10 Worst Cruiserweight Champions Ever

By Michael Sanderson /

In 1996 WCW made its most lasting contribution to the world of professional wrestling when it brought Cruiserweight wrestling to the U.S mainstream. At a time when giants still dominated the landscape, the WCW Cruiserweight Division provided a stage for a lot of smaller performers to showcase their talents on a global scale. Without it some of the most successful names in the history of professional wrestling such as Chris Jericho and Rey Mysterio may not have become World Champions. WWE still reap the benefits to this day; Seth Rollins, Dolph Ziggler and Daniel Bryan are among many who modelled parts of their style on WCW€™s Cruiserweights. Two of WWE€™s most highly regarded trainers, Dean Malenko and Jamie Noble, got their first major breaks thanks to the division. The former seven time Cruiserweight Champion Billy Kidman now holds an important position as one of the companies television producers. Unfortunately like everything in life there are always two sides to a story. Whilst we all like to reminisce about the all-time great Championship reigns, we must not forget there have been just as many performers who have had absolutely terrible runs with Cruiserweight Gold. For every Mysterio there is a Hornswoggle, every Malenko a Funaki, without further ado here are the 10 Worst Cruiserweight Champions of all time...

10. Jerry Lynn

In what was a running theme for the division, Jerry Lynn became one of three men to win the WWE Light-Heavyweight Championship on his debut with the company. Just like those other two men his run as Champion was an absolute failure. Lynn won the Championship on the April 29, 2001 episode of Sunday Night Heat. By this point the ECW alumni had been wrestling across the globe for over a decade and as a result had earned a glowing reputation. His early bouts against the Lighting Kid (X Pac) were among the most highly regarding independent matches of their era. After making his way to ECW his battles with Rob Van Dam would become stuff of legend with the hard-core faithful. Upon his arrival to the WWE many expected Lynn€™s talents to help revive what was a dead WWE Light-Heavyweight scene. Instead it took less than two months for WWE to inexplicably give up on Lynn; he dropped the title in June to Jeff Hardy after only making a handful of defences along the way. The writing was on the wall for Lynn. After losing the title he would never make an appearance on either of the WWE€™s flagship shows Raw or Smackdown and was then unceremoniously released from the company just eleven months after his debut.

9. Crowbar & Daffney

Very rarely has the angle of co-champions paid dividends in professional wrestling. In fact it could be argued that the only time the idea has been effective was in the 1980€™s when it was adopted by the AWA Tag Team Champions the €˜Fabulous Freebirds€™. As both a stable and co-champions the trio would pick their spots and confuse their opponents by only revealing which pairing would defend the Tag Team Championship when the bell had rung. As this strategy gave the Freebirds an unfair advantage it worked perfectly in garnering heat from the crowd. In fact the execution was so flawless, that the unofficial rule in where co-champions in a stable could choose who defends the championship has since been affectionately christened the €˜Freebird Rule€™. Nevertheless in spite of the staggering failure rate, WCW decided to drag the tired co-champions routine out on the On the May 15th 2000 edition of Monday Nitro. Oddball couple Crowbar and Daffney would team up to take on then Cruiserweight Champion Chris Candido and Tammy Lynn Sytch (Sunny). Despite this being a mixed tag match the winners would be crowned WCW Cruiserweight Champion. In the end Daffney pinned Sytch and as a result she and Crowbar were declared co-champions. Unsurprisingly the angle bombed. With absolutely no reaction from the crowd a week later WCW ended up switching the belt to just Daffney alone. The damage was done however, her solo reign would only last a further two days.

8. Jaqueline

Many complain about putting perceived male titles such as the WWE Cruiserweight Championship on women. Truth be told, pound for pound Jaqueline is one of the toughest people to ever step in a wrestling ring and could more then hold her own against many of her male counterparts. The problem with this reign was simply down to its complete randomness. When Jaqueline won the WWE Cruiserweight Championship, she hadn€™t been seen on television in ten months. Before that she had spent most of her time looking up at the lights for pretty much every female wrestler in the WWE. Despite this on the May 4th 2004 episode of Smackdown, the champion Chavo Guerrero offered an open challenge to anyone on the roster and some creative genius felt that Jaqueline should be the one to answer the call. It may as well have been Stan of Sweet Chin Music fame for how much sense the decision made. As Cruiserweight Champion, the Texan native would lose on the following week€™s Smackdown to Chavo Guerrero€™s father €“ Chavo Classic. A week later in her first defence Jaqueline would drop the title back to Chavo Jr himself. To rub salt in the wounds the younger Guerrero competed with one armed tied behind his back. This reign can probably be chalked down to a simple thank you gesture to a loyal employee; Jaqueline would be released a month later.

7. Christian

By far the most successful name on this list Christian has won every single€™s title available to him during his WWE tenure. A lot of his reigns have been memorable; his sole reign as the WWE Light-Heavyweight Champion however was a major disappointment. After winning the title on his WWE debut, the future World Champion competed in just three matches in the space of two months before losing the title due to outside interference. If unfortunate as all the signs were there for what could have been an entertaining title run. Christian came to the WWE with a reputation as one of the premier independent wrestlers in America. His initial gimmick as part of the Brood is one of the most fondly remembered of the Attitude Era. The man Christian beat for the title, Taka Michinoku would have been a prime candidate for his first feud. Whilst never considered one of the shows featured acts, Michinoku had carved out a small following on the under-card thanks to an eleven month title reign which produced one great match after another. In the end none of this was ever meant to be. During his days as Light-Heavyweight Champion Christian never even had a singles match outside of the WWE€™s B-Show Sunday Night Heat.

6. Chavo Classic

In 2002 the WWE Brand Split afforded more TV time to the Cruiserweights and a short time later Rey Mysterio would make his company debut. As a result the stock of Cruiserweight wrestling in WWE skyrocketed. Matches between Mysterio, Tajiri, Jamie Noble and Matt Hardy were the highlights of programming. In the fact the division had gained so much traction that Mysterio and Hardy main- evented Smackdown in a match over the WWE Cruiserweight Championship This great run of Cruiserweight competition would culminate in a fantastic contest between Mysterio and Chavo Guerrero at No Way Out 2004. It€™s not only one of the best matches in a stacked year but probably the best WWE Cruiserweight match of all time. So after such progress what did WWE do? Introduce the 55 year old Chavo Classic and give him the title on a fluke win. In his day Chavo Classic was one of the biggest stars in the industry, but this was over 20 years removed and almost inevitably he was portrayed as comic relief. The oldest Guerrero brother would only hold the Championship for a month before being fired for no- showing consecutive house shows. In a different context a man with as much knowledge as Classic could have made it work. Instead his reign ended up being a momentum killer; the Cruiserweight division would never quite recover.

5. Gillberg

If Christian€™s title reign put the credibility of the WWE Light-Heavyweight Championship on life support, then it was the reign of his successor Gillberg that pulled the plug completely. Under his real name Duane Gill, the Baltimore native was a perennial jobber for the WWE throughout the early 90€™s. After being released in 1994, Gill would hone his craft on the independent scene before making a completely unexpected return at the 1998 edition of the Survivor Series. Within weeks of his re-emergence Gill would defeat Christian for the WWE Light-Heavyweight Championship and shortly after be repackaged as Gillberg; a comedy character solely designed to mock WCW€™S biggest star at the time €“ Goldberg. Complete with a personal security team, sparklers and piped in crowd chants, the character was just one of many not so subtle jabs thrown between the two Monday Night rivals. To further parody the WCW Superstar, Gillberg was initially scheduled to go on a non-title losing streak of 173 matches. Whilst it would have been another entertaining aspect to the character, it also showed how much regard the WWE held for the Light Heavyweight division at the time. As was custom during the frantic Attitude Era, plans soon changed and the losing streak never came to fruition. Gillberg wrestled exactly three televised matches in eighteen months and whilst he still came to the ring with the belt, the Light Heavyweight Championship was all but forgotten

4. Madusa

Arguably the most accomplished female wrestler of the mid 80s and early 90€™s, Madusa holds the distinction of being the first women to hold the WCW Cruiserweight Championship. After paying her dues in the AWA and Japan as both a wrestler and manager, Madusa would have significant stints in both WCW and WWE, in the process earning the status as perhaps the best female wrestler in America. Despite this by the time 1999 rolled around her role in WCW was reduced to competing in evening gown matches and featuring as part of a three women entourage for €˜Macho Man€™ Randy Savage. Not deterred the WCW brain trust thought it would be a good idea to put its once prestigious Cruiserweight Championship on Madusa. The way she would capture the Championship was ludicrous even by professional wrestling standards. The man she would defeat, Evan Karagias just happened to be Madusa€™s onscreen boyfriend. Inexplicably the couple would be pitted against each other in a title match; possibly some strange form of couples€™ counselling? During the match Madusa would begin making out with Karagias and then mounted him. Clearly overcome by the PG-13 Dry Humping, Karagias accidently allowed his shoulders to touch the mat and get counted down. The first Championship victory by way of a simulated sex act, with ideas like this it€™s no wonder WCW went out of business.

3. Lenny Lane

In the words of Vince McMahon any publicity is good publicity. Turns out in the case of Lenny Lane this isn€™t always true. Predominantly on the losing end of WCW€™s Cruiserweight Scene, Lane would capture the division€™s Championship with a shocking upset over its kingpin Rey Mysterio Jr. After defending the Championship against such illustrious opponents as Shaggy from the Insane Clown Posse, Lane was stripped of the title and taken of television due to media backlash over his character. Alongside his tag team partner Lodi, Lane was portrayed as an ambiguous homosexual. In the most cliche way possible he would wear pink trunks and glitter whilst sporting pigtails; a lollipop completed the stereotype. This soon caught the attention of LGBT communities who not being able to separate fiction from reality determined that the characters inspired homophobic behaviour among fans. As an apology Turner Broadcasting and WCW took the pair off television. Lane would not even appear to drop the Cruiserweight Championship, instead it was awarded to Psychosis via a statement on the company website. Showing just how genuine their apology was when Lane and Lodi returned WCW renamed them 'Standards and Practices', a group solely designed to mock the executives who took the duo off air - a variation of the WWE€™s €˜Right To Censor€™ faction in you will. Four years later history would repeat itself in the WWE. The tag team of Billy Gunn and Chuck Palumbo portrayed basically the same characters and were met with the same backlash. As you would imagine Vince McMahon€™s apology was just as disingenuous as WCW€™s.

2. Hornswoggle

After the Chavo Classic and Jaqueline debacles, the WWE Cruiserweight Championship eventually found its way back into the arms of Chavo Guerrero and slowly but surely the division started to regain some much needed momentum. Sure the division would never reach the heights of its WCW glory days, but thanks to some notable efforts by Chavo and other under-heralded talents such as Paul London, Psychosis and Kid Kash the division started to make steady progress. Unfortunately any progress made came to a screeching halt when Hornswoggle captured the Championship at the Great American Bash 2007. Hornswoggle won the title as a part of a six-man Cruiserweight Open. He surprised everyone by climbing out from under the ring and pinning Jamie Noble.. This turned out to be the final nail in the coffin for the Cruiserweight Division. On September 25, 2007 SmackDown general manager Vickie Guerrero stripped him of the title because of his status as Vince McMahon€™s illegitimate son (remember that one?) The WWE Cruiserweight Championship was officially retired in 2008 when WWE removed it from its list of active titles. Between Leprechauns, Dry Humping and Homophobia it€™s probably for the best.

1. Oklahoma

Oklahoma was not the just the worst champion in Cruiserweight history but one of the most tasteless characters of all time. Played by Ed Ferrera and orchestrated by Vince Russo, the character only served as a way for the former WWE writers to take shots at their former co-worker Jim Ross. After being hired by the WWE in 1994 the pair soon found themselves as key members of the creative team. For a short period of time their ideas were successful in fact Russo has been credited as the mastermind behind some of the Attitude Era€™s finest moments. The magic however wouldn€™t last and by 1999 both Ferrara and Russo would find themselves without a job. In hopes of saving their sinking ship WCW hired the pair. Unfortunately without Vince McMahon around as a filter this plan turned out to be a disaster. Instead of building new stars and creating interesting story-lines the pair decided to take up valuable TV time trying to get themselves over; Russo at one point even ended up holding the WCW World Heavyweight Championship. With WCW and WWE involved in a bitter ratings war, the two wrestling powerhouses would often take snide digs at each other. The Oklahoma creation was the only one that was needlessly underhanded, even going as far as mocking Jim Ross€™s real life disability €“ Bell€™s Palsy. Oklahoma won the WCW Cruiserweight Championship at the 2000 edition of WCW€™s Souled Out from Madusa. In an exercise of utter pointless he would be stripped of the title three days later for being overweight. Once the home of the greatest Cruiserweights on the planet, WCW would be bought out just a year later