10 Wrestler Introductions You Don't Remember

From Paul Wight to Batista, which wrestlers made highly forgettable first impressions?

By Ryan Berglund /

They say in life that first impressions are everything, and that is especially true in the world of professional wrestling. If you don't believe so, just ask Karrion Kross, The Shockmaster or The Gobbledy Gooker how devastating a poor introduction can be.

Advertisement

On the flip side, a good debut can be the catalyst for a successful run in WWE. The likes of The Shield, John Cena, Kevin Owens and countless others have arrived, made an immediate impact, and gone on to do great things. While some stars debut and immediately have a gimmick that sticks, many wrestlers show up with a poor gimmick and quickly transition to their legacy-building persona. Many fans will remember Kane's beginnings as Isaac Yankem, Steve Austin as The Ringmaster, or even Becky Lynch as an Irish dancer down in NXT.

Despite this, there are several wrestlers whose original gimmick fans do not remember. Whether it be as a wedding planner, hair dresser, or simply a fan in the crowd, there are numerous forgettable beginnings for memorable WWE superstars. With that in mind, here are ten wrestler introductions that you likely don't remember.

10. Paul Wight - Andre's Son

1302756

The man known as Paul Wight or The Big Show is known for his record number of face and heel turns throughout his legendary career. In his 27-year tenure across WCW, WWE and now AEW, Wight has largely kept the same gimmick of The World's Largest Athlete. However, back in 1995 he was brought into WCW as The Giant with a surprising backstory.

Advertisement

The Giant was the latest member of Kevin Sullivan's Dungeon of Doom, a faction created solely to take down WCW Heavyweight Champion Hulk Hogan. At Slamboree 1995, while Hogan was making his was to the ring, there stood The Giant at the top of the entranceway. The WCW audience was told that not only was this man a literal giant, but that he was the son of legendary wrestler Andre the Giant.

Given the size of The Giant, and his kayfabe connections to the Hulkster's greatest rival, it was no surprise when Sullivan's newest addition won the WCW Heavyweight Title from Hogan at Halloween Havoc in Wight's his first match - albeit by disqualification. Despite being a part of WCW for nearly four years, his connections to Andre the Giant were quietly dropped from his character, with nothing in the way of an explanation.

9. Rosa Mendes - Beth Phoenix Intern

Despite never winning championship gold in WWE, fans may be shocked to realize that Rosa Mendes managed to have nearly a decade-long run under Vince McMahon's employ. After coming up short in the 2006 Diva Search, she signed a contract with the company, allowing her to continue training.

Advertisement

After two years in developmental, Rosa made her first appearance as a planted fan in the crowd. She was shown heavily on camera, with a sign showing her support for Women's Champion Beth Phoenix. After several weeks of this, Santino Marella, Beth's boyfriend, announced that she was the couple's biggest fan and had front row seats for many of Beth's matches.

After jumping the guardrail to attack Melina, who was feuding with Phoenix over the Women's Title, Rosa was banned from WWE by Stephanie McMahon. Santino found a way around this by hiring Rosa Mendes as the group's intern. The pattern of attacking Phoenix's rivals continued into the new year, even after The Glamazon lost her championship.

After Beth took some time off, Mendes shifted into a role as the new valet of Carlito, quietly ending her association to Phoenix and Santino. This kickstarted Rosa's run of managing a large number of WWE Superstars throughout her time with the company.

8. John Morrison - Eric Bischoff's Assistant

If there is one thing that John Hennigan is known for throughout the wrestling community, it is his constant changing of his ring name depending on the company he is working for. In the last 12 months alone, he was gone by his John Hennigan, John Morrison, Johnny Caballero, Johnny Superstar, Johnny WrestleCon, and most recently Johnny Elite.

Advertisement

Despite his many ring names, the man has largely kept the same gimmick of a wrestler with a parkour background and a knack for highflying. That was not his first gimmick under Vince McMahon's employment however, as after the second season of Tough Enough, Hennigan was brought in to be Raw General Manager Eric Bischoff's assistant. It was here where his constant name changes began, as in his first three weeks on WWE's flagship show, he was presented as Johnny Blaze, then Johnny Spade, and finally Johnny Nitro.

While obviously a play on Bischoff's previous show, this was the name that stuck for WWE's newest roster member. Johnny Nitro served in this capacity for only two months, as after losing his job in a match to Eugene, he would be sent back down to developmental. Despite leaving the main roster, when Johnny would return several months later, he would hold onto the Nitro name, now as a part of MNM.

7. Alicia Fox - Wedding Planner

Back in the summer of 2008, the relationship between Edge and Vickie Guerrero was one of the largest storylines on SmackDown. The Rated-R Superstar had used his relationship with the blue brand's General Manager to maintain his stranglehold on the World Heavyweight Championship for much of the previous year, and the two were soon engaged to be married.

Advertisement

In the month leading up to the wedding, the WWE Universe was introduced to Alicia Fox, the group's wedding planner. For weeks, Fox could be seen alongside Edge and the rest of La Familia going over details of the ceremony. As is often the case in WWE, all their planning was for nought, as the wedding turned into absolute chaos.

While the wedding was going on, Triple H showed up, bringing with him a video of Edge kissing Alicia behind Vickie's back. This of course ruined the wedding, with Guerrero slapping her wedding planner. What could have been the end for Alicia Fox ended up being only the beginning, as at the Great American Bash, Foxy attempted to get involved and help Edge, only to be stopped by Vickie.

Fox was written off television for a few months before ending up on the rebooted ECW brand. Instead of dropping her backstory as a wedding planner, it was explained that she had moved her business to England where she met her latest client, DJ Gabriel, leaving her career as a wedding planner intact in WWE cannon.

6. Reggie - Sommelier

During the pandemic era of WWE, Reggie has found himself as one of the mainstays of WWE television. He has transitioned from the love interest of Nia Jax into one of the constant figures in the 24/7 Title scene, winning the comedy belt four times. These were not his first storylines in WWE however, as he made his debut alongside Carmella, who herself had undergone a recent character overhaul. With the former Princess of Staten Island now 'Untouchable,' she was given a new wrinkle in her character in the form of a sommelier.

Advertisement

Introduced as Reginald Thomas, a wine expert with a French accent to boot, he wpuld be seen backstage during Carmella's quest to win the SmackDown Women's Championship from Sasha Banks. As is often the case, Reginald soon stepped through the curtain, making his in-ring debut against Banks, in a losing effort.

After being fired by Carmella, his name was shortened to Reggie, and his previous sommelier character was retconned. The former Cirque De Solei performer dropped his his French accent, saying he only became a sommelier in order to get his foot in the door of WWE, with no mention of his previous persona since.

5. Kelly Kelly - Solo Stripper

Many fans will remember the ECW act of the Extreme Exposé, comprised of Layla, Brooke, and Kelly Kelly. For months, they were a highlight for fans who had become used to this type of presentation of women on WWE programming. However, this was not Kelly Kelly’s first moment in the spotlight during the second coming of ECW.

Advertisement

At just 19 years old, Kelly debuted on the first episode of ECW on SyFy as an exhibitionist, stripping for the crowd backstage. Despite taking place on ECW, this was still the PG era of WWE, so Mike Knox was introduced as Kelly’s boyfriend, stopping her show before things got too extreme. Kelly’s Exposé became a weekly segment for the revitalized brand, before Kelly found herself in several mix tag matches alongside Knox.

After being dumped by Kelly in favor of CM Punk, Knox attempted to win her back with flowers, before attacking Kelly and taking her out of action. After a brief hiatus, Kelly Kelly returned, forming the iconic Extreme Exposè, before moving to Raw to start her true in-ring career.

4. Mace - Raw Announcer

With this article focusing on previous gimmicks that fans do not remember, the wrestler known as Mace is hoping that fans soon forget his in-ring introduction as a part of RETRIBUTION. As terrible as this faction was, it was not the man known as Brennan Williams' first taste of spotlight in WWE.

Advertisement

In mid-2019, WWE shuffled around their commentary teams, with Raw's desk being occupied by Vic Joseph, Jerry Lawler and the debuting Dio Maddin. While not great right out of the box, Maddin became a solid edition to the commentary team, playing off Lawler and Joseph well.

His time behind the announce desk was short-lived however, as the decision was made for Maddin to return to the Performance Center to continue training. To write him off, he was attacked by WWE Champion Brock Lesnar; being F-5ed through the announce table for defending Lawler against The Beast.

Dio Maddin might have wished he had stayed a commenter, as his next appearance was a part of RETRIBUTION, a faction that lives in infamy in the eyes of the WWE Universe.

3. Carmella - Hairdresser

While the world of professional wrestling is filled with over-the-top characters, many wrestler's debuts for NXT are fairly straightforward. Often the newest addition to the roster is simply presented as the next wrestler trying to prove themselves and earn a spot alongside the best in WWE.

Advertisement

That was far from the case for Carmella, whose first appearances made her seem like the furthest thing from the next star of the black and gold brand. Leading up to NXT Takeover: Fatal 4 Way, Enzo Amore was scheduled to take part in a Hair vs. Hair match against Sylvester Lefort. This prompted Enzo and tag partner Colin Cassidy to visit a hair salon where they linked up with a hairdresser named Carmella. She gave the tag team a hand in gathering a concoction that could easily remove someone's hair.

While Enzo won the match and kept his hair, Carmella re-emerged the following week, telling the duo she had lost her job at the salon due to their antics. 'Mella then forced Enzo and Cass to give her a tryout in front of General Manager William Regal, looking to start her wrestling career.

In the following weeks, Carmella secured a contract with the brand, bringing together one of the most popular trios in the history of NXT.

2. Santino Marella - Italian Fan

Following WrestleMania 23, Intercontinental Champion Umaga was still acting as the heavy for Vince McMahon in the pair's rivalry with Bobby Lashley. Vince had the idea for The Samoan Bulldozer to defend his title, first offering the match to anyone on the roster, before shifting the focus to the Italian crowd. The Chairman would select a random man in the front row who stood out solely for his bright red shoes.

Advertisement

The lucky fella was barely spoke English and gave his name as Santino Marella. After Santino was dominated by Umaga for the early part of this No Holds Barred match, Lashley would appear, cracking the Intercontinental Champion over the head with a steel chair and then hitting a spear. Bobby would throw Marella's lifeless body over Umaga to win the match and the title for the newcomer.

One of the biggest upsets in WWE history would start Marella's eight-year WWE career. He quickly transformed himself from Italian fan to one of the best comedy wrestlers in WWE history. The funniest part of Santino's debut, is that despite being cheered as a hero by the Italian crowd, and keeping his accent throughout his career, WWE never once acknowledged the fact that he is not even Italian.

1. Batista - Deacon

Many fans look at the famed 2002 OVW class of John Cena, Randy Orton, Brock Lesnar and Batista as one of the greatest developmental successes in wrestling history. While the likes of Cena, Orton and Lesnar all were given the superstar treatment from day one, that wasn't the case for The Animal.

Advertisement

Following The Dudley Boyz being separated in the WWE draft, D-Von had adopted a preacher gimmick, now going as Reverend D-Von. Alongside the Reverend was his protégé, Deacon Batista. Wearing a sleeveless suit and a collection box around his neck, Batista looked more like a cartoon villain than WWE's next main event star.

The pairing would last just six months, with Reverend and Deacon arguing more and more before eventually turning on each other. Batista would drop both the Deacon part of his name and his association with D-Von as a whole while beating his mentor in convincing fashion to end their rivalry.

Thankfully, after leaving D-Von behind, Batista would be shifted over to Raw and quickly joined Triple H, Ric Flair and Randy Orton. The foursome formed Evolution, and the rest was history.

Advertisement