10 Worst TNA Champions Ever

The worst of the worst.

By Scott Fried /

As hard as it is to believe, Total Nonstop Action has been around for almost 14 years. The company that started out as Jeff Jarrett's personal project after WCW closed has undergone many permutations and has experienced many ups and downs.

Advertisement

All said, there have been more downs than ups. Despite having a decent TV time slot for eight years, the company never got close to providing real competition for WWE. Many of the habits (and many of the exact same people) that doomed WCW to failure made TNA a mess, and parent company Panda Energy has lost many millions of dollars over the course of the promotion's history.

This list looks back at some of the low points over the past 14 years - the stars who were given the group's world championship but, for whatever reason, failed miserably. Some never got a proper chance, while others were the wrong people at the wrong time. These are the ten worst TNA Champions ever.

Just a note, before we start: technically, the history of the current TNA World Heavyweight Championship stretches back to 2007, when the belt was established following the removal of the rights to the NWA World Heavyweight Championship from the company. For the purposes of this article, I'm including NWA Champions from 2002 to 2007 so as to cover all of the heavyweight champions in the promotion's history.

10. Rob Van Dam

Rob Van Dam wasn't a terrible TNA Champion, but his title reign was an exemplar of a problem that plagued TNA since its existence - namely, the pushing of former WWE talent at the expense of the company's few homegrown stars. TNA gained a reputation as a home for WWE's castoffs, and decisions like this show it was well-founded.

Advertisement

AJ Styles, the greatest native star in TNA history, was champion when the company made the ill-advised decision to start airing Impact head-to-head with Raw on Monday evenings. Ratings tanked, and though the experiment was brief, TNA made one last-ditch effort to drum up interest before heading back to their own timeslot - a title change on free TV, with no prior buildup. On the March 30, 2010 episode of the show, Rob Van Dam beat Styles for the belt.

The move reeked of desperation, and ultimately did the company more harm than good. Though RVD reigned as champion for nearly five months and defended the title against a host of opponents, his reign was tainted by the EV 2.0 debacle (an ECW reunion in 2010 without any legal rights to the brand's trademarks), and it ended in inauspicious fashion - Van Dam was forced to vacate the championship after being beaten down by Abyss and Fourtune, an angle that was a cover for the fact that RVD was only contracted to work a certain number of dates per year and TNA was burning through them too quickly.

9. Ken Shamrock

To be fair, Ken Shamrock wasn't a terrible choice to be TNA's first champion. Yes, he was a former WWE star, but the fact that he had left that company (and pro wrestling) almost three years earlier and of his own volition made it seem like the fledgling promotion had pulled off a coup by snatching him up. For years, fans had wondered when Shamrock would come back, and now he had, competing for a brand-new organization.

Advertisement

TNA, which ran weekly Pay-Per-View events in its early days, headlined the first show with a Gauntlet for the Gold match (a Royal Rumble where the last two men have a standard bout) for the vacant NWA World Heavyweight Championship. Shamrock won the title, defeating Malice (WCW's The Wall) to capture the belt and give it some legitimacy straight from the outset.

Unfortunately, the rest of Shamrock's run didn't live up to his victory. He continued to feud with Malice for the next few weeks, but wasn't as committed to a pro wrestling return as fans had hoped. At TNA's eighth weekly PPV, Shamrock lost the title to Ron Killings (WWE's R-Truth), then disappeared from the company, despite having signed a one-year deal initially.

8. Eric Young

One of the most universally-acclaimed storylines in recent wrestling history was Daniel Bryan's rise to the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. Though the company (legitimately) didn't see him as a star, fan reaction meant that he had to be pushed to the top spot. At WrestleMania XXX, he defeated Triple H to earn a slot in the main event, then - with an injured shoulder - defeated Randy Orton and Batista to win the title.

Advertisement

TNA saw how successful Bryan's ascent was, and they decided to completely rip it off. Just days after WrestleMania XXX, Young - who had been sporting a Bryan-esque beard - won a battle royal on Impact to earn the right to challenge Magnus for the TNA Championship. With an injured shoulder of his own, Young pulled off the upset and became the champ.

Needless to say, the returns were not the same. Young had been a midcarder for his TNA career, and while Bryan had suffered in the pecking order at times, he was also widely recognized as the best wrestler in the world. Young simply came off as a guy benefiting from creative bankruptcy, and his two month title reign was a constant reminder that TNA was a distant #2 in the U.S.'s pro wrestling hierarchy.

7. James Storm

TNA stalwart James Storm wrestled at the company's very first show, and before long, he was established as a fixture of the tag team division. Storm was part of America's Most Wanted, one of TNA's all-time most successful tandems, and after that team dissolved, he joined up with Bobby Roode to form another heralded team, Beer Money.

Advertisement

In 2011, both Storm and Roode took part in the Bound For Glory Series, a grueling tournament that would determine who would challenge TNA Champion Kurt Angle at the company's annual supershow. Though Storm advanced to the final four, he lost to Bully Ray in the semifinals; it was Roode who would claim victory, challenge Kurt Angle at Bound For Glory, and fail.

Two days later, Storm got a shot at Angle, and he pulled off the upset to unseat the Olympic Gold Medalist as TNA Champion. At the next set of tapings, Storm defended the championship against Roode, and the challenger won when he hit the champ with a beer bottle. In one fell swoop, Roode turned heel, ended his friendship and team with Storm, and became champ. He would embark on the longest reign in the title's history.

James Storm's title win and eight-day reign was part of a compelling storyline, but taken by itself, it didn't do much for "The Cowboy."

6. Mick Foley

Disenchanted with WWE's product, Mick Foley joined TNA in late 2008, trying to lend a hand to the promotion. Foley was brought in as a storyline co-owner of the company, which was fine - using him in a non-wrestling role was ideal.

Advertisement

Soon, however, he began to participate in matches, and at Lockdown, he challenged Sting for the company's World Heavyweight Title. Foley won the belt, and despite his legacy, it was a bit of an embarrassment - he had famously retired from WWE almost a decade earlier, and the average wrestling fan probably didn't even know he was still capable of competing.

Foley held the title for two months and didn't win a single match during that time. His sole "successful" Pay-Per-View title defense came at Sacrifice in a four-way match where the losing competitor had to give something up. Sting won, but he pinned Kurt Angle, so he won Angle's position as leader of the Main Event Mafia.

Contrary to all logic, the avuncular Foley began to exhibit heelish tendencies during his reign. Prior to the King of the Mountain match at Slammiversary, Foley promised that if he retained his title, he would only defend it once a year. He ended up losing the belt to Kurt Angle, ending his days as a heavyweight champion.

5. Jeff Jarrett

In the history of Total Nonstop Action, no man has spent as much time as champion as Jeff Jarrett. Jarrett's six reigns as NWA World Heavyweight Champion total 1,006 days, and have arguably done more to hurt TNA than the exploits of any other champion.

Advertisement

Jarrett was an established midcarder in WWE, and when he jumped to WCW, the struggling promotion made him a multiple-time champion. The company still failed, though, and Jarrett got a reputation as the captain of the sinking ship - one that stuck when Vince McMahon refused to rehire him.

Jarrett started TNA with his father, and before long, he fell into the age-old trap of putting the title on himself. Yes, Jarrett could count on himself not to desert the company or hold himself up for money, but the years he spent with the title in TNA's formative days gave the company a reputation as a second-rate promotion rather than a real alternative to WWE.

Even worse was the template for title matches established during Jarrett's reigns. His bouts were famously overbooked, filled with run-ins and other forms of cheating. This would happen every single month, soon robbing PPV main events of drama.

All in all, Jarrett may have doomed his company from its very onset.

4. Mr. Anderson

Once, Ken Anderson was considered a charismatic up-and-comer in WWE. After a few years in the company, though, he was exposed as an injury-prone one-trick pony. He was finally fired from the company after numerous complaints about his ring work, and naturally, he ended up in TNA before long.

Advertisement

The unfiltered, heavily-pushed version of Anderson turned out to be twice as annoying as he was before. Proudly calling himself an "assh*le" at every opportunity, Anderson bounced back and forth between being a babyface and a heel, finally finding himself in a feud with former partner Jeff Hardy.

Anderson beat Hardy for the TNA Championship at Genesis 2011, becoming the latest in a long line of WWE castoffs to do so. His brief reign came to an end at Hardy's hands, with "The Assh*le" having accomplished very little as champ.

Later that year, Anderson got another short reign with the championship. Then a heel, Anderson cheated to beat Sting for the title at Slammiversary. One month later, he lost the belt back to Sting, and once again, nobody gained anything from the bargain.

3. Rhino

TNA abandoned the weekly Pay-Per-View model in 2004, and the next year, they began to use the traditional format of holding one major PPV event each month. The first, Bound For Glory, was held in October of 2005, and was built around the main event of Jeff Jarrett versus Kevin Nash.

Advertisement

The day before the event, Nash was hospitalized with chest pains and had to pull out of his match. The company was left without a challenger for the NWA World Heavyweight Championship, so a Gauntlet for the Gold match for the slot was added to the card, with the participants made up of men who were already scheduled for matches on the show. Rhino, who had already won a Monster's Ball match, won the Gauntlet for the Gold and earned an immediate shot at Jarrett's title.

The bout was quick, but action-packed - after overcoming interference from Gail Kim and America's Most Wanted, Rhino hit Jarrett with the Gore to pin him and win the title. A huge brawl ensued, and the babyfaces who came out to help Rhino were left standing tall.

Unfortunately for Rhino, his win wasn't the beginning of a new era for the company - it was simply a hotshot switch designed to make fans feel like they hadn't been cheated by Nash's absence. Two days later, Jarrett won the title back from Rhino, rendering the whole victory flat and the very brief title reign pointless.

2. Chris Sabin

In 2012, TNA made a change to the format of the annual Destination X Pay-Per-View. From thereon out, the reigning X Division Champion at the time of the show could give up the title in exchange for a shot at the TNA World Heavyweight Championship. X Champ Austin Aries decided to take the chance, and he ended up defeating Bobby Roode for the belt in a development that was widely praised.

Advertisement

The next year, TNA tried to pull the same stunt, and of course, the returns had diminished. This time, Bully Ray was the heel champion and Chris Sabin - who was one of the most decorated competitors in X Division history - held the secondary title. He vacated the belt and defeated Bully Ray, finally winning the company's top prize.

There were several reasons why it didn't work. Sabin had spent nearly the entirety of the previous two years on the disabled list, and many believed he had lost a step - in any case, his work wasn't as strong as Aries's was and he had been out of sight and out of mind for while. 2013 was also the first year that Destination X was a special episode of Impact and not a Pay-Per-View event. Finally, Sabin's reign itself was extremely weak, as he lost the belt back to Bully Ray in his first defense. The whole thing fell flat and Sabin himself later criticized TNA for giving him the title too soon.

1. Abyss

Abyss has been TNA's most loyal soldier. He's been with the company since 2003 (and even appeared the first show under a different gimmick), been punctured by untold thousands of thumbtacks, and even reportedly turned down an offer from WWE to join the promotion and wrestle Undertaker at WrestleMania.

Advertisement

What's less-remembered about the "The Monster" is that fact that he, briefly, got to reign as NWA World Heavyweight Champion. After years of challenging for the title but serving as a stepping stone for babyface champs, Abyss won the right to get another shot at the belt. He would take on champion Sting at Genesis 2006 in the semi-main event and win the title on a disqualification due to a pre-match stipulation.

That win didn't set him up for a stellar reign, but the next month, he retained his title in triple threat match over Sting and Christian Cage - when he pinned Cage, in the semi-main event again. Abyss's title reign continued, but he still lacked any legitimacy as he had not defeated the previous champion. At Final Resolution 2007, the three men had a rematch in an elimination bout. Abyss was the first man out when Sting pinned him, then Cage ended up defeating Sting to win the title.

Abyss's sole reign atop TNA may have been something of a "thank you" for all of his hard work over the years. Nevertheless, it did very little for him, and even less for the company.

Advertisement