10 Ways WWE Can Prove The Critics WRONG At WrestleMania 37

Drew McIntyre has a chance to prove just how effectively WWE can book a babyface in 2021...

By Michael Sidgwick /

For starters, just call it AEW WrestleMania!

Advertisement

If AEW promoted an event entitled WrestleMania, even though they literally are unable to do this because 'WrestleMania' is a quite famous trademark owned by WWE, the critics would love it!

That's how it works!

Your writer is a critic by profession. You writer is also a critic of WWE through reason.

Many in the wrestling media are, which is interpreted not as damning consensus but rather inherent bias. This tedious discourse resurfaced upon the reveal of this year's Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards, which, not that logic should get in the way, were voted on by fans. They voted for Triple H as Best Booker in 2015, bang in the middle of New Japan Pro Wrestling's critically acclaimed peak. But that's because NXT was as awesome as it was well-booked as it was feel-good. Funny how that works.

The WWE of 2020 and 2021 is none of those things - hence why critics tend not to rate it.

This week's RAW brought so many of WWE's ills into focus. The repetition was numbing; nobody sold, again, the fact that Randy Orton is vomiting jet-black goo; the scripting in Shane McMahon's promo was terrible, confusing, frivolous. That Shane McMahon is even cutting promos is an indictment.

WrestleMania 37 - with the optics of a big crowd set to amplify that which is good - represents an opportunity to prove those critics wrong.

10. On Sundays, They Often Do

When people don't go ballistic in their praise of a WWE pay-per-view, even when the action is mostly strong, the tribalist mutants hold what is on the surface a decent argument: if WWE is a disgrace, as bad as the pathetic death throes of WCW, how could they possibly run such high-quality shows on Sunday nights?

Advertisement

Your writer hasn't ran the numbers, but a typical WWE pay-per-view does very well in the recurring Star Ratings series. **1/2 is average; *** is pretty damn good. Almost invariably, half of the matches on a WWE pay-per-view exceed the latter. Numbers are lost on certain people. These events are invariably praised on this author page and indeed throughout much of the critical community; the ever-controversial Dave Meltzer awarded a WWE RAW match ****1/4 last week, and nothing on the AEW Dynamite show presented 48 hours later matched it.

So why the general, unwavering disdain?

CM Punk said it, and you'll listen to him: WWE can always be better. With the vast financial resources the company boasts, and the world-class talent roster they have recruited to spend it on, what WWE accomplishes on Sundays represents the absolute bare minimum. Those Sundays can and should be better. WWE could hire or utilise expert wrestling minds to craft stories, allow wrestlers to express them, and pay off this elite-level storytelling in amazing unregulated matches that celebrate the incredible range and scope of the pro wrestling art. Tag team wrestling. Lucha libre. Strong style. All of it.

Many top-level WWE PPV matches are very good to excellent. They don't have to be riddled with checklist tropes and worked in the same rhythm.

And they don't always have to be built so unremarkably...

9. ...But Mondays Are More Important

The matches are good because the talent roster is good but this feeling never carries over to television, and the television never enriches those matches, because Vince McMahon is inept and the team of writers he hires aren't there to challenge his baffling and erratic edicts. They are there to script the words of this simpering set of millennials who don't know how to get over.

Advertisement

None of this will happen. You cannot teach an old pal new creative.

But WWE will only ever recover its perception amongst the people who have good taste when they start producing good television. And solid isn't good, or at least good enough anymore. SmackDown is at best solid, overpraised in certain circles against the RAW curve in a bid to feel better about everything. Roman Reigns is a terrific performer, and the talent roster - presumably helped by Daniel Bryan's creative influence - at times forcibly thrusts forward the deadening TV gear Vince McMahon expressly told Shayna Baszler to work in.

But it's all so bereft of energy and angles and expression. Most often fleshed out on the night via the same f*cking contrived expositional administration that has plagued the format for decades, it is old hat sometimes performed incredibly well.

Put on an energetic, immersive wrestling show on the Road to WrestleMania 37 - the ideal time time to do just that - and energised, immersed critics will praise it.

Funny how that works.

8. Don't Do The Roman Reigns Thing With Drew McIntyre

Ahead of WrestleMania 33, Roman Reigns had to be kept strong, even though he was rather strong already, to convince the fans that he stood a chance against the Undertaker. To do this, Reigns brutalised the reigning RAW Tag Team Champions in a damaging and laughably transparent exercise.

Advertisement

"This Roman Reigns fella has the strength of two men! What a great powerhouse!" literally nobody said, except some dipsh*t in Bryan Alvarez's Twitter replies.

It was a double-barrelled blast of quintessentially damaging Vince McMahon bullsh*t. The fans further resented Roman and grew yet more disillusioned with the abject death of tag team wrestling. This was no aberration, either: Triple H was rather fond in the 2000s of casually burying tag teams on his lonesome as a skit, almost.

There's nothing left to kill in 2021. Tag team wrestling is no longer a corpse; it's just ashes. But there's a risk facing Drew McIntyre, who mustn't be killed. He's a rare well-pushed main event-level act, and a babyface no less. Meanwhile, it's difficult not to cheer Bobby Lashley. He just melted The Miz and is an awesome wrecking machine. He is everything the WWE fan was programmed to pop for in their youth writ large.

If Drew annihilates Cedric Alexander and Shelton Benjamin, in the sort of development often forecast through cynical (and accurate) jokes, that might be it for him.

Don't weaponise critics, and they won't shoot. It's so, stunningly simple.

7. Do Something Significant With Kevin Owens

When WWE goes high on a wrestler, it usually means f*ck all. This is a longstanding point of consternation.

Advertisement

You are a biased smark if, for example, you don't fan yourself like a southern belle with a melting fanny when Shinsuke Nakamura gets his old music back and impresses in a Gauntlet match. That is because WWE has done nothing with Shinsuke since. The messaging is as stark as it ever was: do not invest. Investment is punished. And it's not just Nakamura. It's never just one performer.

Kevin Owens feuded with Roman Reigns for several months, losing via chicanery every time, and appears directionless on the Road to WrestleMania. That such a key act can wither into irrelevance underpins the extent to which this is booked week-to-week. KO's lack of direction also exposes the lack of any meaning to this: a top wrestler who took the Ace of the brand to his limit should be awarded with further "opportunities," no? Isn't that how this works? Under the amorphous "opportunity" concept that has plagued WWE's storytelling approach in recent years?

How does it work, actually?

The answer is that it does not - but mapping an arc for Kevin Owens would indicate that the last however many months actually mattered. That investment matters. That this isn't just something tossed out, rinsed and repeated to fulfil the obligation of a TV deal.

6. And Also...

Cesaro.

Advertisement

Cesaro isn't the immense TV star presence his devoted fanbase projects him to be, but he is a sensation in the ring at his best, and more to the point, this isn't dreamy-eyed fan-casting anymore. He is getting the push. Virtually all established precedent renders this meaningless, and to support a point that really doesn't require much support - you'd have to be utterly brainwashed and Fedpilled to believe that WWE is good at mapping out consistent character arcs - Cesaro is getting the push that Shinsuke Nakamura was set to receive. To take Cesaro's push at optimistic face value, you'd have to ignore the events of literally this year.

Critics - informed by things that happen all of the f*cking time - will say that Cesaro is bound, sooner rather than later, though he's done very well to last more than three weeks, for Main Event.

But this one is sticking for now. Cesaro is on course to work Seth Rollins in a match that should by rights deliver to a ****+ level.

When? Fastlane, or WrestleMania?

The storyline or what passes for it is dire, drenched in Seth's pious blathering crap, but that's WWE for you. Under the wave of awful scripted sh*te, they can still deliver a breakthrough win on the biggest stage, position Cesaro for a Universal Title match in the summer, and - this is crucial - gradually cultivate the feeling that getting behind a performer actually means you'll get to see them in a few months' time.

5. Get Mustafa Ali Vs. Kofi Kingston Get Back On Track

None of this matters as a product that makes any coherent sense week-to-week, never mind as some grand narrative tapestry.

Advertisement

Inexplicably, WWE appeared to arrive at an ideal upper midcard WrestleMania programme a month or so back. If it was senseless to turn Mustafa Ali heel - he's an exciting talent and a very upstanding dude - WWE nonetheless located the perfect opponent for him in Kofi Kingston.

The best heels feel in their minds that they are right. Circumstances incited Ali's descent - in addition, of course, to fitful and apathetic booking - but he can project that onto Kofi who in 2019 replaced Ali as Daniel Bryan's WrestleMania opponent. WWE blew the chance to set the story in motion at the event - Elimination Chamber - that plunged Ali into this dark alternate timeline. But all is not yet lost; Ali can sell a loss to Riddle as another continuation of the decline for which Kingston is ultimately responsible.

It's a long-term story with heft that, if it meets its potential, can result in a cracking, energetic WrestleMania opener perfect to unglue the biggest crowd of the pandemic era.

4. Promote A HOSS FIGHT Of A Main Event

The 'WWE style' is often weaponised against the company.

Advertisement

If they're not staring at their bloody hands or crying or talking relentlessly under the mistaken belief that explaining the story is great storytelling, they're smashing each other through barricades in an attempt to tick off every box on the Michael Hayes checklist. Even when the work is blisteringly good, many WWE main events fall afoul of these clichéd trappings and draw derision in critical circles. Despite Michael Cole's forced protest, it would be considerably more surprising if one of these motherf*ckers didn't fall through a table.

You know what's been great? The Drew McIntyre Vs. Sheamus series.

They have nailed the specific strain of animosity that is felt in close friendships gone awry and have articulated it wonderfully in their brutal matches. They don't ask why they're not each other's mate anymore. They don't explain it by talking. They just beat the sh*t out of one another in matches that do not mess about with melodrama.

If WWE presents a hoss battle between Bobby Lashley and Drew McIntyre at WrestleMania 37 in the same vein, it might go some way towards highlighting that WWE does deviate from the checklist on occasion.

3. Make The Firefly Fun House Match FULL Comedy

They baited and switched you last year.

Advertisement

John Cena buried Bray Wyatt in the build, drawing the usual complaints, but it was for an audacious purpose. It was an exceptional subversion of your expectations in that the resulting mind-f*ck was premised on precisely that: Cena's career was reframed and lanced as toxic ego-massage that proved detrimental to the very system he fronted as a good guy mascot. The Firefly Fun House match was a shocking creative triumph.

And Christ Al-f*cking-mighty do they need to do it again because this ongoing Randy Orton programme is spectacularly awful.

Themed on immolation (!) - imagine any wrestler trying to land a dropkick on the Fiend after this, when he literally cannot be killed - it has descended into hokey satanic imagery and Papa Shango prop goo b*llocks. To stand any chance of not further descending into WrestleCrap parody, this joke has to acknowledge itself as and one-up the punchline.

Bray Wyatt is a far more gifted comedian than he is a monster - the Fun House vignettes retained a certain charm long after the Fiend was killed dead - and maybe that black goo, to sell the twist, can find itself pouring out of a different orifice and into a Diva's bag.

2. Promoting A LEGIT MOTY Candidate

AEW and NJPW dominated the year-end lists of most critics because Keith Lee said things like "I am Limitless" before hitting his finish when Damian Priest could have just punched him and because Braun Strowman wore a mask to the tearful euphoria of Bray Wyatt.

Advertisement

WWE matches, again, are heavily produced and patterned in a certain way that has long since descended into cliché, and the lack of danger or the illusion of it - and general expression - suffers in contrast to the work of the artists who are free to create.

To give the best possible chance of showing us dorky insects just what the f*ck WWE is all about, they should situate the indie scene product Daniel Bryan in a 20-25 minute match. They should do this as a matter of course while he's still in his physical prime anyway.

Bryan is a storytelling wizard as fantastic at transitioning through story beats as he is through holds. If anybody can extract an old world response from the distanced 30,000 throng, it is him, and with no direction beyond Fastlane - he can't work Jey Uso again, surely - he should work work Chad Gable. That is totally naive sub-message board fantasy booking, but it's still the best match they have.

So why not do it? Wouldn't it be batsh*t not to?

1. Give The Fans Something To Shout About

The complexion of the WWE crowd changed considerably throughout the 2010s.

Advertisement

They were passionate and loud and hot even if that heat was driven by defiance in 2013 and 2014. By 2015, at the Royal Rumble specifically, a resignation had crept in. Fury had withered to apathy, but they still cared somewhat enough to reject Roman Reigns. By the end of the decade, with none of this complaints addressed, a hush descended across the States, even in the hardcore hotbeds. The WWE fan, broadly, had quietened, content to take in the action with a mildly half-pleased reaction at best. Broadly. You will find exceptions.

This could be so much better had mutated into Hey this is pretty cool I like me some WWE. Those that cared the most had left to care about something else - hence the NJPW U.S. expansion and the emergence of All Elite Wrestling.

A great match is measured by volume, mostly, though there are great matches that by rights should have electrified a crowd but didn't. Critics point to these subdued reactions as proof that WWE has declined, but WrestleMania 37 promises tens of thousands of raucous fans defying those critics. The decision to run 'Mania across two nights is a welcome one. It mitigates the fatigue that is impossible not to feel deep into the sixth (!) hour.

They should be prepared to bring the noise, and if they're hot throughout, it might act as a shred of evidence that WWE isn't just an insipid content factory.

Advertisement