10 Worst WWE Royal Rumble Winners Ever
Everyone loves the Royal Rumble, which makes WWE's poor choices even worse...
WWE has a spotty track record when it comes to speciality match types. Through Money In The Bank, Elimination Chamber, Hell In A Cell, and more, we've seen some legendary winners - and some total stinkers.
The Royal Rumble is the single best stipulation in wrestling (there will be no room for arguing the merits of the Kennel From Hell match), and the first Rumble of the Lockdown Era is fast approaching.
Unlike its contemporaries, the January event has a highly respectable hit rate. Across the 37 Rumble bouts to date, it was genuinely difficult to pick out 10 winners worthy of this list. However, by taking into account the situations in which they won and who they beat to do it, each of these selections can be defended confidently.
The bulk of these entries have come from the 2010s, so take from that what you will about the state of the creative team at that time. The peak of WWE's tone-deaf booking decisions - the influence of The Authority - may be appearing more than once here.
10. Sheamus (2012)
The Celtic Warrior won the Royal Rumble match in 2012; in theory, it wasn't the worst call in the world. After the lightning-quick start to his WWE career, Sheamus was building his way back to the main event in the two years prior to his Rumble victory. He won King Of The Ring in 2010 and had a decent run with the US title, competing with the likes of Daniel Bryan and Kofi Kingston.
When it came time to add the Rumble to his burgeoning portfolio, however, Sheamus was in the midst of a generic babyface run, smiling his way down the ramp to middling reactions. What made the decision to put Sheamus over even worse was, as is so often the way with bad Royal Rumble winners, the fact that the fans had another man in mind.
Chris Jericho had just returned with a new attitude and a brighter jacket and had promised to 'change the world' at the Rumble. Entering at 29, this had to be Y2J's year, thought everybody watching, but Vinny Mac had his mind made up. Sheamus went on to beat Daniel Bryan in 18 seconds at WrestleMania XXVIII in another decision that did not go down terribly well.
9. Braun Strowman (Greatest Royal Rumble)
Such is the strength of the Royal Rumble winners list, the non-canon match from the Greatest Royal Rumble pay-per-view makes an appearance. It was the third Rumble of 2018, which was overkill already before you factor in the 50-strong field. Strowman certainly wouldn't have been the worst option to win the actual 2018 Rumble, but giving him the trinket non-prize of a Saudi belt was an Andre Memorial Battle Royale-worthy death knell for The Monster Among Men.
It was never brought up again, never used by Braun to warrant any kind of push up the card, nothing. The 'belt' itself vanished, presumably thrown into the jets of the WWE's outgoing plane back to the US. Most of the participants were fodder, in a match that was only eight minutes longer than the 30-man Rumble in 2002, making for a stodgy mess that everybody immediately wanted to forget about.
Apart from Titus Worldslide, that was glorious.
This entry is more devoted to the fact that the Greatest Royal Rumble match was a stupid idea to begin with, and was never going to be accepted into ongoing storylines by the fans. They might as well have booked Vince McMahon to win it. Even WWE aren't that thick, though...
8. Roman Reigns (2015)
Looking back on the career of Roman Reigns, it will be a given that he picked up a Royal Rumble victory (more likely two or three when he hangs up the permanently wet hair), but the timing of his 2015 triumph was all kinds of tone-deaf. In fact, it was completely regular deaf on WWE's part, as the signs were there for anyone actually watching the product that this would not end well for anyone.
The entire match was doomed as soon as Daniel Bryan - whose Yes! Movement was still outrageously over - was eliminated early on. The boos pelted down for the rest of the match, intensifying when fan favourites Bray Wyatt, Dolph Ziggler, and Dean Ambrose were also thrown out.
When Reigns got rid of Big Show and Kane at the same time, even The Rock couldn't save WWE's new poster boy from the vociferous reception, especially when Rusev attempted the sneaky elimination only to be dumped out himself. That baffled look on the face of The Great One was probably reflected backstage at the time; "Why aren't they cheering? We've told them who to cheer for, WHY AREN'T THEY CHEERING?!"
7. John Cena (2013)
Cena's 2008 Rumble win was as perfect as you'll see. Returning way ahead of schedule thanks to a comic book character level of regeneration, receiving a thunderous ovation at Madison Square Garden in the midst of Super Cena, everything lined up.
Five years later? Not so much.
The scene had been set for a year heading into the Rumble: Cena vs. Rock 2 was going to happen, regardless of fan opinion or organic storytelling. In Dolph Ziggler and Chris Jericho, WWE had the perfect pairing to go bell to bell, rising stars like Cesaro, Miz, and Cody Rhodes could have taken that next step, CM Punk could have kept his monster title reign going and got his big 'Mania moment, but no.
When those dollar signs appear in front of billionaire Vince McMahon, creative integrity or future planning are thrown off the top of Titan Towers in favour of the immediate gratification. WWE played it 'safe', to the benefit of nobody but Big Match John and Big Film Dwayne. Their second 'Mania bout was much better than the first, but it would have drawn just as well without the title involved.
6. Lex Luger & Bret Hart (1994)
If Bret had won this one outright then there would be no reason at all for this one to be included. As you can see, Bret did not win this match outright;: instead, he had to share the podium with personality vacuum Lex Luger. The concept of both men holding claim to the win could have been interesting... but it wasn't.
This did lead to Owen vs. Bret at WrestleMania X, the greatest 'Mania opener ever, as well as the elder Hart going on to avenge the travesty that was WrestleMania IX by beating Yokozuna for the WWF Championship in the main event. Without the dual-winner nonsense, Hart probably wouldn't be pulling double duty, and we wouldn't have got the Owen/Bret masterpiece.
Therefore, 1994 would end up on a list of best Rumble winners had it not been for the pointless inclusion of poor Lex, who was beaten by Yokozuna in between Bret's two bouts. He just never clicked as that infallible babyface, despite the company's efforts to make him the next leader of the business. Wow, getting major deja vu right now...
5. Triple H (2016)
Honestly, the idea of WWE running a Rumble match to determine a world champion is an exciting change of pace when it's done right (looking at you, 1992). The crowd in attendance get to watch as someone's dreams are realised instantly, no title shot in three months, no potential to screw away that shot before WrestleMania.
When a Rumble is set up to blatantly highlight just two men, however, fans pick up on it. Such was the case in 2016 when the still supposed-to-be babyface Roman Reigns was made to defend his title from the number one slot by the evil, tiresome Authority, and you just knew the 'surprise' was coming as the clock counted down to the final entrant.
Provided you didn't skip entry #8, you can guess what happened next. Reigns made it to end (boo), was eliminated by entry number 30, Triple H (the supposed heel who was cheered to high heaven, yay?), who dropped the belt back to Roman in one of the worst-received WrestleMania main events in recent memory. Sigh.
One last point, which is totally not Roman's fault, but AJ Styles debuted here, and all we got watching at home was Reigns pulling his best confused stoner face.
4. Hulk Hogan (1991)
Hogan winning the Rumble for the second year in a row didn't seem like the worst call in the world at the time. He was still a huge name at the turn of the 1990s but, as we have seen frequently throughout WWE's history, WWE went with the proven star power that was starting to wane over potential future champions.
If this match had played out 20 years later, Mr Perfect would have played the Daniel Bryan role, and Hogan would still be Hulk Hogan, the established guy trying to cling to his main event status at 57. Perfect would be retired by the end of the year due to a ruinous back injury (not that WWE knew at the time), but even giving him a Royal Rumble win and a short run with the world title would have been no less than the great man deserved.
As time goes on, and more stories are told about The Hulkster's backstage pull, his remarkable accomplishments taste a little bit bitter. He would be gone from WWE two years after this event, having passed the torch to a total of zero Superstars coming up behind him on his way out.
3. Alberto Del Rio (2011)
Remember that time WWE said, "Why don't we add ten more barely-used roster members to our already weak Rumble lineup?".
Seriously, after CM Punk and Daniel Bryan kicked things off, we had John Cena at number 22, Alberto Del Rio at 38, and Randy Orton at 39 who had any realistic chance of standing tall in the first and last 40-man Royal Rumble.
The match had real promise in stages, the returns of Booker T and Diesel were cool, and CM Punk hung in to claim the Ironman crown by lasting 35 minutes. Alex Riley gave us the gift of his infamous botched elimination, and the tease of Santino Marella almost being the last man standing would have been, looking back, a far better shock than Jinder Mahal's WWE Championship win.
WWE can't be blamed too harshly for throwing The Mexican Aristocrat the ball. On paper, he had the whole package, but Del Rio was a victim of the 'too fast, too soon' school of booking. WWE's attempts to manufacture a new face of the Hispanic market backfired, but that fan connection eas never there. This would have been an all-time great Rumble with 30 men and a better winner here.
2. Batista (2014)
Well then. What was WWE thinking between 2011 and 2016?! Six consecutive Royal Rumbles with dissatisfying winners, to say the least (ahem, Authority, cough). There can be no doubt, however, that Drax The Destroyer's conquest in 2014 was the most criminal of that torrid spell. It was received about as well as Reigns would be the following year, except this was a legend returning to take a WrestleMania spot away from a full-time worker - and not just any worker.
This was peak Daniel Bryan; the Yes! Movement at fever pitch. Everybody not working for WWE knew this had to be his year to reach the mountaintop. WWE, on the other hand, decided that Randy Orton vs. Batista was a fine 'Mania main event for 2014, which the fans promptly sh*t all over when they figured out that was the plan.
Sure, WWE buckled and went with the Bryan story, but that doesn't change the blinkered booking that marred the Rumble. The simplest tweak to this story (Batista coming back as the heel he plays amazingly) would have at least made some storyline sense, rather than WWE blatantly ignoring the indie guy out of spite until the noise got too loud.
1. Mr McMahon (1999)
How do WWE top Daniel Bryan's robbery? There couldn't be anyone else. Not only did Vince McMahon win a Royal Rumble, but he also did it from the number two position, eliminating only his arch-rival 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin to do so, and hiding for the vast majority of the match. This was prime sh*thouse Vince, ECW Champion Vince, Royal Rumble winning-in-a-jumper Vince in his finest hour of sh*thousery.
Afterwards, McMahon forfeited his title shot, not knowing the rules of his own company, as Commissioner Shawn Michaels informed the boss that the opportunity was given to the runner-up of the Rumble in the case of a forfeit. So Stone Cold gets his 'Mania match against The Rock anyway, and McMahon looks like a wally (which is one good thing, at least).
To fix two Rumbles at once, how about The Texas Rattlesnake wins this one, making it an unbeatable three in a row. If he's going to end up with the 'Mania match anyway, have him win here and then give Kane the rub in 2001. This outweighs McMahon 'winning' the ECW title in the sacrelige stakes, as the Royal Rumble has far more prestige than that belt ever did in WWE.