locales, luchadors with jobber gimmicks. He'd then briefly team with Kalisto before being released in 2014.

Rodríguez has returned to the independent circuit, having missed wrestling terribly while touring as a non-wrestling manager. However, when Del Rio returned to Mexico under the name El Patron Alberto, he invited his old friend to join him. Since Del Rio returned to WWE, Rodríguez found work as a trainer for the Great Khali's school in India.

Advertisement

A hugely underrated performer (his facials are brilliant, he can talk and his finish used to be a corkscrew moonsault, for heaven's sake), Rodríguez was wasted in the role of Del Rio's whipping boy. His time in India seems to be incredibly rewarding for him, however. There are more important things in life than WWE, it seems.

7. Shelton Benjamin

WWE.com

Wrestling for WWE from 2003 to 2010, 'The Gold Standard' was considered one of the most naturally athletic and physically gifted men on the roster for a number of years. He'd become famous as the Money In The Bank ladder match MVP several years in a row, often dazzling with his unique stunt work, before his untimely release six years ago.

Advertisement

A lot has been said over the years about Benjamin's chances in the WWE, had things been different. Yes, he was underrated on the mic and phenomenal in the ring: Benjamin could pretty much do it all.

However, there's that rumoured glass ceiling for African American WWF/E performers to consider... could Benjamin have busted through it? Then there were questions about his attitude and aptitude (he was branded as lazy by man) but Benjamin should have gone a lot further than he did.

Advertisement

It's impossible to say just how far he could have gone, though. At any rate, Benjamin did end up back on WWE's radar in 2016 and was offered a job to return, before an untimely injury delayed matters. Hopefully WWE are still interested in using him in 2017.

6. Matt Morgan

WWE.com

Legitimate six foot ten beast Matt Morgan was offered a developmental deal with WWE in October 2002, and was steadily improving in the ring and on the mic, displaying an unexpected aptitude for the promo (well, he had a degree in public speaking, so perhaps not entirely unexpected). He would wrestle for WWE for brief spells in 2003/04 and again in 05, as a henchman for Paul Heyman and a stuttering bodyguard for Carlito. He was catching on.

Advertisement

Nevertheless, Morgan was released in July 2005, with Vice President of Talent Relations John Laurinaitis advising him to gain more experience. Morgan excelled in Japan and Italy before returning to the US to work for TNA, where he wrestled their best performers, improving in leaps and bounds, and hovering in and around the main event for five years.

Morgan decided to leave wrestling in 2013 to spend more time with his son, and left the business on a high as a polished performer and top star in TNA. Of course, had WWE persevered with him in 2004, things could have been quite different. He really was let go way before he should have been.

Advertisement

5. Luke Gallows

WWE.com

Originally the slow-witted Festus in 2007, then the brooding enforcer Luke Gallows for CM Punk's brilliant Straight Edge Society faction in 2009, Drew Hankinson confirmed his departure from WWE in late 2010 after the stable split.

Advertisement

Hankinson worked in Japan following his release from WWE, and then for TNA for two years as part of the long-running Aces & Eights storyline. He's been a member of the Bullet Club faction in New Japan Pro Wrestling since November 2013 under the name Doc Gallows (D.O.C. stands for 'Director Of Chaos').

A far better wrestler than he was ever given credit for, Hankinson was brought back to the company earlier this year as part of a slow-build to a new Bullet club.

Advertisement

Even though they did bring him back this past year, they should have never let him go in the first place.

4. Drew McIntyre

WWE.com

Hot-shotted to the top of the midcard in August 2009, Andrew 'McIntyre' Galloway was given the official thumbs up by none other than Vince McMahon himself, who told the world he saw a future World Champion in Galloway during an in-ring segment that aired mere weeks after his debut.

Advertisement

'The Chosen One' gimmick didn't set the world on fire, sadly - Galloway would hold on to the Intercontinental Championship for five months, but he was relegated to the lower card shortly afterwards, eventually joining low-ranking jobber stable 3MB, where he spent the final two years of his WWE career before being released in 2014.

It's still difficult to know what on earth WWE were thinking here. Galloway is a large man, with a fantastic look and excellent skills in the ring and on the mic. But it's the Sheamus/Wade Barrett thing all over again: WWE simply isn't using its contracted talent correctly. Certainly Galloway had far more potential than he saw realised in WWE, potential that is being tapped on the independent circuit, as he wrestles stand-out matches all over the world, showing people what WWE is missing out on.

Advertisement

He is now back with WWE and looks to be the top star of NXT moving forward.

Advertisement

3. Brad Maddox

WWE.com

Drafted to developmental in 2008, Tyler 'Brad Maddox' Warner is one of WWE's biggest missed opportunities. A talented character player and gifted on the mic, Warner's in-ring presentation was solid, if unspectacular (although you should see the way he used to enter the ring, in a twisting forward roll from the floor through the ropes that hinted at hidden depths of athleticism).

Advertisement

But what a character. His Brad Maddox persona, as authority figure on RAW, was astonishing considering his lack of experience on television, and following the removal of the gimmick on the main roster, Warner would record more than one absolutely brilliant YouTube video acting as a showcase for his writing and performance skills.

He was in the process of putting together a tag team gimmick with Adam Rose when he was released after a dark match promo in which he - the heel - cut a promo on the crowd, calling them 'cocky pricks'. It's a shame that more wasn't made of Warner's abilities by WWE, as he had the skills to become quite an asset to the company.

Advertisement

2. Derrick Bateman

ImpactWrestling.com

Another always-the-bridesmaid story here: Michael 'Derrick Bateman' Hutter was in three stages of WWE developmental without ever being called up to the main roster, ranging from two years in OVW from 2007, four years in FCW until 2012, and participation in the fourth season of the deadeyed gameshow version of NXT.

Advertisement

Hutter worked with a vast number of WWE's developmental talent over his time in OVW and FCW, many of whom transitioned successfully to the main roster. Despite his evident mic skills and personality, WWE clearly didn't see anything of massive interest in him, and he was finally released in May 2013, reappearing in TNA four months later as authority figure Dixie Carter's spoiled nephew Ethan Carter III.

Hutter has been a revelation in TNA as EC3. His character work has been ruthlessly brilliant, the man holding his own in the ring and on the mic with legends of the industry (and Matt Hardy). It's hard not to see WWE's decision to release him as a missed opportunity. But then, they have talented men and women already on the main roster which they choose not to do anything with, so perhaps it's not so surprising.

Advertisement

Watch EC3 against El Ligero and Pete Dunne for WCPW in 2016...

Advertisement

1. Colt Cabana

WWE.com

WWE€™'s biggest missed opportunity of the 21st century so far has to be their complete misfire when Scott €˜Colt Cabana€™ Colton was signed to the roster.

Advertisement

One of the most talented all-round independent wrestlers in the world, Cabana would become semi-legendary for his amazing series of matches with real life best friend CM Punk, who he first trained with. Punk would later go to WWE, and Colton would send him off from Ring Of Honor by defeating him in a scorching two-out-of-three falls match.

While Punk began to work his way up to being the best thing in the WWE, Cabana continued to be the best thing on the card all over the independent circuit, wrestling all over the world. Eventually, his own time would come, and Colton would debut for OVW in 2007, and later move to FCW when Florida became WWE€™s developmental territory.

Advertisement

When he finally debuted on the Smackdown roster in August 2008, it was under the name Scotty Goldman. Despite Cabana€™s success on the independent circuit and in FCW, €˜Scotty Goldman€™ would only ever wrestle on Smackdown six times before Colton was released in February 2009, jobbing to midcard wrestlers every time during those six months.

Colton returned to the independent circuit, where he set out his stall as one of wrestling's most successful cottage industries, proving that you can make a significant living on the independent circuit if you apply yourself.

Advertisement

Colt Cabana can do it all. As good an all round wrestler as there ever was, he€™s perfect as a heel, as a fan favourite, a comedy character and more. He has an easy natural charisma and can work with anyone of any size or ability.

There might well have been room for Colton to return to WWE to give it another crack, but he became involved in the CM Punk story when he allowed his podcast to be used as the venue for Punk's first interview since leaving the WWE, and has now officially burned his bridges, along with the boats and the houses nearby. It's still WWE's loss, however.

Advertisement