10 Worst WWE PPV Gimmick Matches

They spectacles, in a different sense of the word.

By Justin Henry /

With Payback around the corner, WWE has commissioned a Randy Orton-Bray Wyatt rematch for the WWE Championship, and it won't be any ordinary match - it's going to be a "House of Horrors" match!

Advertisement

While the stipulations aren't clear (as of press time), one has to expect that it will be a strange and bizarre encounter. After all, their "normal" match at WrestleMania featured the super-imposing of insects on the canvas. Yes, their "normal" match.

Gimmick matches certainly have a purpose in wrestling: to raise the stakes, to promise a world of pain for a villain, to end a long-standing rivalry properly. The sheer number of enjoyable, even historic, gimmick matches in WWE's history numbers into the hundreds, be they ladder matches, cage matches, Hell in a Cell, and so forth.

On the downside, there have been many failures in gimmick matches. Sometimes, the performers are handcuffed by stifling match rules. Other times, at least one performer in the match is washed up, thus the stipulation is meant to disguise their weaknesses. There's also the chance that a bad storyline overrides the work of the performers, and mars the match itself. This is known as, "The story of The Undertaker's career."

This list doesn't "honor" the lamest stipulations; instead, it's a look at WWE pay-per-view gimmick matches that just plain stunk.

10. Dean Ambrose Vs. Chris Jericho: Asylum Match (5/22/16)

The two took part in a pretty good upper-midcard match at Payback weeks earlier, and it did the trick of giving Ambrose a credible win over a proven star. Because there's 46 pay-per-views a year, though, they had to have another match, this time taking place inside a steel cage. Ah, but it wasn't your normal cage - this was an Asylum, with various inane weapons hanging from the ceiling.

Advertisement

Because nothing says, "I'll kill you," like a mop.

While Ambrose and Jericho are capable of delivering in a brawl, a comedy match, or a mixture of both, their Asylum match went on for 26 dull minutes as they had to haul out every single weapon and use it. With that amount of time to fill, two gifted workers worked much slower than usual, and it was clearly wearing on the crowd. The ending sequence with the thumbtacks redeems the plodding affair somewhat, but the match was just a waste of both men's talents.

9. Kane Vs. The Undertaker: Buried Alive Match (10/24/10)

With all due respect to The Undertaker and his amazing career, he was asked to take part in some pretty lousy matches in those two and a half decades. In the fall of 2010, Undertaker was working through a serious shoulder injury when he had to blow off yet another feud with Kane. The presence of Paul Bearer and a Buried Alive match conjured up memories of a bygone era, only neither man was as spry as their Attitude heyday.

Advertisement

"The Dead Man" was at less than 100 percent, and his offence looked downright tame. Even Kane was clearly going easy on him in parts. The match, to settle the long-simmering blood feud, was a whole lot of emptiness until The Nexus got involved for some reason and tried to assist with the burial.

Underwhelming in just about every way.

8. The Undertaker Vs. Giant Gonzalez: Rest In Peace Match (8/30/93)

After WrestleMania IX five months earlier, few were expecting anything artistic out of Gonzalez, whose size was his only magnificent quality as a wrestler. He and Undertaker blew off their disastrous feud at SummerSlam 1993 in what was billed as a "Rest in Peace" match. For weeks, the stipulation was talked about on television, but it was never made clear what the rules of the match entailed.

Advertisement

When the big moment came, Howard Finkel announced the rules: no disqualification, no count-out, and there must be a winner. So...call it a no count-out, no disqualification match then?

With those underwhelming modifiers in place, Gonzalez proceeded to hit Undertaker with some of the worst chair strikes ever before Paul Bearer returned from injury layoff, reclaimed the urn from Harvey Whippleman, and then Undertaker mauled Gonzalez with an array of clotheslines.

Thankfully, it was only eight minutes long.

7. Big Show Vs. Erick Rowan: Stairs Match (12/14/14)

It's mystifying that WWE actually amended the official TLC pay-per-view name to "TLC&S" in deference to the "Stairs" match. Were they hoping to spin it off into its own pay-per-view down the line, with a women's Stairs match, tag team Stairs match, Stairs on a Pole matches, and so forth?

Advertisement

The time allotted to the pre-match video package explaining the science behind a set of ring-steps could have been used in more productive ways, like showing Michael Cole counting his pocket change.

The match itself was just as insipid, with the crowd not buying into Rowan ("But he's a vintner now!"). The spot where Rowan stacked up a wall of stairs featured a less-than-thrilling payoff, and the match basically played out as an extended squash. The failure of the Stairs match is probably what doomed plans for future matches of its ilk, like the Guardrail match, the Turnbuckle Pad match, and the dreaded Bulky Outdated Ringside Monitor match.

6. Triple H Vs. Sgt. Slaughter: Boot Camp Match (12/7/97)

This one falls firmly into the category of old-timers that had clearly seen better days. Slaughter was pushing 50 and was all but retired when he returned as the WWF's Commissioner. His feud with D-Generation X was an early WWE take on the establishment vs. the punks, except it's 1997 and the fans were expected to cheer the establishment. The frequent sighting of black Austin 3:16 and nWo shirts hadn't clued the WWF in yet, apparently.

Advertisement

Slaughter looked his age shambling around the ring while Helmsley took the bumps. "Sarge" suffered a little more ignominy when he removed his belt to whip Triple H, only for his pants to continually start falling down. Helmsley tried, but he could only do so much.

The fact that the match ran 18 minutes means somebody in the company has a sense of humor, at least.

5. The Undertaker Vs. Big Boss Man: Hell In A Cell (3/28/99)

The first thought that comes to mind is that of Ray Traylor being hanged in some sort of dark ritual in the match's denouement. It was so horrifying that Michael Cole couldn't believe his eyes. Then he callously segued into a video package while a man was being lynched 15 feet away from him. Can't grieve forever, one supposes.

Advertisement

Even before the post-match silliness, Undertaker and Boss Man engaged in probably the worst Cell match in history, slow and uninteresting compared to Undertaker's previous wars with Shawn Michaels and Mankind. Not that Boss Man needed to go flying off of the cage in order to ratchet up the excitement, but some excitement would have been preferable. Otherwise, why dust off the Cell for a nothing match? You could've lynched a man without having to assemble a giant cage.

Wait, that still sounds awful...

4. Al Snow Vs. Big Boss Man: Kennel From Hell (9/26/99)

For enduring a hanging, cooking a man's pet dog, and stealing the casket of another man's dead father at the funeral, all in the same calendar year, I feel like Big Boss Man should've been given some kind of lifetime achievement award.

Advertisement

That is a resume, folks.

The whole "cooking a man's pet dog" gag came when Boss Man kidnapped Snow's chihuahua Pepper, and then went all Fatal Attraction by cooking the dog and feeding it to Snow. To blow off this insidious feud, Snow avenged his dead pooch by "wrestling" Boss Man inside the Kennel From Hell: a blue-barred cage surrounded by Hell in a Cell (overkill alert) while disinterested, bladder-evacuating dogs patrolled the ringside area.

Snow won by escaping both structures, making him more of a winner than anyone that watched this mess. Boss Man is to Cell matches what Uwe Boll is to film reels. For a laugh, track down Mick Foley's "Hard Knocks and Cheap Pops" DVD, which includes this match, set to sarcastic, over-the-top commentary from Foley and Kevin Kelly.

3. The Undertaker Vs. The Dudley Boyz: Concrete Crypt Match (6/27/04)

Folks who say that JBL winning the WWE Championship from Eddie Guerrero was the worst part of the 2004 Great American Bash obviously didn't watch the entire show. For reasons that make about as much sense as sardine-flavored cereal, Paul Bearer was trapped into a glass case (of emotion), and if Undertaker didn't let Bubba Ray and D-Von beat him up, Paul Heyman would authorize dumping wet cement on the hapless Bearer.

Advertisement

If you survived that paragraph without suffering a debilitating aneurysm, you're a strong one. Bear in mind that the action of the match (basic as it was) would screech to a halt whenever Heyman would chastise 'Taker for kicking too much ass, and then would dump more cement on Bearer, whose kayfabe death would follow the audience's gradual death, caused by confusion and disgust.

Undertaker won, and then killed Bearer himself for a lark, it seemed. The only positive from this tripe was the wrestling website that a week later ran the headline, "Paul Bearer Comments On His Death".

Talk about the sweetened cherry on the dung sundae.

2. Yokozuna Vs. The Undertaker: Casket Match (1/22/94)

Truly, this had to be seen to be believed. Yokozuna and Undertaker's WWE Championship match at the 1994 Royal Rumble could've been described as "mediocre" or "average" before the big finish. It was a brawl between two monsters that wasn't thrilling, but was serviceable. When Undertaker was on the verge of winning, everything went flying off a cliff.

Advertisement

Suddenly, no less than ten heels hit the ring, including Diesel, Bam Bam Bigelow, Crush, and others. Undertaker was thoroughly beaten down and his urn pried open. From said urn billowed colored smoke, which Vince McMahon casually claimed was Undertaker's power escaping from his physical form. He said this in the same matter-of-fact voice you would use to explain how to apply the hand-brake on your bicycle.

So Undertaker loses and the gaggle of heels are happy.

But wait!

Undertaker appears on the jumbotron via CasketCam, and gives a soliloquy on death before floating to the heavens (in actuality, Marty Jannetty in Undertaker's hat and coat). This was exactly how they wrote Poochie off of Itchy and Scratchy, but without the happy music. The year 1994 was a rough one in WWE.

1. Pat Patterson Vs. Gerald Brisco: Hardcore Evening Gown Match (6/25/00)

This may have been the original House of Horrors match, actually. Considering the stacked roster and the hot product of the day, King of the Ring 2000 was already enough of a disappointment without two legendary wrestlers dressed in drag, fighting over a devalued tertiary belt, but hey: when you aim for rock bottom, give it your best shot.

Advertisement

So Patterson and Brisco (who WrestleCrap aptly described as looking like "a satanic Pocahontas") doled out the alleged comedy by resorting to jokes involving maxi pads, a banana, and even a Bronco Buster from Brisco. Are you laughing yet?

The match lasted about three minutes, which was four minutes longer than it needed to be. Crash Holly running in with a trash can to steal the pin was about as welcome as Seth Rollins' WrestleMania 31 cash-in. But WWE dare not ask Brock Lesnar to put on a dress.

Advertisement