10 Weakest WWE Return Pops Ever
Spare a thought for poor old Brian Christopher...
Few things get a wrestling crowd going like a big return, and the thrill of an old face turning up completely out of the blue can't be matched. It provokes the kind of hysteric, adrenaline-fuelled response that makes the sport worth watching in the first place, drawing even the most jaded fans into the moment.
From Triple H's return to Monday Night Raw in 2002 to The Undertaker's Judgement Day 2000 re-emergence, wrestling comebacks have provided some of the loudest, most memorable pops in the sport's history. Even The Great Khali, one of the most maligned World Heavyweight Champions ever, got an excellent crowd reaction at Battleground 2017, which pretty much says it all.
Nothing is foolproof, however, and surprise returns are no different. Khali's example proves that they can draw a reaction for even the lowliest wrestlers, but if the circumstances aren't right, the crowd will kill the moment with dreaded silence. Some of the names included within are genuine wrestling legends, making their lack of audience acknowledgement saddening, while others were never particularly popular in the first place.
Whatever the case, none of their returns produced the response that the company or performer had hoped for, leaving both red-faced...
10. Layla
Nikki Bella had been WWE Divas Champion for just six days prior to Extreme Rules 2012. She'd scored an opportunistic pinfall over previous champ Beth Phoenix in a Lumberjill match on Raw that week, with a rematch slated for the PPV. Phoenix wasn't given medical clearance to compete after suffering a kayfabe sprained ankle, leaving Nikki without opposition.
WWE switched to a "mystery opponent" angle, and the Bella Twins cut a basic, cocky promo beforehand, calling Nikki's foe to the ring. What should have been a familiar theme song hit, and out came Layla, who'd just missed a full year of action after suffering a double ligament tear in spring 2011. Unfortunately, the Detroit crowd barely mustered a murmur for her, and the return fell flat.
Layla's reaction was a far cry from the one Nikki would later receive at SummerSlam 2016, when she returned from her own lengthy injury absence. Michael Cole tried to muster some enthusiasm on commentary, but there was no masking the dire reaction.
Layla defeated Nikki that night and held the Divas Title for 140 days, fortunately recovering some of her lost popularity along the way.
9. Carlito
Perhaps the lack of response to Carlito's WWE return in November 2009 shouldn't be a huge surprise. The Puerto Rican had only been gone from television for a couple of months, and wasn't exactly flying high at his time of departure, having just left a forgettable alliance with Rosa Mendes. Still, he walked into a heated situation and completely sucked the life out of the building, all thanks to a terrible pop.
John Cena was WWE Champion at the time. He'd been thrown through a table by Sheamus one week prior, and was set to face the Irishman at the upcoming TLC pay-per-view. Cena hit the ring full of thunder, ready to tear Sheamus apart: he called him out, but got Carlito instead of his number one contender.
The former Intercontinental Champion got nothing from the crowd, even as he ran though his trademark routine by spitting a mouthful of apple in the champ's face. Seconds later, Carlito was laid out with an Attitude Adjustment, and he was pinned clean by Cena the following week. His comeback had made a terrible start, and things didn't get much better, as he was eventually released the following May.
8. Paul Orndorff
Hulk Hogan's feud with Paul Orndorff is widely regarded as one of the most successful of his first WWE run. 'Mr. Wonderful' was one of his era's highest drawing wrestlers, and while his name is rarely mentioned on WWE television these days, his narcissistic gimmick made him a perfect foil for Hogan's ultra-face persona, though he was never able to take Hulk's WWE Championship.
Orndorff was inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame in 2005, but hadn't featured on company television in several decades prior to WrestleMania XXX. There, he appeared alongside Hogan, Roddy Piper, Mr. T, and Pat Patterson, all of whom were part of the first ever 'Mania main event back in 1985.
A few days later, 'Mr. Wonderful' featured as one of many legends brought in to celebrate Hogan's birthday on an episode of Raw. While the crowd went nuts for Piper and Ric Flair, Orndorff's arrival drew absolutely nothing from the fans. The poor guy spent close to a minute trying to whip some kind of reaction out of them, but he got nothing, making this one of the most dismal pops a WWE HOF'er has ever received.
7. D'Lo Brown
He was never going to be a main eventer, but D'Lo Brown was one of the Attitude Era's most underrated wrestlers. Always good value between the ropes, he was a solid midcard presence from 1997 onward, accumulating a single Intercontinental and four European Title reigns, playing a prominent role in the Nation of Domination, and later forming a fun sideshow tag team with The Godfather.
D'Lo's career unquestionably fizzled out over the years. By 2000, Brown was barely featured on mainline WWE television, and had resorted to teaming with Chaz as Lo Down - one of the era's most listless teams. He wasn't over at all, and few tears were wept when he was eventually released in February 2003.
WWE decided to bring D'Lo back for a second run in 2008. He made his televised comeback that July, defeated IC Champ Santino Marella in a non-title bout, but he didn't get any kind of reaction from the crowd. Few people remembered him, and for those that did, their most recent memories were of his fruitless 2003 alliance with Teddy Long. D'Lo disappeared from TV shortly after, and was released again six months later.
6. Erick Rowan
Former Wyatt Family member Erick Rowan has never fared well on his own. WWE's attempt at pushing him as a babyface singles act was a complete failure in 2014, and he's had next to nothing to do since Bray, his master, was sent to Raw in the Superstar Shake-Up. If Rowan draws heat, it's usually down to whoever he's aligned with, and this will likely continue throughout his career.
Erick suffered a torn rotator cuff in October 2016. Doomed to seven months on the sidelines, he sat out much of the Bray Wyatt/Randy Orton storyline, before returning two nights after 'The Viper's' defeat of 'The Eater Of Worlds' at WrestleMania 33. With Randy and Bray going at it in the ring, Rowan jumped the barricade, threw the WWE Champion around ringside, then pulled off his new steampunk-themed mask to reveal his identity.
The crowd went mild. Even attacking SmackDown's apparent top guy couldn't draw a significant pop, and they were deathly silent as Erick threw him around the place. Even play-by-play announcer Tom Phillips sounded bored as he called the action, putting an exclamation point (or removing one) on 2017's most heatless comeback.
5. Tensai
It's a good job that Matt Bloom has excelled as NXT's head trainer, because his last in-ring WWE run was a total bust. Having last competed as A-Train, Bloom had been gone from the company for eight years by the time he returned in 2012. He'd forged a considerable reputation as AJPW and NJPW's Giant Bernard during this time, becoming a two-time IWGP Tag Team Champion, and establishing himself as a steady presence on most major tours.
WWE took his Japanese experience and tried to turn it into a gimmick. Bloom was renamed Lord Tensai, and finally re-debuted on Raw after several weeks of vignettes that April. Unfortunately, Tensai's gimmick was dead on arrival, and it started with a flat match against Alex Riley.
Fans recognised the former Albert, but they didn't care. He'd never been anything more than a solid midcarder during his first run, and WWE had given them little reason to get invested in the Tensai character. Bloom was soon haunted by mocking "Albert" chants everywhere he went, and though his first few weeks brought notable victories over CM Punk and John Cena, his push was soon killed by a lengthy losing streak.
4. Christian
"It's... it's Christian."
Is there a more anticlimactic commentary in WWE history than Todd Grisham's 10 February 2009 proclamation? It's extremely unlikely.
A beloved Attitude Era tag worker, Christian first left WWE after declining a new contract offer in 2005. He jumped to TNA shortly afterwards, and immediately became one of only a few ex-WWE stars to actually push the company forward. Over three years, Christian became one of the promotion's most important acts, securing two NWA World Heavyweight Title reigns along the way, but he departed towards the end of 2008.
He returned to WWE television as part of the ECW brand, but despite Christian's undeniable popularity during the Attitude Era's heyday, the crowd response was muted. Grisham's awful line compounded the situation, and while the fans eventually worked up to 'Captain Charisma' as he challenged ECW Champion Jack Swagger, the initial pop was awful.
Bringing Christian back on Raw or SmackDown would've almost certainly drawn a bigger reaction, and the same goes for entering him in the 2009 Royal Rumble. His run as ECW Champion was good for the brand, but from Christian's standpoint, WWE didn't exactly maximise the first few months of his return.
3. Evolution
Evolution ruled WWE from 2003 to 2005, but inevitably collapsed when their respective egos could no longer coexist. Randy Orton was the first to go, then Batista, before Triple H eventually turned on Ric Flair, bringing the group's dominant run to an official end.
They reunited for a single night in December 2007, but otherwise stayed dormant until April 2014, when the group was reunited. Daniel Bryan had just defeated all three of Triple H, Batista, and Orton in the same night to become WWE Champion, and 'The Viper' and 'The Animal' came together for a tag match the following evening. They attacked Bryan ahead of a title defence against Triple H later that night, but The Shield jumped 'The Game' during the bout, sowing the seeds for their return.
The Shield were booked in an 11-on-3 handicap match the following week, and Evolution's theme hit across the PA system. Unfortunately for them, it wasn't the big moment they were hoping for. The Birmingham, Alabama crowd either didn't remember the group, or didn't care, making this one of the more embarrassing comebacks of their respective careers.
2. Jake Roberts
Jake 'The Snake' Roberts' complete lack of pop upon returning during Old School Raw on 6 January 2014 was unforgivable. Here was one of the greatest heels of all time with an incredible real-life comeback story, making his first WWE appearance in nine years, and the vast majority of the crowd didn't even know who he was.
The return came on the back of a lengthy battle with drug and alcohol addiction, which Jake successfully overcame after moving in with Diamond Dallas Page in October 2012. Roberts kicked his destructive habits, lost 50lbs, and regained much of his old mobility, claiming that if it wasn't for DDP, he'd likely be dead. Sadly, the Baltimore, Maryland crowd didn't recognise this: the announcers (and Dean Ambrose) marked out, but most of the audience did not.
The pop was disappointing, but Jake was inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame later that year. He gave one of the most rousing induction speeches WWE has ever seen at the ceremony, which more than makes up for the reception he received on Raw. Regardless, put 6 January in a bubble, and it's a huge letdown.
1. Brian Christopher
It's easy to forget how popular Too Cool were at the height of their power. Grand Master Sexay and Scotty 2 Hotty were often outshined by teams like The Hardy Boyz, but they were extremely over with the audience, particularly when teaming with Rikishi. The crowd's fondness for them dwindled in 2000, and Sexay was released the following year, but their success when feuding with groups like the McMahon-Helmsley Faction can't be denied.
Sexay returned to WWE television under his original ring name, Brian Christopher, as a one-off in 2011. He was used as part of the ongoing feud between his father, Jerry Lawler, and Michael Cole, with the latter using Brian's testimony to out 'The King' as a bad father, and Christopher's lack of reaction was frankly hilarious.
The old Too Cool music hit, and Brian strutted out onto the stage like the old Grand Master Sexay. He danced his way down the ramp, probably hoping to draw some nostalgia cheers, but was greeted by a wall of silence. The reception was so dismal that it spawned a great meme response from one Reddit user, and it remains the benchmark against which all other failed return pops should be judged.