10 Worst WWE Wrestlers Of 2017

Duds, deadbeats, and donkeys.

By Andy H Murray /

It's difficult to stand out on WWE's crowded roster. The likes of AJ Styles and Cesaro do so through prodigious in-ring talent. For Shinsuke Nakamura and The Miz, it's their electric charisma. Braun Strowman has his 'holy s***' factor, Samoa Joe is genuinely ferocious in the sanitised PG era, and Brock Lesnar's special aura remains intact thanks, in part, to his relaxed working schedule.

Advertisement

Such performers catch the eye for the right reasons, but others? Not so much.

With WWE's working standards higher than ever before, subpar performers have never been so noticeable, and 2017 has been full of duds. Granted, many have suffered from bad booking, but their mere presence on WWE shows has become tedious at best, and unbearable at worst, so lowly is their form.

Note that wrestlers are ranked on performances, not their position in the hierarchy. Curt Hawkins, The Miztourage, Aiden English: they're jobbers, but great in their roles. Jason Jordan was omitted on the strength of his recent ring work. Enzo Amore, the worst pure worker in the company, was saved by his dynamic personality. James Ellsworth barely wrestled.

With those (dis)honourable mentions out of the way, let's examine the worst of the worst...

10. Dana Brooke

Dana Brooke is pure canon fodder.

Advertisement

Called up to the main roster entirely too early in 2016, she has failed to show any real progression in her performances since graduating from NXT. Her promos are stunted and awkward. The ring entrances resembles a WWE 2K18 CAW spamming multiple taunts at once. She's in the roster's bottom 5% when it comes to ring work. Her character? Non-existent.

Once considered a promising-but-green developmental prospect, Brooke has become an anchor on Raw, where she continually drags everyone down around her. She had a listless babyface run at the start of the year, but reverted to villainy without explanation a few weeks later, and has been primarily used as a squash match victim throughout. Tellingly, Dana has won only three televised matches in 2017, two of which came on Main Event.

Every division needs enhancement talent, but Brooke's complete lack of seasoning suggests she isn't even cut out for this role, as she's lacking as both a bumper and seller. At her worst, Dana has been difficult to watch in 2017. She desperately needs another Performance Center stint.

9. Titus O'Neil

It's fitting that Titus O'Neil has repeatedly tried to recruit Dana Brooke into his 'Titus Worldwide' group throughout 2017, as the former Prime Time Player has effectively become her male equivalent.

Advertisement

The big man loses constantly. His televised win/loss record currently sits at 5-15, with just two of those victories coming on Raw. He's generally a guy the company only call upon when a more celebrated talent needs a straightforward two-minute win: this is fine, but it doesn't change the fact that even after eight years with WWE, O'Neil remains a big, lumbering stiff.

He started the year attempting to join The New Day in a cringe-worthy micro-story that saw Titus continually rebuffed. From there, O'Neil continued to eek out a meagre jobber-like existence, before recruited the uber talented Apollo Crews to join his weird lower-card cult. The former Uhaa Nation soon became as pointless as O'Neil, and the duo have been directionless since failing to convince Akira Tozawa to align with them over the summer.

But while Crews has a noticeable upside, Titus does not. Now 40-years-old, it's clear that the cumbersome oaf is never going to get any better, so why retain him as an in-ring performer?

8. Big Cass

It'd be ghoulish to call the torn ACL that brought Big Cass' ghastly 2017 to a premature end in August a good thing, but it may prove to be a blessing in disguise for the troubled giant. Yes, he's missing a huge chunk of his athletic prime, but it has forcibly dragged him away from a godawful storyline that had badly exposed his shortcomings, and rendered big chunks of Raw unwatchable.

Advertisement

Cass vs. Enzo was the pits. The matches were universally atrocious, and things got even worse when Big Show entered the picture, with the two seven-footers working a complete borefest at SummerSlam. It was abundantly clear that Cass was nothing without his livewire sidekick. The heel run flopped, and must be recalibrated when Cass eventually returns to the ring, unless WWE want to tank his career entirely.

It's too early to write him off completely, but Cass accomplished nothing in 2017. Though lightyears ahead of their singles bouts, his early-year tag work alongside Enzo saw them cast only as supporting players, and offered little hope for upward momentum. Booked like a fool and woefully overexposed, he'd probably love to put the past 12 months behind him.

7. Dolph Ziggler

While last year's Intercontinental Title feud with The Miz came close to reviving the long-suffering Dolph Ziggler's career, 2017 saw him dive right back into 'get off my television' territory.

Advertisement

Still an elite athlete and a great bumper, Ziggler is an unwanted presence on SmackDown's midcard, with only a minuscule fraction of his once mighty fanbase remaining. Sadly, the bookers are only partly to blame.

The 2017 version of Dolph Ziggler performers very much like a man who gave up giving a f*** several years ago. His disinterest is palpable, and it's hard to shake the feeling that he's mailing it in until his contract winds down, and he's finally free from the company's grasp. On one hand, the volume of garbage creative have dumped on him over the years makes this understandable, but he's still a professional. Ziggler should be better than this.

Booked like a dweeb throughout his feud with Kalisto and Apollo Crews, Dolph needlessly went 50/50 with Shinsuke Nakamura at Backlash, burying the newcomer's momentum. Then came the historically bad impersonation gimmick, and another go-nowhere feud with Bobby Roode. He's set to close 2017 with a United States title shot at Clash Of Champions. Fortunately, victory seems an impossibility.

6. Tamina

She's usually booked on the periphery, but Tamina has snuck back into focus in recent weeks.

Advertisement

Pushed into the spotlight in a heatless monster vs. monster showdown with Nia Jax at Survivor Series, she proceeded to wrestle SmackDown Women's Champion Charlotte Flair earlier this week, delivering 'The Queen's' most tedious singles match in recent memory. Both spots highlighted her as the division's worst full-time competitor, and made it increasingly difficult to understand why she's even still around.

Tamina had been absent since May 2016 when she returned to SmackDown this past April, but drew cricket chirps from the live crowd. She has generated precisely zero interest since then, working primarily as a tag match spot-filler prior to recruiting Lana as her manager, though 'The Ravishing Russian' has little impact on her fortunes.

There's nothing to Tamina's act whatsoever. The Jimmy Snuka situation means WWE can't even push her as a second generation star, and she rarely looks convincing, even as a silent bodyguard. Nia Jax isn't consistently delivering on Raw either, but she's worlds away from her woeful SmackDown counterpart.

5. Kane

Assuming that fans actually want to see Kane in a featured program in 2017 is one of the most tone-deaf assertions WWE have made all year. He has only been around for a few weeks, but 'The Big Red Machine' has continually stunk Raw up since bursting through the ring on October 16th, and rather than enhancing Braun Strowman, Kane's feud with the former Wyatt Family man is only dragging the new generation's monster down.

Advertisement

Old, slow, and out of shape, Kane has devolved into self-parody. Yes, he's one of the best 'big men' of all time, and he deserves boatloads of respect for suffering through so many atrocious storylines over the years, but time passed him by a long time ago.

Corporate Kane should've been his death knell. We don't need Mayor Glenn Jacobs donning his mask, burying Finn Balor, and halting Strowman's momentum. 'Sideshow act' show be his ceiling in 2017, yet here we are.

The best we can hope is that his eventual match with Braun is as good as 'The Monster Among Men's' early-year Big Show bouts, but given how cumbersome Kane looked against Balor and in TLC's main event, it's hard to see that happening. Get ready for a one-star special.

4. Lana

While attempting to push Lana as an in-ring competitor wasn't an inherently bad idea in itself, WWE's execution was a complete disaster that buried 'The Ravishing Russian,' sending her scampering back to her old managerial role with her stock lower than ever.

Advertisement

It started at Money In The Bank. Her and Naomi wrestled an awkward, disjointed bout for the SmackDown Women's Title, with Lana losing. Bizarrely, WWE then decided the best course of action was to have the managerial wunderkind fall in increasingly embarrassing fashion. This culminated in a brutal 10-second loss to the champ in July, and while Lana worked a handful of other bouts throughout the summer, the Naomi burials effectively tanked her singles career.

The experiment failed, and Lana's complete lack of seasoning was woefully exposed. Perhaps she'll develop into a functional in-ringer competitor someday, but it won't be anytime soon, as she's now stuck managing the listless Tamina on the midcard.

Regardless, Lana remains active on the house show circuit, primarily fighting on the losing side in multi-person tag bouts. Perhaps she wouldn't be on our list at all if WWE had given her this experience beforehand.

3. Jinder Mahal

Much has been written on Jinder Mahal's failings as a top guy over the past few months, but while 'The Maharaja's' harshest critics tend to go overboard in their appraisal of his WWE Title run, their core arguments have merit.

Advertisement

Jinder's skill-set is full of holes. He deserves credit for legitimately carrying himself like a big deal, but that image is shattered the moment his ring entrance ends. The former WWE Champion is a dry, unengaging talker, who rarely alters his tone or cadence, spewing each repetitive promo with identical delivery to the last. This is far from his greatest shortcoming, though.

No other WWE Superstar works a style as basic as Mahal's. He's a slow, ponderous '80s-esque territorial heel who has somehow washed up in the hyper-athletic modern era. This would've been fine 30 years ago, but it's 2017: people want action, not restholds and sloppy slams, with Jinder's stop-start style more effective at sending audiences to sleep than drawing heel heat.

It took the great AJ Styles to finally drag an acceptable match out of Mahal on November 7th. His reign was characterised by legitimately terrible pay-per-view bouts, and if we're lucky, his upcoming rematch with 'The Phenomenal One' will be his last.

2. Randy Orton

Randy Orton is an excellent professional wrestler.

Advertisement

Smooth, slick, and safe between the ropes, he carries himself like a megastar, and he's got one of the most pop-worthy finishers in the company. He's Vince McMahon's ideal main eventer, and while never flashy, he's more than capable of delivering a great match when the mood takes him.

That said, Orton has consistently been one of the worst things about WWE in 2017, producing the most miserable 12-month period of his career.

Randy started brightly enough. His allegiance with Bray Wyatt was intriguing, and he delivered a great bout with Luke Harper at Elimination. Things soon took a turn for the worse, though. Burning Sister Abigail's burial ground was laughable, WrestleMania 33's bug match was comical, and the House Of Horrors was a WrestelCrap-worthy bulls*** baguette that all but guaranteed 'The Viper's' inclusion on lists like this.

The historically bad Wyatt feud ended, and Orton drifted into another stinker of a storyline. His and Jinder Mahal's promos were tired, and their matches putrid, with the Punjabi Prison's needless revival sitting comfortable alongside the House Of Horrors as one of the year's worst. From there, Randy cruised through internet darling Rusev, featured on SmackDown's Survivor Series team, and will close the year wrestling Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens at Clash Of Champions, where he'll presumably sleepwalk through another soulless showing.

1. Bray Wyatt

Randy Orton's partner in crime for much of 2017, Bray Wyatt really came into his own as WWE's worst performer in the year's second half - a period that has firmly established 'The Eater Of Worlds' as the promotion's most ghastly character.

Advertisement

Having already covered the Orton feud, let's shine a light on Wyatt's post-'Viper' horrors instead.

His brief rivalry with Seth Rollins was entirely uneventful, but Bray's next storyline was a perfect microcosm of everything wrong with his act. The Finn Balor story started with the rambling swamp wizard delivering his textbook 'cryptic' warnings. Wyatt actually won the first act, defeating the Irishman on Raw, then covering him with a gloopy blood-like substance, but reverted to type at SummerSlam. Bray lost in Brooklyn, then fell to Balor again at TLC, and was all set to battle his 'Demon' as Sister Abigail before illness struck, robbing us the sight of Wyatt wrestling in drag.

The former WWE Champion's promos are tedious and nonsensical, his matches are never anything better than average, and his supernatural powers lost their edge along time ago. In 2013, he was dangerous, edgy, and intoxicating: four years later, he's a hokey, babbling mess. Nobody's ever elevated through working with him, and his chronic losing habit shows no signs of easing up.

Bray Wyatt is finished. Thanks, 2017.

Advertisement