Aside from the build to WrestleMania, the most important part of the WWE calendar is the summer. Free of the need to organise a blockbusting 'Mania card, the creative team can take a few riskier decisions with their booking, often resulting in very original, inventive storylines. Unfortunately, sometimes this originality can come slightly too far out of left field, resulting in the sort of wacky, overly-convoluted angle that makes wrestling fans tear their hair out in frustration. In other instances, a single booking decision can ruin a once-promising angle, turning a promising summer of excitement into a few months of drawn-out torture. It's no surprise that summer angles have greater potential to go wrong, given their tendency to be slightly stranger than their 'Road To WrestleMania' counterparts. Everything from the Royal Rumble onwards is usually treat in an ultra-serious fashion, ensuring that 'Mania's main feuds are given a serious feel, fuelling the event's epic atmosphere. Summer angles, on the other hand, give Vince a chance to exercise his notorious sense of humour, and the bookers a chance to flex their creative muscles - often with disastrous consequences. Here are the worst ten summer storylines in WWE history, some ruined by a single misstep or poor booking decision, others doomed from the minute they were conceived.
Advertisement
10. The Summer Of Punk - 2011
The Summer of Punk is a strange one; it must certainly also be regarded as one of the best summer angles in WWE history, so groundbreaking was its beginning. CM Punk aired his real-life grievances in one of the greatest worked-shoot promos ever, threatened to win the WWE Championship and walk out of the company...and then did! The storyline drew mainstream attention to the promotion in a way not seen since the Attitude Era, while Punk was hailed as a hero by swathes of the WWE's audience, disgruntled fans tired of seeing the same few stars hold onto their positions at the top of the card. The booking team should have taken the storyline and ran with it all the way to WrestleMania, but it was dead in the water before the end of the summer and it bled into a lacklustre autumn of Punk. The first mistake was bringing Punk back too early. He returned after a week to challenge Cena, retained the title at SummerSlam...and was immediately jumped by Kevin Nash of all people. Nash's attack allowed Alberto Del Rio to successfully cash in his Money In The Bank contract, leaving Punk without his title and severely damaging his momentum. He lost his next PPV match to Triple H at Night of Champions, and went on to feud with John Laurinaitis of all people. What could have been...
9. The Nexus - 2010
Another angle with all the potential in the world, only to fall victim to horrendous booking decisions. On the June 7th edition of Raw, a stable of NXT stars made their debut during the main event between John Cena and CM Punk. Led by Wade Barrett, they leapt the crowd barrier and destroyed everybody, from the wrestlers to the referee to the ring announcer (an incident which saw Daniel Bryan temporarily fired, for uncomfortable parallels between his choking of Justin Roberts and Chris Benoit's Crossface). The Nexus were fresh, exciting and dominant. They interfered in the main event matches of Fatal 4 Way and Money In The Bank, and a title reign surely loomed for leader Wade Barrett. A 7-on7 match was booked for SummerSlam, pitting the Nexus against a WWE team. However, in a match the hot new stable should clearly have won, Cena overturned a climactic 2-on-1 situation with ease, pinning Justin Gabriel and submitting Barrett to become the match's sole survivor. That loss was the beginning of the end for the Nexus. Their momentum would never truly recover, and they quickly saw their subsequent schemes foiled by Cena at every turn. Eventually, Barrett lost a feud-ending TLC match in which Cena literally buried him under a mountain of chairs. The symbology was very apt.
8. The D-Generation X Reunion - 2006
The reformation of DX (as a two-man outfit of founding members Shawn Michaels and Triple H) in June 2006 was met with great initial enthusiasm. The pair cut "edgy" (as "edgy" as they could go in a post-attitude era, kid friendly promo requirements), impersonated Vince and Shane McMahon, spray painted their name on the boss' private jet, and foiled the Spirit Squad at every turn. It sounds like tremendous fun, but quickly became tedious. Back in the Attitude Era, DX legitimately pushed boundaries with their risque promos and infamous antics. Their 2006 incarnation seemed like a tame imitation, and their stunts quickly started to grate. Skits such as dumping foul-smelling waste on opponents can be fun once in a while, but shouldn't be the basis of an entire gimmick. Therein lay the other major flaw with the DX reunion. Cena's unstoppable rise had fuelled criticism of his inability to put over anybody else, preventing younger stars from establishing themselves. Michaels and Triple H were just as bad in this regard, if not moreso. They utterly crushed the Spirit Squad several times, a group containing future main-roster talents Dolph Ziggler and Kenny Dykstra, preventing fans from seeing their opponents as anything other than a joke. The return of DX may be one of the most divisive entires on this list. Many will fondly remember it as a feel-good summer angle of dominant babyface wins and nostalgia, but it took up a lot of television and Pay Per View time which could have been used to put over a few of the new generation.
7. Hogan vs Michaels - 2005
Recent allegations regarding Hulk Hogan aside, his mid-2000s return was another career blemish. After teasing a future match with Austin and helping out the wildly offensive babyface character Eugene, the Hulkster eventually settled into a feud with Shawn Michaels. The build to their dream match at SummerSlam was...interesting. Rather than booking a logical face vs face encounter, the WWE turned Shawn heel - despite his immense popularity since returning to the ring in 2002. This was apparently a demand of Hogan's - one which HBK didn't take too kindly to. Another rumoured plan was for the pair to have two matches over the course of the year, with Hogan winning one and Michaels the other. However, true to form, the Hulkster refused to lose a rematch, and the idea was scrapped. They instead faced off in a one-off encounter, which a disgruntled HBK mercilessly butchered. Michaels didn't ruin the bout by performing badly (it's doubtful whether he can have a bad wrestling match, even on purpose), but by over-selling to a ridiculous degree. He sold single punches by tumbling to the outside, sprang to his feet and ran around in a daze after a big boot, and generally prevented Hogan from being taken seriously.
6. Triple H's Dominance - 2003
The formation of Evolution wasn't a bad idea at all. It made the careers of two legitimate main-eventers who became huge stars of the modern era, brought Ric Flair back to relevance, and resulted in two memorable face turns - one terrible (Randy Orton) and one brilliant (Batista). It did, however, utterly ruin Raw's summer of 2003. The roster split saw the establishment of brand-specific Pay Per Views, and Raw's were consistently robbed of suspense and drama by one man: Triple H. When people talk today of The Game's inability to put anybody over other than himself, they're referring specifically to this era. For much of 2003/04, great swathes of Raw programming would be taken up by rambling Triple H promos, proclaiming himself the greatest wrestler ever, and ramming his dominance down the audience's throats. It went beyond effective heel work; fans weren't desperate to see him lose because they hated the character, they just wanted to see someone else get a chance. The summer of 2003 was dominated by Triple H. Flanked by Evolution, he defended his World Heavyweight Championship (a belt that was merely awarded to him by Eric Bischoff) against all-comers. He beat old friend Kevin Nash in an uninspiring Hell in a Cell match at Bad Blood, won the SummerSlam Elimination Chamber at the expense of molten fan favourites Goldberg and Shawn Michaels, and slowed the company's post-WrestleMania momentum to a crawl.
5. Lita And Kane's Pregnancy Angle - 2004
The Lita/Kane/Matt Hardy love triangle was one of the most ridiculous WWE angles of the 21st century, feeling less like a professional wrestling storyline and more like a B horror movie. The angle began with Kane repeatedly jumping Lita's onscreen (and real-life) boyfriend, Matt Hardy, in an attempt to seduce the redheaded diva. A short while later she cut a promo announcing that she was pregnant, and Matt came down to the ring to propose the following week. The pair were interrupted by Kane, who claimed that he was the father of Lita's unborn child - a fact later verified by a DNA test. He and Matt fought in a SummerSlam match under one of the most ridiculous stipulations ever: Lita would be obliged to marry the winner. The legal implications of this were brushed over without too much consideration. Kane won an underwhelming bout (in just six minutes), and wedded her on the following edition of Raw. Then, unbelievably, the storyline took an even more farfetched (and greatly offensive) turn. Relative newcomer Gene Snitsky accidentally caused a "miscarriage", striking Kane with a chair and causing him to fall on Lita. The pair put aside their considerable differences - like Lita being married against her will - to team up against the heel. This new feud would last the rest of the year until Kane finally defeated Snitsky at New Year's Revolution, but should never have seen the light of day in the first place.
4. Vince McMahon's Illegitimate Son - 2007
Few angles in the history of the WWE were as downright silly as the saga regarding Vince McMahon's "illegitimate son". The owner of the company seemed determined to feature heavily in 2007's summer angle, regardless of its content. Originally he faked his own death, a storyline which was quickly (and wisely) nixed after the Chris Benoit tragedy. Instead, WWE fans were treated to an even more excruciating saga with a terrible pay-off. Vince became the subject of a kayfabe paternity lawsuit, which revealed that a member of the WWE roster was his illegitimate son. Originally this was planned to be Mr. Kennedy, an up-and-coming superstar readied for a huge push. He fell victim to an untimely injury, which forced the company to scrabble for a replacement. On the September 10th edition of Raw, the son's identity was revealed. After teasing a reveal of the son as Triple H (which would have brought about some uncomfortable incest-based implications, given The Game's marriage to Stephanie McMahon), the mystery man was revealed to be none other than...Hornswoggle. The revelation was received extremely poorly, and led to a number of terrible skits between the "father and son" - including a horrendous mocking of Jim Ross' Bell's palsy - before it was retconned. Finlay was outed as the true rather, rendering the entire storyline pointless as well as awful.
3. King Mabel - 1995
Back in the 1990s, King of the Ring was a big deal. Then a relatively new concept, it was used to elevate present and future stars such as Bret and Owen Hart, Randy Savage and Ted DiBiase. However, in 1995, the WWF bafflingly booked Mabel to win the tournament. The man who would go on to become Viscera had debuted two years earlier as part of the Men On A Mission tag team, a pair of hulking, heavyset rappers. It was never a gimmick intended to propel either man to the top, but for whatever reason, the booking team decided that Mabel deserved a push. He defeated Savio Vega to win the crown, but more alarmingly, actually defeated the Undertaker en route to the final. Mabel became the company's top heel and lost a stinker of a championship match to Diesel at SummerSlam, before becoming a mere pawn in Davey Boy Smith's ill-advised heel turn a week later. He (and tag partner Mo) joined forces with Smith and Jim Cornette, attacking Diesel and apparently establishing a new villainous stable. This never came to pass, however, and Mabel's push was killed as quickly as it had begun. The reason for this was reportedly his unsafe working style; he'd actually injured Nash in their SummerSlam encounter with a horribly dangerous sitdown splash.
2. Hogan vs Zeus - 1989
The summer of 1989 was a hot one for wrestling; top star Hulk Hogan was riding a wave of momentum thanks to a fantastic feud with Randy Savage, culminating at WrestleMania V. An impending continuation of their rivalry was expected, or perhaps a new marquee match with another of the company's top heels at SummerSlam. Instead, fans were treated to Hogan vs Zeus. Zeus was a character from No Holds Barred, a WWF-financed movie released in June which saw Hogan star as Rip Thomas, a thinly-veiled fictional version of himself. Disgruntled at being billed underneath Hogan (and angry at losing the movie's climactic bout), Zeus showed up in the WWF to challenge him to a match. This would have been fine if Zeus had debuted in the form of Tom Lister (the actor who played him in No Holds Barred), but he actually appeared as his fictional self. The rivalry made no sense in kayfabe terms, with Hogan, a real man, facing off against a movie character. To make matters worse, Lister had very little professional wrestling experience of his own. The pair squared off in a tag match alongside respective partners Brutus Beefcake and Randy Savage, rendering the whole PPV a promotional tool for an already-released film. Needless to say, Hogan and Beefcake won.
1. The Invasion
The Invasion angle was one of the most exciting storylines in wrestling history. Fans had waited years to see their favourite WWF and WCW stars clash, and when Vince McMahon bought out his competition at the turn of the century, such fantasies were set to come true. The world was excited to see Austin vs Goldberg, Undertaker vs Sting and The Rock vs Booker T. Instead, they got a severely depleted invading force bolstered by key WWF figures Steve Austin and Kurt Angle, while 'Team WWF' handily dominated the vast majority of the war, despite constant infighting and the defection of the roster's various ex-ECW stars. Apparently WCW were originally planned to win the war, setting up their own TV show to rival Raw, and establishing an epic, long-term continuation of the Monday Night Wars. Instead, Vince McMahon allegedly didn't rate the competition upon their arrival. He failed to sign a number of key names including Hogan, Sting and Goldberg, and allowed his booking team to utterly bury potentially electrifying stars such as Diamond Dallas Page. Ultimately, many believe the angle to have failed because Vince couldn't bear to portray his company in a weak light - even if doing so would have proven wildly successful from a business (and entertainment) point of view. Technically the angle extended beyond the summer of 2001, culminating with an elimination match between the two sides at Survivor Series. In reality, however, the damage was already done. WCW were never built up as credible opposition, and predictably lost the supposedly climactic encounter.