10 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE Extreme Rules 2019
Solid wrestling, smarter booking, but Brock is back.
Let’s get right to the bottom line: WWE Extreme Rules overall was a good PPV, featuring solid action and some smart booking. However, it was hampered by questionable booking on top, though it might be forgivable in time.
You see, Extreme Rules might be a reset show of sorts, with Paul Heyman and Eric Bischoff taking over Raw and SmackDown, respectively. This PPV was set in motion before they were tapped to lead the shows, so it’s possible the outcomes were designed to help set both of them up going forward.
Regardless, huge credit has to go to the wrestlers, who could have throttled it down since this was kind of a throwaway show. Instead, they ramped it up and had good matches up and down the card. The worst match was watchable, while the best was pretty darn good, though nothing reached the “classic” level.
We saw a few new champions along the way, which always adds a little excitement, and we learned that WWE is capable of smart booking, as they found a way to accentuate the positive and minimize the negatives in the Undertaker & Roman Reigns versus Shane McMahon & Drew McIntyre match.
There’s plenty to unpack here so let’s saddle up and get to it…
Downs...
7. Last Man Standing Match Drags On
When it started, the Last Man Standing match between Bobby Lashley and Braun Strowman looked like it was going to be a dull, plodding affair.
But things ramped up in the latter half, with both men teeing off on each other. Lashley used the steel steps, a chair and the railing to injure Braun, but Strowman came back with a suplex into the wall on the concourse. The two continued to battle back into the arena, with Lashley driving Braun through the barricade, and Strowman tossing the All Mighty into the announcers’ desks at ringside and in the arena.
The match ended with Braun powerslamming Lashley off a seating section through a gimmicked platform, which was an obvious spot, but an effective one. Thankfully, rather than a double count-out, Braun punched his way out to be the last man standing.
Still, this match dragged on for probably about 5 minutes too long. You could have had both men use various objects to wear each other down (you know, the PPV is called Extreme Rules) and shave some time off. When you have guys going down after a shoulderblock for a 5 count, it’s just going to drag the match to a standstill.
However, this wasn’t a bad match, so it only gets a tacit “down” here. Hopefully, this feud is over, and Braun can start wrecking fools with a real, sustained push, because WWE can’t keep doing the stop/start deal with him.
6. Bayley Does It Herself
So why is a match where Bayley overcame the odds and persevered a negative?
It’s hard to peg, but it’s also hard to believe WWE is going to continue booking Bayley stronger. She defeated two women who were teaming together seamlessly – there was no major mistake one of them made that led to their downfall – in a handicap match with no outside interference. If we had confidence WWE was doing this to build Bayley up, then we’d give it a pass.
This match also was screaming for someone – namely Sasha Banks – to come down and provide support for Bayley. She was all-but name-dropped twice in the last six days on WWE TV, seemingly hinting at her return, which would have made perfect sense to help Bayley retain.
Instead, the Huggable One beat two challengers herself. Now, here’s the caveat: If WWE is serious about booking Bayley as a top-level star, then this is an easy “up.” But for now, this feels more like a game-time decision to have Bayley retain without heel miscommunication or a friend bailing her out rather than some long-term planning.
5. IC Title Still The Bridesmaid
One of these days, the Intercontinental Championship will be treated like the workhorse secondary title it was for so long.
But in watching Finn Balor lose the title to Shinsuke Nakamura – both solid wrestlers, mind you – you couldn’t help but note that Balor hadn’t defended the title very much during this three-month reign. Sunday’s kickoff show (yes, they were relegated to the “people are still filing in” slot) match was only Finn’s fourth televised defense, with zero PPV main shows and zero defenses on SmackDown, where the title is housed.
A defense on Raw, a televised live event and Super Showdown were the only other matches where the IC title was on the line this spring and summer. And then it changes hands on the kickoff show. That’s embarrassing, and unforgivable.
Maybe things will change with Nakamura holding the title, but we won’t be holding our breath… but we’ll keep our fingers crossed.
4. Muzzle Graves
The more the announcers talk, the more this writer is tempted to just mute the play-by-play and just watch the PPV in silence. Sure, you might miss a key plot point, but is anyone else really listening for that amongst all the sniping and chirping for four hours?
Corey Graves has reached intolerable levels with this. He seemingly had a new-age Bobby Heenan role down perfectly when he was in NXT and was first called up to WWE, but that has morphed into an argumentative, sniping hypocrite (the character), who spends more time verbally battling the other commentators than actually calling the match.
It doesn’t add to the event – in fact, quite the opposite. Graves spends most of his time arguing with Renee Young and Byron Saxton in unconvincing fashion, which does nothing to put the product over. Even when that seems to be the goal, it falls short.
During the main event, Corey kept prattling on about Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch’s relationship and how it would be their downfall, and blah, blah, blah. Yes, Graves clearly is getting his marching orders for what to focus on, but we still have to hold the show accountable.
If the announcers stopped talking 30%, it would make a tremendous difference. Any chance we could make this happen?
3. Convoluted Main Event
When the Extreme Rules main event was made, many were confused and needed a tutorial. But after seeing it in practice, we really need some charts.
So let’s see if we’ve got this all correct: It was a winners take all, extreme rules mixed tag match, where the men fight the men and the women fight the women, you have to tag in and out, but because it’s extreme rules, there are no DQs, so those other rules don’t apply.
If that’s all true, why didn’t Baron Corbin do what he did at the end of the match in the beginning? Lay out Becky Lynch, tag in Lacey Evans, pin The Man, new champs. The ref couldn’t DQ Corbin, so you might as well use it to your advantage.
The match itself wasn’t the Dumpster fire it could have been, but it certainly had no business main-eventing a PPV. The bout was slow at multiple times and just wasn’t convincing. No one was buying Corbin and Evans as world champions to begin with, but they also didn’t look like they were threats.
Still, this could have been worse, so we’ll give it that much.
2. Kofi Escapes With His Title
This is a hard one to verbalize, but you can’t help but think that Kofi Kingston’s run as WWE Champion is nothing more than a placeholder.
After defeating Samoa Joe Sunday night, Kofi netted his sixth televised defense, also beating Kevin Owens, Dolph Ziggler, Daniel Bryan and Sami Zayn along the way. While those are all solid wrestlers, none of those men really were top guys at the time of their title shots (save for Bryan, who was the champ before Kingston, but took a month off before getting his rematch).
The match against Joe was fine, but unspectacular. And that’s really a great way to describe this reign. Owens turned heel to get his shot and promptly lost, and now he’s turned into the anti-hero, Stunnering Shane McMahon. Ziggler came back from months away to lose twice to Kofi, and he jobbed out to KO in 20 seconds at Extreme Rules. Bryan just lost the tag titles. And Zayn has lost nearly every match since returning.
So it’s not like Kofi has been defending against Murderers’ Row here. And he’s not winning in convincing fashion, as he was on the ropes for much of his match against Samoa Joe Sunday night but yet never felt like he was in jeopardy.
Again it’s an odd feeling, but it also can’t be ignored.
1. Yay, More Brock!
It’s fair to say that we had to expect that we’d be getting more Brock Lesnar the moment he “won” the Money in the Bank briefcase back in May.
And back then, this column blasted the decision, with the opinion that Brock needed to go on a long vacation, not become the focal point of the entire promotion again. So here, when Lesnar cashed in the briefcase and won the WWE Universal Championship, we have to give that a “down” here.
It’s even worse when you consider that Seth Rollins was amped up after demolishing Baron Corbin for attacking Becky Lynch, and yet he rolled over in seconds to two German suplexes and one F-5. It just made him look impotent. And really, that’s the message you want to send? Your champ is a geek who can get punked out and beaten like it’s nothing. Rollins had access to chairs and kendo sticks and failed to do anything to protect himself.
And now we’ll get more of Lesnar… well, that actually means less, as he’ll likely disappear until SummerSlam and then again until Survivor Series… maybe.
But hey, maybe with Paul Heyman at the helm of Raw, perhaps there’s actually a real plan here to make it all work. Prove this wrong, WWE.
Ups...
10. Bigger Things For Balor, Right?
While it’s easy to categorize Finn Balor losing the Intercontinental Championship as a negative, let’s face facts: He wasn’t exactly setting the world on fire with the title.
Balor traded the title with Bobby Lashley before regaining it at WrestleMania 35 and then being sent over the SmackDown. Since then, he’d successfully defended it three times: on Raw the night after Mania, at the WWE house show featuring the Shield’s final match, and at Super Showdown.
Notice what’s missing? Regular PPV title defenses. He didn’t defend the title at either Money in the Bank or Stomping Grounds, nor had he defended the title on SmackDown even once. The title was being wasted on him, and he wasn’t doing anything of note.
With a regime change coming with Eric Bischoff at the helm of the blue brand, could it be that getting the title off Finn is signaling bigger things for him? He can’t be in the background for a long time – he moves way too much merchandise – so perhaps this is a reset of sorts for him.
9. Gulak Rebounds
Saturday night at Evolve’s 10th Anniversary show, Drew Gulak battled Matt Riddle in a tough, physical match where he came up short.
Sunday night, the WWE Cruiserweight Champion rebounded to convincingly defeat former champ Tony Nese in his hometown of Philadelphia. Gulak was physical throughout the match, hitting a shotgun dropkick at the bell and continuing throughout. He and Nese had a nice reversal sequence toward the end that led to a Gulak powerbomb for a close 2, followed by a Cyclone Crash for the win.
And bonus points for Gulak wearing orange and black, the colors of the local NHL team, the Flyers, a team known for its gritty (pun intended), hard-hitting attitude, much like Gulak himself.
8. Love Letters To Philly
As someone who lives near Philadelphia, this writer typically enjoys smart references to the City of Brotherly Love when WWE comes to town.
No, this doesn’t mean booing Santa Claus, or mocking Allen Iverson’s “practice” rant or something like that – we’re all a little more than tired of that one.
But Sunday night, we got a couple nice shout-outs: Hometown boy Drew Gulak wore the orange & black of the NHL Flyers for his Cruiserweight Championship match, which he won; Street Profits dropped a “Trust the process” mention, a mantra used by the NBA Sixers; Corey Graves noted that Otis looked a lot like the Flyers’ mascot, Gritty (which is actually somewhat true); And of course, we had a Paul Heyman sighting at a PPV called Extreme Rules, just a few miles from the old ECW Arena.
All of those were subtle enough references that got the message across without bludgeoning us. Of course, Becky Lynch and Seth Rollins tried to get cute with talking about the Liberty Bell and William Penn, but we’ll let those slide.
7. Taker Has Better Showing
If Super Showdown was the last match Undertaker had ever had, we would have bene talking about what a disappointment his career ended on.
Thankfully, Taker rebounded Sunday night in a tag team match with Roman Reigns against Drew McIntyre and Shane McMahon. After looking old, sluggish, clumsy and well past his prime, UT looked much crisper at Extreme Rules, hitting his signature spots and moving around the ring pretty well.
The fact that this was a tag team match where Taker wasn’t called upon to carry the entire bout definitely helped, but that’s part of the point. At this stage in his career, this might be the ideal use for Undertaker: a special attraction who occasionally teams up with someone or wrestles someone who can mask any shortcomings.
Regardless, kudos on this match, leaving a better taste in fans’ mouths.
6. Tag Team Clinic
Fans must have been worn out by the opening match Sunday night, because The Revival and The Usos put on a pretty good Raw Tag Team Championship bout in the second contest of the PPV.
Scott Dawson & Dash Wilder’s usual tactics of cutting off the ring were in full effect, but fans were mostly quiet – though never seemingly bored – save for when the Usos chanted. They really came to life when the referee missed a tag to Jimmy Uso, sending fans into a frenzy and a “Ref you suck!” chant, to which Dash & Dawson bowed.
Revival continued with their tag team clinic, hitting a Power Plex for a near-fall, with Jimmy saving with a splash of his own. But Dash & Dawson managed to overcome a series of superkicks to hit a Shatter Machine to retain their titles.
If the tag division was booked better, matches like these likely would get a much better reaction. But when a feud is partly based on junior high pranks (which thankfully seem to be well in the rear-view mirror), it’s tough to get fans fired up.
5. Smart Booking Aids Tag Match
The tag match that involved non-wrestler Shane McMahon and part-timer Undertaker – in Philadelphia – could have been a lightning rod of criticism. Philly fans are notoriously tough, and if they had to sit through three hours of PPV and get to a subpar match, it could have been a disaster.
So what did they do? WWE put the match on first, kicking off the PPV proper with the tag bout and drawing fans in while energy levels were high. The result was a hot crowd that popped for nearly everything, including whenever Roman Reigns went after Shane McMahon. The crowd’s energy definitely added something, chanting “You still got it!” at Taker and “Let’s go Roman!” while he was in peril.
The booking itself – making Shane an opportunistic jerk rather than some accomplished grappler – helped immensely, as it was easier to digest Shane in this role than for us to try to take him as a threat. And Elias provided the assist that McIntyre needed in carrying the offense for his team, which then opened the door for Shane’s two big contributions: a leap of faith elbow and a coast-to-coast dropkick.
All around, this was some smart booking by WWE, so we’ll give some kudos here.
4. Black, Cesaro Slug It Out
Sometimes, a good, old-fashioned slugfest is what you need on PPV.
We got a pretty good battle between Cesaro and Aleister Black, a match with minimal setup: Black wanted someone to challenge him to a fight, and the Swiss Superman obliged. The two had a hard-hitting, stiff match, with Black’s kicks, knees and strikes competing against Cesaro’s European Uppercuts and feats of strength.
At one point, Black went for a second meteora off the ropes, only for Cesaro to catch him on his shoulders, toss him up in the air and nail a European Uppercut for a 2 count. Then, Cesaro went for a second springboard EU, only for Black to counter with a jumping knee.
But in the midst of a flurry of strikes, Aleister nailed Black Mass for the win. What they do with both men next is anyone’s guess, but we’ll give this positive marks on the sheer strength of the match itself.
3. Stone Cold Kevin Owens
Well, they gave Kevin Owens the Stunner as a finisher, so it’s only fitting that he’s now turning into “Stone Cold” Steve Austin.
KO wiped out Dolph Ziggler in less than 20 seconds Sunday night, hitting a Stunner almost immediately for the pin, hopefully putting this mini-feud to bed. Owens then grabbed a mic and continued his rant at Shane McMahon from SmackDown, laying into the blue brand commissioner for hogging TV time.
This new persona for Owens could work really, really well if it’s allowed to breathe and continue. KO has been under-utilized in recent years, and the crowd reaction to him shows that there’s clearly a market there for him as the anti-hero, an area where WWE has fallen short for years.
Just don’t have Owens drinking Molson Light on SmackDown this week, OK?
2. New Day Once Again Rocks
Hats off to New Day, who captured the SmackDown Tag Team Championships Sunday night, becoming six-time tag champs, an accomplishment that says a lot about their staying power.
Xavier Woods & Big E outlasted Heavy Machinery and champs Daniel Bryan & Rowan, with E catching Bryan’s trademark backflip out of the corner so they could hit Midnight Hour on him for the win.
Along the way, all three teams went at 100 kph, with very few (if any) slow points: Otis and Tucker hit Big E with a suplex/crossbody combo; Woods and Bryan showed off their speed to start the match; E had a nice Hulk-up moment when Bryan was kicking him; Rowan got taken out by Heavy Machinery in a collision of big men.
Although the tag divisions are short on depth, this match showed there’s potential there if the new regimes want to make some hay of things. Perhaps there’s hope yet.
1. The Club Cheats To Win
As much as Ricochet deserves a nice, long run with a title to establish himself on the main roster, you can’t deny AJ Styles reuniting with Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows.
The Club can be a formidable force on Raw, but losing Sunday night would have hampered their ascent. So it made sense for Styles to win the United States Championship with the help of his running buddies, solidifying his standing and setting us up for hopefully a good run for this reformed heel stable.
The match itself was really good, with Ricochet countering nearly everything AJ and his cronies threw at him, almost overcoming the odds, but ultimately falling to Styles after Gallows interfered. Styles as US champ with two henchmen could make for some interesting TV on Raw, provided the new regime decides to let them flourish.
Hopefully, there’s also more goodness in Ricochet’s future, and given how this match shaped up, you’ve actually got to believe that.