10 Ways WrestleMania 36 Will Shape WWE’s Future
A huge, transformational 'Show of Shows' awaits this weekend.
Avoiding the negativity vacuum surrounding WWE's WrestleMania 36 build is impossible.
An unforeseen global health crisis has forced drastic action, with a show defined by bombast and theatrics pretaped in an empty Performance Center, wrestlers pulling out, matches dropped, and an abundance of filler cropping up. While WWE is doing its best with the dealt hand, the situation has created a lack of enthusiasm reflected in recent Raw and SmackDown viewership figures.
It's hard to get amped for these deathly quiet shows, particularly when you're supposed to take 'Mania as the year's biggest show, though this writer is choosing to feel optimistic about WM36 as a whole.
Regardless of how it goes down, this year's 'Show of Shows' has much to teach about WWE going forward. This is a weird, unique 'Mania, the likes of which we will never see again. Its potential ramifications stretch far beyond Saturday and Sunday night and while the opportunity to forget about the bigger picture and get lost in its escapism is welcome, that this could be one of WWE's most transformational shows in decades can't be ignored.
Incorporating some points from the build, let's break it all down...
10. A Brand Devalued
That the WrestleMania brand will be devalued by 36 seems inevitable.
Nothing about this 'Showcase of the Immortals' will look, sound, or feel like past events. This is the biggest, most over-the-top event on WWE's calendar, and an incomparably wild carnival of everything that makes Sports Entertainment Sports Entertainment, and it's going down in a barren gym. Drew McIntyre may raise his newly-won WWE Championship aloft staring at a wall instead of basking in the adulation of 90,000 screaming fans. A show that's all about creating moments will generate clips that stick out obnoxiously on future highlights packages, while outsiders and casual fans may point and laugh at what might be the only wrestling show they watch all year.
This thing is being sold as "Too Big for One Night." In reality, it's the smallest scale WrestleMania in history. Those advertisements couldn't be faker.
Going through with WrestleMania 36 in this format leaves WWE with an unenviable rebuilding job on their hands. Vince McMahon will need to work fastidiously and relentlessly to repair any damage done by relegating 'The Grandest Stage' to the smallest one because even if 36 is a great show, the optics of it, most certainly. are not.
9. A Little Discourage
New reports this week suggest that WWE is considering shutting up shop for a few weeks after WrestleMania 36 goes off the air. Its hand may have been forced by a statewide stay-at-home order issued by Florida Governor Ron DeSantis and while we know the promotion has taped enough content to cover the 6 April episode of Raw, said footage would likely be kept on ice in the event of a temporary shutdown.
While the stay-at-home order likely supersedes everything else, a WrestleMania peppered with intended big moments that don't resonate because they're playing out to silence may discourage WWE further. Their (seemingly inevitable) hiatus may be expedited and they may be less inclined to emerge from that slumber if it means more empty arena shows, opting against a comeback until it starts showing on the bottom line, it becomes possible for them to hold events in packed buildings again, or both.
It goes without saying that a "big" WrestleMania moment won't resonate like it would be a football stadium. Let's see how WWE react to that, or if they even try to create them at all.
8. Learning From The Promos
If one aspect of WWE's mainline product has improved through all this, it's the promos.
Guys like Edge, Randy Orton, and The Undertaker have adapted seamlessly. These old pros are crafting engaging, visceral diatribes every single week, accepting and embracing the smaller-scale setting rather than pretending it doesn't exist. The result is a cluster of engaging, intimidate, and human interviews that may signpost the future for what has long been one of the most criticised aspects of your average WWE show.
Perhaps it is wishful thinking, but one would assume that management has taken note of what these guys are doing. Granted, they were already tremendous talkers and lesser performances may not be able to bottle the same magic and yes, Edge and Orton benefit from their history and magnificent feud. It has to be worth a try, though.
While these stripped-back promos are tougher to execute in a sold-out basketball arena, there's nothing stopping WWE from leaving more wrestlers in an empty room with only a camera for company. These things feel real. The average WWE promo does not. With going full-on unscripted seemingly not an option, this may be a happy compromise.
7. The New Ace
Drew McIntyre will likely fell Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 36, capping a tremendous build and rise by finally winning the big one over a decade after first being dubbed Vince McMahon's 'Chosen One' in WWE. If resonates out of the Performance Center - if it feels big and important while watching it through your television monitor - it will have meant WWE has succeeded at doing something they haven't truly done since Lesnar beat The Undertaker. They'll have created a new star.
Such a moment deserves a football stadium and some have suggested that WWE may hold off on crowning Drew until they can do it on a grander stage. This would be destructive. His Royal Rumble was magnificent and his momentum has sustained itself since then, so why risk derailment? Now is the time.
How will WWE look with McIntyre as 'The Guy' on Raw? The long-term fan response to him will be interesting, given the WWE audience's tendency to turn on their favourites, though Drew's comparably bigger toolkit makes him less likely to flop like Seth Rollins before him. Whatever the case, leaving 'Mania as WWE Champion could guarantee his main event spot for years to come.
6. More Two-Nighters?
News that WrestleMania 36 shall air over two nights came as a huge relief to those weary of the event's overlong, seven-to-eight-hour modern format, though WWE was likely influenced more by the venue change than anything else. Imagine sitting through eight hours with no noise.
So we're getting three-and-quarter hours on Saturday and three on Sunday, with a one-hour Kickoff Show on both nights. That's a lot more manageable. In splitting 'Mania up, WWE should prevent the fatigue and exhaustion that inevitably creeps in with these shows, no matter how good they are (because it's hard to get amped up for Becky Two Belts when you've been in the building for half your waking day and already experienced KofiMania), making 'The Show of Shows' a comparatively easy sell after years of marathons.
Could this be a sign of the future, or is WWE only going down this route because, you know, there's a global health crisis? It's hard to tell, but it's encouraging nonetheless.
Chopping WrestleMania into two nights will satisfy those who've been calling it for years. It'll also allow the promotion to earn two live gates as well. A double-winner, then, though it likely depends on how well-received this year's format is.
5. Budget Cuts
WrestlingNews.co's Paul Davis recently reported that several undercard WWE wrestlers have expressed concern that there "may be some tough decisions made this year and there is a fear of talent cuts coming" as a direct result of the current climate. This is believable. WWE isn't generating live gates at the moment and it's highly unlikely, now, that their revenue projections for Q2 2020 (and possibly the year as a whole) will be met, potentially prompting the promotion to protect the bottom line with cuts.
That the roster is already so bloated with talent compounds this, as does the knowledge that AEW (whose safety net is less secure than WWE's) may not be looking for new acquisitions at the moment, removing one of the biggest factors driving WWE's hoarding.
Vince McMahon may also choose to scrap certain planned expenditures. Could this mean pulling the plug on something like the long-rumoured Japanese Performance Center or holding out on bumper contract offers? As failure-proof as the company has become, it isn't hard to see these things happening.
WWE is a capitalist juggernaut, their coffers are deep, and they're in a far better position to weather this storm than anyone else. That doesn't mean they won't make concessions.
4. Declining Audiences
Raw and SmackDown's average viewership has trended downwards since transitioning to empty buildings. Predictions that content-hungry, stay-at-home viewers would tune in in greater numbers were wide of the mark and this week's Raw number was particularly troubling, with the show pulling under 2 million for a WrestleMania go-home episode - a decline of 700,000 on the previous year.
It's reasonable to assume that some of the viewers who have abandoned these shows will return once everything gets back to normal. The format is the biggest enthusiasm-killer and people are eager for things to go back to the way they were, though nothing is guaranteed here. These are unchartered waters. Again, it's a fair assumption, but nobody can guarantee these lapsed viewers are going to come back weeks (months, even) down the line.
Such a dent could prove harmful to a company that has lost half its audience since 2014. WWE is good at many things, but recapturing lost fans isn't one of them, meaning everyone who matters at Titan Towers likely has their fingers crossed at the moment.
3. Future TV Deals
Not caring about television ratings is one thing; saying that they don't matter is another.
The first is subjective, so it's fine. Numbers don't need to impact your fandom. If you aren't interested in viewerships, there's nothing wrong with discarding them.
To claim the aren't important is to disagree with every decision-maker who matters in professional wrestling, however. Declining steeper than average cable figures they be, but wrestling's ratings are still the key metric considered in negotiations. Objectively, they matter, and that isn't changing until television isn't WWE's biggest money-maker.
Vince McMahon's current deals with USA Network and FOX have essentially made his promotion failure-proof, though things may not be so easy the next time he heads to the negotiating table - particularly if there's no clear recovery from this lockdown-induced slump. It's something that wouldn't take effect for a few years from now, but definitely worthy of consideration. The next deal is always as important as the current one.
WWE is a refined, effective, capitalist machine with an incredible aptitude for squeezing increasing amounts of money from a shrinking fanbase. They'll be fine, though future contracts may not be so lucrative.
2. Health First?
News that WWE wouldn't force anyone to work through the current crisis broke just before the WrestleMania 36 tapings. That the company were reportedly fine with talent pulling out of bookings without repercussions was a sign of compassion from a promotion not always associated with such traits, though Roman Reigns, as far as we know, is the only wrestler to take his employers up on that offer so far.
Reigns' leukaemia battles leave him immunocompromised. He's a higher-risk person than anyone on the roster so he pulled out of 'Mania, with The Miz showing up to the Performance Center with symptoms the tipping point. Other wrestlers absent through undisclosed illnesses include Miz himself, Rey Mysterio, Dana Brooke, and Murphy, though their pull-outs were enforced by WWE.
The situation makes you wonder if this will mark a shift in WWE's philosophy on wrestler wellbeing, or if it's just a one-off due to extenuating circumstances.
In a sport that sees countless premature deaths and performers physically ruining themselves for the craft, it'd be heartening to see WWE take extra steps to safeguard their wrestlers' wellbeing going forward, beyond the current Wellness Policy.
1. The Pay-Per-View Rights Deal
Vince McMahon himself has confirmed that WWE is looking to shop its pay-per-view rights in 2020, though the current situation made hitting his Q1 target impossible. "There's no better time to exercise the selling of our rights," McMahon said on WWE's Q4 2019 earnings call. "All the majors are really clamouring for our content. That could be a significant increase, obviously, in terms of revenue."
A huge windfall theoretically awaits, though WWE is playing a dangerous game by offering WrestleMania 36 out as a pay-per-view costing between $59.99 and $69.99 on various platforms - a move seen by the promotion as a dummy run for future content delivery.
Roughly 5,000 PPV buys are expected for a show that can be viewed via free WWE Network trial. If these projections are accurate and Vince is still looking for $150 million, his hand is weakened immeasurably.
On top of this, WWE is using WrestleMania 36 as part of the push towards any deal. This 'Mania, which may well be enjoyable, but will look more small-time than ever, going down in an empty Performance Center. It's not exactly the most convincing advertisement and could leave hopes of securing a deal anytime soon in the toilet.