10 Wrestlers That Fell Off HARD

Not everyone reaches the summit of the mountain, some fall down.

By Michael John-Day /

Carving out a career as a professional wrestler is about as easy as running a marathon backwards with a blindfold on. Adding to this is that you're surrounded by a sea of other people trying to do the same thing. There are, of course, those lucky few who break into a big promotion and reach the sun. But, sadly, even then, there's no guarantee it will last.

Advertisement

The wrestling industry is a fickle thing. It thrives on finding new talent to launch into the stratosphere and will take risks on many people who seem fit for the job. Unfortunately, making a superstar is a difficult task, as you need all the planets to align and luck on top of that for it to work. Having a great physique, presence, and presentation is not always enough.

These ten wrestlers are great examples of this, as they all found themselves in a pretty great spotlight and seemed poised to find long-lasting success. However, their careers came crashing down like a Jenga tower, leaving them to gather dust in the hall of "what-ifs."

They prove that the bigger they are, the harder they fall.

10. Ted DiBiase Jr.

Being the child of a beloved Hall of Fame wrestler isn't a guaranteed path to success, but it sure does help. The likes of Randy Orton, Cody Rhodes, Charlotte Flair, and more have carried the legacy of their names well and carved new history into them. Ted DiBiase Jr, however, didn't quite match up.

Advertisement

The son of Ted DiBiase got a big build in WWE when he hit the main roster. He entered right into a championship programme, winning the Tag Belts alongside Cody Rhodes. This eventually led to the formation of the Legacy stable, with Rhodes, Orton, and DiBiase teaming together as a collective of multi-generation wrestlers. This stable put Orton on top of the company, and it seemed they were all destined for great things.

However, his time with WWE would eventually fall flat. His run with the Million Dollar Championship and an eventual babyface turn failed to get him out of the midcard. DiBiase ended up leaving the company in 2013 due to issues with depression and anxiety.

Unfortunately, a failed wrestling career is the least of DiBiase's worries right now, as he's currently in danger of ending up in jail due to a welfare fund scandal. It seems he might have taken his old man's scheming ways a little too seriously.

9. Marc Mero

Taking a single well-delivered powerbomb is, barring some pain upon the bump, not going to damage anybody's career. However, there is one exception where a wrestler's whole reputation was tarnished at the hands of a powerbomb, and that wrestler was Marc Mero.

Advertisement

Mero began building his respectable career in WCW as Johnny B. Badd before jumping to the World Wrestling Federation under his own name. He captured the Intercontinental Championship within less than a year in the promotion, proving that the company had high hopes for him. Of course, it didn't hurt that he had his real-life wife, the eye-catching Sable, by his side as a valet. But that which brings someone up can often be their downfall.

His kayfabe split from Sable was primed as a chance to turn him into a dastardly villain, with plans for him to feud against the newly crowned WWF Champion 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. However, during his rivalry with Sable, he took a Sable Bomb from her. Many deemed this a sign of weakness, including Austin himself, who didn't want his character beaten up by someone publicly powerbombed by a woman. This led to a drastic decline in his career.

Mero eventually parted ways with the company and had a semi-decent TNA run before retiring from wrestling in 2006. One powerbomb did all that damage.

8. Mr. Kennedy

When looking back on the history of WWE, you're going to see a lot of people who came close to grabbing the brass ring, only for it to slip out of their hands. Mr. Kennedy (Ken Anderson) is one such wrestler.

Advertisement

Mrrrrrrr... Kennedy came into WWE with a hell of a lot of steam behind him. He had tremendous mic skills and the ability to put on good in-ring performances to boot. The man was ready to become a mainstay in the company, even winning the Money in the Bank briefcase.

However, it all came tumbling down after he was forced to vacate the briefcase due to injury. Unfortunately, after dropping it to Edge, it was revealed that his injury was misdiagnosed and not as severe as first thought, meaning he could have kept it.

From there, his career was as stop-and-start as a broken-down car. Any momentum he built would end up being squashed by varying issues - the most infamous example of which was when he accidentally injured Randy Orton in 2009, which led to the company firing him.

His post-WWE career didn't fare much better, as he broke into TNA with some hype and even captured the World Championship twice, but was soon relegated to the midcard. He joined the NWA after leaving Impact and flopped there, too.

7. Curtis Axel

Again, simply being the progeny of a wrestling icon does not mean you will make it. Curtis Axel is another fine example, as he had in-ring prowess flowing through his veins as the son of 'Mr Perfect' Curt Hennig. But that royal blood could only take him so far.

Advertisement

The real-life Joe Hennig was repackaged as Curtis Axel in 2013 after a dire run as Michael McGillicutty. Hennig was never an exceptional star on the mic, but he did have some impressive in-ring skills worth investing in. As such, WWE chose to pair him with someone who could do the talking for him, the iconic Paul Heyman.

As a Paul Heyman guy, Axel started to build some momentum, even scoring two victories over Triple H. Neither was a clean win, but it was still a sign of faith. He then captured the Intercontinental Championship and held it for 5-months. But, eventually, his stock plummeted.

Despite his talent and the pairing with Heyman, things just weren't working, and he was soon stuck at the bottom of the card. After being dumped by the ECW legend, he floated around in teams like RyBaxel, The Social Outcasts, and The B-Team before eventually being released from the company in 2020.

He worked as a backstage producer for three months in 2022 and has since vanished entirely from the business.

6. Bart Gunn

The story of Bart Gunn is one of bizarre creative decisions, decisive knockouts and a burning hatred between Jim Cornette and Vince Russo that will never die. One way it differs from the other entrants on this list is that Gunn was never meant to be in the prominent position he wound up in, and that's likely why it came tumbling down so quickly.

Advertisement

Gunn rose to infamy thanks to the much maligned Brawl for All. This competition, for the uninitiated, was a bracketed tournament that paired wrestlers off into real, unscripted, shoot fights. Gunn was a midcard wrestler who was seemingly only added to boost the numbers, but he ended up winning the whole thing. This came as a big surprise to management who now had to figure out what to do with a star they'd never intended on having.

The powers that be were not confident enough in Gunn to push him into a feud with Steve Austin, as originally intended for their predicted winner 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams. Instead, they put him in an exhibition match at WrestleMania XV against professional boxer Butterbean, who knocked him out in 35 seconds.

After this, Gunn was released from the company and eventually retired from wrestling after a decade or so of working in Japan and making sporadic US appearances.

5. Jack Swagger

There was a time when Jack Swagger showed a lot of promise. His athletic build, tall frame, and All-American gimmick painted the picture of great talent with a strong career ahead of him. But that was a long, long time ago.

Advertisement

Swagger, also known as Jake Hager, began his career in WWE's Wish version of ECW, where he won the ECW Championship. This momentum eventually carried him onto the main roster, where he would show some promise. After unsuccessful attempts to win the US Championship, he was thrust into the main event after winning the Money in the Bank briefcase and cashing it in to gain the World Heavyweight Championship.

Sadly, his run with the belt did not go well. He simply wasn't ready to hang with the big dogs and needed a little more time in the oven before trying to break into the main event. He hadn't built enough momentum and, as such, always felt like a weak champion. This led to the reign falling flat, causing him to be lost in the shuffle. One run in The Real Americans aside, his WWE career never found much traction again.

After leaving WWE, he played a role in Lucha Underground and even became the promotion's last-ever World Champion before it was cancelled. However, that momentum did not carry over into his current position in AEW, where he, again, plays a lacklustre background role.

4. Tomko

Tomko is a man who fell hard again and again. He fell hard in WWE, NJPW, TNA, and even real life.

Advertisement

This impressive performer joined OVW in 2002 and made his WWE TV debut two years later as Christian's bodyguard. He eventually went solo and got a monster push with a short undefeated streak. Then, he lost his momentum after losing to John Cena and quit the company soon after. So, WWE didn't work; where to next?

Tomko moved to Japan and wrestled for NJPW, winning the tag belts alongside Matt Bloom/Giant Bernard. But, this stay was also short-lived, as he would be released from his contract after two years. Gosh, okay, so where now? TNA!

In TNA, Tomko was again paired with Christian. He was in the main event picture thanks to Christian being World Champion and continued to be put in decent spots from there. Then he got released due to alleged contractual issues, which many have speculated was also a result of his drug use. Oh, come on!

This happened again and again as a failed return to WWE, a lackluster TNA return, and legal troubles after being arrested for robbery showed how hard he had fallen. Thankfully, the talented athlete is doing much better now as the owner of multiple businesses. After all his troubles, that sure is nice to hear!

3. Ryback

This big guy was once poised as a main event star during a time when WWE was going through a leading man crisis. Now, he's an absolute ghost in the wrestling world, with his online legacy mired with off-kilter Tweets and a semi-successful YouTube career.

Advertisement

Ryback got his first shot with the company as part of The Nexus, where he mostly faded into the background as Skip Sheffield. But, he got some traction when returning from an injury in 2012 with his new character of Ryback. He put on dominant performances, had an impressive physique, and a catchphrase that caught on quickly: "Feed me more!"

He hit a peak during the first year of this run, challenging for the WWE Championship multiple times against CM Punk and John Cena. However, as time went on and his attempts to get the big belt kept failing, he slipped further and further down the card.

After a while, he was placed into a makeshift tag team with fellow fallen prodigy Curtis Axel, and this became the beginning of the end. A lacklustre Intercontinental Title run did nothing to bring him out of the undercard, and he would eventually part ways with the company in 2016.

Nowadays, he is completely retired from the industry, focusing instead on making YouTube videos and being an occasional menace on Twitter.

2. Austin Aries

Austin Aries is a fine example that being considered one of the best wrestlers on the planet won't last forever. This man was an absolute indie darling and a hardcore fan's dream, but now he's a guy AEW won't even consider signing up. Think about that!

Advertisement

Aries rose to prominence thanks to his time in ROH and eventually TNA, where he impressed as a stellar storyteller and in-ring technician. He was a bonafide star with multiple World Title reigns, and after his NXT debut, fans believed things were poised to get even better. Oh, how wrong they were.

His time in WWE was full of nothing, with lackluster painted over all his endeavors. He couldn't even capture the Cruiserweight Title, which really says it all. Things got even worse from there, as after his release, he would eventually become a ghost in the industry.

Becoming The Belt Collector on the indies/Impact wasn't enough to keep him relevant, as his notoriously difficult-to-work-with attitude eventually made all his prospects dry up. This came to a head after the infamous Bound for Glory 2018 "No Sell" incident, where he got up and walked out directly after the finish.

Nowadays, you'll be lucky to see him working for any promotion with even a twinge of clout.

1. Alex Riley

Pairing an upstart wrestler with the right mentor can help get them over quickly, and it seemed like WWE struck gold with Alex Riley. Having The Miz mentor him for NXT Season 2 was a genius move, as Riley's jock-like personality blended perfectly with Miz's arrogance.

Advertisement

This clever pairing brought Riley into the spotlight as he worked alongside Miz during his WWE Championship run, meaning he had cameras on him during the main event. So, what went wrong? Well, quite a few things.

Riley's solo push after splitting with The Miz was quickly halted as he slid down the card. There are claims that this sudden decline resulted from backstage heat with John Cena. If that's true, then it's no surprise, as rubbing the top star the wrong way will never help a career out.

In a bizarre and unexpected decision, Riley was suddenly moved to NXT to be a colour commentator. He worked hard for an in-ring return, leading him into a feud with Kevin Owens that had him getting eaten alive nonstop.

He was soon released and tried to reinvent himself in the indies to no avail. His most recent notable appearance was in the NWA, where he lost against EC3. Oh, dear.

Advertisement