10 Ways To Repackage WWE's Struggling Wrestlers

A beacon of hope for WWE's lost souls.

By Andy H Murray /

WWE.com

WWE don't always make the most of their massive roster, but the group has rarely been as rich with talent as it is today. From top to bottom, Raw, SmackDown, and NXT are all stacked with world-class wrestlers, and while the group suffers from a lack of high level star power, this is largely down to the way they've been written.

Advertisement

The company currently have close to 140 individuals listed as active performers. That's a lot, and Creative have unenviable task of coming up with a well-defined character for each. Unfortunately, they fail just as often as they succeed, and while some flops are inevitable on a roster of this size, the number of WWE superstars currently saddled with go-nowhere gimmicks is far too high.

These performers are crying out to be repackaged, and while switching their characters wouldn't guarantee improved fortunes, their current roles are only dragging them down. They need personas that cater to their strengths, hide their weaknesses, and allow them to build momentum. Success where their current situations have failed, in other words.

Who are these wrestlers, and how should they be repackaged? Let's take a look.

10. Goldust: Theatrical Heel Manager

'The Golden Age' has flopped. It began when Goldust turned on partner R-Truth back in May, and continued with a series of well-acted, well-produced segments over the next few weeks, before the story returned to the ring. Unfortunately, the build was all for nothing; Goldust and R-Truth's physical altercations got no reaction from the crowd, and their feud will go down as one of 2017's most forgettable.

Advertisement

WWE tried to rejuvenate the elder Rhodes brother, and it didn't work. It's a shame, because Goldust is still a good worker even at 48 years old, and as one of the most underrated performers of the last few decades, he deserved one final run. That window now appears to have closed.

'Dust has since announced that he'll reveal his "masterpiece" at SummerSlam, hinting that he's about to take a young protégé under his wing. Assuming he's not bluffing, slotting him into a managerial role makes all kinds of sense. If WWE can't get him over on his own, they may as well use his talking ability to benefit someone else, and leaning heavily on his Hollywood influences would make for some unique promos as he "directs" his client's career.

9. Dolph Ziggler: NXT Gatekeeper

WWE are said to be plotting a second Superstar Shake-Up, and there's talk that NXT could be involved. Not only would this mean a number of call-ups, but several existing main roster wrestlers joining the developmental brand too.

Advertisement

There are a number of viable candidates for such a jump, but Dolph Ziggler makes the most sense. 'The Show-Off' is one of the least interesting wrestlers in the world at the moment. Ground down by years of terrible booking, his popularity has nosedived along with his usage rate. His 2016 feud with The Miz was great, but he has since returned to the mire, and there's no saving him on SmackDown.

Having spent the last few years as an also-ran, moving to NXT would allow Dolph to transition into a veteran's role. He was in developmental himself, so he knows what it takes to get through the system, and whether working face or heel, Ziggler would be an effective gatekeeper for younger wrestlers to get through en route to the NXT Title.

The brand's less restrictive wrestling style may also compel him to start putting in great performances again, relighting a fire that was extinguished a long time ago.

8. Luke Harper & Erick Rowan: The Reunion

Things have been rough for The Wyatt Family's two lost sheep lately. Luke Harper looked set to become a major babyface force following the Bray Wyatt/Randy Orton feud, but vanished shortly after. Erick Rowan, meanwhile, has done next to nothing since returning from injury, and while the duo wrestled each other at Backlash, they've barely been involved since.

Advertisement

Many fans would still love to see Harper pushed as a singles act, but WWE have made it quite clear that they aren't going to do this. They blew the perfect opportunity to do so earlier in the year, and if they're not going to put Luke back on television as a singles act, they might as well reunite him and Rowan.

Finally free of Bray's hold, the duo could shake his influence off once and for all, and adopt a more straightforward set of personalities. SD's tag division could use a set of no-nonsense power-brawlers (no, The Ascension don't count) to contrast with more exuberant teams like The New Day, and Breezango's ongoing whodunit saga could provide the perfect reintroduction.

Unveil Harper & Rowan as the perpetrators, rebuild them as a couple of stoic badasses who let their fists do the talking, and the duo can play a big role again.

7. Jason Jordan: Leeching Heel

Unveiling Jason Jordan as Kurt Angle's son was a huge misstep by WWE. It's the kind of corny wrestling storyline that should've been left behind in the '90s, and the big reveal has gone over extremely poorly, with some fans even jeering Jordan on this week's Raw. It's going nowhere, and though we're less than a month into the story, it's already falling apart.

Advertisement

The former American Alpha man won't get over this way. Toronto is the only city to boo him thus far, but he has been met with complete indifference elsewhere. It's time to nip this dumb storyline in the bud before the poor guy's career becomes unsalvageable, and the best way to do that is by turning Jordan heel, and revealing his relationship with Kurt as a hoax that he'd concocted to propel him to the top.

Portraying Jordan as a leech on Kurt's reputation should draw heat from the crowd, and the company could use it to finally book Angle's in-ring return, with Jason obviously going over. There's no guarantee this would work, but given how badly Jordan has flopped as a pushed babyface, it's got to be worth a try.

6. Mickie James: Bitter Old Veteran

Is Mickie James the most underused woman in WWE today? The five-time Women's Champion can still be very effective between the ropes, but currently finds herself at the bottom of Raw's ladder. The likes of Sasha Banks and Alexa Bliss overtaking her is understandable, but James is barely even used as an enhancement talent these days, which doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

Advertisement

If WWE have any interest in giving Mickie one last big push, they'd be missing a trick by not turning her current lack of usage into a storyline. Her skill, experience, and ability to play a wide range of different characters makes James ideal for a bitter old veteran's role, angry that she's been surpassed by the younger athletes, but not quite ready to let go of her spot just yet.

WWE have told this kind of story plenty of times before, but it usually goes over well, and could transform Mickie into one of the division's biggest heels. If it works, WWE could even use the story to build James up for one last run with the belt, before ultimately falling to one of the young wrestlers that spurred the turn in the first place, thus serving her comeuppance.

5. The Ascension: Surf Dudes With Attitudes

The Ascension's current role as peripheral figures in the Fashion Files is the best thing Konnor and Viktor have ever done on the main roster. They've been largely useless since graduating from NXT, and WWE have given the fans no reason to care about them on the main roster, having completely failed to come up with regular angles and storylines for the record-breaking developmental Tag Team Champions.

Advertisement

Nobody's ever going to take the duo seriously in their currently pseudo-Illuminati, power and paint roles. It's time to throw that gimmick in the trash, reconsider their place in the company, and bring their Southpaw Regional Wrestling act to primetime television.

Konnor and Viktor showed more personality in their 20 seconds as the Surf Dudes With Attitude than they have throughout the rest of their run combined, Fashion Files aside. WWE comedy gimmicks tend to veer towards WrestleCrap territory before long, but Breezango's success proves that they can still work if presented correctly, and it's not like playing serious heels is doing anything for The Ascension anyway. It'd anchor the duo in the lower-card for the rest of their run, but at least they'd be entertaining.

4. Anderson & Gallows: Bantering Babyfaces

WWE have fortunately been able to distance Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows from the awful nonsense they were forced to endure in 2016 (The Old Day, anybody?), but the duo's characters still aren't particularly well defined. They're just a couple of nasty bald guys who stroll around, call people nerds, and lose every big match their booked in, which is a gross misuse of their respective personalities.

Advertisement

Anyone who's ever heard Gallows and Anderson on a podcast can attest to how charismatic they are. Whether appearing on Talk Is Jericho or hosting their own show, Talk 'n' Shop, the duo are a riot together, and it's time to let some of their real-life personality traits come out on WWE television.

If Gallows and Anderson were allowed to be themselves on Raw, they'd be one of the most popular tag teams in the company. Their chemistry, catchphrases, and banter are extremely contagious, and the ease with which they bounce off one another would make for some tremendously entertaining mic work. Though WWE's insistence on scripting every last word of their wrestlers' promos makes this repackaging unlikely, it'd almost certainly transform the 'Good Brothers' into an awesome babyface tandem.

3. Rusev: Wrestling Machine

It's almost impossible not to appreciate what Rusev brings to the table. He's an outstanding all-round performer who has been served a boatload of terrible ideas over the past few years, but usually does everything in his power to make them enjoyable. This isn't always possible, but there's no doubting the man's effort, and his quality usually shines through.

Advertisement

His latest return to WWE television hasn't been handled well, and after labouring through another dumb USA vs. the world program with John Cena, Rusev has now been given a go-nowhere feud with Randy Orton.

'The Bulgarian Brute' is at his most enjoyable without the jingoism. He should never be thrown into another anti-USA storyline, and ideally, a repackaging would see the last vestiges of his nationalism stripped away.

Instead of this, WWE should push him on the strength of his ring work, using exhibitions like his recent match with Chad Gable to get him over. Rusev is undoubtedly skilled enough to pull a 'wrestling machine' gimmick off, and if he can adopt some of the gym class bully traits that made Kurt Angle such a great heel back in the day, this repackaging could be the spark that ignites Rusev's career revival.

2. Lana: Return To Management

Regardless of whatever WWE are trying to do with Lana at the moment, it isn't working. 'The Ravishing Russian' was drawing significant crowd reactions during the formative stages of her reinvention as a wrestler, but she has done nothing but lose in increasingly humiliating fashion ever since, and nobody cares anymore.

Advertisement

Her latest repackaging is only a few months old, but it's time to throw it on the scrapheap. This would effectively mean a stubbornly proud company admitting their own mistake, which WWE don't exactly have a long history of doing, but there's little point in persisting with this failed angle anymore.

Lana was tremendous in her previous role as Rusev's manager, and while giving her a shot as a wrestler was probably worth a try, the experiment has failed. Can she be a successful in-ring competitor in the future? Sure, but her flaws are many, and she still needs a lot of work before she goes back to primetime television.

'The Ravishing Russian' must ditch the dancing and get serious again. She's an excellent talker and a strong character, and WWE would be wise to play to those strengths rather than accentuating her weaknesses between the ropes.

1. Dean Ambrose: Smart, Psychological Heel

Though he certainly isn't struggling for airtime, Dean Ambrose's character isn't in a good place at the moment. He was legitimately one of the company's most compelling acts during The Shield's run, and while Roman Reigns had the size and Seth Rollins the eye-catching moveset, Dean always felt like the group's most natural star, but his character hasn't panned out that way.

Advertisement

Ambrose has had plenty of memorable moments since The Shield imploded, but his gimmick stinks. WWE would love to have you believe that Dean is an unhinged Brian Pillman-esque loose cannon, but he's often nothing more than a goofy prop comic, and no longer feels like a white-hot babyface commodity.

A heel turn is long overdue, and WWE could use his ongoing storyline with Rollins to pull the trigger. Having 'The Lunatic Fringe' snap on 'The Kingslayer' can provide the impetus to bring Ambrose's character back to something resembling his old Shield persona, when he was a dangerous, calculating villain, often summoning shades of Jake 'The Snake' Roberts. It's a character type that's sorely lacking on Raw at the moment, and given Dean's previous success in the role, there's little doubt this repackaging would work.

Advertisement