10 WCW Greats That WWE Didn't Know What To Do With

By Scott Carlson /

When you talk about WCW wrestlers who rose to even greater prominence in WWE, the list reads like a Who's Who of professional wrestling: "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, Mick Foley, Kevin Nash, Eddie Guerrero, the Undertaker, Chris Jericho and HHH, just to name a few. All had varying levels of success in WCW before jumping to WWE and becoming world champions and some of the biggest stars of our generation. However, that does not mean that WWE had the magic touch when it came to taking a WCW star and turning him or her into a household name. In fact, in several cases, WWE dropped the ball and turned what should have been easy money into a dud. These are wrestlers who either were well established or were poised for a breakout and for whatever reason, superstardom never materialized. For purposes of making it too easy to craft a list of 10, let's acknowledge that the vast majority of the WCW guys from the Invasion angle could qualify for this list. A few definitely still made the cut though. Some of the others might be surprising...

10. Lex Luger

It's easy to discount Luger given the slug he became in the dying days of WCW, but in the early 90s, Luger was a hot commodity. He was fresh off a run in NWA/WCW as a tag, US and world heavyweight champion in 1992, when Vince McMahon signed him... to the World Bodybuilding Federation. Ugh. When Luger finally got around to debuting in the WWF in 1993, he was The Narcissist, a gimmick that went nowhere and was abandoned once Hulk Hogan left, because, you've got to have a blond superhero on the roster at all times, right? "Made in the USA" Lex Luger slammed world champion Yokozuna and then jumped on a bus to campaign for a title shot, because nothing says world champion material more than a guy who takes his case to the fans rather than getting in the champ's face. Luger never won the big match and was gone from WWE just two-and-a-half years after debuting, returning to WCW and making a huge splash on the very first Nitro in the process. He never rose to the level of a megastar in WWE and is still regarded as a WCW product first and foremost.

9. Mark Jindrak/Shawn Stasiak

These two members of the Natural Born Thrillers who could have been perfectly serviceable WWE stars in the early 2000s. In fact, Jindrak was originally tapped to be a member of Evolution before being replaced by Batista. (No word on how Jindrak would look in skinny jeans with a nose ring.) He settled for being a poor Narcissist knockoff for a while before serving as Kurt Angle's lackey. Not exactly the career that his replacement in Evolution managed. Stasiak bounced back and forth between WWE and WCW, starting out as Meat in WWE before being taken somewhat more seriously in WCW. He established himself as a credible wrestler, only to return to WWE during the Invasion with a klutz gimmick and later became known as the man from Planet Stasiak. Here WWE had the son of the company's fifth world champion, and instead of at least trying to use that, they made him out to be a geek.

8. Lance Storm

As crazy as it sounds, WCW got this one right. Lance Storm came in as a wrestling machine, capturing the U.S., Hardcore and Cruiserweight titles in a two-week span. He created the Team Canada stable and was a large focus of the promotion in 2000-01 and was a rare bright spot during WCW's dying days. Then came Storm's WWE tenure. While the Un-Americans had potential, the group imploded way too soon (it was rumored that the group was broken up because Christian and Test wouldn't cut their hair short like Storm). From there, Storm shared screen time with "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, who urged the crowd to chant "boring" at him. Funny how that didn't work to get him over. Lance Storm is a rare case of downward spiraling WCW figuring out how to use him, but WWE just missing the boat. They almost had something with the Un-Americans, but a three month stable doesn't salvage his run, especially since it also involved him cabbage-patching.

7. Dean Malenko

The Man of 1,000 Holds. The Iceman. Double Ho Seven. One of these things is not like the other. Why didn't WWE just call him Chilly McFreeze and be done with it? Dean Malenko came to WWE in early 2000 along with his Radicalz stablemates Chris Benoit, Perry Saturn and Eddie Guerrero. They were treated as high-profile defectors who left WCW and took WWE by storm. Malenko captured the Light Heavyweight title, but that is about it for him. Deano Machino was never going to be a major star in WWE, but as Chris Jericho proved in WCW, Malenko's no-nonsense persona could have been played as a perfect foil to the types of characters that dominated WWE in 2000-01. He would've been a solid midcarder or tag-team partner. Instead, we got a cheap James Bond rip-off who tried to date Lita.

6. Scott Steiner

When you hire a musclebound "genetic freak" who is prone to verbal and physical outbursts and fits of unpredictability while wearing a chainmail headdress, what do you do? If you're WWE, you bring him in as a babyface and have him engage champion HHH in nonsensical feud that involves posedowns and arm wrestling contests before they compete in one of the worst WWE PPV title matches you'll ever see. Steiner's second act in WWE should have either never happened, or it should have picked up right where his WCW run ended €“ with him as a brash, loudmouth, loose-cannon of a heel. If they had played that angle, he could have come in and wreaked havoc on the faces in two-minute squashes and executed lead pipe beatdowns. Talk about going against typecast.

5. Mike Awesome

To be fair, WCW also misused the former ECW champion, but WWE should have recognized the talent they had in front of them. In bringing Mike Awesome into WWE, they had the opportunity to hit the reset button and build him up as a tough competitor who would fight for the Intercontinental title or be the muscle in a prominent tag team. Unfortunately, the highlight of the late Mike Awesome's WWE career took place on his first night, when he won the Hardcore title. After that, it was all downhill until his release less than two years later.

4. Sean O'Haire

Man, talk about wasted potential. Sean O'Haire was one of the most impressive figures of WCW in 2000-01. He was a big man who could really move with a great finisher, a senton bomb that looked better than Jeff Hardy's ever did. When he got to WWE, they gave him a great "devil's advocate" gimmick, which showed that he could talk too (!), at which point, any wrestling promoter probably would be counting money in their sleep. However, O'Haire got paired with "Rowdy" Roddy Piper, which killed any momentum he had, and once Piper was released, O'Haire wasn't long for the company. He wasn't going to be a John Cena, but O'Haire should have been a main event-caliber wrestler based on his look and ability. Instead, there wasn't one memorable feud after the Invasion ended. But I'm not telling you anything you don't already know.

3. Goldberg

The hottest star WCW created from the ground up (and subsequently destroyed, but nevermind that now), Goldberg was one of the last big names to make the jump to WWE. It was a huge deal. WWE programmed Goldberg in against their biggest star, The Rock. You would think that would have helped establish Goldberg, but after being trained that WCW stars are inferior, the WWE fans weren't buying. But the biggest muff in Goldberg's one-year run by far was the world title chase. Goldberg had to wait until SummerSlam for his title match €“ which makes little sense if you knew you had a one-year contract that started in March €“ which he lost to an injured HHH. Goldberg would win the title the next month, but the damage was done. Everything after that was just HHH staying in the title picture until he got the belt back. Goldberg should have come in and established himself with the power moves and squashes that built him up in WCW and moved quickly up the card to a title win.

2. Diamond Dallas Page

It's been talked about to death, but DDP got hosed when he came to WWE. He was arguably the biggest star to make the jump when WCW folded (World champ Booker T carried more prestige but wasn't as recognizable), and he was programmed into a feud with one of WWE's top dogs. Bless him, DDP tried to make the feud work, but it wasn't meant to be. In WCW, Diamond Dallas Page was one of their top homegrown stars, their People's Champion. He skyrocketed to superstardom by refusing to join the nWo and fighting with the Macho Man for months on end. He was a three-time WCW World champion. Fans flashed the diamond cutter sign every time he appeared. This wasn't a hit-or-miss prospect like some of the others on this list. DDP's unmasking as the stalker of Undertaker's wife sent the crowd into a frenzy, proving that he was not just recognizable, but still immensely popular. But WWE completely misplayed his entire run, abandoning the idea of DDP getting into 'Taker's head and using him to climb the WWE ladder and instead turning him into an actual stalker. Then Undertaker buried him six feet under. Then Positively Page happened. Then DDP was gone. But DDP has contributed more positively to the WWE community than anyone could ever imagine with the miraculous turnarounds of Scott Hall and Jake "The Snake" Roberts.

1. Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat

Savage-Steamboat at WrestleMania III is probably one of the all-time great, most well-known matches out there (just ask Chris Jericho). For a lot of fans today, they hear about that match and think of Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat someone who rose to prominence in WWE. But Steamboat already was an accomplished and decorated wrestler, having won numerous NWA titles prior to his initial WWE run. When Steamboat returned to NWA/WCW in 1989, he and Ric Flair proceeded to tear the house down with their feud. It legitimized Steamboat as a top-tier performer and showed that he was capable of being a focal point of a promotion. When Steamboat trekked back north to WWE in 1991, he wasn't pushed as a world title contender or even inserted into an Intercontinental title feud. He emerged as the fire-breathing Dragon, with little to no reference to his previous success. Just to prove that WWE dropped the ball with Steamboat, when he returned to WCW once more, he went on to capture the Tag Team, TV and U.S. titles in a four-year span. WWE had one of the best in-ring performers and one of the most natural babyfaces on their roster not once, but twice. But somehow, he never materialized as more than a popular midcarder with one very classic match on his resume. Let this be a warning for fans who think that Samoa Joe, A.J. Styles and Bobby Roode should all jump to WWE right now and get pushed to the moon €“ there's no guarantee they won't end up breathing fire, staring into a mirror, having a posedown or cabbage-patching to the ring.