10 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Raw (Nov 18)
Have you ever heard of 'brand supremacy'?
If you’re the type of person who simply counts the ups and downs, then you’d think this was one of the best episodes of Raw in years. And make no mistake, this was a good show overall.
However, Raw was beset with an ongoing, three-hour ailment. Thankfully, it’s treatable, and the prescription is time. Let six more days pass, and everything will heal itself.
You see, Survivor Series is an affliction. It infects WWE for about a month, with normal rivalries being pushed aside for the good of this concept of “brand supremacy,” a WWE term that means absolutely nothing. It doesn’t mean that one brand gets some sort of reward, like a lump sum of cash, or new contracts, or the #30 spot in the Royal Rumble matches, or even a damn trophy.
They get to brag that they’re the superior brand – for all of one week before everyone goes back to their respective shows and have to start building to the next PPV.
So despite some good in-ring action Monday night, the brand supremacy nonsense permeated a good chunk of the show, dragging it down. While the ups were noteworthy, some of the downs were colossal.
Still, Raw gets passing marks here, but we’d really give an award to some enterprising WWE writer who convinces the brass to change course for Survivor Series 2020.
With that said, let’s get to it…
Downs...
6. Carrillo Missing Something
You have to give partial credit to WWE for trying to push someone new on the roster, but when it isn’t done properly, it deserves some criticism.
Humberto Carrillo has potential, and he’s gotten a few high-profile matches against AJ Styles recently, even pinning him on Raw last week in a six-man tag match. Monday night, he got the win over Karl Anderson – with a little help from the Street Profits.
However, Carrillo isn’t getting the greatest reaction from fans, definitely not during his entrance. His high-flying moves garner some “oohs” and “ahhs,” but he’s not there yet. His personality isn’t coming through at all, making him appear like an avatar rather than a three-dimensional character.
WWE has to know this watching the program week after week, so hopefully they will make an adjustment. It might be something as simple as letting him really go out there and perform at a high level. The endorsement from Rey Mysterio was a big step in the right direction, but unless and until we see it carry forward, this will remain as a mild critique.
It’s also worth noting that on Raw this fall already, we’ve seen Cedric Alexander get a stop-and-start push against Styles, and like Carrillo, he’s a 205 Live alum.
5. Why Are They Fighting?
When the announcers repeatedly point out how stupid something is, you’ve got to acknowledge it here.
During Raw, we were treated to an excellent match between Drew McIntyre and Kevin Owens (more on that later). However, both men are supposed to be teammates on Team Raw at Survivor Series in six days. So why were they facing each other? There was no widely stated rivalry between the two, so there was no pressing reason for them to be fighting.
And then later, Natalya and Asuka battled despite being teammates for the Raw women’s team. Why?
We might not have GMs on each show, but if Survivor Series is all about “brand supremacy,” shouldn’t someone have stepped in to stop this match so both men don’t theoretically hurt themselves before they have to team up?
The announcers made this point numerous times, to no avail. And that’s just ridiculously sad.
4. That’s Some Brand Split You’ve Got There
Remember way back a month ago when WWE conducted this high-profile draft, separating the roster into two brands, forever changing the landscape of the company?
Well, six weeks later and it’s Survivor Series time, so “oh well.”
Yep, despite being told on WWE programming that each performer is exclusive to his or her respective network, we’ve suddenly seen crossover between Raw and SmackDown, with Lucha House Party showing up Monday night to attack Seth Rollins and Andrade. And later, all hell broke loose, with a good chunk of the blue brand showing up.
As stated multiple times before, it’s fine to do this, but then don’t establish these supposedly ironclad rules when you know you’re going to violate the hell out of them in less than two months.
It’s insulting to anyone who actually tries to pay attention to any details.
3. Unrestrained Groaning
Can we get a restraining order for this abysmal angle?
Lana and Bobby Lashley hit the ring Monday night so Lana could inform us that she filed for divorce from Rusev earlier that day. That’s right, the storyline must continue. But more than that, she took out a restraining order against Rusev, which she helpfully put up on the screen.
And maybe this was done to add some “realism” to the situation, but the form naturally listed both Rusev and Lana’s real names, noting that they “perform” as their characters.
Um, what?
Look, it’s 2019. We all know that the wrestlers in WWE are performers playing characters. We know Seth Rollins is a character played by Colby Lopez. We also know Han Solo was a character played by Harrison Ford, but Han never pulled out a document showing his “real name” to move along the storyline.
Breaking character isn’t always a bad thing – when done in extremely rare, extremely careful situations. But this godawful angle does not warrant it. It’s just stupid.
2. It’s The Brand Supremacy, Stupid!
Raw featured three high-profile matches Monday night.
All three ended the same way: DQs or non-finishes due to outside interference.
Seth Rollins/Andrade, Kevin Owens/Drew McIntyre, and Randy Orton & Ricochet/Viking Raiders all ended prematurely due to SmackDown or NXT personnel showing up, because it’s Survivor Series season, so we must have constant battles for brand supremacy.
If you checked the results of the Raw and SmackDown episodes right before Survivor Series during the brand split, it’s a safe bet that nearly every one of them ended in a massive brawl… because that’s what you do to show how serious this battle for brand supremacy really is.
It’s so expected that when the Raw Tag Team Championship match happened in the main event, you would be excused if you didn’t react to the “possibility” of the tag title changing hands and merely kept an eye out for the interference.
That’s just so sad, that WWE is so predictable that you could write the entire ending three hours before it happened.
1. Cue The Clichéd Brawl
If it’s the go-home Raw before Survivor Series, you can count on a massive brawl with a bunch of colored T-shirts involved. It’s almost as constant as beer at a football game.
Sure enough, Raw ended with SmackDown wrestlers charging the ring and battling Raw superstars. But this time, NXT joined the fray, attacking everyone and leading to a disorienting, convoluted three-way brawl that ended with the black-and-yellow brand holding the ring.
Watching this, this writer couldn’t help but note that come next Monday, after Survivor Series, everything will carry on like nothing happened. That’s what always happens here. We spend a month hearing about how important “brand supremacy” is, one side wins, and then we all go on our way as if nothing happened 24 hours later.
It’s stupid. It’s pointless. And it shows no sign of stopping.
Ups...
10. Little Things, Boston Edition
Hats off to Paul Heyman for knowing his geography and history at the same time.
Heyman delivered a backstage promo during Raw, and it was noticeable that he was wearing a New York Yankees tie, which makes perfect sense because Paul E. is a New York guy, so that didn’t seem all that strange… other than the fact that his ties aren’t usually sports-oriented.
And then you slowly realize that Raw emanated from Boston Monday night. The Red Sox/Yankees rivalry is baseball’s most historic, storied feud, going back 100 years. Heyman wore a damn tie just to jab at the Boston crowd, to remind them that he’s a heel, through and through.
No outspoken cheap heat, just a subtle call-out for those who were observant. That’s dedication, and that’s attention to detail.
9. A New Face On Commentary
Apparently, Dio Maddin is still reeling from his single F5 through the announce desk two weeks ago, because he was still out Monday night.
But huzzah! That meant that we got to hear Samoa Joe for three hours, which was a welcome treat. Joe has been doing kickoff show commentary recently as he recovers from injury, and he’s apparently done well enough to merit a shot on the Raw desk.
And he did more than just fine. Joe has plenty of in-ring credibility. His promos have always been top-notch. He’s smart, well-spoke and knows the business extremely well. He was clearly a heel commentator, but he knew how to temper it. He added to the broadcast without trying to be the center of attention.
If this was an audition for a future gig after his wrestling career is over, you’ve got to think that Joe passed with flying colors.
8. Cruiserweights Shine
Man, imagine if we had gotten this match on Raw for the WWE Cruiserweight Championship. Fans might actually care about the title.
Akira Tozawa and Buddy Murphy had a barnburner of a match Monday night, going at each other at 100 kph with high-impact, signature spots. It looked like Tozawa was going to be little more than a jobber fed to the bigger Murphy, but in his first Raw match, Akira hit Buddy with everything in his arsenal.
The fast-paced match ended suddenly with a Murphy’s Law, allowing The Best-Kept Secret to continue his winning ways. Afterward, he had a tense staredown with Aleister Black.
That could be a hell of a hard-hitting feud.
7. We Don’t Care Either!
Oh, wanna bet Becky Lynch got a talking-to when she walked back behind the curtain Monday night?
The Man led off Raw with an in-ring promo where she called out Shayna Baszler and Bayley, then immediately threw down the gauntlet: Everyone is talking about “brand supremacy,” but she doesn’t give !*$% about brand supremacy.
And the place erupted.
Now, that could have been for the swearing, but it also could be because fans are tired of the stupid “brand supremacy” BS we’re forced to swallow around Survivor Series season every year. It means absolutely nothing. It’s not like there are stakes involved – like, the winning brand of the big interbrand matches get #30 in their respective Royal Rumbles. (Hey, free idea WWE!)
Thanks to Lynch for saying what we all were thinking.
6. Faces Can Be Devious
WWE seemingly forgets how to properly book babyfaces regularly, other than to make them gullible idiots.
So it was refreshing to see the Street Profits use a little “two can play this game” method Monday night. The duo came out during a match pitting Humberto Carrillo against Karl Anderson, with the rest of The OC ringside. As the match broke down, AJ Styles distracted the ref and Luke Gallows neck-snapped Humberto on the ropes. Anderson grabbed a small package…
…And Montez Ford immediately rolled the package over so Carrillo was covering Anderson for the three count.
Turnabout is fair play, and let’s give it up to the Street Profits for getting retribution rather than just standing there impotently getting outplayed. People want to cheer heroes who are winners, not virtuous losers.
5. Authors Of Pain Strike
After months of delivering taped promos, the Authors of Pain finally struck Monday night.
Backstage, Zack Ryder & Curt Hawkins were giving an interview about a Raw Tag Team Championship title match later that night, when AOP stepped up to them and quickly beat them down.
The beating was short, but it took Hawkins & Ryder out of their tag title match, and it followed exactly what Akam & Rezar have been saying in promos for months. They got in another team’s face, stared them down and then beat them into submission.
Hopefully, this is a sign that we’ll see them in the ring soon enough.
4. Rollins, Andrade Show Respect
Yes, it is possible to be a “bad guy” and show respect to a good guy without changing your stripes.
Monday night, Andrade challenged Seth Rollins for his captaincy of Team Raw at Survivor Series. After a match that began slowly, the two ramped up to a solid bout that was getting going pretty well… until Lucha House Party showed up from SmackDown to attack Rollins and cause a DQ. They then attacked Andrade until the two could chase the trio off.
Afterward, Andrade and Rollins shared some mutual respect, leaving the bout out there for (as Rollins suggested) a rematch down the line.
3. Lynch Continues To Spit Fire
She might be stuck in a “brand supremacy” storyline, but Becky Lynch isn’t going to let that slow her down.
The Raw Women’s Champion denounced the annual Survivor Series rite of passage, ignoring the interbrand rivalry and just going right after Shayna Baszler and Bayley, calling them out to open Raw. When the IIconics came out instead, Becky wasted no time in challenging the two of them to a 2-on-1 match.
Later, the NXT Horsewomen attacked Lynch and Charlotte Flair, but the two women gave chase… until security broke it up. But rather than be content with that, Becky decked (and the replay showed she seriously decked) one of the security guys, flattening him.
Again, Lynch might be mired in the boring Survivor Series foolishness, but she’s making herself stand out by being herself.
2. KO, McIntyre Light It Up
Setting aside the stupidity of two Survivor Series teammates beating the hell out of each other six days before the PPV, Kevin Owens and Drew McIntyre had an absolutely incredible TV match Monday night.
The two veterans unloaded their moveset at each other, throwing bombs and kicking out repeatedly. Fans were losing their stuff as McIntyre hit a Death Valley Driver on the apron, Owens hit a cannonball off the apron, both men hit their finishers – and both men got their feet on the ropes.
Can you imagine if there were actual stakes to the match? Like if one of them was the WWE World Champion?... Oh right, that guy who only wrestles six times a year has the title right now. Right. Ratings. Mainstream press coverage. Blah, blah, blah.
But hey, KO, McIntyre… let’s do this again.
1. Rey Makes You Care
Rey Mysterio might be winding down his in-ring career, but he has been churning out some incredibly good promos.
Monday, he hit one out of the park as he addressed Brock Lesnar and the no holds barred stipulation for their Survivor Series match. He asked whether it would be an advantage for Brock, or for him. He noted that Lesnar attacked him and his son, so he would do whatever he needed to get revenge.
Mysterio then observed that old him would have demanded an apology, but Sunday, he wasn’t coming for an apology, he was coming for the WWE Championship.
This feud looked grossly one-sided, and while Brock probably isn’t going to lose his title like this, Mysterio’s quiet rage made you believe he has a serious chance of vanquishing The Beast.