10 Unique Pitches To Save Struggling WWE Stars
Not every WWE star is thriving under the Paul Levesque regime, so let's try to save them!
While some WWE stars have never shined brighter than they have in 2024, others have been steadily dimming for a long enough time that they've started to fizzle out—or, worse, have already faded into obscurity.
It's always a shame to see someone get released when the company has given up all hope, so before that kicks in, it's worth trying out some other ideas and throwing anything at the wall to see if something sticks. For some, that could mean a heel or babyface turn, while others need to join a tag team or take their characters in entirely different directions.
While that may also be true for stars who have grown stale, but are still booked in a largely successful way (such as NXT women's champion Roxanne Perez as a heel or recent United States champion LA Knight as a less and less popular face) many others are just flat out struggling and could use any help they can get.
For the wrestlers slipping into irrelevance and/or those that have lost the spotlight altogether, is there a way to turn their careers around for the better?
10. Pete Dunne
From the very beginning of NXT UK, Pete Dunne was positioned as a prominent star for the brand. Eventually, he would go on to have the second-longest reign with the WWE United Kingdom Championship until he was dethroned by Gunther, showing just how impressive he could be despite his smaller size.
For some reason, when joining the main roster, he was renamed Butch. While The Brawling Brutes wasn't bad by any means, his gimmick of being effectively a feral child was awful, and when it was abandoned, he was far better off.
Yet, for some reason, all WWE can come up with him lately is for people to call him Butch to upset him. It's not the best motivator, and when he fails to win those matches, he doesn't even seem intimidating anymore. He's basically reverted back to being a small dog with a quiet bark and little bite.
Dunne needs to find his edge again and be booked as a threat while also having someone else talk for him, but shy of William Regal filling the role of his manager, the best option might be to put Dunne with Gunther and Ludwig Kaiser to refill that third spot of Imperium.
Alternatively, teaming up with Ilja Dragunov, when he's returned from injury, could pave way for a resurgence of the Bruiserweight nickname and give the tag team division a hard-hitting duo to freshen up the scene.
9. The Miz
The Miz took a break from his normal shtick for a few months by reforming Awesome Truth, but since splitting from R-Truth, he's been saddled with a story of begrudgingly hanging around Final Testament somewhat out of fear of The Wyatt Sicks—two teams that will both be on this list, mind you.
This feud has to be nearing its end, and it's going to leave The Miz either with a reconciliation with R-Truth and merely reverting backwards, or he'll be by himself, losing matches and whining about it.
At this point, The Miz is well past "future Hall of Famer" status. He's an absolute legend, even if he may never get the credit he deserves. So why not treat him like the veteran he is and finally give him a true stable that isn't a gag like The Miztourage.
There aren't many viable candidates on Raw or SmackDown, but bringing him down to NXT for a little while would not only be a change of pace for him, but give him an instant sense of authority over the rookies who could vie for his attention and tutelage, such as Edris Enofe or Kale Dixon and Uriah Connors.
8. The Wyatt Sicks
For a few weeks, The Wyatt Sicks was an interesting mystery angle with a lot of potential. Sadly, any intrigue quickly dissipated, and they've largely been kept off-screen for the past two months or so, only feuding with Final Testament through minor backstage segments at a time.
The constant cryptic messages ran their course and became too generic, proving doing more of the same is not sustainable. Unfortunately, none of the members have caught on enough to carry the group like a normal stable, and WWE is running out of time to try to give them any personality to fix that.
If they're going to remain together as a spooky team, that's what needs to happen, though. They cannot keep going as five barely seen generic dark characters where if you asked someone to explain who they are, they might not even be able to tell you their names.
Why is Joe Gacy pretending to be Huskus the Pig Boy, instead of just being himself? What benefit does Dexter Lumis get out of being Mercy? Erick Rowan went from a sheep to a rabbit because...?
WWE needs to sit down and develop ways to differentiate each member, let them wrestle more frequently to show their unique styles, and let them speak in more than just poetic but meaningless puzzles. Right now, anyone could fill these roles and do the exact same job, so long as they have the masks on.
7. The Final Testament
Karrion Kross has so many tools that should have made him a world champion by now in WWE, but the ball continues to be dropped with him with every pass.
The Final Testament was a good shot at turning things around, but WWE fell into the trap of not making the faction strong enough and clearly not investing in them, dragging out a half-assed feud with The Pride into a do-nothing WrestleMania XL match that wouldn't have even made the card if it weren't two nights.
Paul Ellering does nothing for the group, Scarlett is only there for eye candy, and The Authors of Pain aren't the dominant tough guys they once were. When Kross threatens people, it has little merit, as he's not accomplished anything on the main roster, either.
If this feud with The Wyatt Sicks just ends with Dallas and company moving on to the next target, Final Testament will continue to be stuck in limbo.
Sometimes, the only way to break a cycle is to deviate wildly, so let's turn Final Testament babyface and convert them into more of a Demolition or Legion of Doom style team to offset how The Viking Raiders are no longer sporting interesting gear.
It's tricky, as going too far will go back to Kross wearing that horrendous gladiator armour, but making them more like the NXT version of The Ascension could give young fans an easy visual to latch onto, rather than keeping them a drab, all black, group of losers who think they're tough, but can never back it up.
6. Giovanni Vinci
If we're being honest, Giovanni Vinci may be a lost cause, as WWE went out of its way to make him look like a complete and utter failure.
He was the sacrificial lamb of Imperium for almost its entirety, booted out of the group, spent months away, came back with a retread of his fashionable model-esque gimmick that didn't work in NXT, lost a few matches within mere seconds, and promptly disappeared again. If he's on the roster just to lose to Apollo Crews in dark matches before SmackDown, that's not a career worth saving, and he might as well be released.
But there is a saying that if at first you don't succeed, try and try again. Another phrase is that the third time's the charm. Maybe that can be the philosophy and this time, Vinci can take that model gimmick and be paired with Pretty Deadly.
Kit Wilson and Elton Prince are jokes, but they're fun to have around. Some comedic characters are necessary to keep the wheels turning. Vinci's biggest problem with this gimmick has always been that he's had no personality, but he could be the straight man to their jokester act.
5. Gallus
Gallus boys on top? More like Gallus boys heading toward rock bottom. And that's not a reference to how Gallus helped 'The Great One' prepare for WrestleMania XL, but about how they've been lingering in NXT for years with nothing to do.
Every couple of months, WWE gives at least one of them a random push, but Joe Coffey continues to not win any singles gold to elevate his stock, nor are Mark Coffey and Wolfgang at the top of the tag team division anymore. Even when they were being more heavily utilised, it wasn't their best stuff. The golden days of Gallus are years ago from NXT UK and they're running out of steam.
It's past time they join the main roster, but if they just show up on Raw or SmackDown without any tweaks, they're going to crash and burn. If WWE can't even use Pretty Deadly more these days, they're not going to have much to work with for the stoic Scottish brawlers.
One person who could work with them, though, is The Scottish Warrior, as their friendship with Drew McIntyre could pave the way for them to be his stablemates for a new faction to wreak havoc on Monday Night Raw. That would also give them The Wyatt Sicks, The Final Testament, and other groups to feud with as a change of pace.
4. Andrade
The best thing Andrade has done since rejoining WWE has been winning the Speed Championship, which isn't saying much. He's settled into a comfortable spot as an upper-midcarder not worth investing in as the actual United States champion, but perpetually hovering over that belt.
A heel turn isn't good enough to justify an increased push for El Idolo. He'd just switch up dance partners and work with the babyface side of the blue brand. But if he were to turn heel and start his own group, that might turn things around.
The trick is that WWE absolutely cannot give him a team of Latino wrestlers and play off his time as part of La Facción Ingobernable. As tempting as it might be to wait until Rey Fenix and Penta El Zero Miedo are free to join the WWE roster and put them together, it will come off too repetitive and potentially problematic to have three similar teams on the roster alongside LWO and Legado del Fantasma.
Instead, he should play into his clear love of the Batman villain Black Mask and lead up a more mafia-inspired gang, maybe bringing in other strays like Apollo Crews and to bolster his ranks and try to take over.
3. Omos
Omos stands at a statuesque 7 feet, 3 inches, making him the third tallest WWE Superstar of all time just under Giant Gonzalez and Andre the Giant. He is a bona fide special attraction just in his mere existence. How has he not wrestled a single televised match since the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal on April 5th?!
No reports state that he's dealing with an injury, and his treatment prior to WrestleMania XL wasn't any better, as he was just squashing Akira Tozawa, Odyssey Jones, and R-Truth on house shows dating back all the way to Backlash 2023, outside of the 2023 SummerSlam Battle Royal and 2024 Royal Rumble.
You shouldn't have to tune in to Netflix's Unfinished Beef hot dog eating contest to see Omos, but that's the last time he did anything on camera for WWE, which is wild.
Omos could easily be someone's bodyguard and work tag team matches on at least a semi-frequent basis, or still be a singles star and feud with Bronson Reed over who is the true "big man" in WWE today. He doesn't need to be repackaged into a happy-go-lucky giant, but he could also show off more of his personality and possibly turn babyface, too, if WWE thinks just having him as a stoic juggernaut has run its course.
Just using him at all at this point is all it would take, as the biggest thing holding him back is how WWE just simply doesn't want to.
2. Alpha Academy
Alpha Academy or Alpha Babes or whatever the contingent of Otis, Maxxine Dupri, and Akira Tozawa together has been played out. They're no longer doing anything actually funny, but just being loud and colourful while losing all their matches.
Perhaps that's just how WWE sees all three of them, and they're stuck in that comedic supporting player role. Even still, they could be doing something different, as the worst part of being a humorous act is when it grows stale. And since they aren't going to be taken seriously as tag team contenders, splitting them up won't harm the division.
Dupri can stand on her own as is. All she needs to do is continue to improve and she'll be used more in the women's division.
Tozawa may have been pigeonholed as enhancement talent for too long to likely escape that gravitational pull, but he could be rehabbed. It would be nice to see his edge come out again as a vicious sidekick to Shinsuke Nakamura.
Otis, meanwhile, has two potentially perfect teammates ready to go in Hank Walker and Tank Ledger. All three burly, goofy guys could form a much better trio than what Alpha Academy is doing lately.
1. Natalya
Natalya has perhaps the easiest change that can be made, as it requires almost no changes at all except one big shift: WWE just has to let her win.
It's not a radical concept, but with her win-loss record and lack of notable achievements in recent years, it feels crazy to say Natalya should be a higher priority, given her status as a legend. Why she isn't at least on permanent reserve for upper-midcard spots like filling in multi-women title matches is a little sad.
But WWE has the perfect opportunity to turn things around without even changing her gimmick. All she has to do is win the inaugural tournament for the WWE Women's Intercontinental Championship.
That is going to be considered a workhorse title, and given her length of time in the company and the number of matches she's had, she certainly fits that bill. Plus, she has the lineage behind her of Bret Hart, Owen Hart, and British Bulldog all holding the men's Intercontinental Championship. It would make sense for her to set the tone for the title and be able to put her name in the same history books as the first-ever women's champion of that kind.