10 Worst WWE Hell In A Cell Matches EVER - According To Dave Meltzer

Meshed Potatoes

By Michael Hamflett /

With two matches set to take part within the fearsome structure and a WWE Title clash destined to disappoint, SmackDown Live! will present the ninth annual edition of the Hell In A Cell pay-per-view three days removed from the twenty year anniversary of the gimmick itself.

Advertisement

Back in 1997, the novel concept was devised in order to provide a satisfying conclusion to the bitter blood feud between The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. 'HBK' had relied on repeated interference from Triple H, Chyna and Ravishing Rick Rude in their televised scuffles and prior pay-per-view battle. Ordered by new no-nonsense Commissioner Slaughter, the Cell was as much a rat trap as an entity of destruction in its own right.

Needless to say, the 'Heartbreak Kid' and 'The Deadman' set the bar incredibly high that night, with Dave Meltzer considering their display one of the best matches in wrestling in a year where WWE, WCW, ECW and All Japan Pro Wrestling were rewriting expectations of mat classics.

He'd be relatively kind to nearly every incarnation of the match, with only a select few earning the sharper end of his wit and wisdom. Some of the contests must have felt like true hell for the wrestlers to experience - they certainly were to watch.

(NOTE: In the event of a tied rating, the most recent match gets preferential treatment. Wrestling evolves at a breakneck pace, and any older contest outperforming a contemporary equivalent is deserving of the elevated status)

10. Roman Reigns Vs Rusev (Hell In A Cell 2016, ***1/4)

The sheer quality of most Hell In A Cell matches perhaps unfairly places this contest amongst the 'worst' in the twenty year history of the concept, but the spirited brawl between 'The Big Dog' and the 'Bulgarian Brute' served more to highlight how needless the annual presentation of the gimmick is.

Advertisement

The US Title match was one of three Cell efforts on the broadcast, with bouts for the main male and female singles titles taking far greater precedence over the midcard match.

Frustratingly, Rusev and Reigns perhaps warranted the cage more than Universal Title rivals Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins. They'd been fighting for months, including a SummerSlam match that couldn't even officially take place thanks to rising hostilities between the two. Regrettably, WWE deemed it unacceptable to include a defence of the top title without it being encased in steel, though notably it's a gesture that hasn't been extended to Jinder Mahal and Shinsuke Nakamura in 2017.

The company have perhaps having realised how an over-reliance on the gimmick watered down all three battles last year, especially when all three encounters were forced to employ outside entities as well as 'Satan's Structure'.

9. Randy Orton Vs Sheamus (Hell In A Cell 2010, ***1/4)

Lightweight irritant Enzo Amoré hilariously referred to the 205-and-under league as the 'Snoozerweight Division' in celebration of his unlikely title triumph. Replacing flips with quips, he obnoxiously suggested that the crew should be grateful for his injection of personality into their weekly treadmill of dives and holds. He's not wrong.

Advertisement

With the best will in the world, some wrestling matches are just so...dull. It's not a show of disrespect to the incredible performers that risk their bodies for the art, but there's sometimes too little bell-to-bell that allows for the all-important emotional connection to be made. And no matter how many of his fellow wrestlers worship at the Church Of Chinlock, there has long been a blockage in the pavlovian pipes connecting Randy Orton to the 'WWE Universe'.

Sheamus had been rushed into the main event scene following a late-2009 WWE Title victory over John Cena, but had struggled to gain further traction with the audience at large despite a second title win midway through 2010. The contest subsequently lacked all the heat needed for the supposed 'Hell' they were both enduring. That they were forced to share the stipulation with The Undertaker and Kane (more on that later) afforded the gimmick one of its weakest ever years.

8. D-Generation-X Vs Vince McMahon, Shane McMahon & The Big Show (Unforgiven 2006, ***1/4)

A festival of McMahon-grade comedy and violence resulted in a blood feud climax descending into farce as Vince and Shane's largely one-sided 2006 rivalry with D-Generation-X ended in graphic fashion.

Advertisement

Like the majority of their comeback conflicts, Shawn Michaels and Triple H had had little trouble despatching opponents in virtually any scenario, resulting in increasingly daft contests with the father and son pairing that were littered with failed interference and heel hijinks.

Having bulldozed all five members of the Spirit Squad as well as much of the Raw and SmackDown upper card talent, 'HBK' and 'The Game' were finally felled by bloated ECW Champion The Big Show, justifying his place in a brand new super-sized cell that housed the feud's final battle.

Gimmicked within an inch of its life, the contest had patches of drama, but lacked a clear narrative thread to link individual spots together. Despite Show's size and renewed dominance, the result was also never in doubt, removing any lingering sense of peril from the beginning.

Furthermore, Vince's decision to bring back the hideous Kiss-My-Ass Club earlier that year contributed to a grim finale. Shortly before his Hunter literally broke a sledgehammer over his head, McMahon's coiffured bonce was rooted deep inside The Big Show's sweaty caboose.

7. Charlotte Vs Sasha Banks (Hell In A Cell 2016, **3/4)

They tried. They really, really tried.

Advertisement

Charlotte and Sasha Banks should not shoulder the majority of the blame for their passable Hell In A Cell 2016 show-closer not quite managing to live up to WWE's insane overblown hype job.

Make no mistake, it was an enormous deal that the two ferociously talented females were selected as the first in their gender to ever conclude a WWE pay-per-view (with Sasha and Bayley having already done so in NXT a year earlier).

However, the company had already squeezed far too much juice out of the fruit long before they arrived at the October pay-per-view in Banks' hometown of Boston, Massachusetts. Hotshotting the title in a foreshadowing of how reckless they'd be with the belt for the next several months, Sasha scooped the prize twice in blockbuster Monday Night Raw encounters in between Charlotte stealing the gold back at SummerSlam.

Worryingly, the matches were getting progressively worse, with much of their chemistry coming from Banks' gripping first title chase. Furthermore, booking her as a multi-time loser had significantly harmed the 'Boss' persona, and her diminutive size unfortunately meant that table bumps and other Cell high spots fell a little flat.

The result? A good-not-great match that ended with a whimper as Charlotte took back her prize to further a undefeated story arc they eventually blew the end of six months later.

6. The Undertaker Vs Shane McMahon (WrestleMania 32, **1/2)

Dave Meltzer was perhaps kind to Shane McMahon in a show of respect for another audacious stunt from the 'Boy Wonder', but when the contest is barely remembered for that manoeuvre, it highlights how little else went on in their perplexing WrestleMania 32 effort.

Advertisement

Unlike Mick Foley's incredible plunge from the structure at June 1998's King Of The Ring, Shane's own flight through a table was all his own doing, and fiercely predictable from the moment the match was announced. It didn't make the stunt any less thrilling to see of course, but it did reduce the spot to just that - little more than a stunt.

It was needless in the context of the match of course, which was predictably dominated by 'Shane-O-Mac' having an answer for each Undertaker's submission and stand-up game despite Michael Cole's repeated inferences that 'The Deadman' was the 'best pure striker' in the history of the company, and perhaps the world.

Awaiting the big moment they were duly rewarded, the record-setting crowd rightfully felt no reason to invest any energy beforehand, which further hampered the remainder of the contest. That lack of investment at least made the total reneging of the pre-match stipulations 24 hours later a little easier to swallow.

5. Mark Henry Vs Randy Orton (Hell In A Cell 2011, **1/2)

Yet another deathly dull Randy Orton encounter, Mark Henry's first major defence of his newly-won World Heavyweight Title was severely hampered by the limitations put upon Champion and Challenger by the both the stipulation and the risk of repetition with the blatantly more important WWE Title clash later in the card.

Advertisement

Checking 'The Viper' into his 'Hall Of Pain', Henry was a charismatic beast during his unlikely run with the blue brand belt, but he achieved the most success as something of a proto-Braun Strowman. Leaving behind a strewn wasteland of bodies amidst the chaos of his attacks, the 'World's Strongest Man' was at long last living up to the potential Vince McMahon saw in him 14 years earlier when he signed his whopping first deal with the organisation.

Orton simply wasn't the man to give Mark a battle to suit his style inside the cage though. Going nowhere and doing so at a snail's pace, the match just refused to come to life until Orton attempted his punt to the head after an RKO could only garner a two count. Henry's brisk counter resulted in a World's Strongest Slam and defeat for the 'Apex Predator', concluding a lacklustre programme and freeing the Champion up for a substantially more interesting feud with The Big Show.

4. CM Punk Vs Ryback & Paul Heyman (Hell In A Cell 2013, **1/4)

A flat payoff to CM Punk's feud with Paul Heyman despite the best efforts of the 'Straight Edge Superstar' (and Heyman's post-match bravery), his Hell In A Cell rematch with Ryback following their controversial effort a year earlier (more on that later) summed up the miserable 2013 return that would indirectly lead to his January 2014 exit.

Advertisement

The cowardice of Brock Lesnar's advocate became the central story of the match, with Heyman taking refuge atop the Cell whilst Ryback and Punk did battle. With little of the passable chemistry they'd had on opposing sides a year earlier, the bulk of the match played out to apathy as the crowd waited patiently for Punk to catch up with his true nemesis.

Smashing Ryback through a table with his godawful elbow drop, Punk eventually scaled the structure and delivered the crowd-pleasing annihilation of his former friend. Hitting Heyman with 16 kendo stick shots and a Go2Sleep, it was the necessary catharsis for all involved, but the reduction of the Cell to little more than a speedbump for the 'Straight Edge Superstar' was an unforgivable sin.

3. CM Punk Vs Ryback (Hell In A Cell 2012, *1/2)

Marginally worse than their battle on opposite sides of the heel/face divide a year earlier, CM Punk's WWE Title clash with Ryback was hampered by a rotten finish that destroyed the momentum of the 'Big Guy' at the worst possible time for the company.

Advertisement

Panicking over a real life injury sustained planned challenger John Cena, WWE booked themselves into a corner by positioning the red hot undefeated Ryback as a viable Number One Contender to Punk's title and lengthy championship reign. However, a summer heel turn for the 'Voice Of The Voiceless' had signposted a Royal Rumble showdown with The Rock, rendering the months in the build-up to the blockbuster clash largely moot.

Desperate to protect Ryback but stuck on the Punk/Rock showdown, WWE elected to book a dreadful finish in which corrupt referee Brad Maddox fast-counted the challenger. As a one-off, it wasn't ideal, but the company still had no intention of shifting the title in rematches, resulting in further defeats and setbacks for the previously indestructible monster.

The match itself failed to remind audiences exactly why they'd fallen head over heels for him ahead of the disappointment of his defeat. The event drew one of the best B-show buyrates of the year, highlighting genuine curiosity that quickly dwindled in the aftermath.

2. Kane Vs The Undertaker (Hell In A Cell 2010, 1/2*)

Though their explosive relationship began inside the confines of the very first Hell In A Cell encounter, a 2010 retread of the regularly revisited rivalry generated a rock bottom battle that only highlighted how aged both the performers and their connective tissues were.

Advertisement

Kane ripped the door clean off the original structure, but metaphorically kicked it in when he debuted so emphatically. Dropping his storyline brother with an impactful Tombstone to cost him a victory he so desperately needed against Shawn Michaels, the 'Big Red Machine' was instantly established as threat becoming of his planned WrestleMania showdown with 'The Deadman'.

He was less worthy of wearing the World Heavyweight Title in 2010, but Undertaker himself was equally unsuited to be challenging for it. WWE's main event scene had largely been taken over by the ongoing scuffle between John Cena and The Nexus, allowing experimental periods for both titles that yielded mixed results.

The aforementioned Randy Orton/Sheamus rivalry was bland, but Kane and Undertaker's final go-around was all the wrong kinds of brutal.

Chasing a nostalgic buzz, the company even brought Paul Bearer back to life for the angle, with the rotund 'Father Of Evil' swerve-turning on The Undertaker in the match to gift victory to Kane. Even that lacked the urgency and intensity of the three's original melee in the mesh.

1. The Undertaker Vs Big Boss Man (WrestleMania 15, DUD)

Jinder Mahal wasn't considered worthy enough of defending the WWE Championship inside Hell In A Cell at the very pay-per-view that champions the 'Devil's Playground', but may have dodged the double-cage disaster Big Boss Man couldn't hide from in 1999. Mahal escaped the Punjabi Prison with his title in tact, but the Boss Man was less successful in Unforgiven's miserable 'Kennel From Hell' that infamously topped an atrocious WrestleMania clash against The Undertaker.

Advertisement

The p*ss-stained dog fight was comfortably the most awful caged encounter during a torrid year for the gimmick, but the WrestleMania 15 Hell In A Cell battle still represented a surprising late entry amongst Undertaker's worst ever 'Show Of Show' bouts.

Overwhelmed by a convoluted power struggle storyline between 'The Deadman' and Boss Man's gaffer Vince McMahon (that was ultimately revealed to be one big plan at Steve Austin's expense), the contest was further hampered by the fact that neither could summon the necessary physical intensity to give the match the potency it required.

Furthermore, the body of the contest itself was almost immediately negated by the swinging one of the Boss Man himself. In a scene only uglier in hindsight, Undertaker and his Ministry of Darkness goons hung the prone law-man from the Cell in a grisly spectacle to conclude the entire wretched ordeal.

Advertisement