There comes a time in every wrestler's career when they simply can't perform as well as they'd like to. Maybe they struggle to stay up-to-date in the ever-changing world of professional wrestling, or maybe they simply get too old. Either way, when the time comes for this wrestler, they usually wind themselves down, wrestle a few more matches, then bow out gracefully. Or, they wind themselves down, wrestle a few more matches, bow out gracefully, come back for a few more matches, wrestle continuously for years and years, wind themselves down, wrestle some more, wind themselves down again, have a tearful and magnificently booked retirement match, go to TNA, wrestle much much more, sort of just stop, wrestle again, then actually sort of stop. But that last one's just Ric Flair. The perfect, textbook example of a retirement done well is Shawn Michaels. He felt he had done it all, had achieved all of his goals. He saw the next generation of up-and-comers and thought they were better than he was. He had his retirement match when he was still good enough in the ring to make it amazing, and he went out on a high; with fans and peers alike praising his career. Sometimes though, a wrestler is forced to retire before they're quite ready. Sometimes it's politics, or a sudden injury, or maybe they just lose their love of the game. When this happens we, the wrestling-loving audience, get robbed of some great matches, great promos, or even just a chance to say goodbye. Here are 10 wrestlers whose career ended too early...
10. Stone Cold Steve Austin
Stone Cold Steve Austin. Arguably wrestling's biggest ever star. Wrestling made the transition from cartoon-like entertainment aimed towards children in the 1980s and early 90s, to adult-themed, culture shock television in the late 90s and early 2000s, and the catalyst to this was Stone Cold. The beer-swilling, middle-finger brandishing everyman, except he wasn't an everyman because he actually kicked people asses. Stone Cold was wrestling's Larry David from Curb Your Enthusiasm: he did and said the things we all wished we could do and say. Except, unlike Larry, Stone Cold not only got away with it, but it won him world championships. Austin left the WWE in June 2002 after no-showing a Raw episode, claiming differences in opinion about his character. He returned in time for one more match with The Rock at Wrestlemania 19, which turned out to be his final match. The neck injuries that had plagued Austin's career had become too much. Austin though, having only recently made amends with Vince McMahon and the WWE, was clearly not ready to give up the wrestling business altogether. He hung around in various on-screen "backstage" roles, like the Co-General Manager of Raw and the "Sheriff of Raw", which basically allowed him to storm out to the ring with his theme music playing, hit the Stone Cold Stunner on people, drink a few beers and storm off. It was certainly fun to watch, and it certainly looked like Austin was having fun doing it, but it was hard to shake the feeling of what might have been. The space he left in the main event was filled by deserving wrestlers. John Cena, Edge, Brock Lesnar (briefly) and the emergence of the Evolution stable all rose to prominence after Stone Cold had laced up his boots for the last time. It's hard, though, to not wish for proper feuds with Stone Cold vs each of these. John Cena for one, would definitely have benefitted from a torch-passing match with Stone Cold. As would the audience.
9. The Rock
Sure, he's still involved in wrestling now. Like the time he came back in 2011 and said this: "I wanna tell you 'thank you'. I love you. And it is because of you that I am back in this ring and it is because of you, and I give you my word, I am never ever going away" Remember? When he said that? Before he went away again? The Rock left the WWE for the first time in April 2003 after losing to Goldberg at Backlash. He left to pursue his acting career full time (some joke that turned out to boh wait, no, that totally worked out) after spending the previous few years taking the occasional brief hiatus to film movies. It was the WWE fans though, during this period, who created The Rock's greatest character: the "Hollywood Heel". The Rock, who was the WWE's biggest baby face at the time, kept taking time away from the company to film movies, and the fans got sick of this. They expect their heroes to stick around and fight for them week after week. Rocky wasn't doing this so they turned on him, creating perhaps the most underused heel run of all time. The Rock, at his best when playing arrogant "I'm just better than you" characters, thrived in this role. He'd come back from filming, cut promos about how he doesn't need to be there, how he's only there for the money, and he'd go up against a big babyface. This could have continued indefinitely. In reality, The Rock stayed away from the WWE for so long that now he's in that "Legend" category. When he comes back it's exciting and nostalgic and he will never be booed again. Imagine though, if "Hollywood Heel" Rock kept returning sporadically between 2003 and now. Returning, cutting a promo about why he's only back for the money, why this is an easy pay check for him, losing to a top face and off he goes again. It was a fascinating character that was nowhere near being explored to it's full potential.
8. Mick Foley
Now, to be totally honest, Mick Foley probably retired from in-ring competition at the right time. His injury list is legendary and his knees are in such bad condition that just the thought of having to walk down stairs is a terrifying experience for him. Anyone who's seen Foley's "smash my knees violently into the ring steps before launching my body over them" spot won't find that hard to imagine. Outside of the ring though, Mick left far too young. He was always so much fun in the authority roles. His initial run as "Commissioner" in 2000 was joyous, made famous by his run-ins with Edge & Christian or Kurt Angle and his make-shift offices. Choosing to play the role with heart instead of appearing macho was a masterstroke; put simply, nobody plays the authority figure quite like Mick Foley. He was even great as the General Manager of Saturday Morning Slam last year. Now however, a dispute about royalties and the benefits of signing a "legends deal" has seen Foley sever ties with WWE completely. Even though this was an amicable split, it's still too early and a real shame. Foley's acting ability and his gift for selling a story can be useful in so many ways. Just recently a legends panel comprised of Shawn Michaels, Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair fumbled their way through the story on Raw, unable to really get any kind of point across regarding John Cena's rematch against Brock Lesnar. Even in a role as limited as this, Mick Foley's presence would have definitely been felt.
7. Trish Stratus
Trish Stratus is essentially now the benchmark for female wrestling. She joined WWE in 1999, right at the stage when the company was shying away from hiring female wrestlers and preferring to hire attractive fitness models and teaching them a few wrestling moves. She began as a manager and valet, but a love of wrestling and a determination to succeed as a wrestler saw her infinitely improve her in-ring work. She retired in 2006 at the very pinnacle of women's wrestling. Her last match as a full-time member of the roster came at the Unforgiven Pay-Per-View in 2006, when she beat long-time rival Lita and won her seventh WWE Women's Championship, and she retired a champion. All very impressive, but she was only 30 when she left WWE. Her retirement marked the end of a generation in women's wrestling, but she left when she was still more than capable of ushering in the next generation. Her absence left a void in women's wrestling in WWE which is only now being filled. She left before she could effectively pass the torch to the likes of Beth Phoenix or Natalya. The women responsible for leading the next generation still had to live in the shadow of the last. Wouldn't it have been great to see these women go out and beat Trish? It would have helped set up these women as capable of leading women's wrestling from then on, and most of all, it would have resulted in some terrific wrestling matches.
6. Santino Marella
Santino Marella divided opinion. Depending on who you talk to, he was either a fun, hilarious, wildly under-valued worker or he was tedious, cringe-worthy and the laughing stock of WWE. Love him or loathe him, one thing's for sure: there's nobody else like him. His early retirement due to injury has left a big hole in the WWE roster. He was their go-to-guy for funny. Sure, this often backfired. It was usually 50/50 whether his backstage segments would get a chuckle or not, but his in-ring style was always fun. And who can forget the Elimination Chamber in 2011? After four eliminations, the match was down to just Santino and Daniel Bryan for the World Heavyweight Championship, and all it took was one tease that Santino might win to send the crowd into raptures. He didn't (which for probably for the best) but there's no denying he had a connection with "the WWE Universe". Now there's a chance that he might move into commentary, at least on NXT, which is something to look forward to. But in-ring there's nobody else on the WWE roster who can step up. Comedic wrestling is shockingly under-represented at the world's leading wrestling company, and we can only hope that WWE uses this as an opportunity to look elsewhere for a wrestler capable of making people laugh and (cough) actually gives (coughColt) them a chance to (coughCabana) do so.
5. Lance Storm
Lance Storm is one of those wrestlers who is almost impossible to praise without sounding patronising. He was never a world champion, but he had a handful of mid-card title runs, several if you count tag team championships as mid-card titles (you should.) Lance Storm's genius, however, was that he made every single one of his many, many opponents look better than they were. Every single one. Put him in the ring with a big monster heel, and he makes them look terrifying. Have him wrestle a cruiserweight and he makes them look unstoppable. He was smart enough in the ring to put over anybody. See? Wasn't that just so crushingly patronising? Storm left WWE in 2005 when he was 36 years old. He left to open his own training school, which is absolutely what he should be doing. For sure. Actually, it should be a rule that you're not allowed to become a professional wrestler without having had at least one conversation with Lance Storm. He can't train everyone, that would be absurd. But surely it's not too much to ask that everyone at least talk to the guy once about wrestling. But, wouldn't it be cool if he kept wrestling in WWE just a little bit longer? He continued wrestling at indie shows sporadically, including as recently as last December when he lost to Chris Hero at a Smash Wrestling show. His wresting mind is second-to-none and he could have continued his great career as a mid-card stepping stone for at least a few more years. Think about all the WWE Superstars who were tipped for greatness from 2005 onwards who never quite made it. Each one of them would look better than they do now had they only wrestled Lance Storm.
4. Nigel McGuinness
When Daniel Bryan (you know, the guy who wrestled twice at Wrestlemania 30 against Triple H and then again winning the title in the main event, that guy) signed with WWE in 2009 it was at the same time as Nigel McGuinness. The two were considered equal in terms of talent, both wrestling for Ring Of Honor at the time, but McGuinness was the one who was really going to make it. Little Bryan could wrestle, but McGuinness had the look too. The had the body of a WWE Superstar. Unfortunately, he was struggling with injuries at the time and WWE didn't follow through with the signing. McGuinness, now retired, is currently the on-screen authority figure back at Ring Of Honor. He has said his injuries are behind him, but sees no need to return to wrestling unless it's something he's never done before. Well, he's never done WWE before. A healthy Nigel McGuinness would have a great chance at becoming a top WWE Superstar, in the same mould as Bryan, Cesaro or Seth Rollins. Even if he was hired just to fill the card in NXT, that would still be a treat. McGuinness vs Sami Zayn, Kenta, or Kevin Steen is something that we would definitely like to see more of. You know what? Even wrestling again in Ring Of Honor would be great. Here's the point: Nigel McGuinness should wrestle again because he's brilliant.
3. Edge
Edge retired in 2011 for the same reason as Stone Cold: his neck. He was suffering numbness in his arms, was beginning to struggle through matches, and was told that one more neck injury could leave him paralysed. He, rightly, decided to retire then and there, his last match being successfully defending the World Heavyweight Championship at Wrestlemania 27. Although he had been on WWE TV since 1998, Edge was only really a main-event level guy for the last five years of his career, after winning his first WWE Championship in January 2006. So his retirement announcement came as a huge shock to the wrestling world, who still considered the thirteen year veteran a young talent. It was also a real shame as he left the WWE right before the beginning of their current "youth movement". He missed out on a feud with a fully-realised (read: fully bearded) Daniel Bryan. A Bryan vs Edge match series would have been incredible, no doubt. He missed out on getting attacked by The Shield, not to mention how much fun it would be to watch Edge and Dean Ambrose's personalities knock against each other. And he missed out on Bray Wyatt. And we missed out on Edge vs Bray Wyatt. We missed out on all of these.
2. Shane McMahon
Whether elbowing Big Show off the stage at Judgement Day 2000, falling 40 feet at SummerSlam in 2000, or getting hurled through (and against) glass panes by Kurt Angle at King of the Ring 2001, Shane McMahon's matches were always impressive. Eager to disprove the feeling backstage that he was only there because he was the boss' son, he took crazy risks during matches that paid off. After featuring on WWE TV heavily from 1999 to 2001, and appearing sporadically until 2009, he finally left the WWE entirely in order to peruse other business interests. He's now the CEO of a broadband company in China and is involved with the International Sports Management company. That's all well and good, but wouldn't you like to see him FALL OFF THE TITANTRON AGAIN?The Shane vs Vince dynamic was always interesting and, although WWE went to that particular well a little too often back in the Attitude Era days, it would be fun to revisit it. Especially these days with Triple H's ever increasing backstage involvement becoming more public. While Triple H leading the company in real life is something to be celebrated, an on-screen authority battle with Shane McMahon might be interesting. And now that the WWE has enough Kurt Angle-level talent at their disposal, it's certainly possible that he could be carried to a match as good as that one at King of the Ring 2001.
1. CM Punk
He was always going to be number 1 on this list, wasn't he? The exact details of his departure are still unknown, but it's looking more and more like CM Punk has retired for good. Well, at least for now. And while it's true that WWE have coped with his departure better than most expected, there's no doubt that adding CM Punk to a wrestling product will inevitably improve it. It has been said that Punk lost his momentum when he dropped his WWE Championship to The Rock at the 2013 Royal Rumble, but that's not true. The rematch at Elimination Chamber was excellent, and he and Heyman's work in the build-up to his match with The Undertaker at Wrestlemania was incredible. What really knocked his momentum was that, after taking some time off to heal up after Wrestlemania, Punk returned at the Payback event in his home town of Chicago. Which meant that he had no choice but to return as a babyface. The resulting few months of him feuding with Paul Heyman ended up being underwhelming as, once the amazing SummerSlam match with Brock Lesnar was over, he had no real opponents left. Ryback and Curtis Axel were never going to be threats to Punk. So he had to hover there in the upper mid-card, stuck in his own little world separate from Daniel Bryan's Authority story. Stuck with no hope of realising his dream of main eventing at Wrestlemania. When CM Punk left, he robbed us of the next phase of heel CM Punk. He revels in the heel environment. Whether singing to Rey Mysterio's daughter, or preaching between every entrant of the Royal Rumble, or mocking Jerry Lawlor's heart attack, or emptying out Paul Bearer's ashes, or The Pipe Bomb. Perhaps the greatest heel in modern wrestling is now getting the most heat of his career by simply depriving us of his work. All that's left for us to do is to hope that he's happy enough and healthy enough in whatever he's doing right now that one day he'll want to come back. And that when he does, we must hope that it's not long before he's doing something so despicable that we can't help but boo him out of the building. Let us all raise a glass of Pepsi and toast the Best In The World. When you're ready Punk, please come home.