10 Wrestlers BANNED From Getting Over

WWE tried to do this with Bryan Danielson THREE separate times (!)

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW's form is uneven, but the promotion is an absolute f*cking godsend and perspective really, really needs to be maintained.

Advertisement

As part of its core philosophy, Tony Khan encourages his talents to get over. This does not always work out, but good on Jon Moxley for putting over Marina Shafir's potential on the Sessions podcast recently, because she has otherwise been stigmatised for her quite inexplicable "You know me...you don't know me!" promo.

An argument could be made that this process could be tightened up to an extent - not to shackle talent but rather to encourage them to focus. Using a recent example, it is impossible to determine whether or not Sammy Guevara is a babyface. This longstanding identity crisis has affected his career. He has world-class heel potential, always did, but seems weirdly intent on playing the wide-eyed dreamer babyface pup role at the exact same time.

This system has allowed MJF to become a World champion and the generational talent he markets himself to be, allowed Hangman Page to experiment and succeed with a bold mental health arc that simply wouldn't have happened in any other major promotion ever, and encouraged Dr. Britt Baker to become one of the funniest wrestlers of her generation. WWE hasn't even attempted that with a women's division talent.

AEW might feel rushed and janky at times, but on the following evidence, the promotion did in fact save pro wrestling in the US...

10. Zack Ryder In Pretty Much Every Respect

The most cynical take is that Vince McMahon only wants to get the people he likes over. It is the hottest take, a rite of passage for a WWE fan almost.

Advertisement

It is also the correct take.

Dante himself could not have penned a more cruel ironic punishment than that to which McMahon sentenced Ryder in 2012. Ryder getting over was not in the plan, and while he was never a great worker and may not have evolved into a main event-level talent with the machine behind him, it's important to put his breakthrough into context. The standard wasn't amazing at the time. Ryder hasn't been mythologised, though it may look that way through a 2023 lens. He hustled, created his vastly influential YouTube series, and fans loved his self-deprecating act.

WWE, and you could almost hear the passive aggressive sigh, "rewarded" him with the United States title before turning him into such a joke that he could never reach the same level again. He was repackaged as an incel, given a slapstick assortment of injuries to sell, but was pushed - into oblivion by Kane!

Booking Kane to push Ryder off the stage was nothing less than a peak Simpsons era Mr. Burns gag. The only difference is that, had Conan O'Brien wrote it, the wheelchair would have spontaneously and inexplicably exploded.

The thing is, the bump Ryder took on his coccyx was probably more painful, for f*ck's sake.

9. Keith Lee's Toned Down Style

It's not difficult to get Keith Lee over. That's essentially a pro wrestling saying.

Advertisement

Yes, he feels cold in AEW at present, as his body catches up to what at times felt like a physically impossible ring style, but with Swerve In Our Glory, Tony Khan pinpointed how best to use this version of the man. They were a great, underrated tag team, a symbiotic force, with each partner complementing the other in fiction and reality. Lee was able to more carefully distribute his still-stunning high spots where Swerve brought the kinetic energy to their matches. Lee can't do what he used to do all of the time, but he is booked to do so, and get himself over, whenever possible.

This was not the case in WWE.

When playing the inscrutably stupid and ill-fitting 'Bearcat' character, Lee was told not to speak with his own super-endearing diction and vocabulary. Per his appearance on Talk Is Jericho, Lee was told that he sounded "too smart for his own good". He was also banned from performing his crowd-pleasing double chop spot.

"Raw is already too loud, Keith, there's no need for it!"

Lee also said he was "restricted" in a more general sense on the main roster, which was easily inferred by the fact that his matches were very boring.

Turning Keith Lee into Bearcat Lee was so impressively stupid that it almost borders on an achievement.

8. Cesaro Is Told To Be Less Spectacular

WWE crowds (at least in the United States more often than not) are quiet.

Advertisement

It's the strangest thing. WWE sells out massive arenas for TV tapings every week as an engaged online fanbase basks in the idea that the power is back. TV ratings are impressive; WWE is bucking trends in the wider cable landscape. WWE is, across several objective metrics, hot. And yet, the crowds aren't. It is bizarre. Until the finish, the fans just sit on their hands in a ThunderDome made flesh.

WWE isn't happy with this; if they were, they wouldn't pipe in crowd noise. And it's not as if the modern WWE crowd is rejecting what is put in front of them, compelling Vince McMahon to pretend that his company has been spirited to Bizarro World for the night. They aren't "acting up" or being obnoxious. They just aren't, as Pat Patterson was said to remarking, "going banana".

Why, then, was Cesaro told to tone down his eruption-triggering salvo of incredible, lung-bursting offence?

Arn Anderson, speaking on his ARN podcast, claimed that "[Cesaro] continued to get leaned on to stop doing all that stuff [a reference to his repertoire] as a heel. It was just too flashy and all that stuff."

WWE turned the man heel almost to the second he got over as a babyface in 2014. They booked the guy to be a focal point of WrestleMania XXX!

That almost feels cruel in retrospect.

7. WWE Killed Daniel Bryan: Planet's Champion

Daniel Bryan: Planet's Champion was such an incredible act. It seems impossible that the WWE of 2018/9 allowed him to run with it. This isn't "AEW shill" "bias": Raw was so bad that the McMahons apologised for how bad it was!

Advertisement

Does Vince McMahon need to touch grass? Is Vince McMahon on the AEW payroll? Is Vince McMahon exhibiting "bitchless behaviour"?

And yet, over on SmackDown, Bryan was on outstanding form. He rediscovered his inner technical sadist, using his leverage as top WWE star not to demand a lighter schedule or refuse jobs but to work a stunningly intricate series of awesome matches. He also adopted a new, ultra-sanctimonious character that pinpointed everything that the average American would hate to hear about themselves. They were greedy animal-killing scum destroying a planet more beautiful than their closed minds could ever hope to be.

The man was detestable, and brilliantly effective, and WWE put an end to it after he used his star power to elevate Kofi Kingston. When Bryan returned after WrestleMania 35, he was a mean and somewhat generic heel, and by the summer, he was attempting to murder Roman Reigns and hiring doppelgängers of Erick Rowan for an alibi.

When discussing with Sports Illustrated his thoughts on the creative process, and how he was guided into not losing focus of building storylines, Bryan let slip "Eventually, I wasn’t allowed to say anything about the environment at all."

Thanks lads!

6. WWE Tried To Kill Off Daniel Bryan Well Before That

Some optimists or fantasists might have you believe that, in pairing Daniel Bryan with the Miz on NXT in 2010, the idea all along was to depict the indie legend as a "rookie" in a sophisticated meta bit to get him over in front of the hardcore subgroup of fans. If WWE withheld the gratification, and portrayed Miz in a transgressive role, the fans would want to see Bryan succeed against an out-of-touch machine.

Advertisement

The thing is, this machine doesn't think they're out of touch.

When they toyed with the fan-driven notion that they were out of touch in 2013, as part of the overarching Authority storyline, they pivoted, buried Bryan as a B+ player, and, in a very out-of-touch development, tried to book a Batista Vs. Randy Orton main event at WrestleMania XXX before a seismic fan revolt.

Daniel Bryan knew he wasn't getting a bold, experimental push; speaking on the Network special 'Journey To WrestleMania', he lamented the fact that he was made to dumb sh*t on the NXT game show as WWE, for whatever reason, decided to tell the audience that the next generation of talent was a laughing stock.

Vince said "he doesn't even eat meat" when Chris Jericho championed Bryan to him backstage. Michael Cole cut shoot promos on him constantly. WWE in general treated Bryan with scorn, and whether or not it was some deranged Vince "test", he was banned from getting over in 2010.

And again in 2013, when they tried to give the Yes! chant to the Big Show because he is large.

5. Rusev Day Comes To An End

People loved Rusev, and while his initial push as 'The Best Man' in AEW didn't work out, he alluded on his YouTube channel to it all going somewhere further than the wedding. He was The Best Man because was a gifted all-rounder who was strong in almost every area: he could talk, he could go, he could be scary and intense, but also really funny with his gleeful asides.

Advertisement

A man you could have a beer with before the mood shifted into something very ugly, the idea (if not the execution) was very good.

So why didn't this ultra-talented all-rounder - who was ideal for WWE's favoured top role of "gregarious powerhouse welcomes you to Monday Night Raw" - crack the main event scene?

Well, the act that promised to launch Rusev into that stratosphere was senselessly abandoned. The Rusev Day stable was a very entertaining and over midcard bit, to which fans responded enthusiastically. It wasn't fading in popularity. It just...ended, and that is because Rusev was effectively banned from making that connection with fans.

As Rusev told it in a 2020 podcast appearance with Ryback, "I was told, "don't look at the people, don't smile, don't do this". Vince told him that the crowds didn't like Rusev and were just "f*cking" with him.

Vince heard something he didn't want to hear and twisted the narrative to his own, deranged liking.

4. Hideo Itami Is Not Allowed To Be KENTA

The name doesn't matter.

Advertisement

KENTA and its stylisation was a very cool name, but complaining about it being changed misses the point. That isn't why 'Hideo Itami' didn't get over. Hideo Itami wasn't allowed to be KENTA in name nor essence.

KENTA was one of the most revolutionary wrestlers ever. The acclaimed 21st century generation looks unrecognisable without his immense influence. In the ultimate, cruel irony, since KENTA appeared in WWE after his physical peak, working a style that had been subsumed by countless pro wrestlers, he somehow felt like the two a penny plagiarist to that fanbase by the time he was quasi-promoted to the "main roster" in 205 Live Kickoff matches.

Fearing chants of "CM Punk!" at a time when Punk's name was chanted as code for "He was right, this is sh*t" by WWE fans whenever WWE did something sh*tty, Itami was banned from performing the Go To Sleep manoeuvre he innovated. And, while he eventually did after a slow-burn tease campaign, it meant very little.

He was also prevented from being the nasty, sick f*cker of old. Sure, Itami was gruff and mean and all that, but he wasn't allowed to be the über-stiff sh*t-kicker in WWE. It's not how they do things.

So why sign him?!

3. Seth Rollins Gets Banned From Wearing His Superstar Attire

How important is gear, really?

Advertisement

Is a good look fundamental to getting over?

Yes and no, in that a bad look is so distracting that it can undermine or even ruin a match. Cody Rhodes debuting the neck tattoo at Revolution 2020 was so distracting that it ate the story of his match with MJF alive. It was as if Stone Cold Steve Austin had walked into WrestleMania XIV wearing luminous yellow trunks.

A better look might not have saved either big Seth Rollins babyface push; in 2017, WWE succumbed to the temptation of a Shield reunion a couple of years before the impact could have been maximised, and in 2019, he was probably knackered by his cringe-worthy stand-up scripts before he was made to act like one of the kids from IT at the sight of the Fiend, who was less scary than Tim Curry in Home Alone 2.

But!

Rollins now is getting over because the fans like singing his song and watching him clown around in his extravagant outfits - so is it really too much of a stretch to suggest that, were Rollins to have worn his iconic white SummerSlam 2015 gear as he launched his babyface run, he'd have got off to a much hotter start?

The look was beloved, no hyperbole, because he was at the peak of his powers on the night. He looked like the most dynamic wrestler in the world.

But he only wore it once because Vince McMahon banned him from putting it on again. Rollins revealed as much at an October 2019 signing (h/t Fightful):

"No. Vince won't let me wear it because he's a weird old man who doesn't understand that people think it's the coolest gear they've ever seen. Yeah. He doesn't get it. I get that question more than anything else. What does that mean? It's just huge, man."

2. Virtually Every Cruiserweight Ever

WWE only ever presented a Light Heavyweight title as an experimental, if-we-have-to means of competing with the white-hot WCW cruiserweight division.

Advertisement

Had Eric Bischoff not scanned the wider landscape to differentiate his product, Vince McMahon would never have had the idea to steal it, either as a passion project or as something he felt would make money. It wasn't in his make-up at all.

You'll unearth the odd hidden gem on the Network, but the library of work simply didn't compare to WCW. You'd see a dazzling aerial and the odd international sensation, but what was missing was the energy. That sense of exhilaration, of a dynamic, frantic match accelerating towards the finish, was only ever truly witnessed in a WWE ring when Paul London and Akio were going f*cking nuts on Velocity in 2004.

It was all just...slower and more generically structured, even when WWE reverted to type after the genuinely great Cruiserweight Classic of 2016. The tempo was a bit faster than main roster matches, but not by much - and the rebooted scene was hardly helped by a stylistic trend. By 2016, the majority of wrestlers had incorporated that style into their work.

205 Live was a loveless bit of Content, capital C, and it was more depressing than exhilarating watching the big head drops at the end of a patterned match. The committed talents were bumping big entirely in vain.

1. Every Wrestler WWE Would Not Release

In 2018, at the Needham conference, then-WWE Co-President George Barrios said "[The talent is] under agreement, but both parties could terminate them in pretty short order. So we're not trying to lock anyone up. It has to work for both parties."

Advertisement

In 2019, All Elite Wrestling formed.

FTR, in a bid to finally work that programme with the Young Bucks, salvage their artistic legacy and get over again, requested their release. This was denied in pretty short order by one party. WWE then said to FTR that they'd make a renewed effort to improve and focus on the tag team division.

Shawn Spears was successful in securing his release, which gave Brodie Lee an idea. He too tweeted an exit statement under the impression that he could terminate his agreement in pretty short order. He too wanted to make something of a once very promising career and get over in a promotion that would give him the best shot of doing so on his own terms.

Only, his request was denied. Before his tragic passing, Brodie Lee told Chris Jericho on Talk Is Jericho that Triple H intervened and said they couldn't do it, saying that, optically, it would seem as if the rats were trying to flee the sinking ship. Like FTR, a loose (and unfilled) promise was floated his way: hey Luke, maybe we can allow you to work New Japan Pro Wrestling.

Mustafa could yet leave - maybe he just needs to approach the request more Positive-Ali!!

Advertisement