10 Ways WWE SummerSlam 2015 Could've Been Saved
The biggest party of the summer could’ve been even bigger if they had done things differently…
SummerSlam 2015 was a mixed bag for WWE. The company tried to turn the second-biggest show of the year into a four event that was supposed to make it feel like a second WrestleMania. However, despite all the hype, all the build-up and all the effort put into making the show feel as memorable as possible, the show left a lot to be desired.
Even though it featured some great matches, a relatively loud audience, and some truly shocking moments, the overall reaction to the show suggests that it could’ve been so much better.
Despite some fans choosing to focus on one match or another as the sole cause of the show’s disappointing feel, the truth is that the show was plagued by multiple problems that left it coming off as inferior to the NXT special that had taken place the night before.
Of course, now that SummerSlam is over, WWE’s power-brokers will go back to the drawing board and rethink their strategy for next year’s SummerSlam. Looking back on the event, they’re going to have to avoid making the mistakes they made in Brooklyn.
This article proposes ten things that WWE's booking staff and production department could've done differently to make SummerSlam a much better show than it was. Although it will indeed go down in history as a great show, due in part to some great matches and unique creative decisions, the sad truth is that it could've been so much better, if WWE had made the following decisions...
10. An Exciting Tag Team Title Match As Opener (Between Only Two Teams)
The opening match for such a long show is critical in keeping fans invested and focused on the action in the ring. If that fails to work, then the rest of the show can suffer from increased fan apathy, or worse, people spending more time on their phones than watching the matches unfold.
NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn was booked perfectly, with the Liger-Breeze match being the perfect choice of opener. Seeing a legend take on one of NXT’s finest was an excellent hook, and fans actually cared for who won or lost. In contrast, the Orton vs Sheamus was, well, boring.
There hasn’t been anything particularly novel about this renewed feud, and the only really unique part of the match was that it took Sheamus two Brogue kicks to pin Orton. In further contrast, the match that followed had more action in less time, as the tag team title match was one of the most exciting on the entire card, despite having two teams too many.
Though the Lucha Dragons and Los Matadores did have some interesting spots, the match belonged to the Prime Time Players and the New Day, who stole the show with their antics. Had WWE opted to open with a standard tag team match between these two teams only, and given them the exact same amount of time, it’s virtually guaranteed that the audience would’ve been much more attentive for the rest of the show.
9. More Excitement Around The Intercontinental Championship
Every other championship in WWE has some kind of greater storyline around it that makes it seem valuable and desirable. The WWEWHC is in the Authority’s hands, The Tag Team division is getting ever more interesting, the Divas division is undergoing a ‘revolution’ (of sorts), and the US Title was, up until SummerSlam, being defended on a regular basis in some of the best matches of the year.
And then there’s the Intercontinental Championship, that’s being held by bona fide midcarders and being sought by other midcarders.
Why aren’t other, more established wrestlers challenging for this belt? Why aren’t people like Wyatt, Cesaro, Owens, or Neville, challenging for this belt after failing to acquire Cena’s US Title? Alas, these questions remain unanswered, and so the IC Champion is left to defend his prize against an ageing giant and an irritating sub-Hollywood star.
The IC Championship match at SummerSlam would’ve been far more interesting if the build-up featured more traditional aspects of a title challenge: multiple wrestlers vying for the belt, competing against each other to determine a single number one contender.
I mean, how hard is it to announce a #1 Contender’s tournament, or even do an over-the-top-rope battle royal to determine said position? These tiny details, which would’ve shown that the wrestlers actually cared for the belt, would’ve made a huge difference in a match combination that had already been seen many times before SummerSlam anyway.
8. Have A Better Reason For Why Sheamus And Orton Are Feuding
The opener for SummerSlam 2015 featured a tough-as-nails Gaelic warrior with a devastating arsenal taking on a twelve-time World Champion with one of the most popular finishing moves in the entire WWE. If that description sounds like a license to print money, and you found yourself disappointed in what actually transpired at SummerSlam, then congratulations…you’re just like the countless thousands who were left underwhelmed by the show’s opener.
Sheamus vs. Randy Orton was a match that just screamed ‘thrown together last minute’, and it showed all the problems WWE has when it comes to keeping match-ups fresh. Was Sheamus only attacking Orton because he cost him one match? Does Orton STILL have some unfinished business with Sheamus? Would either man benefit in a major way if either of them won at such a major show?
None of these questions were answered, and so fans were left with a contest that was just put on the show solely for the sake of putting two former World Champions together.
This is yet another feud that would’ve benefited greatly from a better storyline explanation as to why they’re feuding. Adding a simple stipulation (for example: winner faces the WWEWHC at the next PPV) would’ve done wonders for the match, making it more dramatic, and would’ve allowed fans to invest in it more. Every nearfall would’ve made people care more, and both men would be presented as true main eventers once again.
7. Have Braun Strowman Debut At SummerSlam Instead Of On RAW
It’s often said that wins and losses don’t matter in WWE (at least according to Nikki Bella) and if they do, then it’s only the PPV wins that are actually taken seriously (you can thank WWE’s commentators and writers for not making every win/loss feel like part of something bigger, leading to them being literally traded from week to week).
The rivalry between Ambrose & Reigns and the Wyatt Family reached a major point at SummerSlam, and ended in such a way that it gave off the message that, 'even though Reigns and Ambrose won a big match, stay tuned tomorrow to see this rematch take place, for no other reason than to keep these four guys busy’.
Because it was a major PPV, it would’ve been the perfect opportunity for WWE to debut Braun Strowman as the Wyatt Family’s newest member.
Having Strowman demolish Reigns on a major show like this would’ve not only given him (and the Wyatt Family) increased credibility, but it would’ve also made the show (and the rivalry) feel more special, since that destruction would take place on PPV instead of during a throwaway segment on RAW.
With both Wyatt and Reigns in dire need of a long feud to elevate both men, it would’ve been better for Strowman to come in and demolish Reigns and Ambrose at a historical event, adding more surprise to a show that was in need of better shocks than what it actually witnessed.
6. Divas Match Option #1: One Person Gets Eliminated At A Time
WWE’s philosophy of sticking as many people onto a show as possible is tiresome. When you add more people to a show, it makes the matches and storylines more difficult to follow or justify. Nowhere was this more problematic than the Divas tag team match, where one pin or submission led to an entire team being eliminated.
The whole point of the supposed ‘Divas Revolution’ is that individuals are making change, and yet the new faces of the division are put into trios, because apparently that allows more of them to benefit from screen time. And yet, this match was not well thought out.
Team B.A.D. was eliminated in its entirety when Tamina got pinned by Brie Bella. That robbed the WWE Universe of seeing the rest of the team in action, and highlighted the problem of the match’s stipulation.
What should’ve happened instead was that only one person would get eliminated at a time, not the whole team. That alone would’ve led to an entirely different (and more exciting) match, which would’ve allowed fans to see the best of all of the participants.
Imagine seeing team PCB down to one member being forced to take on both Bellas and all of Team B.A.D., for example. With the amount of time they were given for this match, they could’ve done so much more and had a much more dramatic and deeper match than the one that took place at SummerSlam.
5. Divas Match Option #2: A Divas Title Match
The Divas Revolution hasn’t brought about the change that many people had initially expected. Instead of it being all about changing how women are presented in WWE, it has become about backstage egos. WWE’s seemingly unstoppable commitment to have Nikki Bella surpass AJ Lee’s record 295-day reign has led to some frustrating booking decisions.
While it’s somewhat understandable for WWE to want to have the division be represented by someone more loyal to the company, the least Nikki could do is, you know, actually defend the title on a regular basis. She hasn’t defended it in roughly 60 days, twice the (supposed) limit for other belts.
For Nikki to keep blathering on about how she’s going to surpass AJ’s reign without even defending it speaks volumes of an irritating trend of WWE ignoring the rules that are supposed to govern their universe. It would’ve been a much more interesting match if Nikki defended her belt against one or more challengers, instead of taking part in a tag team match that’s likely to be forgotten in a few weeks anyway.
Had Nikki defended her belt, it would’ve opened the door to a plethora of match combinations and potential storylines, and if she were booked to retain the belt, it would’ve done so much more to make her look like a fighting and deserving champion.
4. A Clean Finish For The Cena-Rollins Match
One of the biggest criticisms of Seth Rollins’ current title reign is that he comes off as a perpetual weakling, the mirror image of dominant heel Brock Lesnar was as champion. This problem comes from the manner in which Rollins wins the majority of his matches and title defenses: via interference, disqualification, or some other form of ‘Dusty finish’.
This does little to make him feel like a credible champion, and makes him seem entirely dependent on others for his own success. Nowhere else was his more obvious than in his SummerSlam match with John Cena.
The match was clearly balanced, with both men demonstrating impressive skill. However, Rollins was the superior athlete in the match, and looked right on top of his game in this contest. To really drive the point home that he truly deserved to be WWEWHC (and negate the criticisms that Cena had leveled against him), Rollins should’ve won clean. And he could have…if not for the bizarre decision to have John Stewart screw Cena over.
With that decision, Rollins once again came off as weak and inferior to Cena, who was presented as being so powerful that it’s a necessity for his opponents to cheat to beat him.
Had Rollins won clean, it would’ve given the fans in attendance a genuine moment to be proud of Rollins, and would’ve done much more in elevating the WWEWHC to the top of the card, instead of being second to Cena.
3. Keep The Show 3 Hours Long
One of WWE’s most bizarre marketing ploys applied in recent years appears to be a ‘give them more’ philosophy. This mentality, which might stem from Vince’s idea that every fan lives WWE 24/7, has led to a ‘numbers-based’ approach to making shows bigger.
RAW is now 3 hours long, the 2011 Royal Rumble match had 40 participants, and SummerSlam reached WrestleMania length of a four-hour event, excluding the pre-show.
There’s a reason that only WrestleMania lasts that long: the show’s grandeur and significance makes it worth sitting/standing for hours, whereas SummerSlam is still perceived by many people as a secondary PPV. Unless every match is as stellar and well-hyped as WrestleMania’s, fans will get tired, bored and uncomfortable much more easily, leading to a less-interested crowd.
SummerSlam could’ve been saved by being only three hours long, and having some of the matches shorter but more action-heavy. Both the Orton-Sheamus match and the Intercontinental Title match could’ve been much more exciting if they were each less than ten minutes long, and the ‘special guest’ match shouldn’t’ have gone more than five minutes maximum (it was, after all, a glorified squash match).
Keeping matches shorter keeps the action fresh and prevents the repetition of rest-holds. Though some matches do benefit from being longer, that wasn’t the case at SummerSlam.
2. A Decisive Finish For Undertaker Vs. Brock Lesnar
It’s the finish that everyone has been complaining about, one that goes even further in ignoring the rules of WWE storytelling and making confusing finishes on the fly. Allegedly, Vince needed Undertaker to win, but couldn’t risk Brock looking weak by losing, and so he booked a dirty finish that had Undertaker win without Brock looking bad.
The problem with this thinking is that at this point, no one ever looks weak from losing to the Undertaker. The mere fact of them being in the ring with the Deadman elevates them to new heights, and whether they defeat him or they get Tombstoned, their careers are (for the most part) better off afterwards. This match, which pitted two bitter rivals against one another, was in dire need of a decisive finish that outlined one clear winner and one loser.
The Undertaker tapping out is a legendary feat in itself, and would’ve done wonders to elevate Brock Lesnar (as if he wasn’t a megastar already), and the actual ending of Lesnar flipping ‘Taker off before passing out would’ve been awesome in itself.
The match did not need a screwy finish brought about by a misplaced referee and an overzealous timekeeper. Had the match ended without replays and confused commentators, the match could’ve gone down as an instant classic between two intense foes who put on an impressive MMA-style match.
1. Not Hosting It On The Same Weekend As An NXT: TakeOver Event
SummerSlam 2015 took place in the exact same arena as NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn, which itself took place exactly twenty hour hours earlier. Not only did that show have significant buzz going on about it, but it also set the standard exceptionally high for the SummerSlam card. Unfortunately, despite a lot of efforts, the majority of fans agreed that NXT TakeOver was a better event than SummerSlam.
This is especially true as it relates to scheduling and match booking. NXT was 2 hours long, had six matches and short interludes. It opened with a hot match featuring a wrestling legend, had each match feel special, and was capped off by an excellent ladder match and a stellar women’s singles match.
In contrast, SummerSlam was more or less twice as long, had ten matches, and several random and insignificant segments. The opener was a slow and plodding affair, several matches felt like TV-quality contests, and many matches were either overbooked or featured controversial finishes.
Because of these obvious negatives, SummerSlam would’ve benefited from being both in a different venue and on a different weekend from the NXT event. If that happened, the show’s negatives wouldn’t have been so pronounced, and the Brooklyn crowd wouldn’t have been as critical of the things that NXT did that WWE didn’t do.
With Triple H's NXT growing ever more popular and the audience growing increasingly more cynical towards the main shows booked by Vince and Kevin Dunn, it may be best that the two opposing show philosophies stay away from each other for a while.