10 Worst First Days For WWE Champions
To the winner goes the spoils. Or should that be spoiled? WWE's worst firsts, revisited...
The thing about winning a massive shiny belt in professional wrestling is that - for better and worse - it is the accepted way of showing everybody that you are the best at it.
For those fans that absorb the action as 100% real, it's the symbol of elite-tier excellence for a babyface or being the most effective rule-breaker as a heel. A trophy that goes around your waist so you don't have to lug it everywhere but can still show it off. For those that enjoy the business side of the business, it's the sign to a talent from a booker or promoter that the wrestler can be trusted as the front face of the organisation, no matter what that responsibility entails.
Drawing houses, selling merchandise, managing the interview circuit well or simply getting the best numbers on a tweet. It can all count, and as the standard bearer, it usually all will.
A champion can be expected to carry more than just their belt, basically. If you're not the sort of person that thrives off pressure, this already sounds a little bit nightmarish. But wrestlers are built differently to mere mortals, and the risks they take on a nightly basis must presumably make all of this seem the best dragon to chase.
Imagine then, when living that oddly specific and seemingly unattainable dream becomes a nightmare in less than 24 hours...
10. Chris Jericho
Few first days/first hours/first minutes stories are as bad as the ones told by Chris Jericho about maiden trip to the promised land.
His tale is littered with misery and detritus that it's best left to the man himself to describe, as he did to Viktre.com (and, then later, in several interviews and podcasts) in 2017. From catering jokes at his expense to an empty locker room and a cacophony of hotel catastrophes, it's a real treat, He said;
“I came back through the curtain, everyone was gone because when you’re on last everybody leaves to get out of the traffic quicker. Sat there by myself and then drove to a hotel where room service stopped at midnight, it was 11:58. They wouldn’t serve it, so I got pizza. They wouldn’t bring it to my room, so I had to go down to the lobby to get it. When I went back up, I was locked out. Went back down to the lobby, the guy wouldn’t let me in even though I just checked in a few minutes earlier. Dropped the pizza on the floor when he finally did let me in. So, I spent the night being the first undisputed champion eating cold, fuzzy pizza in a Ramada Inn somewhere in Anaheim, California."
9. Seth Rollins
Seth Rollins' 2016 return from a lengthy injury layoff came with the carefully marketed slogan "Redesign. Rebuild. Reclaim".
In a navel-gazing Network piece on his comeback, Rollins explained how connected he felt to the ethos, noting the scale of the surgery and rehabilitation, right the way through to eventually getting back what had been taken away from him along the way in the form of the WWE Championship.
He managed it fairly quickly, too. Though devastated to miss WrestleMania 32 in April, he was able to make it for Extreme Rules in May to set up a blockbuster main event against Roman Reigns at Money In The Bank the following month. On the night, he got the job done against a 'Big Dog' set to serve a suspension, but forgot all about the titular match earlier on the card.
Longstanding rival/former partner Dean Ambrose ambushed him with the Money In The Bank briefcase and cashed in, completing the trifecta of Shield WWE Champions in a matter of seconds. 'The Architect' had to wait nearly three full years without the gold before building himself back up to where he'd been before.
8. Dolph Ziggler
It's one thing to have your first Championship reign instantly terminated by something like a Money In The Bank cash-in (and more on that elsewhere in this list) or chalked off entirely due to some other brand of pro wrestling nonsense, but Dolph Ziggler's first win exists in a strange hinterland between two.
Recycling an old and slightly laboured idea, Vickie Guerrero awarded him Edge's World Heavyweight Championship after 'The Rated-R Superstar' used his Spear in direct opposition of a blanket ban. He was stripped and fired, with Ziggler benefitting on both counts.
As a stand-in authority figure for Teddy Long, it looked like the plan had worked too. All until the man himself returned from a secret attack by Ziggler and re-assumed control of the blue brand. Long booked an immediate rematch with Edge, and 'The Show Off' was without the title just 10 minutes after strapping it around his waist.
7. Drew McIntyre
WrestleMania 36, all things considered, was quite the creative success story.
The ethics of it could be debated for days and the standard of expectation was set way, way too high for the wrestlers within that wretched Performance Center atmosphere as a result, but WWE actually served its consumers a night of escapist entertainment in the dark days of April 2020. A fleeting moment of something to savour.
Unless you were Drew McIntyre.
Forever immortalised as WWE's newest made man during an unfathomable time, the coronation was the hollowest of any in WrestleMania history, and the disappointed new titleholder had to defend the belt straight after! Due to the company's need to film everything before a brief Florida shutdown, The Big Show was drafted in for a title match that could air on Raw the night after. McIntyre looked every bit of a guy making the best of a bad situation, but "best" had never been so tempered and "bad situation" had never been such an understatement.
It was a clunky, pandemic-y start to life on top for 'The Scottish Warrior', though it would at least become a crucial part of his character's lore in the years that followed.
6. Daniel Bryan
Only Daniel Bryan could make something so surprising to outsiders seem so completely logical when explained in context, and that's what happened when he revealed how little affection he had for memories of his iconic WrestleMania 30 victory compared to an evocative defeat five years later.
Comparing his contrasting emotions between New Orleans and New Jersey whilst speaking on My Mom's Basement, Bryan said;
“My favorite match in my WWE career is my match with Kofi at WrestleMania 35. It’s so special and such a cool moment. One of the things that I love is it’s Kofi winning at the end. WrestleMania 30, my shoulder is horrible, I hurt my neck, I have this horrible pain down my arm and I have to get up and do media the next morning. Everyone comes up to you and are like ‘congratulations.’ There’s a lot of responsibility. When I wrestled Kofi, everyone goes to Kofi and says congratulations to him. I get to have my moment with him and be like ‘Hey man, thanks. That was awesome.’ Then, I get to hug my wife and daughter and go home the next day. Kofi is the one who has to do media and deal with people congratulating him.”
Like one of his exceptional matches, this was sweet, smart and served as a reminder of just how demanding the industry can be.
5. Roman Reigns
Whatever WWE had attempted to create with the closing shots from Survivor Series 2015 had failed. Roman Reigns didn't look sympathetic as bits of his celebratory confetti rained down from the ceiling following his first WWE Championship win. He looked pitiful as they attached themselves to his sweat-soaked grimace following a loss to Sheamus just minutes later.
'The Big Dog' had been neutered by a careful Triple H plan, and all in the hope that fans would feel the way they did for other wronged parties that had suffered similar fates in the past.
Instead, people simply laughed at Reigns' desperate plight, and considered him foolish for not considering the reality of a briefcase-holder stepping in and taking a shot.
He'd win it back soon enough (and then again, for the third time rather than the first in another failed WrestleMania main event), but yet more damage was done to the character in what many consider its worst ever year.
4. Randy Orton
Pretty much the worst way to turn babyface is by having your heel friends turn on you, but that's what happened to Randy Orton just 24 hours after he was strapped up as the youngest Champion in WWE history.
His fairly unremarkable victory over Chris Benoit at SummerSlam a night earlier should have foreshadowed how long we'd all have to put up with "technically sound" and "methodically paced" Randy Orton matches over the years, but instead it was given a generous pass because at least somebody brand new was being given a shot. It just took a day or so to see that he was actually being taken out back like an old horse to receive it.
The turn and title reign went horribly for the 'Legend Killer' after that. Wholly detestable by his very nature, the babyface switch wouldn't have taken even the booking was good. And it decidedly wasn't - Orton ran away from Triple H and the lads for three weeks then lost the belt to him at the very next pay-per-view.
3. CM Punk
The conclusion of CM Punk's WWE Championship match with John Cena didn't mark the first time 'The Straight Edge Superstar' had lifted the company's richest prize, nor was it particularly bleak because of the Money In The Bank cash-in that followed. But trust WWE to end a match determine an "undisputed" Champion with a finish and follow-through that could be disputed for months by about six different claimants.
Beating Cena inside Chicago's molten Allstate Arena the prior month had been the real moment that capitalised on Punk's epic "Pipe Bomb" promo. An intentionally unclear finish in a diluted rematch at the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer' felt entirely as though WWE had taken back complete control of the wheel. Especially when Kevin Nash bulldozed through him and opened the door for an Alberto Del Rio smash-and-grab.
Losing the title wasn't what made any of this the worst first day. But when Punk lost his grip on the angle that could have changed everything, we all lost out.
2. Rey Mysterio
Rey Mysterio being the wrestler chosen for this rather strange role in 2011 remains one of the more perplexing booking decisions in WWE history, and that includes unearthing Big Sexy himself of all people for a payoff down the road.
To recap, before the aforementioned SummerSlam atrocity, CM Punk had brought shame on WWE or John Cena or whatever Vince McMahon deemed most believable with his win at Money In The Bank. No longer under contract in kayfabe, he was thus also not WWE Champion, regardless of how the fans felt.
Told to just get on with their business as if everything was normal, the top wrestlers on Monday Night Raw were lumped into a tournament to become Champion, eventually won by Mysterio. A fresh Cena - despite being the great shamer in all of this - got a shot at the knackered opponent, and won! He'd barely held the belt aloft before Punk returned anyway, dropping an asterisk next to Cena and Rey's name for eternity anyway.
1. Batista
After such a long time removed from the very top of the card, it had been a long hard road back to the WWE Championship for Dave Batista when he finally defeated Randy Orton for it at Extreme Rules 2009, but 'The Animal's dream was yet again cut short by injury.
Big Dave had torn his bicep in the Steel Cage clash with Randy Orton one night prior, and thus barely appeared on screen with the belt before he was beaten down and hospitalised by 'The Viper's Legacy stablemates Cody Rhodes and Ted Dibiase. Orton attempted to declare himself Champion, but an attack by a returning Triple H resulted in both being added to a fatal Four Way match with John Cena and The Big Show weeks later for the now-vacant prize.
Stripped of the gold as he was being strapped to a gurney, Batista returned later that year full of significant sick-of-this-sh*t energy. Getting revenge on Randy Orton before moving to SmackDown, the former Champion violently turned on former friend Rey Mysterio after yet another attempt to recapture gold went awry.