10 Wrestlers Even AEW Couldn’t Sign

Those who passed on the big AEW Dynamite debut…and those who were passed by.

By Michael Hamflett /

Recent precedent suggests that this list could be redundant right as you read it, and not just for all the usual reasons found on this author page.

Advertisement

Depending on how you count this sort of thing, AEW have brought in between 15-20 new permanently contracted wrestlers in 2022 as of October. And that's ignoring those that work on per-date deals, make special guest appearances on Dynamite here and there or do the round across Dark and Dark: Elevation. Inflate those numbers more so for appearances from NJPW/Impact stars, and then add more for those that have represented the rebooted Ring Of Honor, and it's easy to see why audiences have grown weary of any new performers signing on for the foreseeable future.

Tony Khan says tough t*ts to all that, it'd seem. Rush's status was made official shortly after Grand Slam, and matches on the September 28th edition of Dynamite featuring Bandido and Juice Robinson may not have been one-offs for either.

It's possible that every single one of the names below might eventually sign on Jacksonville's dotted line, but highly, highly improbable...

10. The Undertaker

A strange thing happened in 2019 that almost tied The Undertaker to AEW before the former retired from playing the legendary role and the latter even existed.

Advertisement

The company's Double Or Nothing launch event was - as had been the case with All In the prior summer - enhanced by the enormous and wide-ranging Starrcast meet-and-greet event, and in an attempt to make the convention a destination for all pro wrestling rather than simply anybody from outside WWE's orbit, they booked the f*cking Undertaker.

Not exactly a circuit regular at the time, 'The Deadman' made enough headlines that Vince McMahon himself got wind of the deal and was reportedly livid about it. Scuttlebut perhaps, but the February story resulted in Undertaker missing his first WrestleMania in 17 years despite - as was later revealed in a Network special - being backstage for the whole thing and turning up as a surprise on Monday Night Raw the next night.

McMahon might have resigned in disgrace, but cynically back-burnering one of his biggest stars before he exited almost certainly went some way to stopping similar side-swaps from his other legends.

9. Road Dogg

Couldn't? Wouldn't? The point was, they didn't, and thank goodness for that.

Advertisement

Road Dogg has quickly found a home back in the thick of it in Triple H's WWE. As new Vice President Of Live Events (fittingly taking over the wrestler he once "roadied" for in Jeff Jarrett), he's likely got a voice in various important rooms and could well take up an advisory role on a creative level similar to the spot he had in NXT before he was caught by one of Nick Khan's spreadsheet Clear Alls in January 2022.

He was quick to get on the grifters podcast loop along with the likes of Booker T and Eric Bischoff following his cut, initially trying to play both sides before seemingly begging for a job by out-of-nowhere praising AEW, Tony Khan and just about everything else to do with the product. Mindful of some of the far worse things the former Tag Team Champion had said online in his time, Khan paid it no heed. And now, he won't need to.

8. Hulk Hogan

Leave it to Tony Khan himself to rule this one out - even if 'The Hulkster' ever fancied showing his face in All Elite Wrestling, he wouldn't make it past security according to the billionaire boss.

Advertisement

The president of AEW made his feelings on Hulk Hogan known following remarks made by Hulk's ex wife. Replying to an offensive (and since-deleted) tweet from Linda about riots taking place in America at the time, he said;

Khan's got forum form in him when it comes to taking things to Twitter, but this was a bold statement to make in politically testing times, and one he had to know he'd be held to in the years that follows. It shouldn't be too tricky. Hogan's legacy isn't really a part of AEW's DNA, but their attempts to reclaim all of wrestling history in recent years folds him back in. Never say never, but - to use the currency of contemporary parlance - remember this tweet.

7. Kevin Owens

At the end of 2021, Kevin Owens tweeted coordinates to Mount Rushmore, teasing out a possibility that he might reunite with his PWG Rushmore stablemates The Young Bucks and Adam Cole in All Elite Wrestling. Coming at the height of the spate of talent jumps almost entirely in one direction around the time, a move felt inevitable.

Advertisement

Then, unexpectedly, he re-signed.

Beyond folk who were oddly emotionally invested in Owens' bank balance, nobody particularly toasted the decision. Approximately 10 months later and it's proven to be one of the best he's made. A WrestleMania main event with Stone Cold Steve Austin looked from the outside to have been the biggest hook, not least when he pivoted into a midcard-flavoured bit of fun with Ezekiel soon after.

He chose WWE over AEW back then, before Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace and left a space in Gorilla for 'KO' fan Triple H. Assuming that the next few years go as well for Owens as it appears like they may, what could possibly change his mind now?

Speaking of changing minds, where there's an Owens, there's typically been...

6. Sami Zayn

Right around the time Kevin Owens decided to stay put in WWE, so too did Sami Zayn.

Advertisement

He was later fairly up front about the decision - he was relatively happy, presumably well compensated, and had evidently figured out a system that always looked rigged against smaller, technical wrestlers of his ilk. Heading into WrestleMania, he was embroiled in a high profile scuffle with the Jackass cast. This, a year on from working alongside Logan Paul against Kevin Owens spoke to how reliable he'd become in the novelty spot.

This looked and even felt enough, but Zayn's post-'Show Of Shows' story with The Bloodline has been such an unqualified success that it looks as though the very system he's gamed has got extra levels that he's managed to unlock. All Elite Wrestling couldn't bring the independent wrestling legend over, nor could they secure the services of his luchador associate El Generico. Nor will they be able to if things stay even half as promising for the former NXT Champion in Triple H's intriguing new universe.

5. Johnny Gargano

Recent reports confirmed that those within WWE were thrilled to have the opportunity to do business with Johnny Gargano again after he'd allowed his last contract to come to an end in December 2021.

Advertisement

It seemed as though the feeling was mutual.

At various points in 2022, All Elite Wrestling looked to be the natural landing spot for 'Johnny Wrestling'. Numerous fellow NXT alumni had ventured towards Tony Khan's promotion, noting countless examples of botched pushes under Vince McMahon's careless concern dating back decades. Gargano fit the profile of somebody who could have fallen into similar traps, but as he enjoyed time away from the ring and with his wife Candice LeRae and their young son, the internal power shift may as well have been a red (or black-and-gold) carpet rolling towards the former NXT Champion.

His enthusiasm and loyalty has been almost immediately rewarded - Gargano has been featured prominently since re-signing with WWE and has talked glowingly both about the things he's experienced there and the dreams and ambitions he's yet to accomplish.

4. Kane

AEW bringing in WWE's former 'Big Red Machine' should his time as Knox County's one conclude in the near future would complete something of an unholy trinity of signings that kicked off in early 2021 with the arrival of Paul Wight.

Advertisement

When Mark Henry jumped later in the year, a sinking feeling crept in that the company would complete the set of Vince McMahon's favourite massive guys, all with little-to-no obvious on-screen purpose. Since then, Wight's been a ghost, Henry's a Rampage meme (and apparently a very welcome mind backstage) and nary a match has been troubled by either since the former Big Show took a beating from The Gunn Club on the Dynamite after Revolution.

It's for this reason that All Elite Wrestling viewers should console themselves with the logical reality that Kane is a WWE-lifer type in the rich red vein of his storyline older brother. AEW sign a lot of wrestlers, but the veteran star has - at most - what Wight and Henry are already providing.

3. The Rest Of The Control Your Narrative Roster...

...because if Triple H isn't considering the best of what's left, it's unlikely Tony Khan will see you as going begging.

Advertisement

Braun Strowman and Karrion Kross returning in the summer of 2022 following Triple H's ascent to WWE's highest position confounded those that believed Strowman in particular had torpedoed his value by working for the last-but-one version of Ring Of Honor, various North American independent dates and the bizarre Control Your Narrative. In actuality, this shone a light on EC3 and Austin Aries not receiving the same call.

With Kross a favourite of 'The Game' and Braun the type of monster it was always worth having another go with, the remaining centre-points of the strange CYN project look a little out of place in the North American mainstream. A mainstream that includes AEW, who have more than enough wrestlers just like them. That the group were loosely associated with ROH at the end but not when Khan purchased the brand speaks volumes too.

2. Karrion Kross

A crazy one this, considering the existing problem with roster bloat, but AEW couldn’t use Karrion Kross because Karrion Kross politely declined the opportunity to be used.

Advertisement

That was the story emerging out of the usual backstage channels anyway - Kross was supposed to eat a loss to Wardlow during the ‘War Dog’s match to MJF via various foes, but the former NXT Champion elected to sit on his WWE release a little longer rather than eat a Dynamite defeat.

The move, evidently, proved quite shrewd. When Triple H rose to power, Kross’ main roster return was one of the first statement booking moments to reflect the change. Buried and buried under Vince McMahon, this was a redebut, relaunch and complete reset.

He decked drew McIntyre, eyeballed Roman Reigns and - as of writing at least - hasn’t yet lost. Such a rapid fire trajectory is barely offered to AEW regulars, let alone the one-and-dones hoping to turn an opportunity into something more.

1. The Fiend

Bray Wyatt's impending WWE comeback has been one of the most buzzworthy storyline developments in the company's recent history, and it borrows from the successful job AEW did with CM Punk's back in 2021.

Advertisement

Well, apart from all the spooky bullsh*t, obviously. But when's that not been a Wyatt qualifier?

In the heady, dreamlike days of an All Elite Wrestling ready to burst forth from the Daily's Place cocoon as pandemic restrictions eased, Punk's name was never dropped but various on-the-nose clues were. Much like's Wyatt's QR codes have paved the way to Extreme Rules 2022, so too did Punk's to a euphoric "First Dance" edition of Rampage last summer. The difference of course, is in the wrestlers themselves.

Punk promised and delivered his fair share of demons and monsters, but at least those were the figurative sorts that had been part of his make-up forever. The mad sh*t Wyatt's offered out over the years goes way, way beyond even the stupidest House Of Black nonsense, and even that felt out of place in AEW. And it always will.

Advertisement