10 Worst WWE Draft Picks Ever
It's the night where the landscape of WWE changes forever, but sometimes they get it very wrong.
The WWE draft can be one of the most exciting nights of the year, but not always...
Since the first brand split in 2002, wrestlers have jumped between Raw and Smackdown, with ECW and NXT sometimes gatecrashing the party too. It's meant to be a thrilling time, where the landscape of WWE is altered like nothing we've seen before. In reality it's just the same wrestlers you see every week pretending they prefer a different colour from the red or blue that they were wearing the night before.
There's been some truly epic draft moments of course. John Cena making his Raw debut on the Highlight Reel with a delighted Chris Jericho in 2005. Batista bringing the World Heavyweight Championship to SmackDown a few weeks later. Even Finn Balor moving from NXT to Raw in the first round of picks in 2016 was a brilliant statement of intent from WWE.
For every superb pick that's made, there's at least 10 that go under the radar. Often, it's just midcard wrestlers being given a fresh start or tag teams being separated for no reason at all. Other times the picks are superstars who WWE still doesn't have a plan for; they're either gone from the company within a year or they quietly move to another brand again.
Here are the worst of the worst...
10. Lars Sullivan
2019 - Drafted to SmackDown
The 2019 WWE Superstar Shake-Up was different to drafts we'd seen before. Instead of making the announcements live, most of them were either shared on social media or declared on commentary when new acquisitions unexpectedly made their way to the ring. Definitely not as fun as the good old days when brand warfare mattered.
Lars Sullivan debuted on Raw in January, but didn't have a match before he was drafted to SmackDown in April. He lost to Lucha House Party at Super Show-Down, then turn up on Raw again in June to take on the same opponents. Unfortunately for him, a severe knee injury put Lars on the shelf until 2020. He missed the next draft, then returned on SmackDown before being released in 2021.
Jumping between brands isn't the best way to get a new wrestler over, with this stop-start approach cooling any interest fans had in watching Lars have a long run on either show. Besides, having courted controversy away from the ring, fans just didn't want to see Sullivan anymore.
He quietly retired from wrestling after leaving WWE, never to be seen again. The 'E had been working on Lars for five years when they pushed him to the main roster; it really was a waste of time for everybody involved.
9. New World Order
2002 - Drafted to Raw
The first time WWE split the roster between Raw and SmackDown, most of the picks made sense. SmackDown chose The Rock first. Raw got The Undertaker next. It took until the red brand's second pick for things to get strange.
Despite the Dudley Boyz, the Hardy Boyz, and the Acolytes Protection Agency being drafted separately (and Matt and Jeff the only pairing to end up on the same show), the New World Order was lucky enough to move to Raw as one entity... luck for them, unlucky for Raw.
Getting Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, and X-Pac was a real coup when WCW managed it in the 1990s. With the Attitude Era and the Monday Night Wars a thing of the past, WWE's watered down nWo was a group cursed with bad luck.
Within a month, Hall's personal demons had caught up with him and he was released after substance abuse issues and the fabled plane ride from hell. Nash was injured straight away, then returned a few months later just to tear his quads again. X-Pac tried to carry on with Ric Flair, Big Show, and Booker T but it just wasn't the same. Not even a returning Shawn Michaels could save a group that was picked so high but fell so low.
8. Arturo Ruas
2020 - NXT to Raw
Who? That might sound harsh on Arturo Ruas, but if you weren't keeping up with NXT, you'd have no idea who the 60th and final 2020 draft pick was.
Chosen dead last on an episode of Raw Talk, you'd have been forgiven for loading up Wikipedia to find out who he was. If you chose to wait until his first match on Raw to see what he could do then you're still waiting.
Well, he did have a match on Raw before the draft, but you'll have to look back on the Raw Underground era to remember it. Ruas showed up at Shane McMahon's surreal fight club and knocked out Mikey Spandex. Without doing anything at all, Ruas was quickly sent back to NXT and released in 2021. He'd wrestle for AEW under the name Tiger Ruas but that run didn't last long either.
Credit has to go to WWE for trying to bring stars of NXT onto the main roster, it just doesn't always work out.
7. Drake Maverick
2019 - 205 Live to SmackDown
The future was bright for WWE in 2019. SmackDown was about to debut on Fox, so a second draft of the year was held to give Fox executives the exact roster they wanted on their show.
The final 10 picks happened on The Bump, where a long list of wrestlers that have since been released were thrown onto either Raw or SmackDown. There was one exception that stood out for how bizarre it was: Drake Maverick. The multi-time 24/7 Champion was one of three drafted from 205 Live, which was even more surreal because he was the General Manager at the time.
Maverick had one match on SmackDown, before making his way to NXT. He'd still serve as General Manager of 205 Live, making his draft pick completely pointless. It's as if WWE knows content is required for lists like this one!
He'd be released in 2020, rehired later that year, then released again in 2021. It was a surreal time to be a wrestling fan, with numerous releases happening throughout COVID; Drake's heartfelt message to fans after he was fired is what got him back into the company.
6. Hurricane Helms
2009 - SmackDown to ECW
During the days when ECW was WWE’s third brand, a draft meant the not so extreme show’s biggest stars jumping to either Raw or SmackDown. The 2009 draft was no exception; it was also the last one before ECW was put out of its misery. To fill a depleting roster, WWE sent veterans over to ECW to work with its future stars. Sometimes this worked, like with Kane, but often it lead to retirements and releases.
When Hurricane Helms was shipped off to the Land of Extreme as the 35th draft pick (out of 36) he reverted to his real name of Gregory Helms and switched to doing backstage interviews. Fans of his Cruiserweight Championship run under his real name might have been excited, but that enthusiasm was misplaced. This was nothing like that.
Over time Helms transitioned back into the Hurricane when somebody was needed to save the day, leading to feuds with Paul Burchill and Zack Ryder. Although Ryder went on to have a successful singles run, Burchill/Helms was a forgettable story, put together for two wrestlers with nothing better to do.
Both were released on the same day in 2010, when the extinct ECW experiment was ended once and for all. Helms got the chance to return as the Hurricane at the Royal Rumble in 2018 and 2021. Fans were excited about the character again by then; absence makes the heart grow fonder.
5. DH Smith
2008 - Raw to SmackDown
You’d think that the son of a Hart and a Smith would be treasured by WWE. With wrestling running through is veins, Harry Smith made his way through Ohio Valley Wrestling and Florida Championship wrestling to debut on Raw in 2007. Given the new name of DH Smith (which sounds like a British newsagent) he even won his first match. Things were look up until a violation of the wellness policy saw him sit out the next 30 days. When Smith returned, he wrestled in dark matches and on Heat without stirring a crowd that loved his father’s career.
The draft can be the perfect tool to give a wrestler a new start, but that wasn’t to be for Smith. In 2008 he was drafted from Raw to Smackdown, but nothing changed. Without making an appearance he was shipped off to FCW, where he chose to remain on a full-time basis to hone his craft.
When the 2009 draft arrived, Smith was picked for ECW and went on to form the Hart Dynasty with Tyson Kidd and Natalya. He’d finally get the Hart name back as well, extending his initials from DH to David Hart instead.
4. Big Daddy V
2008 - ECW to SmackDown
WWE tried so hard to make Big Daddy V happen; almost as hard as they tried to make Mabel happen. Poor Nelson Frazier, Jr. never stood a chance with the gimmicks they gave him.
His last fresh start was in 2008, when he was drafted to SmackDown from ECW. The two brands had brought in a talent exchange which meant Big Daddy V had spent plenty of time on the blue brand before making the move official; he even challenged for a World Heavyweight Championship match at WrestleMania XXIV. if you're the General Manager of SmackDown, why would you bother drafting anybody from ECW? If they can turn up anyway, you're just wasting a pick...
Anyway, this is another one of those fated choices where they clearly didn't know what to do with a certain wrestler. Two months after being drafted to SmackDown, Big Daddy V was gone from the company without a single appearance on his new blue home. What was the point in all of this?
With more than 20 years spent in WWE, you can't say they didn't want things to work for Nelson Frazier, Jr.; he just never clicked with the fans. The former Viscera found a new lease of life in All Japan Pro Wrestling before passing away in 2014.
3. Teddy Long
2004 - Raw to SmackDown
After WWE first split the roster between Raw and SmackDown, it was two years before the next draft took place.
The picks were up and down. Up-and-coming René Duprée went to SmackDown. The soon-to-be pushed Shelton Benjamin made his way to Raw. The most shocking pick was Triple H, who Heyman proudly announced as the newest addition to the blue brand. He was traded back later that week, in exchange for Booker T and the Dudley Boyz, which gives you an idea of how much they valued those three wrestlers at the time. 'The Game' almost made this list for how quickly he was shipped back to Raw.
With such a small number of wrestlers moving, how about sending a manager to a new brand? It sounds like a waste of time, but Teddy Long was sent to SmackDown. He went on to be the blue brand's longest serving General Manager, but with only 12 picks in 2004, this felt like a waste of time. Heyman did his best to big up Jazz' manager when he announced the pick, but this one really fell flat.
2. The Boogeyman
2007 - SmackDown to ECW
The 2007 WWE draft was first one to feature ECW alongside Raw and SmackDown. The extreme brand had been given two picks when it launched in 2006, but now their superstars were up for grabs too.
This was also the first time picks were determined by matches; each contest was cross brand, with the winner's show getting a randomly assigned wrestler. In all honesty, it was the start of WWE wanting to move a few big names without knowing what to do with everybody else.
Chris Benoit moved to be the new face of ECW. After taking part in the Battle of the Billionaires at WrestleMania 23, Bobby Lashley was promoted to Raw. The Great Khali was shifted to SmackDown, where he'd become World Heavyweight Champion later in the year.
Then there was The Boogeyman moving to ECW.
While still branded as Sci Fi, ECW's network had asked for more over the top characters who matched its target audience; that's why the first episode started with The Zombie. Boogey did have a handful of matches in the new Land of Extreme, but most of them were against other wrestlers that WWE just didn't know what to do with.
1. John Cena
2011 - Raw to SmackDown
John Cena was one of the most exciting draft picks ever when he was chosen in 2005. Walking out on the Highlight Reel, even Chris Jericho had the biggest smile on his face to see the reigning WWE Champion be swapped to Monday nights.
The same can't be said for when he moved brands in 2011...
Right until the end of the show, the 2011 WWE draft was a very strong night. With ECW gone, it was back to just Raw and SmackDown poaching superstars from each other. Rey Mysterio, Randy Orton, and Alberto Del Rio all jumped ship; WWE wasn't afraid to moves its biggest stars.
The first draft pick of the night was John Cena. Going from Raw to SmackDown, this was the first time the Chain Gang Soldier had represented the blue brand since his big move in 2005... or was it? This is where things get silly.
With Team Raw's The Miz, CM Punk and Alberto Del Rio defeating Team SmackDown's John Cena, Christian and Mark Henry in the final match of the night, there was one more draft pick to come...
...AND HIS NAME IS JOHN CENA!
Yes, Cena was shipped back to Raw on the same episode where he was drafted to SmackDown. What a waste of everybody's time. It's telling that the pop from the Raw crowd for the Doctor of Thuganomics leaving was bigger than the one for him coming back, but this attempt at building anything can happen drama really didn't work.