10 Wrestlers Who Are Surprisingly Not All Elite...Yet

From top free agents to friends of The Elite, who is yet to sign with Tony Khan's company?

By Ryan Berglund /

Since All Elite Wrestling was formed on 1 January 2019, there has been a constant influx of the best wrestlers in the world signing on the dotted line for Tony Khan. Whether they be independent standouts, wrestlers released from WWE or relatively unknown stars looking to make a name for themselves, AEW has one of the most talented rosters from top to bottom ever assembled.

Advertisement

No matter how large or talented the roster is on Dynamite and Rampage, fans are always going to be speculating on who could pop up next for AEW. While it may seem like nearly every top star is currently signed to AEW, WWE, or elsewhere, there is a whole host of talented wrestlers currently out of the spotlight. While some fans may harp on Tony Khan for the sheer size of his roster, including some of the best in the world to his company can only be a good thing.

In fact, there are many names out there that fans are surprised have yet to sign with All Elite Wrestling. There are ex-WWE stars not yet signed anywhere else, wrestlers who have deep connections to the higher ups in the company or performers currently appearing on AEW programming, but still remain unsigned...

10. Cole Karter

Cole Karter is a shining example of how to make the best out of a bad situation.

Advertisement

After a somewhat controversial policy violation led to his release from NXT, he was told by WWE management that he could be brought back to the company in a year. That was bitter pill to swallow for the man known as Two Dimes, as he had just become a regular part of NXT television alongside Tony D'Angelo.

However, the former Troy Donovan took control of his own situation by almost immediately after his release popping up in All Elite Wrestling. A handful of matches on Dark were topped off by Karter challenging Ricky Starks for his FTW Championship at Fyter Fest. While he has assuredly impressed the shot callers in AEW, the biggest sign of his future with the company came earlier this month when he joined QT Marshall and The Factory on Dark.

After impressing the wrestling world with his in-ring skill as well as his ability to bounce back from an unfortunate situation, the sky truly is the limit for the Charleston native. While he remains officially unsigned by AEW, it should only be a matter of time before the former NXT star receives his 'Cole Karter is All Elite' graphic.

9. Marina Shafir

While Cole Karter not signing with All Elite Wrestling despite a handful of appearances is surprising, the case of Marina Shafir is even more puzzling. After being released by WWE in June of last year, one of the Four Horsewomen of UFC arrived in AEW back in December - and has been a constant presence on all four of Tony Khan's programs.

Advertisement

In her nine months with AEW, The Problem has wrestled 25 matches across Dark, Elevation, Dynamite and Rampage, with some notable bouts taking place along the way. She has wrestled for both the AEW Women's and TBS Championships, losing to Thunder Rosa and Jade Cargill respectively in standout matches. On top of that, Shafir has also aligned herself with Nyla Rose and Vickie Guerrero to form The Beasts of Burden in recent weeks.

While there has not been much reported on why Marina Shafir is not officially signed to Tony Khan's company, at this point it would simply be a formality. While not a formal member of the roster, an announcement of Shafir's signing might be the first time fans realize she was not signed to the company long ago.

8. Johnny Elite

The Joker in All Elite Wrestling has been a very fun concept unique to Tony Khan's company. In any Casino stlye match, there have been surprise final entrant, normally either a returning wrestler or a debuting star who recently signed on the dotted line. Coming into the Owen Hart Cup, fans were waiting for who the Joker would be on both the men and women's brackets.

Advertisement

Maki Itoh was an underwhelming choice for the women's side, but fans were excited to see Johnny Elite arrive in AEW and face Samoa Joe in the tournament. After losing to Joe, the former John Morrison defeated Marq Quen and was soundly defeated by a returning Miro in back-to-back weeks. Since then, Johnny Mundo has remained unsigned by AEW, opting to perform in Game Changer Wrestling, AAA and a recent Progress tour in the UK.

While Johnny Elite may never be a contender for the AEW World Championship, he has made a place for himself in the wrestling world, being a reliable star no matter where he goes or what his last name is.

7. Samuray Del Sol

Kalisto had one of the most up and down tenures during his eight years in WWE. Starting off as one of the first true NXT call-ups, the Mexican high-flyer had all the potential in the world, with fans already seeing him as the heir to Rey Mysterio. Unfortunately, a series of missteps, in the ring and on the microphone, led to a tumble down the WWE pecking order, in turn leading to his release in April of last year.

Advertisement

Since his release Samuray Del Sol has largely stayed out of the spotlight, wrestling a handful of independent matches across the United States and Mexico as well as a one-off appearance for All Elite Wrestling, challenging FTR for the AAA Tag Team Championships alongside Aero Star. Fans were happy to see Samuray pop up on Dynamite, hoping this might lead to a signing with Tony Khan's company, but that is yet to happen.

With wrestlers like Penta, Rey Fenix, and other incredible high-flyers on the current roster, Tony Khan and company may not see adding Samuray Del Sol as a top priority. Still, at only 35 years old, the former Kalisto has plenty left in the tank and can be a welcome addition to the AEW roster anytime he signs.

6. VXT

Even the biggest WWE supporters have to admit that All Elite Wrestling has been a complete success in their first three and a half years in existence. With all their success there has been only one constant knock against Tony Khan's company, and that is the lack of star power in the women's division. With Britt Baker, Thunder Rosa, Toni Storm and others continuing to grow, there has not been a major influx of talent the way CM Punk, Bryan Danielson and others have done for the men.

Advertisement

One simple way to fix that problem would be the signing of Deonna Purrazzo and Chelsea Green, collectively known as VXT. The current Impact Knockouts Tag Team Champions are two of the best women's wrestlers in the world and have proved it across the globe. The Virtuosa is coming off a banner run, holding the AAA, Ring of Honor, and Impact Women's Championships in the last year. The Hot Mess on the other hand has been touring the country alongside husband Matt Cardona making waves in GCW, Impact and Ring of Honor.

Since AEW has formed, some of the best men's wrestlers in the world have signed to the company, infusing the foundation of the roster with much needed star power. While the women's division is constantly improving, bringing in Purrazzo and Green could be exactly what the brand needs to go to the next level.

5. Sasha Banks

When Sasha Banks and Naomi walked out of Monday Night Raw back in May, fans were split on what this would mean for two of the most talented women in WWE. Some fans saw it as Sasha and Naomi making a statement as means to an end to get the on-screen respect they felt they deserved - while others saw it as the end of the Women's Tag Team Champion's time in Vince McMahon's company.

Advertisement

Over three months from their abrupt exit, and there has been no official solution to the issue with both women. WWE has issued statements criticizing Sasha and Naomi, and suspending the pair indefinitely, while the pair remain largely silent. With the rumor mill circulating about the future of both women, Naomi seems more destined to return to WWE given her marriage to Jimmy Uso. That leaves The Boss with more questions surrounding her, with reports that she was going to be fired by the company on top of conflicting reports that The Blueprint was working on a return to WWE.

If the shoe finally drops and Sasha Banks is truly done with the WWE, there is no better option for The Boston native than All Elite Wrestling. Chelsea Green and Deonna Purrazzo are assuredly two of the best women's wrestlers in the world, but they lack the undeniable star power that Sasha Banks would bring the AEW women's division.

4. Erick Redbeard

When All Elite Wrestling was formed, Erik Rowan would have been one of the last wrestlers fans might have wanted to see sign with the company. As a member of The Wyatt Family, Bludgeon Brothers and alongside The New Daniel Bryan, the former tag team champion did not excel in the ring, on the microphone, and was constantly flopping around different unsuccessful gimmicks.

Advertisement

However, sometimes wrestling is about more than the on-screen product and more about the human beings involved with the sport we all love. Following the tragic passing of Brodie Lee, the entire wrestling world came to a halt to honor not only one of the best wrestlers in the world, but one of the best human beings involved in professional wrestling. At the Brodie Lee Celebration of Life episode of Dynamite, Erick Redbeard would show up, help The Dark Order, and said goodbye to his longtime tag team partner and close friend.

Since then, Redbeard has popped up in AEW a handful of times, wrestling alongside Death Triangle and Danhausen as well as various segments with The Dark Order. With his frequent appearances as well as his real-life connection with the family of the late Jon Huber, officially signing with AEW would be the next logical step for Erick Redbeard.

3. CJ Perry

As a member of WWE's women's division, there is no question that Lana was at the bottom of barrel amongst some of the best wrestlers in the world. However, when The Ravishing Russian was first introduced to the WWE Universe as the valet of Rusev, she was one of the best at what she did.

Advertisement

Since her real-life husband popped up in All Elite Wrestling in September 2020, a large majority of his promos have alluded to his "hot wife." Going on two years with the company, fans have been surprised that, despite being constantly referenced on television, CJ Perry has not arrived on Dynamite and Rampage. Not only would she immediately become one of the best managers in AEW, but her presence would also help to legitimize God's Favorite Champion, who has been hot and cold since signing with Tony Khan.

While CJ Perry will likely be a liability to the women's division should she step in the ring, her aligning herself with her husband would be a welcome addition to the AEW roster.

2. Flip Gordon

Longtime fans of The Young Bucks and their YouTube show 'Being the Elite' remember the days when Flip Gordon was a key part of the show. Before All Elite Wrestling was even a company, Flip was running around like a chicken with his head cut off trying to get himself booked on All In, the event that ultimately led to the creation of AEW.

Advertisement

Due to his association with all members of The Elite, the United States Army veteran seemed like a lock to be one of the first names signed to AEW. It was not to be, as not only was Gordon signed to Ring of Honor at the time, but also opted to re-sign with the company in May of 2020. While the door to Dynamite seemed closed, a window opened when ROH released their entire roster as a part of the company's shut down in 2021.

Since then, the former VIllian Enterprise member has remained out of the spotlight, wrestling a handful of independent shows as opposed to signing with one of the larger companies. As one of the best high flyers in the world, on top of his connections to the top stars of All Elite Wrestling, means Wednesday and Friday nights could be getting a taste of Flip Gordon at any time.

1. Kota Ibushi

Given the close personal relationship between Kota Ibushi and All Elite Wrestling Executive Vice President Kenny Omega, it would have not been a surprise to see The Golden Star sign with the promotion back in 2019. That was not the case, as Ibushi decided to stay with New Japan, and has been near the top of the company in the time since.

Advertisement

The rumblings of one half of the Golden Lovers potentially making the switch to AEW have only intensified recently, with the reports of dissension between Kota and the higher ups at New Japan. Back in 2021, the inaugural IWGP World Heavyweight Champion took to Twitter to criticize both Yusuke Kikuchi, a high-ranking member of New Japan, and the company as a whole for their business practices and treatment of their talent.

To New Japan's credit, they have done almost everything possible to bring one of their biggest stars back into their good graces. NJPW has issued a public apology to Ibushi, disciplined Kikuchi, and stated their intentions to right their previous wrongs. That simply may not be enough to satisfy one of the best wrestlers in the world, and if he truly is done with New Japan Pro Wrestling, making his new home in All Elite Wrestling is a no-brainer.

Advertisement