10 Worst Matches In Extreme Rules History
Extremely disappointing...
Though Extreme Rules hasn't been a part of WWE's pay-per-view calendar for as long as some of the company's other events, it's become a mainstay of the schedule since 2009. Every year in the months following WrestleMania, the stars of WWE clash (often in rematches from the show of shows) in bouts with thrilling stipulations.
In fact, even though the company saves its most attractive matches for 'Mania, there has been no shortage of classic bouts at Extreme Rules. In 2012, Brock Lesnar returned to WWE and took on John Cena in one of the most brutal contests in company history. In 2014, Evolution reformed to take on The Shield in a thrilling brawl. Just last year, the show boasted twin classics in the form of Roman Reigns versus AJ Styles and The Miz defending the Intercontinental Title in a four-way match.
However, there's also the other side of the coin - matches that have been terrible, or ones which have devalued the stipulations they bore. Thankfully, most of these matches have been on the undercard, allowing Extreme Rules as a whole to keep a rather strong reputation. Still, they're far from forgotten.
10. Dean Ambrose Vs. Chris Jericho - 2016
These days, it's a lot to ask that a WWE feud feature world-class talent and be well plotted. That's why it wasn't much of a surprise when the 2016 program between Dean Ambrose and Chris Jericho set up the pair as rival talk show hosts and involved a potted plant named Mitch. Still, the blowoff match would be great, right?
Not quite. The two clashed at Extreme Rules in the first (and only) Asylum Match, which featured a steel cage with no door and several weapons suspended above the top. During the course of the way-too-long match, each and every weapon came into play, including a mop and another plant.
That was basically all that went on for 26 minutes - slow cage climbing and comical weapons usage. At the end, a pile of thumbtacks was introduced to the match, and both guys did some exciting teases before Jericho took a bump in the pile. Still, it wasn't enough to offset a boring 20+ minutes that was anything but extreme.
9. The Big Show And Kane Vs. Ezekiel Jackson And Wade Barrett - 2011
One of the most forgettable matches in WrestleMania history took place at the 2011 event, when the infamous "Corre" stable teamed up to take on Kane, The Big Show, Kofi Kingston, and Santino Marella. The bout lasted less than two minutes and saw the good guys win, but WWE still decided to continue the program.
After WrestleMania, Kane and Show won the Tag Team Titles from Corre members Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel, setting them up for a battle at Extreme Rules with fellow members Ezekiel Jackson and Wade Barrett.
This match, much like the WrestleMania match, was a rush job - it was only allotted four minutes. Also much like the WrestleMania match, it was terrible. It was a Lumberjack Match, which allowed the faces to dominate the heels without any place for them to go. Eventually, Jackson took Big Show down, but Barrett tagged himself in and was chokeslammed for the loss.
8. Dean Ambrose Vs. Luke Harper - 2015
There's no reason that a match between Luke Harper and Dean Ambrose - who, in 2015, were both among WWE's most talented midcard stars - should be bad, but their bout at Extreme Rules two years ago fell victim to WWE's patented cutesy overbooking.
The Chicago Street Fight should have been an opportunity for the two hardcore fighters to really let loose and do what they wanted, but the unique rule set afforded too much latitude. Ambrose and Harper brawled to the back of the arena, eventually reaching the parking garage. At that point, Harper jumped into a car, so Ambrose got into the passenger seat and the two sped off. Still, there were no countouts, so the match technically continued.
Two more matches took place, then during a backstage interview with The New Day, Harper and Ambrose arrived back at the arena. Still fighting, they brawled back to the ring, where Ambrose hit Harper with Dirty Deeds for the win. It must have sounded like a good idea on paper.
7. John Cena Vs. Bray Wyatt - 2014
Bray Wyatt's 2014 feud with John Cena was the first time that 'The Eater of Worlds' was exposed as not being a main-event player, at least in the eyes of WWE management. He suffered his first loss at WrestleMania XXX, and was literally buried by Cena in a Last Man Standing match at Payback.
Perhaps the most damning part of the feud, though, came with Wyatt's sole win over Cena, which took place in a steel cage match at Extreme Rules. The bout was long, boring, and riddled with interference, but fans don't remember that - what they do remember is the absurd finish.
Cena had just hit a legdrop on Luke Harper and was heading for the cage door when the lights went out. When they came back on, a young boy was standing by the door, and began to sing "He's Got the Whole World in His Hands." This so unnerved Cena that he stopped in his tracks, allowing Wyatt to hit him with Sister Abigail and escape the cage.
This was the first appearance of "Deus Ex Machina" Wyatt, who used magic tricks to completely dictate the outcomes of matches - but for some reason, didn't do it enough to actually have a winning record.
6. Beth Phoenix Vs. Michelle McCool - 2010
For much of the late 2000s, Beth Phoenix and Michelle McCool were the top women on Raw and SmackDown respectively. Unfortunately, that's where the comparisons ended - while Phoenix was a top-notch talent who played her character convincingly, McCool was lacking in the ring and annoying in a non-beneficial way.
Once Phoenix was traded to SmackDown, she turned face and started feuding with Women's Champion McCool, which meant that she was also feuding with McCool's "LayCool" partner Layla, and SmackDown GM Vickie Guerrero. Phoenix earned a title match, and when LayCool attacked her with an ironing board and lipstick, it became an "Extreme Makeover" bout.
All that meant, basically, were that the ring was scattered with weapons that had to do with makeovers and housekeeping, ensuring that the women's division of the time was still a joke. After six minutes of nonsense, Phoenix pinned McCool to win the title - but she would soon suffer a knee injury and lose the belt to Layla.
5. Cody Rhodes Vs. The Big Show - 2012
Heading into WrestleMania XXVIII, Cody Rhodes repeatedly got under The Big Show's skin by reminding the world's largest athlete that in his long WWE career, he had never had a WrestleMania moment. To hammer the point home, Rhodes showed footage of Show being eliminated first in the main event of WrestleMania 2000, losing a sumo challenge to Akebono at WrestleMania 21, and hosting WrestleMania X-8 at WWE New York.
Naturally, that meant that Show beat Cody at WrestleMania, pinning him to win the Intercontinental Title. Of course, Cody was owed a rematch, and the two clashed once more at Extreme Rules in a tables match.
In a reversal of how things are usually done, the rematch got even less time than the WrestleMania match. After four-and-a-half minutes passed without note, Cody dropkicked Show off the apron, forcing the champion to take a step back, right through a table. Though only his foot broke the wood, the match was over and Cody had regained the title.
Just to prove that nothing that had happened mattered, an angry Big Show tossed Cody through a ringside table following the bout.
4. Layla Vs. Nikki Bella - 2012
Just days before Extreme Rules 2012, Nikki Bella defeated Beth Phoenix to win the WWE Divas' Championship. Naturally, a rematch was signed for the pay-per-view, but it was cancelled when Phoenix was said to have been suffering from a (kayfabe) ankle injury. Instead, Bella would defend the title against a mystery opponent.
The mystery opponent was none other than Layla, who had been out of action for almost a year after suffering a legitimate knee injury. Though this was meant to be a triumphant comeback for the former Women's Champion, the match itself was a mess.
Layla started off with some armdrags, but Bella targeted the leg of the returning challenger. After a couple of minutes of "action", Brie switched places with her sister to try and pull a fast one on Layla, but the challenger hit a neckbreaker on Brie and pinned her, becoming the new Divas' Champion. Despite the attempt at a feel-good moment, the bout was terrible and the finish felt open-ended.
3. Tag Team Gauntlet Match - 2010
At Extreme Rules 2010, Tag Team Champions ShoMiz complained about not having an opponent and were thrown into a Gauntlet Match against three other teams - with the winner getting a shot at the titles. That meant that there were three matches in a row, and all three ended up getting less than six minutes.
First up, ShoMiz faced John Morrison and R-Truth, which the champs won when Morrison got disqualified. Next up was the team of Mark Henry and MVP, and this time, Miz pinned MVP. Finally, The Hart Dynasty challenged the champs (with the advantage of still being fresh) and beat them to win an utterly nonsensical bout - or series.
2. Michael Cole And Jack Swagger Vs. Jim Ross And Jerry Lawler - 2011
Though it's easy to fall into the trap of hyperbole, there's no exaggeration in the statement that Michael Cole's heel turn and subsequent feud with Jerry Lawler made for one of the worst WWE storylines of all time. The two eventually met at WrestleMania XXVII in a horrendous match that saw Cole win by DQ, but of course, it wasn't over.
At Extreme Rules 2011, the two met again in a tag team contest - Cole was paired up with his "coach," Jack Swagger, while Lawler partnered with his erstwhile broadcast colleague, Jim Ross. Needless to say, this was a bit of a mismatch, but the heels actually got the heat on Lawler during this glacially paced "Country Whipping" match. Eventually, he made the hot tag to Jim Ross, who cleared house.
Ross locked Cole in the Ankle Lock until Swagger broke it up, but then the announcer gave 'The All-American American' a low blow with a leather strap. In the chaos, though, Cole rolled up Ross, pinning him and leaving nothing resolved.
1. Santina Marella Vs. Vickie Guerrero And Chavo Guerrero - 2009
When it comes to stipulations, the good ones enhance the drama and pressure of a match while allowing the competitors to do their best work - that's why the good ones are few and far between. As for bad ones, though, the sky is pretty much the limit - whatever you can think of can be made into a match that can bore an audience to tears.
It's even worse if the workers involved are terrible - or aren't even workers. That was the case at the inaugural Extreme Rules show, when "Santina" Marella defended the Miss WrestleMania crown against Vickie Guerrero... in a hog pen match. Chavo Guerrero was on a team with his aunt to actually do the dirty work, but everybody got dirty.
Basically, Marella and Chavo rolled around in the mud for a couple of minutes, then when Vickie got involved, she was pinned. The live crowd didn't care about any of it, there were actual piglets (which was by far the best part of the match), and it was full of the kind of "comedy" that Vince McMahon and nobody else finds funny.
Thankfully, the show is better remembered for Jeff Hardy beating Edge for the World Heavyweight Title, then losing it to CM Punk on a Money in the Bank cash-in. We've all blocked the hog pen match out of our memories.