The Royal Rumble is one of the marquee shows of the WWE calendar every year. WWE has placed a lot of stock into the event and the Royal Rumble is the unofficial kickoff of the road to Wrestlemania. Many times, storylines that begin at the Royal Rumble event carry over onto the biggest show of the year and fans have every reason in the world to be excited. However, not every year produces a Rumble winner who the fans embrace. Many times, WWE books a winner who makes absolutely no sense or is someone that the fans do not see as a main event guy. With the Rumble being held in very high regards, fans expect major players to be involved in the finish and emerge as the ultimate victors. Guys like Kurt Angle, CM Punk, Chris Jericho, and Randy Savage never won Royal Rumbles but somehow the members of our list did. They have been included for numerous reasons: Either they were too low on the card to justify the Rumble win, they didn't connect with fans after their victory, the match itself was terrible, or the booking was so stupid that the fans hated it. With Roman Reigns having ticked off a large portion of the audience with his win at the 2015 Rumble, we thought we would present you with the worst Rumble winners in history.
10. Lex Luger And Bret Hart - 1994
At the 1994 Royal Rumble, the WWE tried something that it never attempted before in its history: It had two winners of the Royal Rumble. One of them was Lex Luger, a recent WCW castoff who had joined the WWF with Vince McMahon hoping he could turn Lex into the next coming of Hulk Hogan. A recent main event push to a world title match at Summerslam 1993 resulted in a countout victory over Yokozuna but no world title. McMahon was trying to determine if Luger deserved another shot at the title at Wrestlemania X or if Luger's time in the WWF's main event scene was nearly finished. On the other side, you had Bret "The Hitman" Hart. Hart was a former world champion and crowd favorite thanks to his awesome in-ring ability and ability to have great matches with anyone in the company. Bret was being considered for another at the title but Vince couldn't decide whether to pull the trigger or not. So, in a situation where Vince was forced to decide to choose between the Hulk Hogan clone and the small but talented Canadian wrestler, Vince did what he thought was best for business. He choose both of them. In one of the weirdest finishes to the Rumble in history, Luger and Hart eliminated Fatu and Shawn Michaels before turning their attention to each other. Both men tumbled over the top rope and hit the floor "at the same time" (actually, Luger clearly hit first based on replay). The WWF did a little experimenting, announcing both guys as winners and then gauging crowd reaction to each wrestler to see who the crowd favored. Clearly, the crowd was a fan of Bret Hart. While it may have been an interesting social experiment, having co-winners for the Royal Rumble was a fairly stupid idea since it went against everything the Rumble stood for. A convoluted coin toss would be held later and Hart would wrestle twice at Wrestlemania X before capturing the world title from Yokozuna.
9. Big John Studd - 1989
Going into the first Royal Rumble broadcast on pay-per-view, there were very high expectations of the WWF. In 1989, Hulkamania was running wild and Vince McMahon was trying to build interest heading into Wrestlemania V where the Mega Powers would explode. So it made almost zero sense when Big John Studd captured the victory in the marquee matchup of the evening. The main storyline of the match revolved around Hogan's participation in the match and Ted DiBiase's number situation. You see, back then wrestlers used to draw their numbers during backstage segments, leading to some awesome character development based on their reactions. Ted DiBiase drew his number and immediately started to throw his money around to orchestrate a trade. Right before the Rumble, DiBiase was suddenly very, very happy if not slightly lighter in the wallet. As for the match itself, everything was building to Hogan making his entrance and, when he did, he cleaned out the ring, dumping guys left and right and sending the audience into a frenzy. That all went fine until the Twin Towers (Akeem and Big Bossman) started to double-team Hogan and eliminated him with zero fanfare. Think about the way Big Show and Kane eliminated Dolph Ziggler in 2015 and that's how Hogan was dumped. To say the crowd was not happy would be an understatement. However, there was still DiBiase who was revealed to have purchased the coveted #30 spot. He joined a lame final four consisting of himself, Studd, Rick Martel, and Akeem. You would expect DiBiase to grab the win to build some heel heat but nope, instead Studd dominated and tossed the heels, winning the Royal Rumble to the thrill of absolutely no one. Instead, you could have planted the seeds for Wrestlemania V by having Randy Savage win after dumping Hogan while he was distracted, showing a heel side that everyone knew Savage had already.
8. John Cena - 2013
When John Cena won his first Royal Rumble back in 2008, the Cena backlash had not yet reached the level it would hit in 2013. Older fans began to get tired of having John Cena and his Superman-like character being shoved down their throats. For years, it seemed like the odds would be stacked against Cena and he would overcome them because he was John Cena and he never gives up and he rises above hate and all that other stuff. In 2013, the wrestling landscape was changing or at least trying to be changed by fans who were sick of Cena and his stranglehold on the main event. They dreaded the idea of Cena winning the Royal Rumble that year, especially with it being a well-known fact that the Rock was going to win the world title from CM Punk to set up Cena-Rock II at Wrestlemania. Fans were also smart enough to know that there was no way Cena was going to lose to the Rock twice in a row, so it was obvious Cena was headed for another world title run. To make it worse, crowd favorites Chris Jericho and Dolph Ziggler both went over 40 minutes in the match before being eliminated, angering the crowd and not helping WWE's cause. The match came down to John Cena and Ryback as the final two. Ryback had been gaining momentum with a Goldberg-like streak of wins and recently was screwed out of the WWE title by a crooked referee against CM Punk. He was hot in the audience's eyes but not quite ready for the main event so, because Rock-Cena II was happening whether we wanted to see it or not, Cena eliminated Ryback and won his second Royal Rumble. That, of course, led to Cena defeating the Rock in East Rutherford, NJ at Wrestlemania XXIX in one of those finishes that no one outside of Vince McMahon wanted to see.
7. Sheamus - 2012
For the 25th edition of the Royal Rumble, WWE presented one of the best title matches and Rumble matches in recent history. Dolph Ziggler challenged CM Punk for the WWE title in a fantastic match that had the crowd absolutely rabid and showcased both men's talents in a very positive manner. It was the first real tease of Dolph being in the main event and Punk made him look like a million dollars. However, as for the Rumble match itself, it was one of the better booked in recently memory and featured a number of entertaining segments and effective use of the participants. Kofi Kingston stood out for his ability to avoid elimination by walking on his hands and all three ringside announcers participated as well. The final four of the match consisted of Sheamus, Randy Orton, Chris Jericho, and the Big Show. Since no one has bought show as a threat to any world title since about 2000, he was eliminated followed by Randy Orton. Jericho and Sheamus proceeded to have a very good five minute mini-match where both guys teased eliminations on multiple occasions. Eventually, Sheamus eliminated Jericho and won his first Royal Rumble. However, as good as the match was, the winner was less than stellar. Sheamus did not go on to headline Wrestlemania as stated in the advertisements and, as a matter of fact, his match was actually the very first on the show as he defeated Daniel Bryan in less than 20 seconds for the world heavyweight championship. This managed to upset fans because Bryan was a crowd favorite despite being booked as a heel. His Randy Savage-like relationship with AJ Lee had entertained crowds for months and being squashed by Sheamus only made him a bigger babyface in the eyes of the fans. Overall, it wasn't a very effective use of the Rumble winner even if he was success in his title quest.
6. Randy Orton - 2009
The entire point of 2008 into 2009 was to make Randy Orton look like the biggest star in the history of the industry. Despite repetitive matchups and the act that he looks like he's doing long division in his head when staring out into the crowd, Orton had the proverbial rocket strapped to his back in 2008. He led his own stable known as Legacy alongside Ted DiBiase Jr. and Cody Rhodes. Once the Royal Rumble rolled around, it looked as though Orton would be the clear winner. Naturally, the Rumble started off strong with the token midcard guys working a good series of spots before it started getting bogged down by the usual "giants" towards the middle. Along the way, Orton united with Rhodes and DiBiase and fought off basically the entire roster. While WWE should be given credit for actually weaving a storyline into the Rumble, the entire thing was completely predictable and was really hurt by the lack of star power past entrant number 15. After Big Show entered at #30, it morphed into a standard battle royal and all the drama was completely sucked out of the arena. The final four consisted of Orton, DiBiase, Rhodes, and Triple H. Honestly, if you couldn't see the finish coming from a mile away then you had no business being a wrestling fan. Triple H managed to dump the two henchmen but Orton eliminated Hunter immediately after and earned a trip to Wrestlemania, ending a rather dull and lackluster Royal Rumble. As has been the case in recent years, Orton completely choked away his Wrestlemania opportunity, losing to Triple H in the main event of Wrestlemania XXV in a match that was far overshadowed by the Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels bout.
5. Alberto Del Rio - 2011
Here's one that WWE wishes they could have back. In all fairness to Alberto Del Rio, the guy is a great worker and really embraced his heel character during his run in WWE. For whatever reason, WWE just didn't throw the machine behind Del Rio and he sputtered out after too many failed pushes. In 2011, Del Rio was heating up as a heel but really didn't have the crowd heat or the perception to be a Royal Rumble winner. In hindsight, CM Punk probably should have been tapped as the winner here we all know that Vince McMahon was never a huge fan of Punk's, especially early in his career. Punk did end up lasting 35 minutes in the Rumble itself but failed to win the match. 2011 also featured the first time (and hopefully last time) that the Rumble featured 40 men instead of the traditional 30. This led to a parade of jobbers being fed to the upper card talents in the Rumble and some slow portions that really dragged the match down. Speaking of jobbers, somehow Santino Marella managed to be the final competitor in the ring alongside Del Rio. Santino had been tossed between the ropes and lay on the floor as Del Rio managed to eliminate Randy Orton, thinking he had won the match. As Santino climbed back into the ring, wrestling fans actually wondered out loud if WWE would be dumb enough to actually allow Santino Freaking Marella to win the Royal Rumble. Thankfully, Del Rio avoided Santino's jobber offense and eliminated him, winning the Rumble to the silence of an apathetic crowd. Things didn't get any better at Wrestlemania XXVII, one of the worst Wrestlemania cards in history. Del Rio, despite being advertised as winning the Rumble and therefore "main eventing" Wrestlemania, wrestled in the opening match against Edge in his retirement match. At the time, we didn't know it was going to be Edge's retirement match but still, it was equally puzzling because Del Rio choked and lost to Edge. Then WWE turned around and gave Del Rio the Money in the Bank briefcase, thus rendering his Rumble win completely pointless.
4. Rey Mysterio - 2006
In the aftermath of Eddie Guerrero's tragic and untimely death, Rey Mysterio was pushed to the moon on the Smackdown brand and dedicated the Royal Rumble to his late friend. Proving that Guerrero still had a sense of humor, Mysterio drew #1 in the Royal Rumble which, in this rare instance, did not serve as the main event of the pay-per-view (which was Kurt Angle vs. Mark Henry), showing the lack of faith that Vince had in Mysterio as a Rumble winner. The Rumble itself featured a weak lineup showcasing such superstars as Sylvan Grenier, Eugene, Jonathan Coachman, Tatanka, Orlando Jordan, and Trevor Murdoch. Mysterio set a new Rumble record for longevity and actually the #2 participant, Triple H, lasted until the final four as well in a neat booking bit. Mysterio managed to toss out Orton to win the Rumble, lasting over an hour in the ring and booking himself a trip to Wrestlemania. Mysterio would go on to defeat Randy Orton and Kurt Angle in a triple threat match at Wrestlemania 22 to win the Smackdown world title and became one of the smallest champions in WWE history. Unfortunately for Rey, Vince McMahon had absolutely zero confidence in him as a champion. We all know that Vince is infatuated with big wrestlers and Mysterio was the exact opposite of that. Interviews with former Smackdown writers Court Bauer and Alex Greenfield revealed that they wanted Rey booked as a world-beater, someone who overcomes the odds thanks to athleticism and speed. Vince McMahon disagreed. What resulted was a very lackluster title run that really went nowhere and Rey was shuffled back down to the midcard shortly thereafter.
3. Roman Reigns - 2015
Yes, he's probably high on the list because the wound is still fresh. At this past Royal Rumble, Roman Reigns managed to anger the entire city of Philadelphia (and most of the WWE fanbase) by capturing the 2015 Royal Rumble and, with it, a ticket to meet Brock Lesnar at Wrestlemania XXXI. To say that the crowd reacted negatively to Reign's victory would be the understatement of the year. Much like the Pittsburgh crowd the year before, Reign's victory was tainted because he was not who the fans wanted to see win the match. Despite Daniel Bryan being the most over person in the match, Bryan was booked only to last a short while at the very beginning of the Rumble before being cleanly eliminated and send packing to avoid distracting from Reign's win. Once Bryan was eliminated, it was way too obvious who was going to win the match and the crowd viciously turned on it. Two of the final four consisted of Reigns and Rusev, who at least were new superstars who could possibly be main event players and thus deserved that spot. However, the other two were Kane and the Big Show. What is this, 2001? Neither Kane or Big Show has been a legitimate main event threat in years but, since Vince loves big guys, they were given the honor of unceremoniously eliminating crowd favorites Dean Ambrose and Dolph Ziggler. Vince might as well have walked onto the entrance ramp and given the crowd the finger. To show how bad the situation actually was, Reigns suffered a beatdown from Big Show and Kane after their elimination, causing the Rock to make the save...and he was booed. That's right, WWE's booking was so terrible and so roundly rejected by one of wrestling biggest cities that they booed one of the biggest superstars of all-time out of the building. Only time will tell how terrible Reign's win actually was but, unless something drastic happens, Wrestlemania XXXI might not be a pretty sight.
2. Batista - 2014
When the Pittsburgh crowd entered the Consol Energy Center in January of 2014, they had one thing on their minds: Daniel Bryan. Thus, they ushered in a new era for WWE...an era where the crowd can hijack a show and change booking. Bryan wrestled in the opening match against Bray Wyatt and received a hero's welcome. He and Wyatt had a tremendous match that had the crowd on their feet but, unfortunately for Bryan, he lost to the cult leader. However, the crowd was not worried. There was still the Royal Rumble match and even though Bryan was announced as not participating in the match, everyone knew that meant he would definitely be in the match and win the title shot at Wrestlemania. The crowd then turned its venom onto the title match between John Cena and Randy Orton, loudly vocalizing their displeasure at seeing that match for the 10,000th time. The crowd chants were "Boring!", "End this match!", and, most insulting, "We want Divas!". Finally, the Wyatt family interfered and caused a no contest, allowing the crowd to chant "Thank you, Wyatts!" in one final insult. Once the Rumble itself started, it was a bloodbath and not in the good, wrestling way. CM Punk entered at #1 and his presence cooled off the crowd just slightly but not for long. Soon enough, they were chanting Daniel Bryan's name loud and clear for everyone at home to hear. It was impossible to ignore and it was chanted with great anger at the WWE officials. With the returning Batista rumored to win the contest, the crowd began jeering and booing Batista's every move even though he was supposed to be the conquering babyface. Finally, the countdown began for the #30 entrant and every member of the crowd stood up, ready to blow the roof off of the arena if Bryan made a surprise entrance. And it was Rey Mysterio. Probably for the first time in his entire career, Mysterio's entrance was greeted with a chorus of boos unlike anything heard before. This crowd was legitimately upset at the WWE for not giving them what they wanted. With the winner of the match obvious, the crowd completely turned on the Rumble and WWE, calling them out for not listening to their fanbase. When Batista finally won in a foregone conclusion, the crowd absolutely destroyed him. Batista tried to celebrate with fans but was greeted by hand gestures and insults. Batista actually seemed put off by the treatment and flipped members of the audience off on his way to the back. That night changed the course of WWE and actually caused Vince to change the planned main event of Batista vs. Randy Orton to a triple threat including Daniel Bryan. Batista would leave a short time later, frustrated with what may be his final WWE run.
1. Vince McMahon - 1999
It would take a monumental effort to book a worse Royal Rumble winner than Roman Reigns or Batista but the 1999 edition of the show managed to pull it off. That's right, the WWF decided to let Vince McMahon win the Rumble. It the midst of the Attitude Era and the legendary Austin-McMahon feud, the Royal Rumble looked to be another chapter in their story. When Vince used his power to make Steve Austin #1 in the match, commissioner Shawn Michaels countered by making Vince McMahon #2. Austin should have wiped the floor with McMahon, the non-wrestler, and faced his wrath later especially since McMahon offered $100,000 to whoever eliminated Stone Cold. What happened instead was far, far worse than anyone could have imagined. Instead, Austin tossed McMahon through the middle ropes and chased him through the crowd and into an arena bathroom where McMahon's Corporation stable beat him down and sent him to the hospital. McMahon remained out of the Rumble the entire time as well, even doing commentary while the other competitors were wrestling. In any other year, two guys leaving for this length of time would result in their elimination but this is Vince Russo we are talking about. You see, Russo wants McMahon in the match until the very end but it's not believable for him to last the entire hour. So, instead of scraping that idea because it's freaking stupid, he rewrites the rules of the match to let it happen without McMahon wrestling. The Rumble then became a parade of jobbers until around #15 but really everyone was just waiting for the inevitable Austin return. Even Kane, who was not old and useless at the time, eliminated himself because mental hospital workers chased him out of the ring. Yes, that was a thing that actually happened. Finally, the camera cut to the back to see Austin returning to the arena after hijacking an ambulance and charging the ring. Austin cleared the ring and left a final four of himself, McMahon, Big Bossman, and D-Lo Brown. Seriously, the Bossman and D-Lo? Did anyone think they would have a chance? After Bossman and Brown's easy eliminations, Austin dragged McMahon from his commentary position back into the ring. At that moment, the Rock appeared and yelled at Austin from the ramp. Like an idiot, Austin started yelling back, allowing Vince to dump the distracted Stone Cold and win the absolute worst Rumble of all-time.