10 Worst WWE SummerSlam Main Events Ever

When The Undertaker faced The Undertaker...

By Jamie Kennedy /

SummerSlam 2015 is right around the corner, and already people are getting excited to see Brock Lesnar tangle again with The Undertaker. That's understandable, because 'Taker doesn't really perform outside of WrestleMania these days, and the bout will surely help SummerSlam feel like a bigger deal. Traditionally, WWE used to put a lot of focus on the Summer Pay-Per-View. Before 1995, SummerSlam was one of few PPV events to take place annually. Joined by 'Mania, the Royal Rumble, Survivor Series and - by 1993 - King Of The Ring, SummerSlam was a huge deal. These days, it arguably means significantly less, but WWE still like to trumpet the show as a huge part of the calendar. Maybe on August 23rd, 2015, it will feel like it again. There's no way Lesnar vs. Undertaker can fail to be a dramatic affair, but it would be the first time a hot match on paper failed to live up to the hype at SummerSlam. Some of the choices on this list may seem controversial, but it's important to note that their inclusion doesn't necessarily mean that they're bad matches. Instead, they're simply some of the worst main events to take place at SummerSlam, and not as good as many others.

Advertisement

10. Booker T vs. The Rock (2001)

Starting off with a controversial choice, Booker T vs. The Rock wasn't a bad match. In fact, both Booker and The Rock had good chemistry together, and created an enjoyable bout. The main event of SummerSlam 2001 is simply included on this list for one reason, it had a really dumb finish that did nothing to help the whole 'Invasion' angle. In many ways, there's an argument to be made that by the time SummerSlam came around, the WCW/ECW 'Invasion' of the WWF was dead in the water anyway. However, it certainly didn't help when The Rock defeated Booker T to become the WCW World Champion. How was this supposed to aid the idea that World Championship Wrestling was a threat to the WWF? It didn't, and along with some other matches on the card (DDP and Kanyon being decimated by The Undertaker and Kane, as one example) it really killed the whole 'Invasion' deal dead. Booker T was portrayed as someone who desperately needed the help of Shane McMahon to fend off The Rock, and the match itself - whilst fine - felt more like a TV main event than Pay-Per-View.

9. Mankind vs. Steve Austin vs. Triple H (1999)

The WWF was red-hot in 1999, but looking back on the 'Attitude Era' can often provide some fascinating insight. Current stars, including Dean Ambrose and WWE Hall Of Fame inductee Edge have been fairly critical of the period, feeling it may not have been as great as everyone claims. Whilst Edge notes that creativity was at an all-time high, he says actual wrestling fell by the wayside. Looking at the main event of SummerSlam 1999, it's clear that the promotion were starting to just throw ideas at the wall to see what might stick. Due to the event taking place in Minnesota, former wrestler-turned-announcer, Jesse 'The Body' Ventura was installed as the Special Guest Referee. That may have been a fine idea on paper, but Ventura detracted from the Triple Threat headliner, and things didn't feel as focused as they perhaps should have been. The previous year, Steve Austin and The Undertaker put together a tight contest. It was free of the convoluted feel which plagued the 1999 main event, pitting Austin against Mankind and Triple H. Mankind would come out on top to win the title, but it would have been better to see him do so in a bout with a better flow. The story was far too busy going into this one, and the addition of Ventura as referee was unnecessary.

8. The Ultimate Warrior vs. Rick Rude (1990)

The Ultimate Warrior was Vince McMahon's hand-picked successor to Hulk Hogan. At WrestleMania VI, then-Intercontinental Champion, Warrior defeated Hogan to bag the WWF Heavyweight Title, and it seemed set that he'd lead the promotion through the new decade of the 90's. Unfortunately, by the time SummerSlam came along just months later, Warrior was already struggling. Fans weren't as convinced by the new champion, certainly when compared to how people treated Hulk Hogan. The Hulkster consistently came across as the top draw in the company, but Warrior didn't seem to have the same appeal. He was a big star, sure, but not on the level of Hulk. Part of the problem for Warrior was that he was never really given the kind of challengers that his predecessor had. 'Ravishing' Rick Rude was a excellent performer, and few could claim that he didn't belong in the main event mix. A genuinely good heel, the problem with Rude was that The Ultimate Warrior had already beaten him in a rivalry over the Intercontinental Title. Thus, when the pair contested a Steel Cage match at SummerSlam 1990, fans weren't as interested as they should have been. It didn't help that the men didn't see eye-to-eye behind the scenes, stifling their chemistry.

7. The Mega Powers vs. The Mega Bucks (1988)

Whilst the match had a big feel to it, the actual action in the main event of the inaugural SummerSlam Pay-Per-View was sorely lacking. By 1988, Andre The Giant was a shell of the performer he had been earlier in the decade, and the focus seemed to be more on the love-hate relationship between Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage. At SummerSlam '88, 'The Mega Powers' (Hogan and Savage) met 'The Mega Bucks' (Andre and 'Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase). Fans were interested to see what might happen during the bumper headliner, but Andre's limitations and the underlying story between Hulk and 'Macho Man' overshadowed the event. Incredibly, in the first 4 SummerSlam shows, there were 3 tag-team main events. This wasn't the worst of them (more on that later), but people still couldn't shake the feeling that things should have been better. Savage and DiBiase were excellent, dynamic wrestlers, Hogan was a huge star and Andre had the intimidating size and history. Sadly, those elements didn't combine quite as well as they maybe should have.

6. Team WWE vs. The Nexus (2010)

Legendary announcer Jim Ross once remarked that it was "stupid" to see John Cena take a DDT on a concrete floor, then recover to win a match within just a few minutes. That one spot sums up a botched and rushed storyline, the saga of 'The Nexus'. Just a few short months after they'd exploded onto the scene in June, the group were cut off at the knees in the main event of SummerSlam 2010. 'Team WWE', comprising of Cena, Edge, Chris Jericho, Bret Hart, John Morrison, R-Truth and Daniel Bryan, faced Nexus at the event. Bryan had previously been a member of the renegade group, but had been released by WWE after choking ring announcer Justin Roberts with a tie and spitting on John Cena during an earlier angle. His involvement in this WWE squad therefore made little sense. As if that wasn't enough, The Nexus were forbidden from looking like killer heels during the bout. The match went over 35 minutes, which would have been fine had the heels been given ample time to dominate towards the end. Instead, John Cena made a cartoon-like comeback from the aforementioned DDT, and overcame the odds. Within just 2 months, WWE had killed The Nexus idea.

5. Yokozuna vs. Lex Luger (1993)

Much like The Ultimate Warrior, Vince McMahon wanted to make 'American Hero' Lex Luger his next pet project to follow the pattern of success laid down by Hulk Hogan. In similar fashion to Warrior, Luger couldn't remove himself from the shadow of Hulk, and somewhat bombed in the role. The finish to his SummerSlam 1993 main event against Yokozuna really didn't help. Going on a lengthy, cross-county tour in a bus called the 'Lex Express', Luger rallied support for the encounter. Fans were behind him, wanting to buy into the WWF hype machine, which had been on overload since Luger hit Yoko with a Body Slam in July. The original plan called for Lex to win the WWF Title at SummerSlam, but somewhere along the line that idea was changed. The whole build to SummerSlam '93 relied on Luger emerging victorious. Slogans such as, 'Can He Be Stopped?' (in reference to Yokozuna) were used as hype, but the answer was no. Even though Lex Luger won by count out on the night, he didn't grab the gold. This was a foolish move by McMahon, Lex needed the big babyface victory here. Sadly, the match itself didn't cut it. Fans were clearly now already more conditioned to watching exciting, wrestling-focused main events featuring Bret Hart.

4. Hulk Hogan & Brutus Beefcake vs. Randy Savage & Zeus (1989)

A vehicle to hype the WWF-produced movie, 'No Holds Barred', the main event of SummerSlam 1989 was a true anomaly. As the villain from the movie, Zeus teamed with a heel Randy Savage to face the combination of Hulk Hogan and Brutus Beefcake. The results were mixed at best, and fairly flat and unbelievable at worst. This was perhaps a sign of where Vince McMahon wanted to take the WWF product in the coming decade of the 1990's. Always seeking out opportunities to promote outside of the professional wrestling bubble, maybe McMahon felt movies were his ticket to the top. They weren't, but that didn't stop SummerSlam '89 from being headlined by a non-wrestler. Zeus tried his best, but he was obviously very limited inside the ring. Hulk Hogan and Brutus Beefcake weren't the men to carry him, because they couldn't sell effectively for his apparent power house offence. Ironically, Savage may have been a better choice to oppose Zeus, because at least he could bump around for the big guy. The SummerSlam '89 main event was a low point of the 80's in the WWF.

3. Diesel vs. 'King' Mabel (1995)

If SummerSlam 1989 was a low point, the 1995 iteration of the event took things to a whole new depth. Running desperately short on headline talent, the company shunted awkward tag-team wrestler, Mabel up the card. The resultant main event at SummerSlam '95 was far from satisfying, and even made reigning champion Diesel look less like a star. Winning the 1995 'King Of The Ring' to a frosty reception, Mabel was slotted into the SummerSlam headline spot opposite Diesel. In shoot interviews since, Kevin Nash has stated he wasn't exactly thrilled by the prospect, because the clumsy Mabel had a reputation for legitimately hurting opponents inside the ring. That was evident when he kicked his legs out from under him, sitting on Nash's spine and bruising him significantly during the contest. According to Nash, so upset was Vince McMahon by Mabel's performance, that he immediately wanted to fire him when he returned to the backstage area. Mabel did manage to keep his job, but his main event career was firmly over. The WWF Title match had been shoddy, and fans were pretty darn quiet throughout.

2. The Undertaker vs. The Undertaker (1994)

Quite why the decision was taken to end SummerSlam 1994 with an ill-conceived Undertaker vs. Undertaker plodder of a match is anyone's guess. Things are made worse by the fact that the incendiary Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart Steel Cage war was relegated to the co-main event spot, that one should have went on last. It really seemed that fans weren't as interested in the 'Taker vs. Fake 'Taker bout as the WWF were. One of the main problems with the match was that it took place during an era when The Undertaker moved slowly. Deliberate movements were a nuance of the character, and his matches often felt like they were about to grind to a halt due to his zombie-like approach. Having another wrestler mimicking his style didn't make for a very exciting spectacle. Nonetheless, the WWF pressed on with their decision to headline with The Undertaker vs. The Undertaker. Ted DiBiase's fake version would be vanquished quickly by Paul Bearer's genuine article, but not quick enough for most people. Even though the 'action' lasted less than 10 minutes, it felt like a lifetime. This was a failed experiment, and a classic example of making the wrong choice to main event.

1. 2-On-3 Handicap Match (1991)

By 1991, the WWF had panicked and brought Hulk Hogan back into the main event picture. The Ultimate Warrior hadn't really worked out as his replacement, and The Hulkster was badly needed back in the frame. At SummerSlam 1991, Warrior and Hogan would team up, but unfortunately, the former came across as little more than back up for the latter. Worse yet, the actual match itself was terrible. Technically, SummerSlam '91 was 'headlined' by the wedding between Randy Savage and Miss. Elizabeth, but that obviously wasn't a match, so this 2-On-3 Handicap stinker takes centre stage. Sid Justice was the Special Guest Referee, but the main reason for the bout being so horrendous was due to who was chosen as Hogan and Warrior's rivals. Sgt. Slaughter, Colonel Mustafa (The Iron Sheik) and General Adnan made up the heel squadron. Of the trio, Slaughter was the one with the most work-rate at the time, which should give some indication as to how much action fans were in store for. Hogan and Warrior emerged as victors, but the 12 minute match felt like it had lasted for hours, and it was a wholly sub-par main event. What other SummerSlam main events would you have placed on this list? Do you agree with the choices here? Let us know down in the comments section!