Last Sunday's Hell in a Cell PPV saw a particularly bizarre ending which has already divided fan opinion. The main event between Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose concluded with the appearance of a lantern in the middle of the ring, from which a ghostly figure emerged. This was followed by an interference from Bray Wyatt - perhaps marking another main event push for the cult leader - which allowed Rollins to grab the cheap win. Some saw the ghostly special effects as a compelling part of wrestling's usual spectacle and outlandishness, while others were unable to look beyond the fairly unconvincing holographic image and take it seriously. Many have declared it the poorest Pay Per View ending in years, although when compared with other (more universally panned) main events, it doesn't quite stand up alongside some of the very worst in WWE history. Usually the result of poor booking - although often hindered by shoddy in-ring action as well - disastrous PPV endings can drag even the best of undercards down with them. In the same way a good main event can put an unexpected sheen on a lacklustre show, a stinker at the top of the bill is probably going to sour the memory of an otherwise fantastic Pay Per View. From simple cases of the wrong man going over to horrible convoluted finishes, each of the following PPVs ended on an unquestionable down-note. Some seemed innocuous enough at the time and are now regarded as appalling, while the negative impact of others were felt instantaneously. The range across which such terrible endings can be found is a rather disheartening one. This means the next legendarily bad main event could be right around the corner - an unsettling prospect.
10. The Rock Vs Triple H - Judgement Day 2000
The WWF seemed to be onto something good in the spring of 2000. Austin was still recovering from neck surgery but The Rock was at the height of his popularity, his main event feud with Triple H really hitting its stride. Unfortunately, they killed a great deal of momentum with this awful misstep at Judgement Day. A sixty minute Iron Man match will always test the patience of the fans, but both men struggled admirably through a difficult situation. The major problem arose, however, as the clock began to tick through its final seconds. With the score tied at 5-5, and The Rock needing only a draw to retain his WWF Championship, an unfamiliar piece of entrance music hit the speakers - Kid Rock's 'American Badass'. Yes, that's right. The Undertaker, débuting his disastrous new biker gimmick after eight months on the shelf, roared to the ring and attacked the various members of Vince McMahon's stable dotted around ringside. After swiftly dealing with Road Dogg, X-Pac, Shane and Vince, he decimated Triple H with a thunderous chokeslam...thereby awarding him a fall by DQ and allowing him to win the match (and the title) with a score of 6-5. He should probably have taken into account the fact that the special guest referee was Shawn Michaels. This finish did nothing for anybody. It killed Taker's big return and made him look like an idiot from the very start, The Rock lost his title and had his momentum slowed, and Triple H was seen as snatching a fluke victory. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OzCSQR4C-qc
9. Extreme Elimination Chamber - December To Dismember
Widely regarded as a disaster from top to bottom, the ECW-brand exclusive December to Dismember is often cited as one of the worst wrestling Pay Per Views of all time. History could well have looked back on it with kinder eyes had the main event delivered, but it unquestionably failed to do so and helped seal the event's fate. The main flaw in this match wasn't even the concept (although that was slightly over the top), it was the booking. The crowd were utterly molten for Rob Van Dam to win back the ECW Championship, although CM Punk was enjoying quite a lot of support as the hot young babyface on the scene. Punk and RVD were eliminated first and third respectively, with Hardcore Holly falling in between, leaving the unconvincing trio of Test, Big Show, and Bobby Lashley to carry the rest of the match. The crowd were understandably deflated, even chanting "we want refunds" at one point, and completely ruined Lashley's first title win. Their frustration was justified - despite some cool spots (mainly carried out by RVD) the match wasn't a classic. Big Show was billed as having the most dangerous weapon within his chamber pod, a barbed wire baseball bat, and used it once. He missed his target and embedded it in the cage wall. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzGAc0QWv1U
8. The Undertaker Vs The Dudley Boyz - Great American Bash 2004
This entry was met with a mixture of horror and ridicule when it occurred, but everybody was united in condemning it as a bad PPV ending. The match itself was poor, with Undertaker dominating both tag team champions and defeating them pretty easily. This wasn't exactly a huge surprise - Taker sadly has a history of squashing supposedly strong opponents - but it still contributed to the shoddy nature of the PPV. The main point of contention was the match's ludicrous stipulation. Paul Bearer was at ringside trapped in a slowly-filling vat of cement. A delighted Bearer saw his charge win the bout and approach the chamber to set him free...only for Undertaker to declare that there was nothing he could do and pull the fatal lever himself, ostensibly killing his manager. The WWE quickly clarified that Bearer wasn't actually dead, the kayfabe explanation being that he was rescued from the cement and rushed to hospital, but the event could be seen as terrifying and disturbing - especially for younger fans. Others found it simply ludicrous, an unnecessary throwback to the days of the Ministry and it's cheesy, Halloweenish shenanigans. Either way, it certainly had no place in the main event of a WWE Pay Per View and was rightly criticised from all angles. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Dl4CEPkDJA
7. CM Punk Vs Alberto Del Rio - SummerSlam 2011
Some PPV finishes are far worse in hindsight than they were at the time. The finale of SummerSlam 2011 featured Alberto Del Rio cashing in his Money in the Bank contract on CM Punk - the champ heavily weakened by a match with John Cena and a run-in from Kevin Nash, of all people. The finish was pretty poor, especially on the tails of a needlessly controversial finish in which Cena stuck a limb under the bottom rope to cast doubt on Punk's raucously received victory. However, this moment is now seen as the moment in which the Summer of Punk lost momentum. Up until then, the Straight Edge Superstar's meteoric rise to the very top of the wrestling world seemed a beacon of change - a new exciting era of wrestling was upon us. The bizarre image of Kevin Nash shuffling through the crowd and into the ring quickly dashed those hopes, as he not only helped end Punk's title reign, but dragged the Best In The World from the top of the card into a frustrating feud with himself and Triple H. It's frustrating to think what the wrestling landscape could look like nowadays, had WWE stuck to the formula which made Money in the Bank 2011 such a monumental PPV. Instead, by refusing to place too much faith in the newer generation of stars, they set themselves back a good number of years - and brought Kevin Nash back to our television screens. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P83RtRxBjsM
6. Bam Bam Bigelow Vs Lawrence Taylor - WrestleMania 11
Remember Big Show vs Floyd Mayweather at WrestleMania 24? That was a decent celebrity match, certainly nothing offensive. Both men worked to mask the non-wrestler's obvious limitations and Floyd turned in a surprisingly good performance. Now imagine that this match was the main event of the whole show. And Mayweather went over clean. You've got Lawrence Taylor vs Bam Bam Bigelow at WrestleMania 11. NFL star Taylor began a feud with Bigelow after a scuffle at the Royal Rumble, in which Bam Bam shoved LT in his ringside seat. Amazingly, and perhaps showing the insecurity of a company unwilling to move on from the glitzy Hogan era, the rivalry resulted in a headlining match at WrestleMania. Although celebrities have always been involved with 'Mania, this was - and still is - and unprecedented move for the WWE. The match wasn't the best - although Taylor proved able enough to prevent a complete disaster - but the finish was ridiculous, with LT pinning a recognised wrestler clean after a forearm smash from the second rope. This one is curiously brushed over in discussions about the worst WrestleMania main events of all time. Perhaps people misremember Michaels vs Diesel as the last match of the night, or maybe the relatively excited reaction has painted it in a more generous light. Either way, the fact remains that a non-wrestling celebrity headlined the biggest show of the year and neutered an established threat by beating him clean as a whistle. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x65lzr_wrestlemania-xi-lawrence-taylor-vs_sport
5. Triple H Vs The Rock Vs Mick Foley Vs Big Show - WrestleMania 16
This match could have avoided a place on the list but for two key factors: overcomplication and ego. The obvious marquee bout would have been WWF Champion Triple H facing Royal Rumble winner The Rock, presumably with the hot babyface going over for a feel-good ending. Instead, the booking team decided to shove Big Show and Mick Foley (who had supposedly been retired by losing to Triple H at the previous month's PPV) into proceedings. The match itself was decent, but the addition of a McMahon in each wrestler's corner was a brainless, egotistical decision. Particularly bemusing was the alliance between The Rock and Vince McMahon, which turned out to be all a ruse as Vince turned on his superstar and helped Triple H retain his title. Happy endings are a pretty accepted inevitability at WrestleMania, with the crowd favourite going over in the main event far more often than not. This decision to have the bad guy win to send everybody home was never a recipe for success, especially with the overarching idea that Vince is the smartest man in the company forced down the fans' throats.
4. The Miz Vs John Cena - WrestleMania 27
Immediately noticeable is the fact that nothing about this match screams "WrestleMania main event". If anything, it seems the the headline match of a filler PPV sometime between SummerSlam and the Royal Rumble. This match did top the bill at the biggest show of the year however, and thoroughly disappointed everybody in the process. In fairness to The Miz, he showed great dedication and charisma during his push to the top of the card. The problem wasn't with his performance, or indeed that of Cena's. It was the decision of the WWE to reduce WrestleMania 27 to a mere preview of WrestleMania 28. Cena clotheslined The Miz over the crowd barrier quarter of an hour into the match, resulting in a double countout to the fury of the crowd. Luckily the Rock - billed as the "host" of WrestleMania - came out to restart the contest, but things weren't about to improve. Cena immediately went for the AA, only for Rocky to blindside the challenger with a Rock Bottom. Miz made the easy pinfall, and the crowd were left to deal with one of the cheapest endings in Pay Per View history. Imagine paying through the nose for a ticket to 'Mania, only to find out that the main event is nothing more than a glorified stepping stone for Rock vs Cena the following year. The "winner" of the match received no benefit either, slipping back into the sludgy midcard shortly after. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZIerzJeMq6U
3. Bret Hart Vs Shawn Michaels - Survivor Series 1997
Everybody has their own opinions on this story, and the backstage politics are far too complicated to properly explore here in any detail, but in any case - the main event of 1997's Survivor Series was met with widespread disapproval. In what is now known as the Montreal Screwjob, Vince McMahon ordered the bell to be rung - causing Bret Hart to lose his WWF Championship to Shawn Michaels - despite the fact that Hart hadn't tapped out to the HBK's sharpshooter. It differed from the countless cheap finishes throughout wrestling history due to one crucial fact: it was completely real. Vince, Shawn, and a host of backstage accomplices conspired against Hart to rob him of the title in his home nation of Canada. The reasons behind this decision are tangled, but all essentially amount to the fact that Bret was jumping ship to WCW and Vince didn't want to risk him refusing to drop the championship before leaving. The outrage sparked by this incident is still felt to this day, but was especially explosive back when it happened. Just watch the front row of the crowd as the bell rings - they immediately jump to their feet in outrage and confusion. The match's aftermath is just as hectic, with Hart spitting down over the top rope onto Vince and HBK feigning innocence. Although ultimately creating an exciting narrative which we can look back on and enjoy for its controversy, the climax of this PPV must be ranked as one of the worst ever for its utter lack of honour and professionalism. It remains one of the most infamous incidents in professional wrestling history.
2. Hulk Hogan Vs Sid Justice - WrestleMania 8
This is unquestionably the worst-executed of all the PPV endings on this list, but even had it gone off without a hitch, it would still have resulted in an unforgivable booking decision: a DQ finish in the main event of WrestleMania. In order to protect Sid, the biggest heel in the company, Hogan was booked to hit the legdrop and cover his opponent...only to be attacked by the interfering Papa Shango. This sounds a horrendous enough finish even at the best of times, but the actual turn of events was even worse. Shango utterly missed his cue to run-in, arriving far too late to prevent the pinfall from occurring. Sid was therefore forced to kick out of Hogan's legdrop (the first person to do this in WWF history) and the ref called off the match for no reason at all. Shango eventually hit the ring and attacked, but the heels were quickly ran off by the returning Ultimate Warrior - although in reality it was actually Hogan who did most of the fighting. The two mega-faces celebrated in the ring afterwards for an utterly underwhelmed audience, a sight made all the more ridiculous as sparks sprayed up from all four sides of the apron. The whole thing was an utter shambles and reduced the credibility of Shango and Hogan, the former left looking an ineffectual and hapless henchman, the latter a lucky escapee from the unbeatable Sid.
1. Bret Hart Vs Yokozuna - WrestleMania 9
Or, more specifically, Hulk Hogan vs Yokozuna. This is often cited as the worst example of Hogan's legendary selfishness, as he cajoled Vince McMahon into having him regain the WWF Championship at WrestleMania 9 - despite having absolutely no part in the billed main event. A win for Hart over the mountainous Yokozuna would have solidified him as a real fighting champion, and the next big star to carry the company forward through the 1990s. Instead, the heel won thanks to a handful of salt from his dastardly manager Mr Fuji, and Hogan dashed out to ringside to console Bret. Then, in one of the most inexplicable and far-fetched incidents in the history of WWE Pay Per Views, Fuji immediately issued a challenge on behalf of Yokozuna to Hogan. Not only did this make little sense in kayfabe terms, considering the legendary strength of Hogan and the fact that the new champ had already tired himself out in a match, it completely removed Bret from the equation. Of course Hogan won. Not only that, but he won at a ridiculous pace, pinning Yokozuna and winning the championship in twenty two seconds. It was a ludicrously short-sighted decision, one which did absolutely no favours for the future of the company. It also played a big part in the fact that WrestleMania 9 is often declared to be the worst ever, an opinion which would probably carry less weight had Bret kept the belt (especially given the shoddy nature of 'Manias 2 and 11 in particular). As it goes, this horrorshow of an ending makes such an accolade hard for this WrestleMania to shake off.